6 ms·
The Upcoming Mazda RX-9 Will Keep the Spirit of the Rotary Engine Alive
- martinky24 3y agoWhy are we wasting any of our time with concept cars…
- flashback2199 3y agoThis isn't a concept car.
- Etheryte 3y agoSimilarly you could ask why we're wasting time building software prototypes. Just like in software, building prototypes in other industries can uncover unknown unknowns, solicit feedback and help build marketing hype.
- dartos 3y agoAren’t we all just wasting time?
- qup 3y agoNearly all
- tekla 3y agoI'd rather these awesome engineering feats over webapps literally any second of the age of the universe.
- agloe_dreams 3y agoThe concept car was years ago. This article is about the shipped car they are building.
- BradDavis67 3y ago[flagged]
- jqpabc123 3y agoHere is what they should be looking at instead: https://www.rideapart.com/news/618464/erex-one-stroke-engine-design/ https://www.rideapart.com/news/618464/erex-one-stroke-engine... This is the simplest, lightest, most efficient ICE yet.
- fgsfds028374 3y agoVery different intended purpose...
- jqpabc123 3y agoLack of imagination ... this is perfect for a serial hybrid. Which is a variation on what the RX-9 will supposedly be.
- josefresco 3y agoCache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https%3A%2F%2Fwww.topspeed.com%2Fmazda-rx-9-will-keep-the-spirit-of-the-rotary-engine-alive%2F https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https%...
- ck2 3y agoWith so many vehicles on the road and with poor emission controls (if any) the future is magnet-less EV motors, there are now two methods https://hackaday.com/2023/09/10/new-electric-motor-tech-spins-with-no-magnets/ https://hackaday.com/2023/09/10/new-electric-motor-tech-spin... Population is now too dense around the world in most cities to handle all the exhaust.
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoWouldn't the best type of ICE be a flexible fuel backup generator to extend range of otherwise electric vehicles? Which should call for altogether new designs, for example optimization for single RPM and torque to spin a dynamo rather than having to handle rapidly changing load of direct driving. Then over time we can find cleaner fuels and, if one day we have batteries that charge in 15 minutes and something to charge them from eveywhere, ditch it all together without having to revamp every car's design.
- eigenspace 3y agoThat's called a plug-in hybrid (as opposed to normal hybrids which switch from electric to combustion operation depending on power output needs). They're quite good and clever vehicles, but their name has caused a gigantic amount of confusion and problems for them, and they seem to be in serious trouble because of that.
- sjm-lbm 3y agoI think they are actually talking about a series hybrid (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_vehicle_drivetrain#Series_hybrid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_vehicle_drivetrain#Seri...), which is different than a plug-in hybrid (though it would be somewhat crazy to make a series hybrid that was not also a plug-in hybrid). .. as to why those never caught on: I have no idea. Plug-in series hybrids seem like a brilliant solution to most issues with both ICE cars/parallel hybrids and electric cars. My honest theory is that Tesla started pushing all-electric cars much earlier than anyone else would have, and that caused most people to skip plug-in series hybrids.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoYeah, this is a good setup for a rotary. Its kinda like the Porsche 918, with its super high revving, tiny racecar V6 that only made power at high RPM, compensated by a electric motor everywhere else... Though I question if Mazda will really be able to keep the curb weight down. Other manufacturers just can't seem to help themselves, and stuff tons if heavy junk in modern cars. Maybe tuners (or Mazda themself?) will put a centrifugal supercharger on it later. They seem to be en vogue, they are simple and light, and they don't butcher timings/compression and such as much as a turbocharger or other superchargers, with was a major pain point with the RX-8 Wankel.
- HPsquared 3y agoHow about supercharger (or turbocharger) + exhaust energy recovery turbine? Perhaps coupled to an electric generator? Would be a nice match to the hybrid electric system.
- brucethemoose2 3y ago> exhaust energy recovery turbine That would be a turbocharger. And electric turbocharger and driveshaft turbochargers are also a thing. The problem with turbo is backpressure from the exhaust energy recovery part, which compromises some other engine tuning. And the problem with traditional superchargers is low efficiency + high boost in low RPMs, same issue. A centrifugal supercharger is relatively efficient and basically only does anything at high RPM, so from what I understand it won't "upset" the compression of the rotary or highly tuned NA engines as much as a traditional turbo/supercharger.
- potta_coffee 3y agoThey can do it. The ND Miata was actually lighter than the NA Miata, which is quite a feat.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoYeah, the Miata is amazing. Dare I say it, it would be better than the RX8/RX9 if they just put a big wankel in it.
- HPsquared 3y agoI wonder if they could use multiple rotors in series, like a gas turbine engine does with stages of compression/expansion, to improve efficiency. A "compression" rotor, a "combustion" rotor and an "expansion rotor" perhaps? That would give more chance to extract useful work and a lower exhaust temperature. Still have a lot of thermal losses though (lots of surface area in all those combustion chambers, and a long residence time of the hot gases allowing heat transfer to happen... not ideal)
- KMag 3y agoThis has been done in order to make a Diesel Wankel (a Mercedes prototype engine, IIRC), since there's a fundamental upper limit on the compression ratio of a Wankel rotor, which isn't high enough for a reasonably running Diesel. Though, the "compression rotor" and "expansion rotor" were the same rotor. A pair of ports allowed the lower pressure rotor to empty itself at peak compression into the intake of the higher pressure rotor. The higher pressure rotor exhausted itself into that same high-compression space of the low pressure rotor for a second expansion. Note that the original Wankel rotor invention was a supercharger for a piston engine, so it's use in staged compression was thought of from the beginning.
- KMag 3y agoToo late to edit, but it was Rolls Royce trying to stage Wankel rotors for a Diesel engine, not Mercedes. The Mercedes (Daimler-Benz) attempt was a modified rotor shape to increase compression. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_Diesel_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_Diesel_engine
- _ea1k 3y agoLess than 100hp from the electric motors? That might not be bad, but maybe that shouldn't have been the headline figure. More interesting would be the torque data. I'm guessing that is fairly good, as it would solve the rotary's problems with lacking low end torque. I still think they'd have been better off with a 100% BEV, though. I doubt this will do particularly well in the market.
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoI try not to link youtubers, but I'll make an exception for F9's Wankel video. https://youtu.be/-3HBAvkc4a0?si=9NJd4B-VK1LxfXWy https://youtu.be/-3HBAvkc4a0?si=9NJd4B-VK1LxfXWy Although he's basically a motorcycle blogger, the production values manage to pump a lot of great physics[1] / MechEng information into the entertainment. There's not many mediocre videos on his channel, but this is one of the better ones. The gist of this video: the Wankel does have some[0] fundamental problems as a concept. There's workarounds (none of which I could find in the OP, although using a Wankel as an ePMU is probably ideal) but also a point of diminishing returns apart from specialized platforms like UAS. Rotational, high-flow, high-rpm . . turns out you're already halfway to a gas turbine anyway. [0] Rather a lot [1] The host is a physics major, IIRC, rather than mecheng, which was interesting.
- freedomben 3y agoIt felt like that video was targeted more at teenagers and/or immature dudes (which is totally fine, it just didn't resonate with me). I really liked these two: How rotary engine works (Mazda RX-7): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sd6pJtR4PaY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sd6pJtR4PaY What new to RX-9 from RX-7: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-3gzQVGEqF4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-3gzQVGEqF4
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoYeah, I'll buy that. I use F9 to sneak some moto knowledge into my nephews, who have . . I don't even know what they call attention spans these days. . negative attention? Unless it's some incomprehensible card game. Anyway, good vids!
- jagged-chisel 3y agoBoth links go to “How rotary engine works”
- freedomben 3y agoOops sorry, fixed, thanks!
- stodor89 3y ago> The principal flaw of the rotary engine was inefficient combustion, which led to poor fuel efficiency and emissions issues. Wasn't the principal flaw of the rotary engine that it tends to die?
- jacquesm 3y agoSeals are/were the big issue.
- flashback2199 3y agoI had the same thought. Nobody wants to touch those used rx-8's with a 10 foot pole. But I guess that doesn't matter so much for people who don't care about the trade in value down the road. Which is a surprisingly high percentage of new car buyers I've observed.
- pwython 3y agoI so was hyped for the RX8 back in 2003. For its time it looked pretty cool and the interior layout was even better. But I kept hearing about the reliability issues after just a couple of years. So I ended up going with a 6spd Nissan 350Z instead. That car was solid as a rock, and man did that VQ engine sound beautiful. I wish Mazda didn't half-ass the RX8, as the RX7 was such a classic.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoI love rotary engines but even I can acknowledge their mechanical deficiencies. But I will still love them regardless. I'd love to see some new engine concepts like an electric drive vehicle. I think I heard some cars do this but need to double check.
- threemux 3y agoIf they pull this off (especially if it's possible to do all-electric at low speeds for short distances) I'll be on the preorder list for sure. A manual would be preferable, but that may be too complicated to allow given the powertrain setup.
- jacquesm 3y agoManual what? It would have all of two gears maximum or so I would think?
- aidenn0 3y agoI'll bet you a beverage of your choice that it will have at least a 6-speed transmission (whether that's manual, automatic or manumatic). A 4- or 5-speed isn't out of the question (The RX-8 had a version with a 4-speed automatic), so I'm giving you a bit of edge over your prediction of a 2-speed. To be fair, I should point out that TFA predicts an 8-speed automatic.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat would be interesting because I see no way how you'd have a hybrid (either series or parallel) with multiple motors and gearboxes. What you could do is to have an automatic transmission in a parallel setup and maybe a gear (or two) for the electric motors or a series version where the ICE drives a generator to drive the electric motors (which is how I understand this one works). In that case there would be no gears at all or maybe just two to match the electric motors better to the speed you are driving at. Can you explain how you think an actual 6 speed transmission (manual or automatic, not 'fake' gears from a CVT) would work with a parallel hybrid? Because the only way that would work is if the electric drive system is entirely optional and just there to relieve the ICE a bit. Edit: Ah ok, I see it now, so the in-hub electric motors aren't geared at all (they can't be) and the ICE can run across a regular gearbox. So this is a parallel hybrid with the electric motors only coupled in right at the hubs rather than somewhere further upstream. So indeed the electric motors are 'optional', and they are managing the balance by either switching the automatic gearbox to neutral and then use the electric motors to drive the vehicle, not power the electric motors but just use the ICE or a combination of both. This does indeed allow for a variety of different geartrains.
- HorizonXP 3y agoI recently took delivery of a Mazda CX-90 PHEV. My other car is a 2012 Acura TSX. I wasn’t ready to jump fully into EV simply because I wanted a larger family hauler that didn’t break the bank. My driving is limited to less than 15 km per day. Therefore, the EV portion of the CX-90 was more than enough, with the ICE portion available if we ever need it. I really like Mazda and I’m glad they exist to push things like the rotary. Maybe I’ll consider the RX-9 as a fun vehicle. I want EVs to succeed but they simply don’t make sense for all use cases yet. But they don’t have to. Maybe I’ll get an EV to replace the TSX if it ever dies. But, Mazdas are great cars. I wouldn’t sleep on them.
- falcrist 3y agoI hear there are concerns about plug-in hybrid's that don't use their engines often developing issues because those engines never get used. Does the CX-90 have any features to help with that?
- jeffbee 3y agoMy PHEV just runs the engine for no reason, if it hadn't run in a long time. Also it comes on for surprising reasons, such as when the battery is fully charged and you apply the brakes.
- HorizonXP 3y agoNot that I’m aware of but to be honest, I doubt I’ll have that problem. 42km of EV-only range means that every so often, I’ll need the ICE. Plus, I have a heavy foot, so if I want to experience all 340 ponies, I gotta fire up the ICE. That said, the appeal of EV-only and adaptive cruise control means I drive more calmly. Most of the time. Just need to get a Comma 3X running on this and I’ll be set!
- coldpie 3y ago> I want EVs to succeed but they simply don’t make sense for all use cases yet. I think they do? There's a couple really small corner cases, like if you're on the road 99% of the time for work, or live in sub-zero temperatures all year long, or something exceptional like that. But EVs are already there right now for everything non-exceptional people use cars for. The things people think EVs can't do are the kinds of things people think they need to be able to do, but don't actually ever do, like go on 400 mile road trips every week with zero stops. YAGNI. I really like Mazda, too. They make good stuff, and their recent "anti-touchscreen" stance really jives with me[1]. [1] https://www.motorauthority.com/news/1121372_why-mazda-is-purging-touchscreens-from-its-vehicles https://www.motorauthority.com/news/1121372_why-mazda-is-pur...
- Andrew018 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 11thEarlOfMar 3y ago“… a considerable percentage of the fuel leaving the chamber unburned.” I bought a used ‘79 RX-7 in 1990 with about 130,000 miles on it. When it started up, it emitted a large cloud of white vapor. When I turned it off, usually at the gas station, that un burned fuel ignited in the exhaust line. It was not unlike a gunshot. I’d like to apologize to those whose hearts I stopped.
- learn_more 3y agoOh yeah! Give a throttle blip during shutdown and you could cause a huge back-fire, sometimes occurring after you already exited the car! Always a crowd pleaser.
- jeffbee 3y agoHow does Mazda have the mental energy and monetary budget for their endless series of fruitless journeys into weird forms of combustion? They still haven't made that Skyactiv-X thing work, their Miller cycle engines never worked right even though everyone else now makes Miller cycle engines, and rotary engines are only good for the track where the owner is willing to rebuild it hourly.
- hatsunearu 3y ago>They still haven't made that Skyactiv-X thing work source? i thought it's shipping with mazda 3's
- threemux 3y agoThe "Skyactiv-X thing" absolutely works and is available on Mazda 3s in Europe now. It doesn't work in the US because of our very stringent NOx emission rules (which, incidentally, is one of the reasons diesels are less popular here). I'm not aware of Mazda trying a Miller cycle engine outside of one trim level on the Millenia. I have heard that their experiments with that helped the development of their Skyactiv engines in general though. I'm also not aware of anyone else making Miller cycle engines currently. Perhaps you're thinking of Toyota's heavy use of the related but not the same Atkinson cycle engine.
- jeffbee 3y agoBeing able to meet CARB specs is not a detail, it is the top line outcome of engine design.