3 ms·
Based on your bullet points here, I'm not sure what you find misleading? The headline doesn't specifically say outside of games, but I don't think that makes i
by Dylan16807 3y ago
Based on your bullet points here, I'm not sure what you find misleading?
The headline doesn't specifically say outside of games, but I don't think that makes it misleading, especially because the "for all" makes it clear that it's only about some cases. And people generally know that games pay.
Being announced in advance, not affecting previous versions... none of that is implied otherwise by the headline.
- aroo 3y ago"Unreal Engine will no longer be free for non-gaming companies" is 100x less misleading. You are right in that technically speaking it's not misleading, but to me it feels like it's skirting the line of lying by omission. Obviously now with hindsight I can see how the "for all" changes the meaning, but it wasn't obvious (at least to me).
- lholden 3y agoThe title, especially in light of the stuff that went on with Unity, makes one think that this will affect a much wider group of people than it actually does. Unreal was never "free for all". For game development, there has always been revenue thresholds. The new licensing is around commercial use outside of game development, and will also be revenue threshold based. Meaning, just like with game development, if your project is making you money over X threshold, then the licensing kicks in. The title is misleading.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> The title, especially in light of the stuff that went on with Unity, makes one think that this will affect a much wider group of people than it actually does. If you look at the title and think of a different company, that's not the headline's fault. It doesn't even try to reference Unity. Also what I said in my previous comment is relevant here. > Unreal was never "free for all". I accept that it's bad wording, but I don't see how that misleads anyone unless you thought the engine was completely free.
- pests 3y ago> If you look at the title and think of a different company, that's not the headline's fault. It doesn't even try to reference Unity. Things don't happen in a vaccuum. The Unity fiasco is still fresh on everyone's mind. For any company anywhere in the gaming sphere to change their prices so soon - is going to draw comparisons to Unity. The fact multiple people are discussing this with you should prove that.
- Dylan16807 3y agoDo they need to explicitly contrast the situation with Unity in the headline to avoid being misleading? Headlines don't have a lot of space! And as I said in a different comment, the subheading seems to address the main complaints, and in most situations you'd see the headline and the subheading together.
- pests 3y agoI think the mere fact this is an engine license change happening so close to the Unity fiasco that yes, it is impossible to talk about this without automatically invoking thoughts of what Unity did. Some news and blogs will take advantage of this association and use it for clicks.
- Dylan16807 3y agoAre you suggesting it's impossible to avoid being misleading, or do you have a solution in mind? Since you didn't really answer my question. If it's the former then I think that absolves the author.
- pests 3y agoI just read through this chain of comments and I do think there is a lot of talking past each other. I do not think the author was purposefully being misleading. I do not think they need absolution for anything. I think it may be interperted as misleading by some (as it did for the original commentor) based on the reader's recent experiences with Unity and the latest drama; which is not a property of the article, the headline, or the author - but the reader.
- ezekg 3y agoNo, the headline is blatantly trying to elicit a negative response towards Unreal i.r.t. Unity's recent pricing change.
- Dylan16807 3y agoBlatantly! Please explain how this headline connects to Unity at all? Yes we can assume a lot of people reading the headline will know about it... but I don't see this blatant connection. Would they have to explicitly say it's not like Unity in the headline to escape this? They even put "non-gaming creatives" in the subheading. Maybe whoever posted should have copied that? If you post the link on most social media you'll automatically see the headline and the subheading.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- isaacremuant 3y agoIt's very obvious clickbait. It's clearly exploiting the Unity news. Clickbait can only be analyzed in terms of the title, not the sub header or content. Because the title is what gets reposted and makes people follow a link.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Fissionary 3y agoThe headline assumes the point. If Unreal Engine will no longer be free for all, that implies that, right now, it is free for all, like e.g. Godot. Which is just emphatically untrue. It's like saying (to use the classic example), "I will no longer beat my wife." I never did, just like Unreal was never free for all.