7 ms·
Am I the only one that still finds SO to be quite useful? If I paste an error message into Google, it's still quite likely that the SO answer is the best one.
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
Am I the only one that still finds SO to be quite useful? If I paste an error message into Google, it's still quite likely that the SO answer is the best one. And if it doesn't, I contribute an answer if/when I eventually find it because I still think I get more out of SO than I put in. I've received 21 necromancer badges doing that.
- f6v 3y agoIt solves most of my issues. But I the problem for SO is that most helpful pages are from the past.
- mellosouls 3y agoChatGPT generally solves stuff quicker and more precisely for me. I have yet to receive a badge but could add that to the prompt or custom instructions as an alternative to its encouraging words when I'm nearly there.
- radicalbyte 3y agoIt does now. If StackOverflow stopped then it would certainly not be as useful in several years time.
- injidup 3y agoIt will just learn directly from the code suggestions it gives you. Did you use the suggestion it gave you? Did you fix it manually? Did you generate or write a test case that passed for the suggestion. There are many ways for such a system to learn.
- radicalbyte 3y ago..until the next generation comes along who have only ever learned to code with AI doing most of the work....
- sremani 3y agothe context ChatGPT provides around some of my error message inquiry is incredibly useful. on stack overflow, I have to read and discern the context.
- agumonkey 3y agothis is the whole value of GPT so far, they can pivot the structure and align it to the context at point
- antimora 3y agoFor finding answers, Stack Overflow may be useful, but for posting questions, it is not. I ceased posting questions a while ago due to the aggressive moderation, which often labeled my questions as duplicates or too common. I was very upset with the direction Stack Overflow had taken, as it seemed to embody the very criticisms it had once had about forums. The Stack Overflow community has lost its vibrancy and has become stagnant. I am pleased that platforms like ChatGPT are emerging as real competitors.
- crakhamster01 3y agoIs ChatGPT a competitor? I always viewed LLMs in this context as an interface for SO. They're not contributing new answers/code, right?
- trenchgun 3y agoIt bootstraps from the internet, including SO, but in fact they do have coders in house teaching it stuff: https://www.semafor.com/article/01/27/2023/openai-has-hired-an-army-of-contractors-to-make-basic-coding-obsolete https://www.semafor.com/article/01/27/2023/openai-has-hired-...
- crakhamster01 3y agoOh wow that's interesting, thanks for sharing! I thought that the value in today's LLMs comes from the wealth of "free" crowd-sourced answers online. It seems like OpenAI is trying to create more source material specifically for "basic coding", though I wonder how cost-effective that is in practice. Or effective in general, for that matter.
- d3w4s9 3y agoSuppose you are just learning C++ language. There is a syntax error or type mismatch. The error message is 50 lines long and it does not make any sense to you. You already spent 10 minutes on it. What do you do now? If there is an experienced C++ developer around who is happy to answer questions, great. Otherwise you are stuck with having to figure it out by using trial and errors and Google-fu. If you post it to a forum, it could take a while for anyone to respond. If you post it to stackoverflow, very likely nobody wants to look at your horrible code (natural for a beginner, you know), and your question gets downvoted. By contrast, ChatGPT can look at your code and explain very clearly what is wrong with it within seconds. This is just one example. And it's not only for beginners. I have found that ChatGPT can answer high-level questions in programming very well. The alternative would be searching for the Internet and sift through all the noise to find the answers as well.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- manonthewall 3y agoI love stack overflow, however I also hate it. I have asked some, I thought very reasonable question on there, and they got shot down and removed. The elitism, in this day & age of nearly infinite search and data storage capabilities makes me not feel all that sorry for them though. I do hate that we are doomed to AI generated trash answers on google now for at least a decade though.
- kzrdude 3y agoI sometimes contribute. There's a lot to be done on the Python side, because Python and libraries change faster than the answers do. "In theory" - I think at least - answers should be updated when new things become possible. A lot of answers used to be "you can't do that with X, do Y instead" and should now be updated to either, "You can do that with X" or "You have to use Z"..
- ggregoire 3y agoSame here. I look for answers about 10 times a day I'd say and in 90% of the cases I found what I was looking for, in a few seconds, for free. I also post answers when I found old questions and the answers are outdated or not complete. I know it helps other people cause I usually get 1-10 upvotes / year for those answers on old questions. Mostly about python, sql, postgres, js, react, aws and docker, so popular topics. I rarely have to post questions on my own, usually cause it's already asked and answered, or cause I'm experienced enough to find the solutions on my own or somewhere else. Anyway, have been using SO for 12 years and still think it's great.
- lokar 3y agoI’m curious what you are doing that leads you to lookup stuff 10 times a day.
- dmurray 3y agoI'm curious what kind of programming job you could have where you look up stuff less than 10 times a day.
- ahoka 3y agoSomething they are actually competent doing, I suppose.
- lokar 3y agoThat seems needlessly harsh. But, generally, yes, I tend to know the details of what I'm doing already. If anything I might check some API docs for a library.
- d3w4s9 3y agoIf much of your development is spent on implementing business logic in a language you are familiar with, and you have a decent IDE, I don't know what you use stackoverflow for at that frequency. Occasionally you may need to consult stackoverflow for a specific issue in string manipulation or API usage, but that's not something you run into a lot.
- Trufa 3y agoEvery time SO comes up on HN, I’m wondering what universe I live in where it’s such a useful site with strict guidelines that actually make it useful. Maybe it’s the bias of being there since the early days and really getting how to ask and answer questions.
- francisofascii 3y agoExactly. The biggest issue for me is duplicate questions, which is why mods are tough on new questions. 99.9% of the time the question has been asked. I also racked up a ton of necromancer badges doing what you do.
- kar5pt 3y agoFor Android development SO is pretty useless. I often find answers on there from <=2015. That's when Android 6 came out, its way too old to be relevant. But if you try to re-ask the same question they mark it as a duplicate.
- bhandziuk 3y agoI'm skeptical that if you ask a good question and the "duplicate"is so old that it's not relevant anymore that your question would be closed.
- IshKebab 3y agoI am not. The mods there absolutely love closing questions as duplicate. It has earned that reputation for a reason.
- Etherlord87 3y agoCan you give one example? I keep reading the negative comments about SO, how the moderators are bad, and there's never one example confirming it.
- drewnoakes 3y agoI've found that SO varies a lot by tech/language. In my experience, the C++ and JS subworlds are pretty brutal. C# is middle-of-the-road when it comes to culture. Clojure is very friendly and welcoming, but obviously more niche. This may explain why folks have different experiences on the same site.
- IshKebab 3y agoI agree. Rust is the worse by far in my experience. There's a couple of really prolific people on there (Shepmaster and Stargateur) who treat it as their personal fiefdom. Shepmaster does provide a ton of high quality answers but I don't think that gives them the right to be so unfriendly. Kind of ironic considering how the Rust community prides itself so much on being welcoming.
- catlover76 3y agoOf course not. It's still my first recourse if GPT-4 can't answer my question adequately.