5 ms·
Android devices with backdoored firmware found in US schools
- neilv 3y agoFrom the original report, linked to by this article: > A Chinese manufacturer (possibly many manufacturers) builds a wide variety of Android-based devices, including phones, tablets, and CTV boxes. At some point between the manufacturing of these products and their delivery to resellers, physical retail stores and e-commerce warehouses, a firmware backdoor— based on Triada malware—gets installed and the product boxes are sealed in plastic, priming these devices for fraud on arrival at their destination. Isn't it OK to name that manufacturer and affected brands? US brands deal all the time with dilution due to counterfeits made in sketchy factories. Why protect the manufacturer/brands in this one case? Especially when there's a particularly problematic supply chain problem involving the manufacturer, and to which they might be especially vulnerable (if not complicit or even the perpetrator)? In addition to the obvious reason of providing negative feedback to parties involved and in a position to improve, the last sentence of the article demonstrates how not naming them hurts legitimate but lesser-known/upstart brands who are not involved and who don't deserve the negative feedback: > recommending that users choose familiar brands when purchasing new products.
- vuln 3y agoThe Non-US company will just keep shipping under a different brand name. It’s akin to playing wack a mole. Any US Companies targeting the US education system as clients comes with insane markup (anything iPad). The US based companies are still going to data collect (see chromebooks) the schools are so underfunded, their only choice is to use cheap Non-US knock offs.
- parker_mountain 3y agoMicrosoft charges next to nothing, and even subsidizes hardware, for edu MDM'd devices. Basic services are more expensive than enterprise, but not by much. The second you want any educational specific SKUs, though, holy shit.
- pyeri 3y agoI think Microsoft, Github and many other companies also provide many free/subsidized services to those who can prove they're students, that includes even web hosting on AWS or digital ocean IIRC. Even leaving those aside, there are also plenty of open source options (such as LibreOffice) for those "services" and software that kids find useful.
- doubleg72 3y agoIdk, I used to work IT in schools and in NYS, funding is distributed to schools based on their poverty levels. So that wasn't the case, we were buying chromebooks from reputable vendors and brands. Most all use Dell for regular laptops and desktops.
- wolverine876 3y agoPossibly they didn't have enough evidence to name the brands.
- orangepurple 3y ago> A Chinese manufacturer (possibly many manufacturers) builds a wide variety of Android-based devices, including phones, tablets, and CTV boxes. At some point between the manufacturing of these products and their delivery to resellers, physical retail stores and e-commerce warehouses, a firmware backdoor— based on Triada malware—gets installed and the product boxes are sealed in plastic, priming these devices for fraud on arrival at their destination. It is probably not the case in this instance, but the NSA TAO does this for a living.
- hulitu 3y ago> It is probably not the case in this instance, but the NSA TAO does this for a living. Why not ? Especially given the case that they were bought in bulk so this made life more easier. Ciscos are also made in China but i don't see people blaming China for Cisco's backdoors.
- kristopolous 3y agoProbably legal said no.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- est 3y ago> Isn't it OK to name that manufacturer and affected brands? Because it doesn't matter. It costs 0.01USD to change the name of the manufacturer and brand tag, or even to no-name at all. The entire factory line and staff can be renamed/reallocated by the customer's wish.
- fatfingerd 3y agoSo force them to rename. The article acts as slander against long term Chinese companies that haven't renamed themselves and probably do as much or as little as the fake Western Brands to secure boot.
- rewmie 3y ago> Because it doesn't matter. It costs 0.01USD to change the name of the manufacturer and brand tag, or even to no-name at all. I disagree, it does matter. It might not be a silver bullet that prevents this problem from ever happening again, but it helps the public stay away from devices that are already in the market and provides the necessary information to track and avoid manufacturers. > It costs 0.01USD to change the name of the manufacturer and brand tag, or even to no-name at all. It's still the same device. You can identify it by looking at it. It might not prevent further abuses, but it helps counter the ones already in place. There is zero reasons to not name the manufacturer.
- samus 3y agoIt matters a lot. Like this, the article contributes zero actionable information. Knowing the brand can at least make device owners aware that they should consider switching. Also, the article might just as well avoid mentioning that the brand is Chinese. Like this, this article can be dismissed as slander against Chinese brands in general.
- timbo1642 3y ago[dead]
- judge2020 3y agoAnd people wonder why Apple goes through the trouble of stopping fakes and not allowing third-party software (malware) on devices. Someone in the distribution chain hacks the device, rootkits it, then returns it to the setup state. The consumer would have 0 idea that their device is sending data back to some chinese company for blackmail/adware/botnet/etc. I'd love to see a foolproof solution that makes it so that only the (non-tech-savvy) person who actually purchased the device and owns it gets to install third-party software without risking a supply chain attack before it gets in their hands.
- chongli 3y agoThe issue is really complicated. People demand the right to repair. They also want to be able to buy cheap 3rd party replacement parts instead of paying a premium for Apple's official parts. But then they also don't want to be hit with malware. Apple puts a lot of effort into having a secure, verified supply chain. That costs money. Unfortunately, the benefits of all that effort are hard for most people to measure. Apple measures it by looking at their overall reputation. They'd rather be known for having expensive products than for faulty or untrustworthy ones.
- simpaticoder 3y ago>The issue is really complicated. As a counter-example, consider the Precursor[1] who's CPU is "... an SoC on an FPGA, which means you can compile your CPU from design source and verify for yourself that Precursor contains no hidden instructions or other backdoors." Device manufacturers could ship firmware as FPGA images, such that end-users can start with a "blank slate" and then install arbitrary firmware upon delivery. They choose not to. 1 - https://www.crowdsupply.com/sutajio-kosagi/precursor https://www.crowdsupply.com/sutajio-kosagi/precursor
- chongli 3y agoThat’s not going to work for a SotA phone like an iPhone. FPGAs are not even close to as fast and efficient as a purpose-built, SotA CPU.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago> recommending that users choose familiar brands when purchasing new products. Good luck with that. I have a friend that only buys no-name AliExpress specials, boasts about how cheap they are, and then bitches to me about all the problems he has with them.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI had a new hire complain about his Wish.com order… I just couldn’t muster the slightest bit of empathy.
- gmerc 3y agoLet’s not pretend amazon is better please
- lionkor 3y agoWhy not? Amazon regularly delivers what I ordered, in a timely manner. That's already much better than Wish.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoI'll agree on delivery speed, but > Amazon regularly delivers what I ordered, Given that Amazon's biggest problem is counterfeits, are you sure?
- lionkor 3y agoI really havent had any problems, in Germany with amazon.de
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI have had several. There's a reason their return policy is so generous.
- palmfacehn 3y agoMeanwhile sensitive services are demanding phone based logins under the pretense of security.
- blindriver 3y agoI would love to know how many Android devices in military and government institutions are backdoored.
- sambazi 3y agoi'd say it's the majority. interesting part is who owns the backdoor.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chimen 3y agoDo a search for "residential proxy" and browse through the results a bit, all claiming to own millions and millions of exits in the entire world. The malware could be from the manufacturer or preinstalled apps since all app developers are contacted to inject various SDKs into their code source in order to act as residential proxy nodes and make profits based on the target's internet. It's on phones, android TVs, routers etc. I wouldn;t be surprised if some of the devices we, as technical users, use are infected - who reads that TOS when updating apps anyway?
- LoganDark 3y agoIf any of my apps tried to act as an exit node, my firewall would let me know :) Nothing gets past the Portmaster.