4 ms·
The headline is not supported by the article. The actual truth of the article comes in the middle: > Borrowers who use autopay pay off between 8% and 17% less
by crazygringo 3y ago
The headline is not supported by the article. The actual truth of the article comes in the middle:
> Borrowers who use autopay pay off between 8% and 17% less of their monthly credit-card balances compared with customers who make manual payments, according to the study... When credit-card customers sign up for autopay, they typically have three options for monthly payments: the required minimum, the statement balance in full or a custom amount. Most people who enroll in autopay choose either the minimum payment or full balance, said Wang.
In other words, if you're already in the financial position to set it to full balance, then you're doing great, and autopay isn't making you worse at anything.
While if you set it to minimum payment, your financial position is obviously not great, and you're paying more in interest. But there's no evidence autopay is the cause here. Your lack of money is the cause.
If you're somewhere in the middle where you can pay more than the minimum but not the full balance, obviously you're not using autopay, because the amount probably changes each month based on what's left over from your other expenses.
The idea that autopay is the cause of not paying your bills is absurd. Causality runs in the other direction -- people who are already among the worst-off and can only afford the minimum, turn on autopay. (As well as those who can afford the full balance, of course.)
- Rapzid 3y agoI auto-pay with minimal and log in at the beginning of every month and pay the full balances.
- CydeWeys 3y agoWhy though? Are you actually paying the full statement balance in time each month this way and this avoiding interest charges? If so, then by paying before the due date you're giving away money unnecessarily, especially with interest rates at 5% now.
- michaelmior 3y agoNot the OP, but the most likely reason I can think of is manual payments give an opportunity to review all charges. But still having the minimum set to autopay ensures that if you forget or unable to, the consequences are less severe.
- Rapzid 3y agoYes this is exactly it. I like to review stuff and typically don't keep a large cash balance. An expensive month could 5x or more my spend; maybe I just paid for an overseas vacation, my home owners and auto insurance is hitting, and whatever all in the same month. Want to make sure everything is in place before kicking off the payments.
- alexfoo 3y agoI do as the GP, autopay the minimum to avoid fines (not just interest) but then go in and pay the remaining balance before the end of the month. Autopaying the full amount would work 95% of the time, except when I put something like a big holiday on my card and autopay pays the entire balance and the payment either fails because I forgot to have sufficient funds in my debit/checking account, or leaves me with very little whilst I wait for the money that was going to come in to pay for it.
- lolinder 3y agoBut if you're going to check it every month anyway, why have the backstop be the minimum payment and not the full payment? You don't lose the right to dispute a charge just because autopay paid the statement off, and setting it to pay in full means you won't be charged any interest at all if you forget to check one month.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoIf I autopay the full amount before realizing there's a fraudulent $1,000 charge on my card, then I'm in for a surprise when an extra $1,000 is missing from my checkout account. A pending fraudulent charge on my credit card isn't a problem. Cash missing from my bank account until the investigation is complete CAN be a problem.
- sagarkamat 3y agoBut there are usually 25 days between when a statement is generated and an Autopay is deducted for that statement. Just have your checkup of the statement scheduled between those 25 days
- ganoushoreilly 3y agoSame, it's a good fallback in case you forget to login and make that payment.
- rqtwteye 3y agoWhy would you do that?
- lazide 3y agoSo they psychologically notice and feel the amount spent perhaps?
- adamredwoods 3y agoSafety net in case it is forgotten. With children and life getting in the way, it is easy to forget some bills.
- boc 3y agoThis seems less efficient/more dangerous than simply asking for mailed statements and then auto-paying the full balance. They'll deliver you a physical statement in the mail for you to look through/digest, and you aren't risking missing a month and paying interest.
- clockwork-dev 3y agoWith higher interest rates, I stopped paying the full balance and instead try squeezing a little extra interest out of the money (I buy USFR, which is giving around 5.3% right now). I still pay the statement balance of course.
- landemva 3y agoDoes USFR have principal risk? The price of USFR appears to fluctuate.
- cwilby 3y agoWell said.
- michaelmior 3y ago> If you're somewhere in the middle where you can pay more than the minimum but not the full balance, obviously you're not using autopay… That's not obvious to me. Just because someone can pay more than the minimum balance, doesn't mean that they do. I think that's one case where autopay could cause someone to run up unnecessary interest. A person may know that they can't pay the full bill, so they set up autopay to make sure they at least pay the minimum. However, someone poor at managing their finances might have gone in to pay more than the minimum if autopay wasn't available. But since it's set to autopay, they might not bother to make any additional payments. This isn't necessarily caused by autopay, but you could argue that if autopay didn't exist, some fraction of people who are currently paying the minimum balance, might have paid down balances more quickly. I don't hav any particular evidence to support this, but it seems plausible enough to me not to be dismissed out of hand.
- rqtwteye 3y agoI think the problem is the term "minimum payment". A lot of people don't seem to understand that this is a basically arbitrary number. They will make them same mistake without autopay.
- jimt1234 3y agoI once worked with a company developing a payday loan app. We interviewed hundreds of people with money problems. It was amazing how many people thought the minimum payment was the payment. I tried to explain to a handful of folks that it was possible to pay more than the minimum payment and that would help lower the balance. Lots of blank stares, then "But it says the payment is $50; why would I pay them more than I owe?" All the people I talked to seemed like good people, but the lack of basic financial knowledge was shocking to me. Not as shocking as the payday loan industry, though. But that's a different topic. (If you're in the payday loan industry, quit now. Start dealing meth, you'll be doing the world a favor.)
- orev 3y agoI’m surprised that you’re surprised about this. Credit card bills are the original dark pattern. Every other bill you receive has a single number in a box that says “pay this amount”, and when you pay that amount, you’re done. But with credit card bills, the number in the “pay this” box doesn’t mean you’re done, it means that you’re going to keep paying forever. It took a literal act of Congress (CARD Act - 2009) to force them to add the disclosure to the bill that making the minimum payment would increase the time and interest you’d be paying.
- lazide 3y agoOr, that autopay allows people to not look at the credit card bill (or directly pay it) psychologically allowing people to ignore it easier and spend more than they’re making? Which isn’t really an autopay issue, so much as an ‘enabled by autopay’ issue.
- timerol 3y agoSome people are just bad at managing finances. I had a loved one who racked up $10k in credit card debt because autopay was set to pay the minimum payment. The payments were low enough that they thought they had more money than they did, and adjusted their spending accordingly. Eventually the interest caught up with their monthly expenses, and they came to me confused and overwhelmed. I helped them consolidate the debt and changed the setting to "full statement balance" - it's now been over a year with no issue. (We talk finances monthly to confirm that everything's still going smoothly.) Manually paying would have caught the issue before it snowballed. Setting up autopay for the full statement balance in the first place would have entirely prevented the issue, as the extra money went entirely to luxuries that they thought they could afford.
- fdye 3y agoAgree this is a UX problem. They need an option, "Pay minimum + X amount each month" so a user could set it to be $25 for their min + $50 to pay down a bit of the balance. This is actually the prescribed way most places recommend to repair or keep a high credit score. If you pay it entirely off you get dinged, if you just pay minimums you get dinged.
- redblacktree 3y agoHow do you get dinged for paying it off entirely? I pay all my credit cards in their entirety each month, and it has not seemed to ding my credit score.
- inetknght 3y agoAs I understand it, your credit score isn't dinged per-se, but it doesn't increase as much as it would if you carried a balance. Remember that credit scores try to score your credit worthiness: are you capable of paying off a balance. How can that be measured if you never have a balance? Instead it simply appears that you have a lot of available credit without ever using it.
- kccqzy 3y agoYou are incredibly confused about terminology here. You have a balance. And then you let Autopay pay it off in full by the due date, which is after the balance appears on your statement and after the balance is reported to credit bureaus. You still don't carry a balance. What you are describing (having zero balance reported) is called cycling the credit limit. This is indeed a dangerous behavior that can not only affect your credit score but also lead to account closures. Don't do it.
- redblacktree 3y agoI wasn't aware that this was a bad thing. I have a couple of "business" credit cards that I use to segregate purchases for some sole proprietorships that I run. (as well as for the rewards, of course) There are occasionally months where I need to spend beyond the credit limit, and I pay the card early in order to do so. I had no inkling that this could be considered a problem.
- charlie0 3y agoIn other words, water is wet and people who are financially illiterate/irreponsible will continue making bad financial choices, no matter what tools are available to help aid them.
- m463 3y agoIsn't that a like like saying people are irresponsible when they fall for dark patterns? This involves money and profit. Privacy policies involve money and profit. In both cases, there are clear financial incentives to make things confusing to the benefit of the financial institution. Because credit cards got so bad, they added "nutrition labels" by law. These are the required disclosures that take about APRs, penalties, grace periods, fees and minimum finance charges, etc
- landemva 3y agoA broader look at credit card industry, for those who can pay off monthly balance, is those people use it to get more points than they would with the debit card attached to the checking account where the funds sit for the autopay. Rewards and benefits on debit cards are low or nonexistent due to regulatory pressure in USA to have lower network processing fees than credit cards. Europe has lower card network fees than USA, so there are fewer rewards cards available.