11 ms·
Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google
- jeffbee 3y agoA person wrote articles that another person felt were defamatory, second person sued Google for indexing them.
- dekken_ 3y agoyep, while I agree defamation is bad, I find the whole "publisher" argument somewhat obsolete. If everyone can be a publisher, then no one is.
- jeffbee 3y agoThe first party is not even the first party, since this "Ripoff Report" site is user-contributed content. It looks like this plaintiff and some American woman were shitposting on that site, and Google indexed it, and the Australian woman sued Google. Full Streisand. https://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/janice-duffy-psychic-stalker-psychics-beware-of-australian-psychic-stalker/internet/janice-duffy-psychic-stalker-psychics-beware-of-australian-psychic-stalker-janice-duff-295712 https://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/janice-duffy-psychic-st...
- dekken_ 3y agoAnd it's only defamation if it's false, which I'm not sure was investigated.
- logicalmonster 3y ago1) IANAL, but there are circumstances and legal jurisdictions where truth is not necessarily an ironclad defense against defamation claims. 2) Ironically, I think the stronger the defamation laws, the worse the problem of defamation becomes because more people become likely to believe dumb random claims they hear are true or otherwise nobody would risk saying it. I believe that a hypothetical society with no defamation laws would be the safest from people believing false random claims.
- DrJaniceDuffy 3y agoWhy would you publish a link to the defamatory content? I know what the Streisand effect is and I can tell you that because of it I have been subjected to horrible abuse over the past few year, even threats put in my letter box.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eckza 3y agoRead another way, > Woman loses 12 years of her life to a legal battle against Google
- Lacerda69 3y agonah she won and did a great service to her fellow human beings. this was not lost or wasted time. people spend decades on far more "useless" things - not that there is anything wrong with that
- HPsquared 3y agoIndeed, society needs such people. Heroic, in a way.
- hn_go_brrrrr 3y agoHeroic, but also pyrrhic.
- b112 3y agoGood grief, she hardly spent every waking moment on it. Court actions are bursts of "lots of work", followed by months of waitng. To hear you people talk, it's all she did! It's like she had a hobby. The way some are talking, she destroyed her life?!?
- dghughes 3y agoDid you read what started it all? She's in no way a heroic.
- eckza 3y agoOh, I'm not saying that she didn't do a great thing. Have you ever spent years of your life tied up in litigation? It's not fun. It's very frustrating, to feel as though a resolution will never happen. It feels indeterminate; indefinite. It's a shame that she should have to spend twelve years of her life pursuing justice. What about the thousands or millions that simply won't try, because they can't rationalize the effort?
- testplzignore 3y agohttps://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/duffy-v-google-inc/ https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/duffy-v... has some actual details of what this is about.
- Popeyes 3y agoCrazy story, so she shit-posted on a dubious forum, they shit-posted back and then she sued Google for defamation.
- aardvarkr 3y agoThat’s my take too. It’s pretty ludicrous
- nullifidian 3y agoThat's UK/Australian legal/cultural norms for you.
- Retric 3y agoSo as is often the case the details are what matter. Google failed to remove defamatory content from their systems after being informed it was defamatory. That’s the case, and they lost because it’s their responsibility to respect such notifications. It’s like that hot coffee lawsuit. They were held 80% liable because the coffee was served at a seriously unsafe temperature, which isn’t total liability. She got 3rd degree burns on 6 percent of her skin and lesser burns over 16 percent, spent 8 days in the hospital and needed skin grafts. But everyone seems to think coffee = hot and not that dangerous when ignoring the possibility it can be made more dangerous.
- fastball 3y agoI think the thing people are surprised by is that auto-complete searches count as defamation, not that Google didn't take them down.
- crobertsbmw 3y agoThere’s a difference between “settles” and “wins”. Sounds like they settled, but then they talk like she won…
- petee 3y agoAfaik a settlement against a company like google is essentially win for a couple reasons -- if Google could win on merit, they can afford to do so; but if they were going to lose, the cost of completing the trial would be even higher than a settlement. Particularly, if she got the redactions and compensation she was looking for, thats certainly a win.
- jfarina 3y agoI don't know about that. Even with a company like Google, 12 years is a long time. What if the responsible attorney retired? I've never worked in a legal setting, but I could imagine that causing their work being reevaluated for cost effectiveness.
- 34679 3y agoShe's quoted as saying it's not about the money, just holding Google accountable. A settlement is money in lieu of accountability. A judgement would deter them from doing it to countless others.
- 3y ago
- HPsquared 3y agoSeems to be about Google making something from "Ripoff Report" available, on which were defamatory statements about the plaintiff. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ripoff_Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ripoff_Report An interesting business model, to be sure... And a clash of two legal regimes, one in which Ripoff Report can operate and another in which Google can be sued for indexing / linking to them. It's like, pick your poison...
- Lacerda69 3y agoi find it mindboggling that criminal records are so accessible in the US - so that something like ripoff report is a legal business there does not surprise me in the least
- shadowgovt 3y agoThere's a lot of historical reasons overlapping here. One is that the country is so large that having that information be public is one of the ways the public protects itself from predatory behaviors... Otherwise, somebody can skip over to another jurisdiction and continue the behaviors they used to cheat people the next town over. In the era before mass communication that was a real problem (the "traveling snake oil salesman" is one iconic example), So making records public to anyone willing to go search them was the least protection the governments could provide. The calculus changes in the era of ubiquitous communication and digital search, but broadly speaking Americans still feel they should be protected from the snake oil salesman.
- arp242 3y agoI'm highly skeptical of this explanation because most countries are large enough to do that, and historically "accessing public records" was not easy so it doesn't seem all that useful. In my observation a far more likely explanation is that US culture sees "criminals" as subhuman monsters hardly worthy of consideration. I'm exaggerating a bit here, but I find general US attitudes towards crime and criminals unhealthy – there are many data points for this: felony disenfranchisement, non-violent criminals routinely shackled by the hands and feet in many jurisdictions, "prison rape lol", death penalty, draconian punishments even for simple things, the state of the prisons, death penalty FOR MINORS until 2005, many minors are prosecuted as adults, the number of people in prison, stand your ground laws, a police force with long-standing ... issues, that "kids for cash" not only was a thing but managed to go undetected for many years (many of the sentences were idioticly draconian and even a single one of them should have set off all sorts of red flags), obsession with crime on TV news and such, routine administration of drug testing, etc. etc. etc. And, of course, the mug shot racket, most of which are taken after arrest and not conviction – sucks to be you in cases of mistaken identity or other harmless arrests where nothing much was going on. A few of these: okay. All combined: a pattern.
- colonwqbang 3y agoNot a single scrap of information about the facts of the case. We should just infer that Google are evil and did something wrong that they deserve to pay for.
- cwillu 3y agoAs far as I can tell, the problem is that google surfaced posts claiming she was a stalker, when she merely lied about a psychic having caused her friend to commit suicide in posts about that psychic. Or something.
- Y-bar 3y agoGoogle appears to be still allowed to surface content which is defamatory, but they still have a publisher's duty to remove it once notified, I think this is key from the summary (linked elsewhere in the discussion): > […] because [Google] was on notice that the material was defamatory and refused to remove the information, it could not be found to have innocently circulated the information
- Symmetry 3y agoI don't think it's reasonable for Google to remove content whenever someone just says its defamatory, in the absence of a court finding that it's actually defamatory. Otherwise we'd quickly lose every reference to Biden winning the 2020 election once it was widely known that the rule existed.
- colonwqbang 3y agoBut the court did find that it was defamatory. There is a world of difference, legally, between disparaging a powerful politician like Biden and a normal private person.
- caf 3y agoThey don't have to remove content whenever someone just says its defamatory. They have to remove defamatory content once someone has told them it's defamatory. Essentially the ball is put into Google's court at the point, with the question: are you willing to defend this as non-defamatory? Which is the same question all primary publishers face.
- donatj 3y agoGoing after Google rather than the company actually making the remarks seems… incorrect Doesn’t seem like it should be Googles job to fact check the internet. Go after the liar, not the search engine. Google seems no more responsible than your ISP for sending it to you or your monitor manufacturer for displaying it.
- petee 3y agoPerhaps if it was someone else's title, but they are constructing their own auto-complete strings, essentially divining it, so their fingers are in fact in the pie. Auto-complete also gives the impression that other people have searched or found it, so it must be valid, despite having little correlation. If an employer starts typing your name and google says you're pedo, you're probably not getting the job
- jeroenhd 3y agoGoogle made the situation a bit harder for themselves with their info boxes (that just repeat the first result, but in an authoritative Google voice) but the "secondary publisher" argument used in the lawsuit makes sense to me. They weren't required to know the truth from the get go, but they had to remove the libel on notice. Perhaps Google disagreed that there was anything wrong with the assertion that this person was a stalker, but that's a rather risky position to take without any criminal convictions to base their claim off, and a stupid one from a business sense. Furthermore, their autocomplete is entirely their product, you can't go after anyone else for that. I imagine this approach wouldn't work in other countries, but if the lawsuit really was baseless in Australia, Google would've won a long time ago, rather than settle now.
- tinus_hn 3y agoSeems the court disagrees with you to the tune of $100000. Seems it is the opinion of the court that Google is rebroadcasting and amplifying slander and refuses to stop when notified and when ordered to do so.
- AdrianB1 3y agoSo is every ISP serving Australia.
- logicalmonster 3y ago> Dr Janice Duffy successfully argued in 2015 and 2023 that Google published defamatory extracts from American website RipOff Report on its search engine page, despite her notifying the company and asking for the posts to be removed. Personally, I don't easily see how Google could be liable for defamation here under any reasonable standard. Their search services generally don't say the equivalent of "Bob murdered a woman in 1989". Their search services generally say the equivalent of "Joe says that Bob murdered a woman in 1989". If anybody is guilty of defamation in that contrived example, it's Joe. Regardless of whether the story about Bob murdering somebody is true or false, Google's service remains entirely factual when they pass along the word that "Joe says that Bob murdered a woman in 1989". That statement is 100% factual. I wish the article went into more detail about the actual impact on this woman's career (not sure if they risk lawsuits reporting the details), but as the posted article reads right now, it's not really clear if she was fired because of some boss Googling her, or if she just had a mental break when she fixated on the Google search results to a possibly unhealthy degree.
- varjag 3y agoThe problem begins when you are Bob and anyone typing your name in the search engine gets "Bob murdered a woman in 1989", without any reference to particular Joe.
- viraptor 3y ago> Google's service remains entirely factual when they pass along the word that "Joe says that ... That's not what they do though. This is a case about autocomplete in the search bar which gave the phrase "psychic stalker" after her name without any context or source. You could expect people to know this is just a random phrase from the index, but: 1. People don't understand how Google works. 2. It doesn't change the result of the negative association for a name used in business.
- GuB-42 3y agoDefamation laws are complicated. In some countries you can be purely factual and still commit the crime of diffamation. An example is talking about someone's involvement in some criminal activity, implying the person in question is a himself a criminal when he is in fact a victim. It is true, but it is still using deceptive tactics (lying by omission in this case) to damage someone's reputation. Here, what I understood made it defamation is that Google autocompleted the defendant name to “janice duffy psychic stalker”. No "Joe says" here. Victim aside, I think it is an important case, and probably the reason why it took so long. By autocompleting, Google puts up information without context, and I think it is normal to hold the company responsible more than for regular search results. In my opinion, Google simply shouldn't autocomplete people names with accusations, true or not. Not only it opens them to defamation, like in this case, but there is enough negativity in this world that I feel like having autocomplete say bad things on people, even assholes, is doing the world a disservice.
- phendrenad2 3y ago> The Court went on to note that the mental element depends on whether the defendant is a “primary publisher” or a “secondary publisher”. A “primary publisher” may be held liable for defamation regardless of whether it knows of the defamatory material, whereas a “secondary publisher” is only held liable if it knows that what it was publishing contains the passage in question or is reckless or careless as to its containing such a passage Why stop there? Hacker News is now a "tertiary publisher" because it links to Google.com, which links to defamatory content! Hell, the judge, in the act of commenting on this case, is a 5th-level publisher! For shame! Anyway, Australia is ranked dead last in my personal ranking of countries that "get it". The cluelessness train keeps rolling over there. We get silly internet laws and even sillier interpretations of silly internet laws every day.
- Nasrudith 3y agoIts not cluelessness. It is deliberately obtuseness. They were the patient Zero of the Murdoch media infection.
- herodotus 3y ago>"In dismissing the innocent dissemination defense, which required that the publisher be a subordinate distributor who did not know or ought not to have known that the matter was defamatory, the Court stated that the defamatory nature of the content was self-evident from an examination of it." (extracted from https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/duffy-v-google-inc/ https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/duffy-v...) I am no fan of Google, but this seems bizarre to me, since it seems to imply that some human has to read every web page linked by Google. Even to suggest that Google must respond to every complaint of content on third party websites just cannot possibly scale. On the other, there is a party that is responsible for the defamatory content, namely whatever web app had collected and posted the comments. The claimant should have pursued them, not Google.
- shadowgovt 3y agoGoogle has a takedown process and it failed. At that point, Safe Harbor no longer applies and we're in this category of "What standard would a newspaper be held accountable to?"
- numbsafari 3y agoJust because it can’t scale, doesn’t mean it isn’t wrong. There is no right to a scalable business model. If you can’t figure out how to do your business without doing it right, you shouldn’t be doing it. Our local coal fired power plant has been yelling for decades that they can’t possibly make a profit and meet all the environmental obligations. Well… guess what.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThat would also imply that there is no right for individuals to have a productive life with plenty of free time per day. Since burdensome, long-lasting, legally required procedures can also be imposed by a court on an individual. Seems like a slippery slope to be honest.
- omnimus 3y ago
- kriro 3y agoIf I'm Google I'd just stop indexing this site after the ruling and also talk to my competitors and suggest they do the same because it's bad for them. Seems like they index it but downweight already. Pretty interesting ruling that a search engine is basically liable for autocomplete (and thus the content they index). The original website seems pretty shady and not being indexed should basically destroy their business model long term.
- acdha 3y ago> If I'm Google I'd just stop indexing this site after the ruling and also talk to my competitors and suggest they do the same because it's bad for them. Seems like they index it but downweight already. That’s what they refused to do after losing the previous case on appeal. That means they no longer have any way to claim they didn’t know about it, since they spent large sums of money fighting it in court.
- kriro 3y agoI get that and I'd accept the ruling (going to the highest possible court because this is kind of important for them). I'd just use it as a good opportunity to de-index a troubling site without any of the potential legal issues that could come with that (unfairly discriminating against said site or whatever).
- acdha 3y agoI think the underlying issue is that Google strenuously avoids taking responsibility for their services. This kind of thing could be handled quickly by a modest customer service group but they don’t want to set the precedent that they do that sort of thing short of a lawsuit.
- tgv 3y agoThe auto-complete is of Google's own making. They built and added it, they can improve or remove it. There's no reason to assume an automated prompt has to repeat defamatory or deceitful statements just because they appear somewhere online.
- Euphorbium 3y agoYou probably need to go into 12 year legal battle against google to get some human response from them.
- rvba 3y agoDoes a response from lawyers count as "human"?
- HHC-Hunter 3y agoFor Google, yes. They're the official mouthpieces
- arp242 3y agoYou're in an optimistic mood today.
- flavius29663 3y agoNot even that, google didn't show up > A line has been finally been drawn under an Adelaide woman's 12-year legal battle against global tech giant Google after she sued the company twice, mostly unrepresented, and won.
- StevenWaterman 3y agoThat line doesn't say that Google didn't show up. It says that she acted as her own lawyer.
- Andrex 3y agoThat sentence implies to me that she represented herself, not that Google was without representation.
- Zarel 3y agoYou're misinterpreting that sentence. This overview of the case was posted: https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/duffy-v-google-inc/ https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/duffy-v... And in it, it talks about Google's defenses (innocent dissemination, qualified privilege, and justification), so clearly Google did show up.
- kkielhofner 3y agoAs other commenters have noted this is a classic pyrrhic victory. If nothing else I have to respect her because I cannot imagine the tenacity it took to pursue this. I can't speak to the merits or substance of the case but I know I don't have it. It's clear from the article she's a fighter with her initial reaction to discovering this: "She contemplated taking her life, saying it destroyed her career in research." To pull yourself together and come back from that is fairly remarkable. On the other hand, you have to really feel sorry for her. She took what seems to be a slight and spent 12 years of her life putting the time and effort into this while incurring the stress, emotional toll, expense, and what I'm sure are plenty of other sacrifices elsewhere in her life. She seems to be happier as a result of these "victories" but I wonder how much better things could have been for her if she spent the last 12 years focusing her energies elsewhere in her life and career.
- account42 3y agoThe woman made up shit about some psychics (after finding out the hard way that there is no such thing as a psychic) and then got mad again when she was served some of that same medicine. Sounds more like someone that wanted to avoid the consequences of her own choices rather than a courageous fighter standing up to the big evil corporation.
- kkielhofner 3y agoI wasn't commenting on any of these points, I specifically said "I can't speak to the merits or substance of the case". I certainly didn't say anything about going up against an "evil corporation". I'm trying to reference the humanity aspects of the situation, which I've found time and time again seems to be completely lost on HN (see: downvotes). It's called empathy.
- mattstir 3y ago> It's called empathy. I suppose it's just hard for many to feel empathy for someone who would go to such great lengths to avoid the consequences of their own actions. The timeline of events is just insane: Dr. Duffy consults with psychics about a romantic partner, gets upset when the psychics don't guess the true outcome, proceeds to lie about her friend's wife committing suicide due to the psychics, has a few posts about her stalking these psychics published on some no-name website, then spends 12 years getting upset at Google for indexing that website and autocompleting search terms instead of getting upset with the authors of the defamatory posts? Empathy is the ability to understand and share the feelings of another, but it's hard for most people to see that chain of events and understand them.
- ourmandave 3y agoI'm just wondering how the Google internal legal dept handled this for 12 years. I'm imagining they called it the Duffy file and gave it to interns every year. Or maybe assigned it personnel with low annual reviews. "Dave, we're giving you the Duffy case until you get your numbers up."
- DrJaniceDuffy 3y agolol-actually Google engaged outside law firms that made millions of dollars in legal costs - in the end they just wanted me to go away - lol - so they settled for 'appropriate' compensation BUT left the liability intact.
- computerfriend 3y agoI'm sure that Janice Duffy, the publicly named claimant, will now forever be unassociated with this case and the defaming material by search engines.
- _trampeltier 3y agoAnd the court needed 12 years for this? Really?
- sdfghswe 3y agoMy rudimentary understanding of law is that there are a lot of "procedural" elements that expensive lawyers can fiddle with in order to delay the case (and try to make the plaintiff give up). It's not necessarily that the decision was conceptually difficult. Altho it might be! I don't know anything about the case.
- _trampeltier 3y agoYes, but please. If the law/court works like this .. thats almost worthless.
- canU4 3y ago[flagged]
- m4jor 3y agoI think the only ones who came out on top of this were the lawyers.
- michaelcampbell 3y agoShe'll be back.
- kazinator 3y ago> She said it's never been about the money, but holding Google accountable. Well, holding them accountable just to her in that specific situation, by paying her the settlement. There is no change in the accountability, as such, of Google.