15 ms·
Stop Arguing over Elite Schools. Just Make Public Colleges Free
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- superduty 3y agoTeachers don’t work for free, nor do janitors or administrators. Building maintenance and leases aren’t free.
- mikeyouse 3y agoFree in this context (and in health care discussions) obviously just means free at the point-of-use. It's so odd that people continue to pretend not to understand that to make some other point.
- robert_foss 3y agoRoads don't build themselves, water treatment doesn't happen by itself. What is society for if not to serve the common needs of the people?
- jwilber 3y agoHow exactly do you think taxes are used?
- eatsyourtacos 3y agoDoes it cost you anything to call the police or the fire department? No- it's free to use. You know what it means; stop trying to muddy the waters with disingenuous arguments.
- kube-system 3y agoYes, "free at the point of use" is what was meant, but for the record, emergency services are not universally free in the US. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_response_fee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_response_fee
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoThis ridiculous talking point isn't the "gotcha" you think it is, and quite frankly, it's getting exhausting to see it all the time. Yes, we know, it's not "free" and is paid for by taxes. Likely even increased taxes. Everyone knows this. And we don't have a problem with it.
- monero-xmr 3y agoNothing is “free”. Sometimes the costs are hidden from most people. It’s like immigration. If you say, “anyone who comes here can’t be kicked out and you instantly get access to healthcare, food stamps, and free housing” then your maximum payout is the entire planet and you are bankrupt once people realize this. For public college to be free, I want to limit access, like happens in Europe. Sure college can be free… to the top N people in the state, with N being decided by the payers (i.e. democratic electorate). Otherwise it’s just wasted money as we delay adulthood for a huge number of people who have no business getting degrees.
- omginternets 3y agoIt's telling that people aren't willing to contend with the corollary of "free education" and "free healthcare": limited capacity. Edit: I should probably mention that I'm generally in favor of state-funded education, for a variety of reasons.
- owenmarshall 3y agoHealthcare capacity in the US is a function of your ability to pay for it. We contend with limited supply today, we just kick the limited supply to groups of people who by and large aren't posting on this website.
- omginternets 3y agoYes... I agree. I'm not sure what your point is?
- owenmarshall 3y agoWhen I've heard this argument advanced before, it's had the subtext that "limited capacity is not a problem today but becomes one in other contexts" I made the assumption that's what you were hinting at.
- 3y ago
- latchkey 3y agoWe've been prioritizing military spending over education for decades. I'd love to see even a bit of that swing the other way. I don't think taking a small amount from the military, by requiring them to optimize a few budgets, would be impactful on our nations security.
- localplume 3y ago[dead]
- jandrewrogers 3y agoThe US spends more on education than the military, it is difficult to defend the idea that spending on education has not been prioritized. Per the OECD, US spending per student is among the highest in the world by a large margin, which raises the question of value for the money already being spent -- any deficiencies compared to other countries aren't for lack of money. The US also spends a lot of money on the military. Whether prudent or not, at least that spending produces an objectively superior product. We spend even more on education with ambiguous results.
- latchkey 3y ago> The US spends more on education than the military "The US spent $877 billion on military in 2022, a new report says — more than 10 times federal education spending" https://www.businessinsider.com/us-defense-military-budget-compared-federal-education-spending-2023-4 https://www.businessinsider.com/us-defense-military-budget-c...
- mwbajor 3y agoCan't see the article but I assume they are comparing it to Dept. of education spending as most do. The vast majority of educational spending is at the state and local level which people frequently leave out when making this comparison.
- toast0 3y agoYou'd need to consider the state military and education budgets as well.
- Swizec 3y agoOne of my favorite cultural artefacts from Europe is that "Oh you pay tuition? Sorry your grades weren't good enough" My university only charged you for retaking exams (after 3 tries) and for redoing a year, if you didn't make a baseline of credits. 1 re-do was free. You can re-take any class for free as long as you're enrolled. I used this to take classes from past years that I didn't pass. While I'm a bad example of using free schooling well, this is exactly the sort of thing taxes should pay for. If the world's richest country can't pay for schooling, ... edit: I also remember various professors explaining how paid tuition and good education are opposites. You can't have good education with high standards, if people expect a return on their investment (a degree). How can you look someone who paid $100k in the eye and say "Sorry, you do not meet the bar. No degree"?
- chmod600 3y agoSome zero-price schools in the US, like high schools, have essentially no standards at all. You can get a diploma even if nearly illiterate. Good schools with high standards can be delivered with or without paid tuition, and the same for bad schools with no standards.
- harshreality 3y agoThat's true in the US, but probably to a lesser degree than in Europe. If you had good enough SATs, you can often get full scholarships to your state's public universities. Other states' schools as well, although to a lesser degree—it would be more selective, like scholarships for private schools, since public colleges obviously prefer to subsidize their own states' residents over others, given equal test scores.
- itg 3y agoI don't follow the logic the author is using. Let's say we make all public colleges free for students. "Elite" schools will still exist, and top students will still target schools such as Ivy/MIT/Stanford/etc. One look at the people in executive offices or top political offices and you'll find a substantial portion are graduates from elite schools.
- A_D_E_P_T 3y agoAgreed, and if anything what the author proposes would intensify the competition to get into those elite schools, for it would simultaneously increase the worth of a diploma from an elite school and devalue the diploma from the public college.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoYou could always make public colleges free, and also make the exams to get in actually hard. That comes with its own suite of issues, of course.
- coryrc 3y agoWe've done the opposite for decades. We've lowered the bar every year and the quality of k-12 education has dropped significantly. Perhaps now that Lucy Calkins is fully exposed as a fraud, reading can get better? https://www.timesunion.com/education/article/phonics-f-sound-n-y-challenges-reading-18355554.php https://www.timesunion.com/education/article/phonics-f-sound...
- piotrkaminski 3y ago> devalue the diploma from the public college Huh? How so? If the only change is that you no longer need to pay for college, but otherwise admission standards and education quality remain the same, then why would the value of a diploma change? Unless the diploma was implicitly a signal for wealth, of course...
- Sohcahtoa82 3y ago
- jasonlotito 3y agoJust a reminder, free public college was the norm for a long time, and many people benefited from it before turning around and working hard to dismantle it. It's not some foreign concept. It's very much apart of America's history. The question we need to ask is whether it's a better system now than it was in the past, and I don't see anyone arguing that it's better now.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoFree tuition at public college might have been the norm; but not free room and board and books etc. Unless you could pay for all of that, there were also no guaranteed loans which meant that college was still unavailable except to the relatively wealthy.
- ojosilva 3y agoThis. Sending kids to public universities in the US has always been a big money issue for even the better-off parents (not elite), especially with more than 1 kid seeking higher education. It's definitely not just tuition. You have to enable 3 young adults financially like in my parents case. They had to juggle a lot to stay afloat! Thankfully I landed a great paying job after 2 years on the market and was able to help push my brother and sister through Arizona State, although we all picked up a lot of debt in the process though credit cards.
- chmod600 3y agoInstitutions on a small scale a long time ago are not easily comparable to institutions means to serve a much larger fraction of a much larger population.
- Simulacra 3y agoThere will always be elite, private schools, and people will pay to go to them. If public universities are completely free, then it becomes a scarcity of resources, as each tries to stretch a dollar. This will mean those who can afford it will pay to go to elite institutions.
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoWho would oversea the spending of our taxes? There's no responsibility to provide a viable product currently because people are forced to pay and can't default on the loan if the product the college sold them wasn't variable to earning money to pay back the loan for payment college requested. Think a world where colleges have to take more responsibility in making sure the loans they demand can by paid back would result in a better system where more people who leave actually end up earning amounts that justify what they loaned to go there.
- kube-system 3y agoI do not think it is a good idea to treat public universities like a big vocational school. Academics at liberal arts institutions provides value to society that is unrelated to those discipline's vocational utility.
- em-bee 3y agoi don't think loans are the problem. quality of education can be measured in different ways. the key thing for me is that by not having everyone pay for their own education, there is no incentive to let them pass just to get their money. quality of education can be raised without risking funds because students drop out. funding of the schools can be made dependent on the taxes that the students pay once they are working. it's a long feedback loop, but i think it could be the right incentive.
- runjake 3y agoI don't believe even public colleges want this. They're raking in too much money, at this point.
- actionfromafar 3y agowho cares what they want.
- runjake 3y agoNobody. That's not the point. The point is that they will fight (and lobby) tooth and nail to prevent such an action. They already have a close relationship with their political representatives, now imagine that plus large amounts of campaign donations and favors. And YOU, you support this?! Why, it would degrade the quality of education students get now! /s of course
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoYou think they'd be raking in less money under this proposal? Why?
- runjake 3y agoBecause public uni income now is obscene (IMHO) and under our broken two party system, funding would likely be much less as the parties squabble over funding and making compromises. It would also be interesting to see how the government deals with the often-immense income from college athletics programs (football, basketball, etc).
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoIt would depend on the details. Let's say public universities educate X students at a cost of $Y. If the government says "We can't pay $Y, we'll pay $Z", then the universities will almost certainly say "We can't educate X people for $Z, we can at most only educate $Z * X/$Y people for $Z". Then the remaining slots are for sale to the highest bidder, who will on average be able to pay more than the average of all X could, because they're the highest bidders. More generally, those who have to pay for themselves are in general more price-sensitive than those who have someone else to pay for them. That's true of the students who have the government to pay for them, and it's also true of the government who has the taxpayers to pay for them.
- chmod600 3y agoA nearly content-free article. The idea is not new, and little data is offered to support it. The success criteria seems to be "enrollment", which leaves a lot of room for things to go wrong. No downsides are mentioned aside from cost, which is dismissed with a tax that sounds like free money.
- em-bee 3y agowhat other downsides could there be from making education accessible to everyone and not just those that can afford it? i can think of two: one is the quality of the education. if it is to low and everyone graduates without having learned much then that would be bad. another is having to many graduates without jobs. but both can be fixed with more quality and being more demanding. one benefit: when you don't pay for education yourself there is no pressure to let you pass classes just to get your money.
- renewiltord 3y agoHow much is college in other places? It's free here in San Francisco. You don't pay anything. You can get an education at CCSF without a dime paid if you live here.
- Jtsummers 3y agohttps://educationdata.org/average-cost-of-college https://educationdata.org/average-cost-of-college That has a breakdown for you.
- mseidl 3y agoFree in Germany. It used to cost 500 euros per semester. but you still get your bachelors and masters here for cheaper than a quarter at some schools. Our bachelors are 3 years masters are 2.
- djur 3y agoCCSF is a community college. Community colleges are great, but associate degrees by themselves don't do much for you. The issue here is public universities that offer 4-year and postgraduate programs.
- adolph 3y agoOver the past few decades, college tuition and fees have metastasized, hitting an average of nearly $11,000 a year for in-state students who attend public four-year institutions, and now undergraduate enrollment is plummeting. There is a solution: Congress and more states should adopt tuition-free public higher education. This will alleviate the student debt crisis and enable low-income students, particularly those of color, to go to college. The article fails to make a case that the stated problem, "tuition and fees have metastasized," will be addressed by "tuition-free public higher education."
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoFirst: That isn't even the correct use of "metastasized". (Unless you assume that any cost at all is a cancer.) That's rather jarring in an article about higher education. Second: If prices are out of control, so people aren't going there because it's too expensive, maybe the answer is to let supply and demand do its thing? This proposal takes universities that are too expensive, and looks for an alternate way to pay them anyway. That's not the answer - or at least, it's not the answer to the problem that they say they're trying to solve. Find a way to lower the cost of college, rather than changing who pays for it. (We can also talk about who pays for it, but the solution to the stated problem is to find a way to undo the insane increase in college costs.)
- Ajay-p 3y agoEven if college were free, I think limits on funding availability will actually make it harder for someone to get in because now they have to be selective. It might lead to less people going to college.
- RajT88 3y agoThat's how it went in Germany. Lots of people are redirected to trade programs. I'm definitely of the opinion that for a lot of folks, college doesn't really make sense. I would hazard a guess that also in Germany, lots of kids who might not be able to attend college are able to, because it is free.
- Jtsummers 3y agoIn the US, many trade schools are either private for-profit programs, or part of what we call "community college". Free community college has been pushed for a long time (some states already had it).
- Ajay-p 3y agoCommunity schools at no cost would be excellent. Not a full bachelors but the associates degree in America, without cost, would at least put many more adults on a level to attain higher education if they so choose.
- karaterobot 3y ago> There’s the age-old question of how we pay for this. Sanders proposed a Wall Street financial transactions tax. A 0.1 percent tax, according to a Congressional Budget Office estimate, could raise $777 billion over 10 years. Or we could hike taxes on corporations and the wealthiest Americans. I have no problem taxing wall street or "the wealthiest Americans", but I don't see the connection between this proposal and this funding source. It feels like taking money away from people who don't vote for you, and giving it to people who do. That's a bad direction to go down, and I'm generally skeptical about politicians who do this (which is a lot of them).
- AmVess 3y agoI have a problem with taxes in general, and this is yet another stupid idea. Increased tax loads always get passed on to the consumer. What we will end up with is higher cost of doing business and 100% for certain federally run universities will still need taxpayer bailouts every single year. Lose lose all the way around. I have an even better idea: get rid of all freebies. If someone wants something, they can get off their asses and work for it for a change.
- flashback2199 3y ago> Increased tax loads always get passed on to the consumer Yep, taxes are a little bit worse than that too because the cost also gets passed to the producer as well in the form of decreased demand. The result is fewer goods and services exchanged - ie less economic activity - than there would have been with a lower tax. Formally, it is called deadweight loss in microecon: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadweight_loss?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadweight_loss?wprov=sfla1
- segfaltnh 3y agoIs there an example of negative repercussions of this in modern society? I hear people complain about extreme taxation relative to history, but I also have plenty of access to goods and services in my region, so it seems there must be other, perhaps higher weighted, factors?
- starkparker 3y agoI was in the second high school class to get Louisiana's TOPS program, which at the time gave four years' full-ride tuition plus fees to any public state university with a nominal ACT score and generous GPA requirements (18 ACT and 2.5 GPA IIRC). Wouldn't be here today without it. My parents couldn't afford anything but the closest and shittiest university, with no compsci program (they only had a business computing program, which taught only COBOL, in 1999). Instead I went to UL Lafayette, which had an actual program, got a room/board merit scholarship, worked through the summers, and graduated debt-free with two degrees. It still didn't accomplish the state's objective of keeping college grads in state — the in-state company I lined up my senior year moved after the governor line-item vetoed a tax incentive, and I wound up in the northeast. But if not for that my career would've probably started working on legacy systems in Arkansas instead of startups in New England.
- AlbertCory 3y agowell, but UL Lafayette was where Bill Evans went. So it's got that going for it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jonhohle 3y ago> My parents couldn't afford anything… Not saying its the right way, but grew up without a lot of financial resources, no money specifically to pay for college, and I went to a private 4 year engineering program starting in 1999 by taking out boat-loads of loans. Going into school I had nothing and needed 100% of my tuition covered by loans, grants, or scholarships. I was reasonably confident that having an engineering degree would allow me to pay back the loans (it did, but it didn't go as smoothly for all of my classmates). Based on my experience, I don't really understand the idea of not being able to afford college (at least for degrees which will put you in reasonably paying positions). Am I an outlier? I doubt it. I didn't go to a particularly well known school, but was able to figure out employment and self-sufficiency. Now I have the pride of finishing a relatively difficult program and paying for it through my own labor. Medical professionals, engineers, and the like have so many opportunities that it's not clear why we should subsidize their education. Educators, on the other hand, have to pay the same price for a degree, have to have continuing education, and then get paid crappy wages. While I'd rather reward them on the back end with better benefits, if there is a program worth subsidizing, it's probably educators.
- kogus 3y agoMaking public colleges free isn't... free. The perception is often that public universities are already getting most of their money from the state or federal government, so why not just close the gap. But the typical funding level is between 40-50%. The remaining 50-60% is currently covered by tuition and philanthropic giving. So closing the gap to make universities free to the public would involve (in most cases) more than doubling the current level of state/federal funding. That doesn't mean it should not be done - but the magnitude of the investment should be made clear.
- brewdad 3y agoThose funding levels you are talking about used to be the norm until "trickle down" become the holy grail of fiscal policy. There's no reason we couldn't return to those funding levels.
- hinkley 3y agoReagan slashed university funding and funded the GI bill instead. No need to draft people, we can just send the poor. It’s a win-win /s
- otoburb 3y ago>>So closing the gap to make universities free to the public would involve (in most cases) more than doubling the current level of state/federal funding. Or, a mix of increasing the level of state/federal funding and closing down a portion of the roughly 1900 public colleges[1] around the country. Unfortunatley, as soon as this approach is used, then the "access" problem rears its head since public colleges that are shutdown require more students to commute/reside further away from their home towns. [1] https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=1122 https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=1122
- BizarroLand 3y agoIt doesn't even have to be free. Just create a subsidy and regulate the colleges that agree to be subsidized. Make it fully voluntary but also give the participant colleges a special badge to let people know that the college is federally funded and therefore has to provide various information to the students or possible put a maximum loan cap on the student, and if the student is making progress and reaches that cap then the remainder of their education is free of charge to the Bachelors level.
- hahamrfunnyguy 3y agoI've always had this crazy idea that we could make high school useful again. Run year round and provide more opportunities for swapping in college-level course work or actual college or trade school courses. This kind of opportunity would have allowed me to finish my education sooner, or at least enjoy it more. As it was, I worked full time every summer since I turned 16 and then 30+ hours a week while I was completing my bachelor's degree and taking classes year-round. I got my degree from a private school, but transferred in about 25% of my credits which reduced the total cost significantly. It sucked and I missed out on a lot of experiences during that time period BUT I had a minimal amount of debt when I graduated.
- munbun 3y agoI honestly believe this is the best possible solution but grade school curriculum and funding being controlled by state legislatures is a real issue.
- rawgabbit 3y agoI agree. High school in America today is full of conflicting priorities. I believe that choice is the only viable answer. Not the two plus two choices we have today (public/charter and private/home schooling). But throw it all open. Each state should publish a minimum curriculum standard for high school. If Big Tech wants to create an online version of high school that meets the standards, parents and students should have that choice. If Big Health Care wants to create a health oriented high school that meets the standards, parents and students should have that choice.
- ARandomerDude 3y agoI’m amazed by how many people use the word “free” to mean “pay even more tax for the rest of your life.”
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoyour is misused here. It's "free" for the person attending. I don't think many people are confused and think there is no cost or that it's not borne by taxpayers.
- DrThunder 3y agoIt's not free for them, it's being taken out of their income to the point their salaries are significantly lower than the US. This is like saying if I pre-order a game and then play it when it comes out I'm getting a free game. I have no idea why this is the default answer whenever this comes up. It seems like you're trying to sway opinions by gaslighting what's really happening. Why is it hard to admit the term free is obviously being misused in this case to present socially funding healthcare as better?
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoThe thing the article talks about is: not charging for tuition, ever. It's not some kind of loan program or pay later program. Those programs have been discussed, are in place in certain places (australia for example), but is not what people are talking about here. Unless you are saying "if everyone goes, and everyone pays taxes, it's a wash"? In which case, that's not close to the reality of the situation. As a percentage of the population, attendees of in state public universities is low and always has been. If you don't think that some subset is being subsidized by the general population is good, that's a reasonable argument, but to suggest it's a wash just isn't accurate.
- DrThunder 3y agoI'm not talking about the article. I'm referring directly to the comment chain about "free" healthcare. Regardless, taxes are NOT FREE. College will never be free, you can only pass the cost on to someone else. Somewhere, someone in the chain has to pay for it. If someone provides you a service then it gets paid for by someone. If no one pays for it then it's slavery and the people providing the service pay with their own bodies/minds. Obviously you're not suggesting professors and people that run the university not get paid.... so who is paying for it? This isn't a hard concept and yet you keep kicking the can down the road suggesting it's free free free. Where does the money come from?
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoOr, just stop making a college degree a requirement for the jobs which don't require specialized training...
- em-bee 3y agoi think the problem here is the low quality of education before college and the lack of alternative forms of education. (on the job training, apprenticeships). improving that should reduce the demand for college degrees.
- s17n 3y agoAs others in the thread have noted, there are two separeate issues here: 1. Young people should be able to get a quality education regardless of their families' financial situation. 2. Everyone should have an equal shot at attaining positions of power in society (not so much for their own good, since almost nobody is going to attain these positions anyway it's a small benefit relative to the total population, as for everyone else's good - we don't want to be governed by a hereditary caste). For (1), you want high quality free public colleges (elite institutions are simply too small regardless of what you do with their admissions process). For (2), you need to make sure admissions at elite institutions is equitable (most important priority: ban legacy admissions).
- ugh123 3y agoWhat are the non-merit based criteria you propose?
- DrThunder 3y agoGiving out legacy admission is Equity. You're giving "legacy" people the same education as people who earned it through merit, which is the definition of being equitable. Unless, you believe equity only applies to race? Equality is the term you're looking for.
- s17n 3y agoEquitable, adj: fair and impartial. If you actually believe that legacy admissions are a fair and impartial way to decide who gets to go to Harvard, I'm not really sure what to say.
- DrThunder 3y agoEquity is an outcome. You're suggesting we FORCE an outcome and apparently you don't want to base it on legacy. So, what are we basing the forced outcome on? Race? Victim-hood? Gender? Class? Are lower class people of color more deserving of equity? How do you make something equitable? You need to think through the process of how that works. It's every bit as "fair" to gift admissions to family members as it is to someone because they're a different skin tone. Which is to say, both are stupid. How about we give people the resources and they can prove they deserve it through merit?
- _8j50 3y agoI couldn't bring myself to be indebted at such a young age so I skipped college then. But this is america, not europe things are different. For better or worse, indebting people at a young age is how the "college educated worker" pipeline works and the class system functions and controls upward mobility. Not to mention military service. If you are ok with mandatory military service and more stringent and competitive college entry exams as well as the government telling you based on your score what degrees you can pursue for free, now all you have to do is convince this union of 50 different states to agree with you and it is doable. Even though college is paid, you can still get plenty of well paying jobs without college or work your way up by gaining experience to compensate for lack of college. This is only possible in America. It doesn't matter how much skills or experience I have, no one will hire me in the EU or Asia based on lack of degree alone for example, but even if it is 10+ years, I can make up for it in America. I am just saying it isn't as simple as they're making it sound.
- em-bee 3y agothe government telling you based on your score what degrees you can pursue for free in germany this is solved by allocating a number of slots for each degree. those slots are then filled with the best students first, until all slots are allocated. the score that you needed to get in was effectively the lowest score of any student that did get in. this means that in one year it could be that you needed an A to get into eg physics and in another year a C was enough. so it's very much supply and demand, and better grades give you more choices.
- _8j50 3y agoThat's a very level headed approach. But I wonder if the US would be more like India where kids kill themselves over college admission scores because since college is free, everything you can do in life depends on it. Personally, I like free college but only for very specific degrees where is demand and having a degree makes sense. Like IT shouldn't be free but medicine or law should, because you can learn IT on the job and it is more close to a trade you can apprentice in. Where apprenticing or learning on the job makes sense, degrees should not be subsidized and pursuits like philosophy where there isn't any economic demand for the degree should be paid by the student.
- DrThunder 3y agoDo you realize how "free college" works in other nations? Not everyone gets to go. In places like Germany you're put on a track when you're like middle school age and if you're not on the university track you do not get to attend college. IF we're going to start using tax dollars to full fund public higher ed then not everyone gets the chance to go like they do now. Maybe this is a better way of doing it but I can guarantee you a lot of people will not like the outcome of mostly minorities (minus Asians) being axed from ever getting the opportunity to attend college. If tax dollars are to be used then you HAVE to use them appropriately and giving out free education to a lot people that'll just fail and waste it is not a good solution.
- cma 3y agoIt is close to that in the US. In middle school you are put on an advanced/honors track and without it you won't get AP or other advanced classes in high-school. You can make all A's and won't be anywhere near the top of your class because A's in those advanced class are usually set up to count for more on your GPA.
- DrThunder 3y agoIt's not. You might not get into Ivy League school but ANYONE can take out a loan and get into a state university of a public university. Hell, a lot of colleges don't even require SAT or ACT anymore. Where are you getting the idea that you need to have good grades to attend college in the US?
- dbrueck 3y agoI agree with the 'stop arguing over elite schools' bit. To me, elite schools look like a huge waste of money and I urge anyone considering an elite school to study the law of diminishing returns. To other people, going to such a school is absolutely worth it and crucial to their life plan. Let them charge what the market will bear and let them accept students within the same framework that any other business follows when determining what customers to work with. Part of what makes so-called elite schools elite is scarcity, so even if you completely rewrote how they operate, the number of actual students affected would be too small to move the needle anyway.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoElite schools transmute money into merit. Even if we completely marketize them, the human biases that exist in relation to them are sticky. This doesn't mean that "people's biases are wrong, therefore the consequences are irrelevant." It means that the choices made must account for those biases. The choices we make regarding merit laundering, must account for people's biases toward graduates. We would be fools not to.
- dbrueck 3y ago> Elite schools transmute money into merit. Eh, I don't know. Those schools transmute money into networks for sure, but the degree they do it for merit seems drastically less, perhaps it's even initially a negative at first. I mean, the lazy rich kid who got into Yale because of daddy is such a well-established stereotype now that it's almost the default expectation. :)
- kelseyfrog 3y agoThe point of laundering is sneaking in just enough bad with the good that it's more difficult/expensive to sort it out again than it is to accept that it's good and doesn't damage the brand. The reputation of elite institutions is a product of them mixing in just enough bad[sons and daughters of the elite[1]] with the meritorious[high student performers] that it's not worth it for us to sort it out ourselves and doesn't damage the reputation of the institution. The lazy rich kid to you, may be the perfect candidate to a VP hiring for an influential role. I'd be hasty to generalize your own perspective to those who are filling those seats. I brought up merit laundering for a reason: offering free public institutions reduces the merit pool for elite institutions in a way that reduces their efficacy in laundering merit. The meritorious care far less about the reputation of elite institutions than the elite do. After all, the launderers gain more from cleaning the dirty money than they do from dirtying the clean.
- jonhohle 3y agoOr perhaps we should stop pushing everyone to college and encourage those who have the aptitude to go into trades. Of the successful tradespeople I know, the only thing going to college would have done was delayed their entry into the workforce and saddle them with debt. Might they be able to run their businesses 10% more efficiently or grow twice as big had they had more business education? Probably, but there are far more businesses that succeed by being just the right size for the owner than there are hyper growth oriented, lean machines.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoI don't think it's fair or reasonable for only those from well off families to have the chance at college though. College access shouldn't be tied to ones socioeconomic background.
- jonhohle 3y agoI commented elsewhere, but I came from a not-well-off single parent house. I paid for college with loans. Then I paid off the loans. If someone has done well in school and wants to go into a stable, well-paying profession, it's probably the only area (besides a mortgage) that I'd recommend taking a loan. I paid zero dollars for four years to go to school and live and eat on campus. Going into an engineering program, the risk was relatively low that I would not be able to pay it back while still in my 20s (which I did). 20 years later, while the cost of the degree was high the opportunities that it made available were beyond what would have been available without it and payback was amortized over time.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoIf you think the cost of the degree 20 years ago was high, you should see what the cost is today! It just seems like there's endless excuses to write off empathy & countless "I did it and so can others" anec-data, that doesn't reflect on what has become of a social opportunity both for the student, and for society to invest in & improve itself, in the long term.
- deleted 3y ago
- otoburb 3y ago>>Over the past few decades, college tuition and fees have metastasized, hitting an average of nearly $11,000 a year for in-state students who attend public four-year institutions, and now undergraduate enrollment is plummeting. >>[...] Last year, as enrollment stagnated or declined in other states, New Mexico posted record gains. From spring 2022 to spring 2023, overall enrollment grew by 6 percent, and it jumped nearly 12 percent at branch community colleges. This entire article conveniently omitted the fact that another driver for plummeting undergraduate enrollment is the "enrollment cliff"[1] that has already started to affect colleges across the board. Yes, affordability is a large factor, and it's great that New Mexico was able to increase their enrollment numbers (as the article stated, a true anomaly), but the demographic backdrop should have been at least acknowledged. [1] https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/23428166/college-enrollment-population-education-crash https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/23428166/college-enrollmen...
- currymj 3y agoETH Zurich and EPFL (in Lausanne) are elite technical schools, which also have extremely low tuition (roughly $1000 total per semester) and open admissions. There is no entrance exam required for students who have a Swiss high school degree that qualifies them to attend university at all -- they may simply enroll. The trick is that the first year or two are made extremely difficult so many people drop out. However, tuition is so low that this is not really a disaster that derails your whole life.
- jsndidneske 3y ago^This proves my point well: course work is so easy that if school was largely free for applicable courses tye jobarket would get Very swamped.
- candiodari 3y agoOnly if you satisfy a long list of conditions. The reason this is the case is that Switzerland sorts kids very early, at 12 years essentially. Get sorted wrongly once and while you do get a second chance, they make sure it takes you 2 years absolute minimum, 4-6 years normally and even more is possible to enter university. Oh, and if you get sorted wrong (lang or kurzgymnasium), it takes years and expensive courses to get back. The low tuition only applies if you enter before you turn 25 years old. And Zurich is very expensive to rent a room. Even once in university, you only get one chance (you should see the crying on results day), if you want to redo a year, you can do it in Germany (closest) or France/Italy that do allow it. Which of course is anything but cheap, as a non-local you do not qualify for any kind of aid. But sure, what you say is correct, tuition is not that high and if you really try, yes you can get through it as a very poor person. But one mistake and it'll take you a very long time to claw back, and a lot of money. (this is about ETH Zurich, EPFL is similar, but not quite as bad)
- currymj 3y agowhat is the tuition if you are over 25? I think it is still about 800 CHF. This is extremely cheap. Compare to MIT which is about $40,000 a semester, with the average student after financial aid paying $20,000, and is in Cambridge, a city where rents are about as bad as Zurich (although most students live in MIT dorms). if MIT failed out 50% of their class with $40-80k in debt, this could not be tolerated.
- gumby 3y agoThis is an excellent point. The selective private schools account for a tiny number of students (e.g. MIT takes in about 1K undergrads a year). And in my experience of both having attended such a school and having hired tons of people from all sorts of backgrounds over almost four decades, while some really do benefit from that fancy schooling, most end up with an OK education. Meanwhile the ones who did community college->state school have all been great hires, and you can get a super education at a lot of state schools.
- Quillbert182 3y agoIt’s already free in several states. Georgia pays full tuition for in-state students who maintain a certain GPA, and I know Florida does something similar, both funded completely by a tax on the lottery. Students do still have to pay some fees, but the cost is relatively quite small.
- RecycledEle 3y agoIt is much cheaper to offer online courses than to offer in-person courses. Source: I teach college. What if state schools offered free online tuition? Cheating would be an issue, so we make the students take some tests in testing centers (like we did for industry IT certs before the reaction to COVID-19 started.) We gradually automate as much as we can using tools like AI.
- godelski 3y agoA bit off topic, but honestly meeting people at top schools and mid/low ranked schools, I don't see much of a difference except in the opportunities these people have. Whether it is physics or CS, I don't see a meaningful quality difference in their work, only that the Stanford/MIT/Berkeley kid gets more internships and has an easier opportunity getting a new job if they mess up at their old one. I routinely see people from very prestigious universities with PhDs fail on rather simple concepts that are within their domain (or answered by a google search). E.g. I've had someone from a top 5 CS school, with a PhD in ML, ask on my github to solve a tensor mismatch for them when my research code uses pytorch's nn.Embeddings and we direct them to the correct checkpoint to use (but they don't). (not our code so we don't directly provide the embedding checkpoint, but we indirectly do) A bit on topic, if this trend is as strong as it appears to be (many people I talk to see the same thing) then it really shows an over valuing of elite schools and frames this entire argument a bit differently. It would make sense that this should happen too, as teaching positions are highly competitive so there's a strong trickle down effect. You routinely see at low ranked schools professors from high ranked schools (often in a soft retire, for location, or in a junior position). It would make sense that quality levelizes when a single top ranked school produces more PhDs than there are positions to fill nation wide. And on top of the general _trend_ that you can only work at a university lower in ranking than the one you attended (immediately post graduation).
- goalonetwo 3y agoI will echo this. The only things top school really do is gate-keep who is allowed to get in, providing as a consequence some sense of exclusivity. The quality of education does not seem to be that different. And even if it was, it doesn't matter that much in a field like CS that is mainly self-learned and gets reinvented every decade.
- rented_mule 3y agoI had an interesting experience a decade ago when I spent a week recruiting at UT Austin and the next week recruiting at MIT, both for software engineering jobs. UT Austin is no slouch, but it doesn't have the reputation of MIT for software engineering related majors. We collected several hundred resumes from each. Only the best resumes from UT Austin were as good as the worst resumes from MIT. But, talking to the students and interviewing them revealed that the quality distribution, in terms of what we wanted to see in interns and new grads, was much harder to tell apart. My conclusion was that the MIT admissions process did a great job of selecting for people who present themselves well on paper, probably because admission is so competitive. Both schools offer a great education for those who take full advantage of it. And we wanted to hire from that pool of people, regardless of school.
- yowzadave 3y agoIt'd be great if the U.S. would invest in very affordable elite educational institutions, to the point that they are superior academically and research-wise to the private universities. They should be national (rather than state) universities, to draw attendees from across the country. In an ideal world, today's "elite" private universities would have reputations more like Amherst--fancy places where rich people send their kids, but not schools that the best and brightest aspire to attend. The U.S. pubic universities are arguably superior to the private ones already in aggregate, we just need a few flagship schools to take the crown of "very best".
- imchillyb 3y agoProfits are not equal amongst Public Schools. What you're suggesting would work well, for an industry not designed to milk every bit of money from their 'subscribers.' Colleges are profit driven. Free doesn't drive profits.
- bentt 3y agoIt's important to refer to this as "taxpayer funded" and not "free". That doesn't mean it shouldn't happen, but saying something is free strips it of value. What we should be internalizing is that this is a public good, like roads and bridges. Nobody's like "Dude, we are getting a free road!"
- monicaaa 3y ago[dead]