26 ms·
Automakers invented the crime of jaywalking (2015)
- sandworm101 3y agoHow quickly we forget history. Horses were also lethal. Look at the number of people killed by horses, either being thrown from them, trampled by them, or run over by carts pulled by horses. Streets were not some utopic garden of pedestrian safety prior to cars. There were no jaywalking rules because society had evolved over thousands of years being rather acceptive of horse-related dangers. When the new device came around, no matter its relative danger, then new regulations were needed. There were once almost zero regs regarding candles, objects that killed thousands almost daily by fire. But soon after electricity came along then we suddenly needed rules to manage the new "dangerous" thing despite its use preventing untold thousands of deaths.
- swatcoder 3y agoActually, it wasn’t new technology — the 20th century saw a massive shift in expectations around health and safety and it reverberated through every part of life, regardless of whether new technology was involved. It had more to do with secular humanism almost fully supplanting diverse traditional value systems at the government level, and with capitalism’s insatiable hunger for living bodies that can produce and consume widgets.
- akira2501 3y agoRephrasing the headline for honesty: "Automakers accept the responsibility for the thing they've created and attempt to improve safety outcomes in a patchwork regulatory environment dominated by gridlock and disagreement."
- Fricken 3y agoQuite the opposite. Automakers passed the responsibility on to people who don't even drive.
- sandworm101 3y agoExcept for the speeding laws. And the red light/intersection/right-of-way laws. And the drunk driving laws. Those laws placed plenty of the responsibility on drivers.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoBut they did not make the cars inherently safer. A red light does not stop a driver from driving through a pedestrian crossing when people are there. Speeding laws do little for the bikers in unsegregated bike lanes, mere inches away from an inattentive driver.
- wredue 3y agoMaybe I’m just thinking outside of the box here, but how exactly do 3,000 lbs pieces of metal and glass become safer for people crossing the street in an addressable way by auto makers, when it’s the buyers demanding larger and larger vehicles? On segregated bike lanes, I’m afraid to tell you, cyclists don’t use them anyway, so why on earth should anyone focus on putting them in?
- alexanderchr 3y agoOh cyclists do use segregated lanes, they just have to be done properly. Primarily they need to be safer than sharing the road with heavy vehicles, something that most bike lines spectacularly fail at.
- maest 3y ago> cyclists don’t use them anyway This claim is so ridiculous is invalidates everything else you might be trying to argue, come on.
- wredue 3y agoMy dash cam filled with video of cyclists riding in a car lane beside a protected bike lane, and otherwise ignoring signage (stop and yield signs, signs stating road exceptions where bikes must use and share the sidewalk with pedestrians instead of the road) is definitely not ridiculous. Also hilariously “why do cyclists not use the bike lanes” is a top alternative question result when searching bike lanes. Clearly this is not some random anecdote. Cyclists frequently do not use the bike lanes, and I am absolutely not anywhere near the only person to observe this frequently. Never mind that: -Protected bike lane implementations often congest and slow traffic, which increases idling and carbon emissions no matter how many people say they’ll bike if it was safer. They won’t get their fat ass off out of bed 40 minutes earlier. You’re kidding yourself. -in colder climates, they’re useless for 50% of the year and exceptionally increase carbon footprints -some cities don’t actually observe reduced injuries from protected bike lanes (often because cyclists are extremely prone to ignoring the rules of the road), and cyclists disregard their own safety and get slapped by a turning vehicle, for example. We often see the excuse that “cars should pay more attention” and they should, but also, motorcyclists have built a sentiment that you have to “ride like you’re invisible”, whereas cyclists tend to “ride like you’re the king of the road”. This is not just a car problem, but an arrogant community with a lack of self preservation problem.
- tim333 3y agoThe UK has no jaywalking laws (apart from full motorways) and about 1/3 the pedestrian deaths of the US (https://usa.streetsblog.org/2020/10/10/exactly-how-far-u-s-street-safety-has-fallen-behind-europe-in-four-bombshell-charts https://usa.streetsblog.org/2020/10/10/exactly-how-far-u-s-s...). There are other ways to do things.
- seanr88 3y agoNo other country has anything to teach the USA. The USA is unique and special for a large number of reasons and so foreign methods won't work here. If I recall they even drive on the other side of the road in the UK, that will never catch on here.
- alexfoo 3y agoYou could phase it in slowly like Ireland did. Cars on a Monday. Lorries and HGVs switch on Wednesday. All remaining traffic on the Friday. Done!
- talideon 3y agoCitation, please?
- alexfoo 3y agohttps://www.engineersireland.ie/Engineers-Journal/Civil/could-ireland-emulate-sweden-and-switch-to-driving-on-the-right https://www.engineersireland.ie/Engineers-Journal/Civil/coul... (Note that it was a follow up to patently satirical parent comment, but it does remind me that Sweden made the change on 3rd Sep 1967)
- cfstras 3y agois this satire? I honestly can’t tell.
- talideon 3y ago
- moritzwarhier 3y agoI immediately thought of this as well (horse sleigh scene in Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment comes to mind, I mean, neither of us has experience with horse-first transportation, I assume). I just arrived at a different conclusion. To compare the number of people killed by automobiles and their infrastructure, compared to the numbers for people killed by horses (I can't give precise numbers for either, I'll admit that) - that comparison seems absurd to me. In other words, relative to the population in urban areas, I'd be very surprised if horses causes as many deaths as cars+roads.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoYou surely have to compare the rates per horse not per unit population.
- moritzwarhier 3y agodepends, I don't think it's even possible to have as many horses on earth as there are automobiles :)
- Tade0 3y agoWell, the "village idiot" was usually one not because he was born this way and his parents cared for him until adulthood, but because he got kicked by a horse/cow and survived, albeit with brain damage.
- turtlesdown11 3y ago> There were once almost zero regs regarding candles, objects that killed thousands almost daily by fire. "killed thousands almost daily"...source for this?
- Tade0 3y agoA modern equivalent of this is the death toll from kerosene heaters/lamps, which are considerably safer than candles: https://www.hindustantimes.com/kolkata/two-west-bengal-toddlers-charred-to-death-in-fire-started-by-kerosene-lamp/story-ATGBkfTwSyN60nv6IVmY4M.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/kolkata/two-west-bengal-toddl...
- inglor_cz 3y agoOne famous person who was killed by a horse cart was the Nobelist Pierre Curie. In 1906 no less, at the twilight of the long horse cart era.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sparrish 3y agoTo protect pedestrians... oh, those evil automakers.
- stuaxo 3y agoIn other countries we manage without this.
- stronglikedan 3y agoAnd thank goodness someone did. Although, my boss getting ticketed for walking across an empty downtown LA street just shows it's still ripe for abuse. And the most ironic part was the cop running his car up onto the sidewalk to jump out and write the ticket.
- leptons 3y agoCalifornia has a new jaywalking law https://www.cbs8.com/article/news/local/californias-new-2023-jaywalking-law/509-75b956b1-2965-430a-9940-4a1435c7d5f0 https://www.cbs8.com/article/news/local/californias-new-2023... "Starting Jan. 1, the Freedom to Walk Act officially becomes law, allowing pedestrians in California to jaywalk without fear of a ticket, as long as it's safe." Also, most people including police misunderstand how jaywalking works, or is intended to work. Nobody should be expected to walk a mile out of their way simply because that is where the only crosswalk is. Jaywalking is technically only possible near a crosswalk, so if the pedestrian was near a crosswalk but didn't use it, then that would be jaywalking. If the pedestrian is say half a mile from the nearest crosswalk, they are free to cross so long as they yield to oncoming traffic and don't cross dangerously.
- f4c39012 3y agothe perils of "big car"
- jowea 3y ago> A hundred years ago, if you were a pedestrian, crossing the street was simple: You walked across it. What about horses and carriages?
- paulryanrogers 3y agoYou looked both ways, and probably heard them coming even if not. You didn't get a ticket for not walking to the block corner.
- tzs 3y agoDeath rates from horse accidents were comparable to death rates from auto accidents nowadays [1] [2]. [1] https://www.bmj.com/rapid-response/2011/10/31/cars-and-horses https://www.bmj.com/rapid-response/2011/10/31/cars-and-horse... [2] https://legallysociable.com/2012/09/07/figures-more-deaths-per-capita-in-horse-accidents-in-nyc-in-1900-than-in-auto-accidents-today/ https://legallysociable.com/2012/09/07/figures-more-deaths-p...
- pengaru 3y agoPSA: On January 1, 2023, jaywalking became legal in California with the Freedom to Walk Act, reversing what was once one of the strictest laws against this practice in the country. Now, pedestrians can cross the road at places other than intersections and crosswalks without penalty.
- rurban 3y agoBecause of this incident: https://abcnews.go.com/US/california-cops-scrutiny-teens-jaywalking-arrest-caught-video/story?id=33861780 https://abcnews.go.com/US/california-cops-scrutiny-teens-jay...
- pengaru 3y agoHere's the letter of the bill as well: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220AB2147 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...
- cjensen 3y agoThe Library of Congress has a great film taken from the front of a cable car in pre-fire San Francisco [1]. It's absolutely terrifying to see how unsafe the streets were. It wasn't just cars either: horse-drawn carts dart in and out of traffic just as cars did, pedestrians cross at-will in front of all vehicles, and at one points kids mess about jumping on the back of vehicles. It's obvious major regulation was needed, and not just for pedestrians. Pretend cars didn't exist on that street for a moment and think about the changes needed to make it safe: carts needed lanes and rules for changing lanes, cable cars needed dedicated lanes, intersections needed a system to allow traffic from multiple directions, and pedestrians were being a bit too free with their judgement calls. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uINgSqEU26A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uINgSqEU26A
- paldepind2 3y agoVery interesting video. Thanks for sharing. It looks a bit chaotic but honestly not _that_ unsafe to me as everything is going quite slow. It reminds me a bit of the idea of "shared space" which is a recent concept that is actually claimed to make streets safer.
- ilaksh 3y agoI think it comes down to things like speed. If we accept that the road is a place to be able to quickly move a lot of vehicles, then that just isn't a safe place for pedestrians. If we go back to lower speeds then maybe it could be manageable in a same way. But as it is actually used now for 3000 pound vehicles to zoom about in, it makes no sense for pedestrians to be intersecting and sharing the space at all. Just due to the physics of collisions between a person and a vehicle. I don't think slow vehicles is a good solution because we do need to get places. I think an actual good (but very expensive) solution is for new cities to be designed differently in several ways. One of which is for roads to be only for small autonomous vehicles and entirely separate from pedestrian paths. To make that reasonably practical you need some other core assumptions to be changed. And also a totally new development probably.
- 3y ago
- jcynix 3y agoIf you cross the street "near" a red traffic light, that costs you 5€ in Germany. If you admit that you did it intentionally, the ticket price doubles. Happened to my wife some years ago when walking to a bus stop on the other side of the street. How did the cop know that it was intentional? She remarked that there was no car in sight, neither left nor right, on a straight road in town. Oh, and what's the definition of "near" you may ask? While in Germany almost everything is regulated in detail, the definition of "near" is up to the cop. ObJoke: it's midnight somewhere in Europe and no car in sight, but some people are waiting for the traffic light to turn green? You can bet that these are Germans ;-0
- macleginn 3y agoAs many other aspects of the German ethos, this seems to be dying away. I live near Stuttgart, jaywalking is rampant, and nobody cares; in two years, I haven’t seen a traffic cop anywhere except for accident sites.
- watwut 3y agoIt was not near crossing, surely :) But like, German do not actually respect all the posted rules. Nec ver did.
- Detrytus 3y ago[flagged]
- thenewwazoo 3y agoIs this comment an assertion of the truth of Great Replacement theory, i.e. disgusting Nazi propaganda? Because that is how it reads.
- quantified 3y agoYes, you're downvoted but correct.
- nerdjon 3y agoI am all for a pedestrian focused city, BUT cars will likely never fully disappear for emergencies, shipments, and people with disabilities. In this particular situation I feel like while the Automakers had ulterior motives it was ultimately a net good. Pretty sure we know who will win in in a car vs a human body. Also as much as I do believe in pedestrian focused cities, that isn't the norm in the US and likely will never be and will instead of smaller pockets (I mean it just makes sense given how large the country is). We should have more car free zones, but where we have to share the space it makes sense. I am not going to sit here on a high horse and say I don't jay walk. But I do it knowing the risks.
- stuaxo 3y agoIn other places cars are supposed to stop for pedestrians even on non crossings, in practice the penalties for hitting and killing them are way lower than killing a person in another situation.
- nerdjon 3y agoPedestrians should also take responsibility for acting dangerously. To me it's the same if a driver cuts in front of me and then slams on their brakes, there was nothing I could have done about crashing into them no matter how safely I was driving. If a person runs in front of a moving vehicle it shouldn't be the driver responsible if they basically cut the car off. A car can't stop on a dime. Drivers should be held responsible if they were clearly driving in an unsafe manner, but we have the share the space somehow.
- JWLong 3y ago> To me it's the same if a driver cuts in front of me and then slams on their brakes, there was nothing I could have done about crashing into them no matter how safely I was driving. It shouldn't be. The risk to you is much greater if you hit another car, than if you hit a pedestrian. Addtionally, while you are right that a car can't stop on a dime, speeds have a large influence on the size of coin needed for a car to come to a complete stop. And I think we both know that they are not linear. Over the decades, posted speed limits in North America have only increased. https://www.brake.org.uk/files/images/Speed/Infographics/_large/6819/Speed-Stopping-distances-infographic.jpg https://www.brake.org.uk/files/images/Speed/Infographics/_la...
- csswizardry 3y agoAs a Brit, ‘jaywalking’ is so alien to me. I once jaywalked in front of a police car who stopped and waved/signalled me across the road! Whenever I’m overseas, crossing anywhere when the road is clear is second nature to me and I have to remind myself not to. Conversely, you can always spot a foreigner in the UK: they’re the ones waiting for the signal at a deserted crossing at 2am.
- leni536 3y agoTo be fair in the UK pedestrian traffic lights at intersections are absolutely horrible, feels like they are never ever green.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoThere are not many countries in Europe that have jaywalking laws. Only Germany and Poland come to mind.
- input_sh 3y agoI'd say the most common rule across Europe would be "you can cross anywhere as long as you're not within X meters of a crosswalk". As in if there is one within your line of sight, it's there for a reason and you should use it. If there isn't one, cross away.
- xyzelement 3y agoIn the US this is very regional. In NYC, you never weight a light. In places like Seattle (just as one example) and lots of other places, it's considered very rude to not wait.
- kzrdude 3y agoI'll defend the waiting people: If I don't know the city or country that well, then I'm more careful.
- retrac 3y agoWorth pointing out that "jaywalking" is not a universal crime. There are jurisdictions in the USA where it's legal. And it's legal here in Canada. Even the term stands out -- I'm familiar with "jaywalking" but you only use a term for it if it's illegal. We just call it "crossing the street", or "impeding the flow of traffic", depending how you do it. (It's not exactly a free for all: in Ontario there is still a requirement for pedestrians to use pedestrian crossings, and to follow stop lights, where those are installed.) There are too many cases where it's perfectly safe and reasonable to do that I see any sense in making it illegal. But it is, to be fair, very dangerous in some cases. It's hard to judge how fast a car is moving, sometimes you simply don't see one coming at you. Toronto Police call this a "mid-block crossing", and in the city, they account for a significant % of all pedestrian fatalities, particularly at night, and in busy traffic.
- flockonus 3y agoDefinitely not true for Canada as a whole, i know of several people who got jaywalking tickets in BC. Example: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/jaywalkers-curb-jumpers-be-warned-police-are-watching-1.4412760 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/jaywalkers-c...
- retrac 3y agoYes, not obeying pedestrian signalling is one of the exceptions. I'd say that's fairly reasonable -- if people cross freely against indicators it messes with the flow of traffic. I've only seen this actually enforced with examples like in the article, outside a busy transit station.
- seanr88 3y agoEven the concept that the flow of traffic is more important than the pedestrian's flow is indicative of the change in attitude. Somehow the car has come to be most important while the pedestrian is a nuisance. Both own and pay for the road but the pedestrian is a second class citizen (obviously some people will moan on about road tax and fuel tax, but these taxes don't come close to paying for the road infrastructure, I doubt they would even pay the rent on the area dedicated to roads in one major city - say NYC).
- trothamel 3y agoNote that like most laws, Jaywalking laws tend to make more sense when you read them. Here's the law in New York: https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/2015/vat/title-7/article-27/1152 https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/2015/vat/title-7/artic... 1152. Crossing at other than crosswalks. (a) Every pedestrian crossing a roadway at any point other than within a marked crosswalk or within an unmarked crosswalk at an intersection shall yield the right of way to all vehicles upon the roadway. (b) Any pedestrian crossing a roadway at a point where a pedestrian tunnel or overhead pedestrian crossing has been provided shall yield the right of way to all vehicles upon the roadway. (c) No pedestrian shall cross a roadway intersection diagonally unless authorized by official traffic-control devices; and, when authorized to cross diagonally, pedestrians shall cross only in accordance with the official traffic-control devices pertaining to such crossing movements. So what's criminalized isn't crossing the road - it's crossing without checking. Which seems like a good idea to me. Looking on the other side of the spectrum, Wyoming's law is: (a) Every pedestrian crossing a roadway at any point other than within a marked crosswalk or within an unmarked crosswalk at an intersection shall yield the right-of-way to all vehicles upon the roadway. (b) Any pedestrian crossing a roadway at a point where a pedestrian tunnel or overhead pedestrian crossing has been provided shall yield the right-of-way to all vehicles upon the roadway. (c) Between adjacent intersections at which traffic-control signals are in operation pedestrians shall not cross at any place except in a marked crosswalk. (d) No pedestrian shall cross a roadway intersection diagonally unless authorized by official traffic-control devices. When authorized to cross diagonally, pedestrians shall cross only in accordance with the official traffic-control devices pertaining to the crossing movements. Which is similar, except for (c), which only matters when you're close to a crosswalk - and almost certainly, on a busy road.
- black_13 3y ago[dead]
- jeremy_wiebe 3y agoMy issue, as a driver, is that more and more pedestrians walk wherever and whenever they want with complete disregard for their environment. I’ve had to hit the brakes pretty hard on several occasions when I had “right of way” (right turn light, for example) and a pedestrian stepped off the curb with their face buried in their phone. I see the fines for jaywalking as a function to encourage safety rather than criminalizing sensible behaviour (ie crossing a completely empty street probably won’t yield a fine but crossing a busy street while holding your arm out to stop traffic will, and should).
- Vinnl 3y agoThen again, the only reason that that's particularly dangerous is because of the car. Such behaviour in front of a bike, for example, would ve annoying but not really dangerous.
- mcbutterbunz 3y agoIt would be more dangerous for the cyclist.
- Vinnl 3y agoWhen a pedestrian and a cyclist collide, it would be more dangerous for the cyclist indeed, I think. But it would be less dangerous for the cyclist, than it would be for a pedestrian to collide with a car. And of course, in the former case, it's the person who chose the riskier mode of transport who assumes the risk.
- peoplefromibiza 3y agobike brakes are usually pretty terrible though
- joshuahaglund 3y agoMaybe yours but not most people I know who use their bike frequently. Maintaining a bike is cheaper and easier than maintaining a car.
- jcpst 3y agoWhere I live in the US, people simply do not stop at pedestrian crosswalks. It doesn’t matter that there’s a large fluorescent sign, and bold white stripes on the road, and a person waiting to cross. I’ve even had a police officer drive straight through while I was waiting to cross. But it seems like they’re respected if you install large flashing lights that the pedestrian can activate.
- alexfoo 3y agoIn the UK the law is sufficiently vague. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1997/2400/part/I/crossheading/movement-of-traffic-at-crossings/made https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1997/2400/part/I/crosshe... “ Precedence of pedestrians over vehicles at Zebra crossings 25.—(1) Every pedestrian, if he is on the carriageway within the limits of a Zebra crossing, which is not for the time being controlled by a constable in uniform or traffic warden, before any part of a vehicle has entered those limits, shall have precedence within those limits over that vehicle and the driver of the vehicle shall accord such precedence to any such pedestrian. “ The point is that simply waiting to cross you are not “on the carriageway” and therefore the driver of the vehicle is not required to stop (by some reading of the law). Common custom is that you do stop for people waiting to cross but sometimes you really do have to stick a foot into the road to make people stop for you and allow you to cross.
- switch007 3y agoRight But the Highway Code says drivers MUST stop if the pedestrian is /on/ the crossing: > you MUST give way when a pedestrian has moved onto a crossing This should be sufficient to make drivers understand that you give way to pedestrians at zebra crossings
- willsmith72 3y agoI like to act like I'm about to start crossing and only stop at the last possible moment in these cases. That way at least 50% of the time they or someone else in the car freaks out. I hope it teaches them. Even if you can't see anyone, if there's a pedestrian crossing, especially in an urban area, just slow down in case.
- dang 3y agoRelated. Others? The Invention of ‘Jaywalking’ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33825009 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33825009 - Dec 2022 (4 comments) California greenlights jaywalking. It’s a step in the right direction - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33769009 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33769009 - Nov 2022 (107 comments) Jaywalking is decriminalized in California under new law - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33077573 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33077573 - Oct 2022 (6 comments) What does a guy have to do to get a jaywalking ticket in this town? (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29135602 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29135602 - Nov 2021 (6 comments) Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto industry made it a crime - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25497772 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25497772 - Dec 2020 (438 comments) “Jaywalking” Shouldn't Even Be a Thing - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22050973 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22050973 - Jan 2020 (3 comments) Jaywalking: How the car industry outlawed crossing the road - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18187751 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18187751 - Oct 2018 (2 comments) How Automakers Invented the Crime of “Jaywalking” - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16158918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16158918 - Jan 2018 (424 comments) The Invention of Jaywalking - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14246003 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14246003 - May 2017 (1 comment) California's Broken Jaywalking Law - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9384972 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9384972 - April 2015 (65 comments) How automakers invented the crime of “jaywalking” - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8893738 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8893738 - Jan 2015 (189 comments) The Invention of Jaywalking - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3888104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3888104 - April 2012 (81 comments)
- orangepurple 3y agoA technological advance that appears not to threaten freedom often turns out to threaten it very seriously later on. For example, consider motorized transport. A walking man formerly could go where he pleased, go at his own pace without observing any traffic regulations, and was independent of technological support-systems. When motor vehicles were introduced they appeared to increase man’s freedom. They took no freedom away from the walking man, no one had to have an automobile if he didn’t want one, and anyone who did choose to buy an automobile could travel much faster and farther than a walking man. But the introduction of motorized transport soon changed society in such a way as to restrict greatly man’s freedom of locomotion. When automobiles became numerous, it became necessary to regulate their use extensively. In a car, especially in densely populated areas, one cannot just go where one likes at one’s own pace one’s movement is governed by the flow of traffic and by various traffic laws. One is tied down by various obligations: license requirements, driver test, renewing registration, insurance, maintenance required for safety, monthly payments on purchase price. Moreover, the use of motorized transport is no longer optional. Since the introduction of motorized transport the arrangement of our cities has changed in such a way that the majority of people no longer live within walking distance of their place of employment, shopping areas and recreational opportunities, so that they HAVE TO depend on the automobile for transportation. Or else they must use public transportation, in which case they have even less control over their own movement than when driving a car. Even the walker’s freedom is now greatly restricted. In the city he continually has to stop to wait for traffic lights that are designed mainly to serve auto traffic. In the country, motor traffic makes it dangerous and unpleasant to walk along the highway. (Note this important point that we have just illustrated with the case of motorized transport: When a new item of technology is introduced as an option that an individual can accept or not as he chooses, it does not necessarily REMAIN optional. In many cases the new technology changes society in such a way that people eventually find themselves FORCED to use it.) While technological progress AS A WHOLE continually narrows our sphere of freedom, each new technical advance CONSIDERED BY ITSELF appears to be desirable. Electricity, indoor plumbing, rapid long-distance communications ... how could one argue against any of these things, or against any other of the innumerable technical advances that have made modern society? It would have been absurd to resist the introduction of the telephone, for example. It offered many advantages and no disadvantages. Yet, as we explained in paragraphs 59-76, all these technical advances taken together have created a world in which the average man’s fate is no longer in his own hands or in the hands of his neighbors and friends, but in those of politicians, corporation executives and remote, anonymous technicians and bureaucrats whom he as an individual has no power to influence. [21] The same process will continue in the future. Take genetic engineering, for example. Few people will resist the introduction of a genetic technique that eliminates a hereditary disease. It does no apparent harm and prevents much suffering. Yet a large number of genetic improvements taken together will make the human being into an engineered product rather than a free creation of chance (or of God, or whatever, depending on your religious beliefs). Another reason why technology is such a powerful social force is that, within the context of a given society, technological progress marches in only one direction; it can never be reversed. Once a technical innovation has been introduced, people usually become dependent on it, so that they can never again do without it, unless it is replaced by some still more advanced innovation. Not only do people become dependent as individuals on a new item of technology, but, even more, the system as a whole becomes dependent on it. (Imagine what would happen to the system today if computers, for example, were eliminated.) Thus the system can move in only one direction, toward greater technologization. Technology repeatedly forces freedom to take a step back, but technology can never take a step back—short of the overthrow of the whole technological system.
- chung8123 3y agoThis is like saying automakers destroyed the trolly system. It was the people that did this by popular opinion. Most people in the US use cars, like the convenience of cars, and will vote in a car centric manner. Blaming automakers is just absolving the people of blame.
- tmnvix 3y agoYou should be thankful it was just jaywalking. In Kaplan, Louisiana they've now made the simple act of walking after 11pm illegal. https://www.klfy.com/local/vermilion-parish/kaplan-starts-permanent-curfew-against-late-night-walking-and-bike-traffic/ https://www.klfy.com/local/vermilion-parish/kaplan-starts-pe...
- frob 3y agoHoly crap! That article is full of low-level facistic quotes: > “I was approached by a couple of citizens asking if there was anything we could do about certain people walking around at night riding their bicycles,” "Certain people" > “The curfew would more or less be at the officer’s discretion,” Cool, so you're explicitly giving cops a legal reason to harass people if the cop thinks they looks suspicious. I can't see how any subconscious or overt bigotry could come into play here. > “The chief noticed a big influx of bicycle traffic during the night and people walking around, [...] It’s not usually a good thing when that happens." > "Louisiana is a stop-and-identify state, so that ordinance is not really to hurt anybody it’s just to stop these people walking that have no reason to be walking,” Yup! Sure doesn't hurt you at all for your existence to be criminalized and your mere presence on the street to be probable cause for the cops to harass you. > "There’s a fraction of people that believe that is infringing on people’s rights, but at the same time, I think people can sit back and put a little perspective on the situation and agree that the good simply has to pay for the bad right now,” Something, something, possibly apocryphal quite about trading freedom for security and deserving neither. > "that ordinance is not really to hurt anybody it’s just to stop these people walking that have no reason to be walking,” Sir! Step back and lie on the ground! Your feet are a threat to the State of Louisiana! I'm going to need to confiscate them and you along with them. Fuck these fascists and the spineless politicians who enable them.
- andix 3y agoAs a European I never really got what "jaywalking" is. We just cross the streets whenever we want and whenever it's safe. It's not allowed on motorways off course, but they usually have fences, so you can't do that anyway. In some countries you need to use a pedestrian crossing if there is one within 20-50m.
- gooseyman 3y agoMy experience in Germany was very different. I walked across a street without the walking man and people looked at me like I was naked.
- andix 3y agoIf there is are traffic lights and they are red, you're not allowed to walk. Germans really seem to care about those rules, in many other countries people also walk on red lights if there are no cars coming, and nobody cares.
- oldbbsnickname 3y agoAutomakers are also directly and/or indirectly responsible for the destruction of American local mass transit and the dysfunctional regression in urban planning* towards inefficient suburbanization. * It wasn't unplanned. It was the purposeful design of city planners who failed to take into account unintended externalities including gridlock, pollution, and cost.
- seoulmetro 3y ago[flagged]
- quantified 3y ago"Who Framed Roger Rabbit" is a great introduction, its characters are fictional but the story is somewhat true.
- voisin 3y agoI’ve heard several times but never verified that trees aren’t planted on boulevards anymore because of automaker lobbying. Something about drunk drivers might hit them. As if driver preference, even drunk drivers, should supersede the public interest.
- bobbylarrybobby 3y agoI've also read that drivers drive faster on streets without trees than those with because they feel more open
- sircastor 3y agoThe same is the case with islands between lanes. The lanes aren’t actually smaller, but they feel smaller because the space looks like it’s contracting. And they’re much nicer in a neighborhood than speed humps
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoDon't forget how transportation has been one of the key areas of conflict for racial integration and has been used again and again to ensure that black and brown people did not have access to certain areas of cities. Robert Moses being the most egregious direct example, but Plessy v Ferguson enshrining racist segregationist laws around transportation which then provided precedent to spread to other segregationist laws.
- isykt 3y agoMy neighborhood was built pre-cars, and it shows. The sidewalks are narrow, so everyone walks in the street. If you’re a lucky motorist, we might move over and let you pass. If it’s dark, or snowy, or raining, or the pedestrian is wearing headphones and doesn’t notice you behind them… forget it. You’ll have to drive slowly until the pedestrian reaches their destination or turns out of your path. I wouldn’t have it any other way.
- neilparikh 3y agoMany streets in parts of Asia (Korea and Taiwan for example) are similar. A majority of the "side" roads just don't have sidewalks, and people walk on the road. I was a little nervous the first few times I encountered it (having grown up in very car oriented suburbs and then lived in Canadian downtowns after that), but it definitely grew on me.
- frankzinger 3y agoAs a motorcyclist I wish jaywalking was a crime in my country. Here people step out in front of you out of nowhere. A collision with a pedestrian would ruin my year at least if it didn't kill me.
- evanjrowley 3y agoIf you don't like this law, then come to Baltimore. Civil disobedience is practiced widely. Car drivers are constantly under threat of random people walking right in front of them without looking.