4 ms·
American companies not complying with European law is quite common. That's not a problem as long as they and their owners don't care about doing business in Eur
by jeroenhd 3y ago
American companies not complying with European law is quite common. That's not a problem as long as they and their owners don't care about doing business in Europe.
There's not a lot Europeans can do about it, nor is there much Americans can do about European countries doing things Americans don't like. Take, for example, the copyright lobby; they'd love to take down libdvdcss so you need to pay for licensed software to play DVDs on your computer, but French law allows them to operate freely.
Companies like Clearview (or YCombinator for that matter, as HN accounts can't be deleted), don't strictly need to comply with the privacy laws as long as nobody is willing to enforce them. Illegal (and unethical) as that may be, you'll have a hard time convincing any kind of European government agency to take action.
- deaddodo 3y agoThis is the thing, and the same goes in reverse. You only have to care about complying if you officially do business there (e.g., if someone buys your product from a third-party without an official relationship with you, you're generally safe). Companies like Apple, Google, Facebook, Ford, etc (and VW, Zeiss, etc in the inverse) comply because they themselves directly operate in foreign regions. And smaller manufacturers do because they have a relationship with a distributor.
- MightyBuzzard 3y ago[dead]
- marcus_holmes 3y agoNot always true. Kim Dotcom was extradited from New Zealand to the USA for doing things that were legal in NZ, but illegal in the USA [0]. Obviously, the lesson here is that you can be prosecuted for doing stuff that the USA doesn't like, if it's annoying a politically-connected entity enough [1]. The libdvdcss thing is probably just the French being awkward in that way they love to do; if it had been the UK they would have rolled over without a word of complaint. Europe probably has the same reach, but less inclination to do anything with it (imho). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Dotcom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Dotcom [1] also see Julian Assange, who at the heart of it is being imprisoned and extradited for annoying the USA.
- Narann 3y ago> The libdvdcss thing is probably just the French being awkward in that way they love to do; if it had been the UK they would have rolled over without a word of complaint. As much as we have fun co-bulling with UK, this statement does not make sense. Allowing libdvdcss is consistent with a long story about the medium/support/distribution not being legally sanctified against the content. Beyond the chiming about entertaining content (MP3/MP4 VS CD/DVD), the point is to never let anyone/anything (individuals, professionals, and most important public services), being locked to a particular support if their think its not in there interest. Before the DRM mess, this has been a source of problem when some software editors fall down and we had billions of documents in a closed format and some research project to convert those files back to something readable (which is kind of non-sense). If support and distribution sucks, you should not being locked to it and can choose to invest time and money to change it. The simple fact you are ready to invest in unlocking yourself is almost considered good enough. The “Cour de cassation” (most important juridical instance) always decides in favor of content owner than content distributor. I suspect the globalization makes those statement even more important as you don’t want your public service to be locked down to software solution of another country. I don’t think it’s that much award. Many countries are doing the same and some considers copyright as an American soft power, especially for softwares. Content openness is such a thing it has modified the way even big software companies are making money. Hope this helps.
- marcus_holmes 3y agoThanks for the clarification. I agree completely and I'm glad someone is fighting the good fight ;) My original statement was mostly tongue-in-cheek - my bad for not marking it as such
- mmanfrin 3y agoNot complying with delete requests is also illegal in California.
- Alupis 3y agoThere's a number of built-in features of the law that exempt many things from deletion requests.
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoExcept Y Combinator doesn't comply with them, and one day it's going to piss someone off enough to make it an easy lawsuit. They instead scramble your username, because preserving conversations is more important to them than obeying the law.
- chaps 3y agoCan you say more about this?
- 1123581321 3y agoThe CA law doesn’t require deleting communications. YC is in compliance.
- BLanen 3y agoThe EU law does.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoIrrelevant.
- 1123581321 3y agoIt doesn’t either. You just need to remove identity which anonymization of usernames accomplishes.
- 3y ago
- arp242 3y agoIt's not really clear to me HN comments are even covered under GDPR's right to deletion. The GDPR doesn't guarantee wholesale deletion of every bit of information you've posted on the internet (by that standard you can also demand some open source project scrubs your name and email from the git history, and all comments on the issue tracker/PR reviews). Accounts can be renamed, and specific comments can be deleted, which seems to cover GDPR in my reading of it.
- crote 3y agoThe largest tech website and discussion platform in The Netherlands, tweakers.net, uses a similar approach. They restrict the time a message can be edited, and after the timer expires you can't delete it anymore. They do allow you to delete your account but your messages will still remain with a numeric "Anonymous User #1234" identifier. Such an approach is justified using the exceptions under Article 17.3.A, which states that "[The right to erasure] shall not apply to the extent that processing is necessary for exercising the right of freedom of expression and information". They argue that deleting comments has a significant negative impact on the discussion as a whole, and it would be a violation of the other users' freedom of expression. I'm not sure I completely agree with this interpretation, but as far as I am aware it hasn't been tested in court yet so who knows.
- ReflectedImage 3y agoYes but of course you must go through every comment the user made and check for personally identifying information and remove it.
- gumby 3y agoThey sell to law enforcement so they will get permission to violate the law in every jurisdiction.
- dmantis 3y agoThat's an espionage company which is openly violating privacy rights of other countries citizens outside of the US jurisdiction. I would agree with you, if all companies and individuals in the world could openly violate right of US citizens outside of the US without the extradition and sanctions risk. It would be fair to drop all extradition agreements with the US if the US allows such behavior from their companies or enforce the extradition and jail time for C-level management of such companies based in the US if they leave the country anywhere (like it happens with others).
- gman83 3y agoWould this imply that no Clearview executives could ever travel to Europe again?
- boppo1 3y agoWhat if I have dual US/EU citizenship?