11 ms·
Ishkur's Guide to Electronic Music
- Borg3 3y agoYeah, great site. I really liked the old 2.5 version tho. I have it mirrored locally :)
- andruby 3y agoI love the original version so much. I don’t think I would have ever discovered Italo, Trip-Hop or Ghetto Tech if it wasn’t for Ishkur’s Guide. Thanks for this gem!
- amatecha 3y agoYeah, it absolutely accelerated my exposure to a bunch of styles that would have taken me a lot longer to find out about through organic "searching around and checking stuff out", giving me a ton of snippets to get a feel for and pique my interest. Though once I got to know my favorite styles more, I could think of more specific examples -- but it looks like newer renditions of the guide have wayyy more examples anyways! : )
- usrusr 3y agoA gem it was! I'm not interested in an internet that does not have Casiocore in its Ishkur's guide. Guess I'm getting old.
- sedivy94 3y agoI’m often disappointed in these chart as an avid fan of experimental bass music and everything adjacent to it (dub, dubstep, riddim, trap, DNB, UK garage, glitch hop, neuro hop, etc.) Genre-bending has become the norm, making it increasingly harder to describe music and trace lineage. The scene I’m into right now is blossoming yet underrepresented. There’s some artists out there really pushing the envelope. I highly recommend Of The Trees, Daily Bread, Esseks, FRQ NCY, and IMANU, for starters. Some friends pushed me to dive into Techno about a year ago. Totally different animal. I’m not quite “there” yet in terms of my understanding and appreciation for that musical movement, but I the juice is there and it is indeed sweet.
- languagehacker 3y agoA total classic from the Internet 1.0 days and one of the first places I discovered so many great genres and artists.
- andyjohnson0 3y agoVoices in the Net [1], a Tangerine Dream discography, has a similar early-net vibe. Looks like it hasn't been updated for a couple of years though. For a couple of decades Tangerine Dream have been my go-to coding music - along with Eno and Harold Budd, and more recently Max Richter, for when I need something less driven. [1] https://www.voices-in-the-net.de/ https://www.voices-in-the-net.de/
- sjkoelle 3y agosweet
- arittr 3y agoone of the all time greatest, always happy to see this pop up. i hope it never goes down.
- techsupporter 3y agoToday in niche requests: Does anyone have pointers to streaming electronic music (ideally trance / progressive trance, upbeat synthwave[0], or house) that has absolutely no vocals? I listened to a lot of no-vocal electronica back in the 80s but I can't find anywhere to stream it now, even just as a long playlist on Apple Music or Spotify, without a vocal track being dropped in. Vocals are fine but I like non-vocal/just-electronics tracks upbeat music as ambient or to listen to while zoning out. I emailed SomaFM and di.fm to ask and they have one stream apiece that mostly fits the bill but maybe there are others out there? 0 - Upbeat because I know about "lofi beats to study by" and that's a bit too slow for what I'm after. :)
- whompyjaw 3y agoI would love this same exact thing. I have not found any source that doesn't have vocals. I produce on the side as a hobby and one of my goal albums is to create something like this. 1-2hrs of a mix style album that is upbeat with no vocals. The only thing that comes close are finding specific artist's that don't use vocals much in their mixes. Cercle has a lot of great mixes that come close. Sebastian Leger's mix might be one of those. But some parts of the mix are a little distracting.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- meisel 3y agoJust search for “instrumental trance mix” on YouTube
- acchow 3y agoThis is will get you very generic music. You'll need curators (DJs) to do the work to dig deeper for you.
- m5g 3y agoTry https://www.di.fm/ https://www.di.fm/ , they have a ton of different genres that stream 24/7. However, I'm not sure if you have to pay nowadays to access all the channels.
- z8rHZM8Svhu8hE2 3y agoLast visited maybe 10 years ago. Nice to see it is still active and developing, thought it was a static site of the past.
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agothis hasn't been updated in a while
- trollied 3y agoLove the humour on this site. "Drum n Bass MCs aren't like Hip Hop MCs. Some rhyme but most are just glorified hype-men. And some are quite good but most just sound like they're trying to eat a set mousetrap." :D
- evanelias 3y agoSounds about right... maybe 1 out of 10 DnB MCs is amazing, but the rest are kind of intolerable in the exact same way. The funniest take on this I've ever heard is the sketch at the end of DJ Freaky Flow's mix cd from 2001: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6lIcptQ2RfA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6lIcptQ2RfA
- elevaet 3y agoThat's gold! Reminds me of the UKG Horse Race: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hf-cHNC6hRU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hf-cHNC6hRU
- ladzoppelin 3y agoI always thought Mc's were a way to keep people from recording dub plates and using them in there own mixes as most mixes from 1996 - 2001 are not listenable today. MC + crappy recording + DJ spinning at 200 bpm for some reason killed so many sets that would be awesome to listen to today.
- traeregan 3y agoBahaha! I started getting into DnB in the mid-nineties and have left shows because of MCs that I just couldn't tolerate. And while we're on the topic, and because it's rare for me to get to chat about DnB with anyone... here are some fun short stories from over the years: A friends Dad happened by when I was listening to DnB without headphones and said "THAT is NOT music... it sounds like a toilet flushing". --- I like listening to DnB during focus-intensive work. On a road trip with friends I'd been working without music for a bit and when I finally put headphones on with some DnB my friends were cracking up saying that I started typing at warp speed once the music started. Hey, it works for me! --- I was wearing a Bass Drive radio t-shirt underneath an unbuttoned long sleeve shirt, so if you can picture it opened down the center and partially obscuring both sides of the large "Bass Drive" logo, and a friend starts staring at my chest and chuckling. I ask what's so funny and he says "Heh-heh... why're you wearing an "ass doctor" shirt?". "ass Dr", ha. --- I use to work on the computer late into the night at a friend's house and he had a roommate who lived in the basement. I usually worked at the dining room table, which happened to be directly above the roommate's bed, with a hardwood floor between us, and on more than one occasion he'd come upstairs half-asleep and say "PLEASE stop tapping your feet on the floor". The last thing I'd ever want to do is torture him awake with that, but I'd be so into the DnB in my headphones that it was happening subconsciously.
- nyolfen 3y agooh man, i was telling my wife about this a few weeks ago, i was certain this had disappeared with the flash web
- epiccoleman 3y agoAlways felt like there was something I would enjoy in the EDM genre, but I haven't really found the right thing. But I recently got way into Lotus, a sort of combination of jam band / rock / electronic genres. Their stuff is fantastic, I need to spend some time digging through their influences and see if I stumble on some more electronic stuff that I like.
- seanthemon 3y agoI find it's rarely genres that I like in electronic, it's specific songs that give off the right vibes, there's a lot if content to wade through.
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoTrying Lotus now. Thanks for the tip.
- epiccoleman 3y agoI really like their live album Escaping Sargasso Sea. They're incredibly tight live too, and recently pulled in Tim Palmieri for guitar - great fit for the band. Bunch of recent shows available free on bandcamp too for a taste of modern Lotus
- xkcd-sucks 3y agoWait, THE Tim Palmieri of The Breakfast / Lotus / plays with Adrian Tramontano sometimes?! Is this a permanent thing?
- epiccoleman 3y agoAs far as I'm aware it is. He's been a great fit for Lotus. Replaced Mike Rempel around 2020. I saw Lotus in February and they absolutely slayed. One of the tightest live shows I've ever seen. Stage lighting was also some of the most impressive I've witnessed. And Tim can friggin shred.
- aeyes 3y agoI wish this was open source and would accept pull requests. So many "wrong" examples in the genres I listen to. But I guess it would end in endless edit wars. It took over 10 years to get some genres fixed on Discogs, people are unfortunately very stubborn about these things. Even with the artists saying their music is style X the mods wouldn't budge.
- Jasper_ 3y agoThe fun thing is that the Guide v1.0 (the Flash version) was originally satire of the electronic music scene. Several of the music genres were flat out made up, with the audio samples being provided by ishkur under an alias (or ishkur's friends). But 20 years later, removed from the forum posts it was trying to parody, and it looks like an earnest exploration of late-90s electronica. Also, genres are fake.
- marc_abonce 3y ago> Several of the music genres were flat out made up I will always defend that buttrock is a real subgenre of psytrance. I don't care if Ishkur meant it as a joke or that nobody in the scene recognizes it.
- akarlsten 3y agoI conversely think it's much better that it's made by just one very opinionated person. Sure, one could argue that some stuff is "wrong" but does it really matter when it's all so arbitrary anyway? I'm more interested in Ishkur's take on things than 100% correctness. FWIW I also don't think artists themselves should be some kind of final arbiters on what genre their music is; "death of the author" and all that. Early italo disco musicians would probably not "correctly" categorize their music as something new and separate from the disco they were trying to emulate, for example.
- ethbr1 3y agoAbsolutely. Anyone should feel free to make "{HN handle's} Guide to Electronic Music" Ishkur has never been anything but transparent that these are 120% his own opinions. (Mostly ranting about white Europeans ripping off funk rhythms :D)
- poisonarena 3y agoHis old version was SO much better
- elevaet 3y agoSomeone has to be the critic: - Moombahton is shown as derived from Miami Bass, however it's a hybrid of Reggaeton and Dutch House. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moombahton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moombahton - Reggaeton is shown as being derived from R&B. It's much more of an offshoot of Dancehall. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dembow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dembow - House and Techno are shown as having independent roots, however they are deeply intertwined. - There is a big important relationship between Rap and Funk and R&B, and even Disco. missing here. - Why does Pendulum (a band) get a node on here? There is no such genre as Pendulum. - Missing genres that are fairly important (Halftime D&B, Jungle (not just Ragga Jungle)) - Lots of questionable genres on here (Freeland breaks? really? As in Adam Freeland?.. Come on no one ever talked about Freeland breaks as a distinct genre) Anyways this is pretty much an impossible task given the multidimensional relationships between all the genres, and an endless variety of perspectives and nomenclatures. So, great job Ishkur keep it up!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nightvoomer 3y ago-> House and Techno They are related and close in proximity (Detroit and Chicago), but you will see a lot of the older DJ and Producers from the era tell the story has Techno being inspired by the sounds of automobile industry in Detroit and House being a descendant of Disco with influences from New York.
- iamjackg 3y ago> Halftime D&B Isn't that Drumstep? If not, I'd love some examples because that sounds very much up my alley. > Why does Pendulum (a band) get a node on here? There is no such genre as Pendulum. The guide actually explains that if you click on the dot: "Pendulum is not the name of this genre. It's technically called Nu Jumpup or Nu Skool Jumpup but I call it Pendulum because Pendulum is more than just an artist or a genre. It is an event. It is one of those events that is so monumental that when people talk about history, they unconsciously draw a line between stuff that happened before the event and stuff that happened after (ie: "we are living in a post X world", where X is something earth-shattering like the atomic bomb or 9/11). We are witness to one of these life-changing events in Drum n Bass. Welcome to the Pendulum Age."
- tlrobinson 3y agoIshkur's Guide V1 is classic internet lore. I'm looking forward to AI models that can describe, classify, and recommend music. Obviously there's Shazam and things like Cyanite (https://cyanite.ai/ https://cyanite.ai/) but hopefully there will be some good open source models too shortly. You could imagine Ishkur's Guide V3 is constructed automatically by AI models, and places every track somewhere on the map, listing all the genres and influences, etc.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI dunno, I like the human touch; music genres aren't an exact science (is this blackened death metal or deathened black metal? Is there a difference?). I mean the data is there; see https://everynoise.com/ https://everynoise.com/, probably linked elsewhere, for a very big list of music genres + examples that IIRC come from Spotify's data lake. That can be used to train a model, I suppose.
- 8bitsrule 3y agoI'd like to see a recommendation program that trains on the many, many aspects of music itself that a person listens to. Rather than artists/labels/style slots/norms/years of release/charts ... it'd analyze your preferences in tempo, melody, harmony, instruments (type and number), vocal styles, novelty. (Getting started would take a while, say, over a month.) Then to refine its model, it'd have you rate some picks (old and new based on what it knows so far), and analyze how your responses fit its model. Would it get better faster for people who like a wide variety, or those with a few specialities?
- throwaway290 3y agoWhat you want is the model to be so advanced that it would probably be capable of just generating music. And actually if all you want is just similarly sounding music streaming into your ears then automatic generation is the natural continuation after automated recommendations.
- thefringthing 3y ago
- mmanfrin 3y agoI really wish someone would make a modern version. I've been listening to some french EDM for the last few years, artists like French 79, Point Point, Nhyx, N'to, and Spotify tells me this is 'french new touch' but I've never seen that genre described elsewhere, and when I tell people about it they have never heard of it. I feel like there's a better term.
- tra3 3y agoI like https://everynoise.com/ https://everynoise.com/ for this as well. It tells me French 79 is "French indietronica" whatever that is. You can branch out from here though.
- doctorhandshake 3y agoNever heard the term either but prob refers to the ‘French touch’ genre including daft punk, justice, stardust, et al
- rumblerock 3y agoHistorically French Touch was interchangeable with French House, dating back to late 90s origins (Daft Punk et. al.). IMO what Spotify calls New French Touch isn't really a genre unto itself, more just a broad encapsulation of modern electronic music, predominantly from France, that retains some of the original DNA – whether that's the technical aspects, disco-samples, family trees of producers / labels, etc. Colloquially I still just call it French House, even if that's technically inaccurate. The genre has evolved and been diluted with elements from other genres to the point of being extinct by its original definition, but the vibes live on :)
- tangwwwei 3y agotry using a mix of everynoise.com and the genre section of rateyourmusic.com
- PeterAndrewN 3y agoReally loved his breakdown and dismissal of "Electronica" as not a real genre in the original flash site. I can't find it here, maybe because the term died off somewhat?
- arshxyz 3y agoIt's there if you punch in "Electronica" in the searchbox. > 'Electronica' does not exist. Not as a genre or a description. It was coined by the North American music press to refer to the second wave of electronic music's explosion in the late 90s. Nearly every popular act of the period -- Daft Punk, Moby, Fatboy Slim, Prodigy, Chemical Brothers, Basement Jaxx, Tricky -- were marketed as 'Electronica' at one time or another, but the person who really popularized it was Madonna and her shallow William Orbit-produced piss-poor attempt at appropriating trance music as something she invented (Ray of Light). But there really isn't any actual thing called Electronica. It's just a corporate buzzword. This is a PSA from the official Electronic Music Genre Standards and Classifications Consortium.
- harry8 3y agoamusing since no genre is "real"
- bratwurst3000 3y agoIt’s ridiculously funny and obviously fake. Cmon German trance… anthem house.. hardcore gothic …
- mountainofdeath 3y agoI vaguely recall DI.FM having a similar map circa 2006, complete with descriptions of each genre.
- gkanai 3y agoDI.FM hosted Ishkur's site when the bandwidth bill was too large for him personally iirc.
- dang 3y agoRelated: Ishkur's Guide to Electronic Music - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26212706 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26212706 - Feb 2021 (9 comments) Iskhur's Guide to Electronic Music - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25083516 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25083516 - Nov 2020 (1 comment) Ishkur's Guide to Electronic Music - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20744571 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20744571 - Aug 2019 (71 comments)
- MenhirMike 3y agoPhilosphers <-> Drum n Bass Fans Calling themselves "junglists"
- arshxyz 3y agoHad no idea this existed and I'm grateful I came across this today. Clicked around a bit to see which Aphex Twin tracks were chosen — Xtal is there! Funny how typing "deadmau5" in the searchbar just returns "Who?". Reading the Info Panel for 8th Note Prog explains why that might be the case. Loved reading through the Info Panels and the FAQs but the UI is a bit clunky to work with. Is there an official dataset? Would love to try my hand at building a different UI around it.
- demondemidi 3y agoFunny I always start with searching for Subotnick and Derbyshire.
- arshxyz 3y agoFor anyone wondering if there is any subgenre that he seems to not vehemently dislike, French House seems to have a surprisingly charitable description. > ...every kick for just a fraction of a second, adding a new dimension of chunky French goodness. > French House is still around because anything this addictively funky will never die. Just like Disco.
- harry8 3y ago>Goa Trance is Trance music at its purest essence, where psychedelia could run wild and free unfettered from the societal norms and bland commercial anthems that corrupted other Trance scenes. Here, and only here, could the unchained spirits of rave roam as they were wont to do. And it is good.
- jamal-kumar 3y agoHe also really likes oldschool trance ("before the dutch got their hands on it"), acid, and italo disco
- batiudrami 3y agoAlso disco house! But the derision is part of the charm imo
- amatecha 3y agoWowwww, so many new entries since the last time I checked! Lots of new artists to check out... Very nice :D Ishkur's guide introduced me to so many styles of music I knew I immediately needed more of, like gabber (which I notice is now just lumped in with "hardcore"), techstep, darkpsy... to name a few!
- bichiliad 3y agoThis site gets better and better. Beyond even the mapping of genres, the write-ups for each genre are gold. Read the one for "Noise" if you're looking for somewhere fun to start.
- listenfaster 3y agoAnd there went my afternoon. "This guide favors authenticity over accuracy, and it aims to entertain before it informs. It is only as accurate as it feels it needs to be." A+
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- omnibrain 3y agoYou can access the original flash version here: https://ooooooooo.ooo/static/?c9faba4a-53dd-0e5d-1626-e9193e138d35 https://ooooooooo.ooo/static/?c9faba4a-53dd-0e5d-1626-e9193e...
- andruby 3y agoThank you! Let see if my kids find this as magical as I did
- justsomehnguy 3y agoSadly scrolling the textbox doesn't work (FF, Ruffle)
- 2f0ja 3y agowow, this is a fantastic experience to click around in. fun to think about how far (or sideways) we could extend this backwards. And excited to see where it extends to in the future :-)
- alisson_dover 3y agoWhile there are undoubtedly new genres since this was last updated, wonder if in general electronic music has entered an amalgamated stage with innovative producers blending genres into very idiosyncratic music that does not fall into a distinct genre. E.g. Clark, Max Cooper, Rival Consoles, Jon Hopkins, Arca are often described as "techno" or "electronica" but in a very broad sense. These descriptors are just umbrella terms. It's like describing both King Crimson and Blink-182 as "guitar music".
- jamal-kumar 3y agoThere was a really talented jazz artist named Austin Peralta who sadly passed away about a decade ago at a really young age from an opiate overdose who used to work alot with flying lotus and brainfeeder. I remember him calling it 'genre dissolution' back then
- notJim 3y agoI've had this feeling in general for music, it seems like genre walls are dissolving, and a lot of music is more of a blend. Some of it still classifiable, but almost all of it borrowing elements from other genres.
- fintechie 3y agoMythical. This used to be a flash site 20+ years ago. Some of these old tunes still give me goosebumps.
- Jagerbizzle 3y agoThe FAQ is absolutely hilarious and worth a read regardless of whether or not you care to utilize the guide.
- iampivot 3y agoOne of the oldest example of hand crafted vector databases?
- benkaiser 3y agoThe every noise at once site is also a great genre map I've sunk far too much time into: https://everynoise.com/ https://everynoise.com/
- softlayer 3y agoI've never understood why people prefer to use the term IDM rather than Braindance.
- Fluorescence 3y agoI am struck by how empty the timeline is from 2000s onward. It might be explained in part by Ishkur's own age / detachment. It matches my own experience but I expect I am a similar age. Is it true that there just aren't any major new genres and subcultures with music? I know people will respond with "I love new genre X" which will turn out to be a handful of bedroom djs on soundcloud. There needs to be some notability standard for a genre which IMHO is that there are multiple clubs that specialise in it and larger clubs have a regular night for it showing some general appeal. Anything else is just some micro-niche that should be categorised under an existing genre.
- srigi 3y agoI believe it is just outdated/not-updated. Atleast in DnB scene I can tell it is missing the recent "flavour" of liquid (melodic DnB with nice, mostly female vocals, see latest Subfocus album), or Crossbreed, very hard flavour od DnB, represented for example by Counterstrike.
- Fluorescence 3y agoLiquid DnB is there classed under Liquid Funk. Probably something different mind. Melodic female lead was always there in DnB e.g. Goldie's timeless. > latest Subfocus album I don't want to offend... but clicking through that... my god that is some nauseating garbage lol! The electronic aspect sounds like a typical 90s dnb video game menu background music and the vocals are the commercial dance music banality that cuts me like fingernails on a blackboard. You are allowed to call be grandad in return :) > Counterstrike Sounds like what I would hear at a typical dnb night back in the 90s that was on the harder side. Not sure why that counts as a new genre. Isn't it what Ishkur would call darkstep?
- leokennis 3y agoOne big development in "dance music" is the music coming from Africa. For example, Amapiano, Afrotech etc. So probably there are also still more subgenres popping up in areas of electronic music I do not follow/listen to. Therefore I think your impression that their absence "...might be explained in part by Ishkur's own age / detachment..." is correct.
- ivxvm 3y agoIt's interesting thing to explore when you already have a nice big picture, but overall it's quite misleading in case of genres (or whole branches) which author is not much into.
- secretsatan 3y agoI remember this one, but I've long since given up on trying to classify electronic music (or any other style), I just tell people I listen to electronica. I can't stand to use the terms EDM or Electro, they've become tainted.