6 ms·
YouTube wants to get you watching more news from 'authoritative sources'
- throwaway4aday 3y agoLooks like I'm going to have to find a good blocker for YouTube content, any recommendations? There's a few chrome extensions to choose from https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/channel-blocker/nfkmalbckemmklibjddenhnofgnfcdfp https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/channel-blocker/nf... https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/blocktube/bbeaicapbccfllodepmimpkgecanonai https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/blocktube/bbeaicap... or maybe some alternative interface? Is there something that allows you to just view channels you subscribe to but also has a decent recommendation system built in?
- jakeogh 3y agoSkytube on fdroid. lets you block chans.
- gabrielgio 3y agoInvidious[^1]. You can enabled/disable what you mentioned (and much more). You can't login with your youtube account but you can import your channels (what I did). You can find public instances but they are a bit hit or miss since youtube can often throttle those instances. I have it running on my home server (so not throttled) and am quite happy with the result. [1]: https://invidious.io/ https://invidious.io/
- throwaway4aday 3y agothank you! I had heard of invidious before but had forgotten about it. Looks like it's time to give it a try
- hifycycyv 3y ago[dead]
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoHow about less news?
- outime 3y agoIt might be that's what they're trying to solve https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37929373 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37929373 - I checked and it may be the case: https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/digital-news-report/2023/dnr-executive-summary https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/digital-news-repo...
- raxxorraxor 3y agoYoutube is also unrolling adblock detection. Some are already affected. I hope their web environment integrity will be a huge fail and miss as well. Authoritative sources are probably those they have a direct business relation with.
- aforty 3y agoUnrolling Adblock detection? I finally caved and got YouTube premium but I’m still on the free trial.
- metiscus 3y agoI think they meant unrolling as in deploying.
- ekianjo 3y ago> Authoritative sources are probably those they have a direct business relation with. Not only. Youtube loves the WHO despite them being wrong about just everything
- outime 3y agoWHO being wrong about many things isn't a bug.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThat's pretty funny coming from a service that seems to push the opposite every time I experiment with starting with a blank-slate account/session. It only takes about two clicks and I'm seeing conspiracy videos all about the WEF the UN and great replacement and so on. Never been a fan of the "MSM" as they call it, but the "opposite" is seemingly worse. I'd opt for neither? To me the problem with YouTube and similar systems seems to be the whole idea of click/impression-based ranking and funding. It creates awful incentives. Funding sources for independent, ethical, journalism is what we need.
- seanw444 3y agoIndependent, ethical journalism that doesn't tell you about potential conspiracies because you have an aversion to them? Conspiracies happen. I will bet my life that there are plenty of major ones going on now, that we'll only possibly learn of in the coming decades.
- jjk166 3y agoIndependent, ethical journalism should present evidence they have found in their investigations, not regurgitate the speculations of anyone with a few twitter followers. Any conspiracy theory that does wind up being true will survive any attempt to debunk it.
- maxehmookau 3y agoI agree, but also don't be too quick to discount the "MSM". Sure, they're big organisations that are open to bribery and corruption like any other; but the people they employ are generally decent journalists trying to do their jobs as well as anyone else.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoI don't disagree fully, though I have a special loathing for American "MSM"; as a Canadian I can't watch e.g. CNN without my gag reflex kicking in. The presentation style, glibness, and superficiality is ridiculous. From the outside, it's just Fox News for smug US liberals instead of crazy radical conservatives.
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- diamondfist25 3y agoYouTube serves MSM on any search query I have for trendy topics. And they are one sided. Its propaganda at its finest
- aunty_helen 3y agoI just want a cat and meme video platform not some “Breaking now” state sponsored information funnel :(
- jazzyjackson 3y agoHave you heard of the saga of the puppy channel? A man had collected hundreds of hours of VHS tapes of cute pets and embarked on a mission to create a broadcast channel featuring no ads, just cute videos. Everyone turned him down, not interested, offended even at the notion that one would need a break from ad-mediated drama-laden television https://www.thisamericanlife.org/233/starting-from-scratch/act-one-24 https://www.thisamericanlife.org/233/starting-from-scratch/a...
- sircastor 3y agoMy wife and I still occasionally break out into a song of "Puppies, puppies, puppies, puppies, puppies, puppies, puppies, puppies, puppieeeeees!"
- neilv 3y ago"Natalie Portman & Rashida Jones Speak Out Again" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GdEdZ8FY_fo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GdEdZ8FY_fo (I can't find the puppies one.)
- neilv 3y agoFor awhile, Reddit did pretty well with "cat pictures". The front page has been compromised for many years, but there's still corners like: https://old.reddit.com/r/Awww/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Awww/ https://old.reddit.com/r/AnimalsBeingBros/ https://old.reddit.com/r/AnimalsBeingBros/
- pelagicAustral 3y agoWithout even taking this into account, I deleted the Google account I had for YT a few days back. I noticed a lot of the creators I was subbed to where also on Odysse, alas not enough of the tech related ones... So it was not a major hit. There is very good content over there... That whole vibe of borderline criminalizing ad blockers did it for me... that and the fact that lately is echo chamber after echo chamber, you search for some content, and because everything is so polarized, it only take a few videos to have your entire feed populated by radicalized content... And to be honest, at times, on the Odysee comments, you can feel like it's a counterculture userbase, but at least in there I dont need to feel like I'm stealing from my overlords by using ad blocker...
- dotancohen 3y ago> I noticed a lot of the creators I was subbed to > where also on Odysse, alas not enough of the tech related ones I had never heard of Odysse, thanks. I just checked some of my top Youtube subs, but absolutely none of them are there. Ave, justrolledin, Practical Engineering, nothing. It seems that some of the usernames are taken, with subscribers but no uploaded videos. It seems that the site has been ruined by spammers and squatters already.
- JohnFen 3y ago> you search for some content, and because everything is so polarized, it only take a few videos to have your entire feed populated by radicalized content I'm so glad that this hasn't happened to me. The algorithm generally doesn't work well for me, but in this case it seems to be fine.
- ruune 3y agoJust wanting to add that this might just be perception. The most harmful bubbles are the ones you don't realise you're a part of
- JohnFen 3y agoI get very few recommendations that are even remotely political in nature, not even ones that I am inclined to agree with. I like that, and it's one of the few things that YouTube gets right for me.
- Someone1234 3y agoThe same YouTube that promoted, in their recommendations page, "alternative news" sources throughout the last six+ years and made many of them popular? YouTube's algorithm with little human oversight has caused major damage and this is the least they can do. Plus "shortform news" is inherently problematic even from authoritative sources, because it has to simply every issue into a black Vs. white to fit the format. Reality is often shades of gray/grey. Try explaining the current Gaza situation in 60-seconds, I couldn't, I couldn't in 15-minutes.
- ekianjo 3y ago> The recommended videos are all from major news publishers like The Associated Press, Sky News, and CBS Evening News. Oh good old propaganda then
- RandomLensman 3y agoNothing wrong with that in a world not only with friends but also adversaries.
- bitsnbytes 3y agoI'm actually glad to see more people waking up to massive propaganda news machines . Especially with ycombinator as it appears that Tech people land on the Liberal side based on the comments I have seen in the past here. Anyhow I look forward to the downvotes . lol
- etchalon 3y agoI did a double-take at "pledging $1.6 million" assuming it was a typo. That isn't a number you brag about as a company at YouTube's scale.
- magicalist 3y agoBut don't worry, a crack team of hacker news users are here to comment on the headline :)
- type0 3y agoTV channels from authoritarian regimes are 'authoritative sources', right?
- colpabar 3y agoOnly if said regimes are friendly with the US of course.
- rightbyte 3y agoI guess there is political pressure to push news down our throats as people zone out from news in general. E.g. MS have started to spam the start menu with news. The sensationalization of web news makes it unbearable. I only read dead tree news papers.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI don't watch or read national/world news at all. I have zero influence over it and it doesn't affect me personally so it doesn't seem worth a minute of my time. I keep up with a couple of local news sources as that news is actually relevant to my life.
- outime 3y agoSo YouTube becoming the ol' good TV full of ads and propaganda? You won't believe what happens next.
- muhaaa 3y agoWhy is competion in the media space through small & independet news outlets a bad thing? If I realize a media outlet provides low quality or baised news, I choose not to watch it. Only Orwellian authorities do not like that!
- mminer237 3y agoI assume they're worried about people with less discerning judgment. I know plenty of people who get all their news from YouTube channels and send me videos about how Italy hacked spy satellites to flip votes to Biden, how COVID vaccines will permanently change your DNA, how Hamas hasn't actually done anything wrong, how you don't really need to eat or drink anything to live except sunlight, how the government staged the Maui wildfires, etc. Regardless of how paternalistic you believe YouTube should be about such content, they probably don't want that to become the association everyone has with "YouTube news".
- carlosjobim 3y agoThose examples are a whole lot less concerning than millions of people going out to be slaughtered or slaughter others in some war because broadcast or printed media told them to.
- throwaway4aday 3y agoI'm pretty sure those people are still going to spout rumours even if the only source of news is "official" channels. Does anyone think that dictating what news is acceptable will actually work? Every authoritarian regime in the past 100+ years has tried this and failed for the most part.
- colpabar 3y agoLike everything else related to content decisions made by free services like youtube, it comes down to advertising money. Advertisers don't want their products marketed underneath a video about how the holocaust didn't happen or how covid was fake. It really, really, really sucks. We're letting some of the most immoral and unethical organizations dictate what is acceptable online based purely on how it will affect their profits.
- thevillagechief 3y agoThis is sad. It has been sad since they started pushing silly late night nonsense. I usually cannot stand watching the same mainstream news channel content I've already avoided on TV. Does anyone actually go to YouTube to watch 'authoritative sources' of news? I think the opposite, people go there to avoid news. They will look back at this as a silly decision a few years down the line when some upstart starts killing them and pivot again as they did with tiktok. Google is so terribly reactionary lately.
- jsnell 3y agoI don't understand your complaint. This is what the article says (emphasis mine): > Google’s video platform is rolling out a new “immersive watch page experience” on mobile that’s designed to suggest more news content *when users are watching news videos*. For somebody who is avoiding news, nothing is changing.
- colpabar 3y ago> For somebody who is avoiding news, nothing is changing. If you choose to believe youtube, sure, but I don't think they deserve your trust.
- jsnell 3y agoWell, the article is entirely sourced on a blog post by YouTube [0]. If you don't believe them, there's no story in the first place. That blog post is basically just announcing a feature that recommends related news videos when you're watching a news video. That's it. You're presumably reacting to the article headline, but the claim in the headline that "YouTube wants you watching more news" appears to be entirely made up by The Verge's headline/clickbait editor. But ok, let's trust the headline and not the blog post. What do you think the lie is? That the news recommendations will actually be shown for non-news videos not related to the event? That there's some totally separate YouTube feature in the works unrelated to the announced feature that's about making you (yes, you!) watch more news from authoritative news sources, that some buffoon at The Verge was privy to, and accidentally revealed in the headline even though it was unsupported by their single piece of public source material? [0] https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/investing-in-a-multi-format-news-watching-experience/ https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/investing-in-a-multi-fo...
- spandextwins 3y agoWhy is everything online so political? Turn off, get out and enjoy life. Plant a tree or something. Take a walk. The world will keep doing what it's doing, no need for it to occupy 90% of your thoughts.
- colpabar 3y agoBecause political content is a sure fire way to generate outrage from almost anyone, and outrage translates to advertising revenue, whereas planting trees does not. As big tech continues to consume the entire internet, more and more political content will be shoved down our throats. And the scary thing is, one day they will figure out how to monetize planting trees, and even that won't be safe.
- daft_pink 3y agoIf I wanted 'authoritative sources', I would just watch TV.
- amadeuspagel 3y agoFuck news. If YouTube wants to promote "authorative" content, there are many documentaries on the platform.
- aunty_helen 3y agoAs hackers, it's our job to solve problems with the tools we have. Each part of society plays a role, ours is building technology to ensure tomfoolery like this doesn't go rewarded. If there was a software that allowed creators to upload to every video platform at once with the click of a button, more platforms would take part of the market share. Maybe there already is? Maybe it's not so great? This seems purely a technology problem that we as a community could help overcome. Frankly I'm sick of youtube and how cosy it has got in a position of power.