7 ms·
European legislation could create liability for free-software developers
- carapace 3y agoThis is good. I love Free Software (all my personal projects are released under GPL) but I'm appalled by the terrible quality of software in general (under Free, Open, or other licenses.) Not a day goes by when some bug or breach or crash makes the news, eh? Speaking broadly (and setting aside art) software is either toys or industrial machinery. If you're writing toys (or art) this legislation won't bother you. If you are writing industrial machinery then it behooves you to do it well, and this legislation seems like a very good step in that direction. I mourn for my hobby, but it's worth it to be sidelined in favor of software produced by responsible parties.
- orangecat 3y agoI mourn for my hobby, but it's worth it to be sidelined in favor of software produced by responsible parties. In other words, this will create even more barriers to entry that will further entrench giant companies who have the necessary armies of lawyers and security engineers.
- lijok 3y agoIt will not. In fact, it might even create jobs and a better ecosystem for developers to work in. Good OSS will become commercial software, which will be upheld to a significantly higher standard.
- cobertos 3y agoNo, jobs created will be with the entrenched companies, who will grow their monopoly over the software labor market and make the software ecosystem _worse_. Tackling legislation and compliance requires scale or money (to outsource the compliance work). This WILL add barriers to entry for new companies.
- lijok 3y agoDo you think that perhaps an increased need for compliance officers would create more compliance jobs, thereby creating jobs and reducing the scale and money required to tackle legislation and compliance?
- cobertos 3y agoExisting business will have to pay for those compliance officers, salaried or through outsourced work. It WILL require more scale. There is no reduction here. In absolute terms, less time will be spent writing software and more time will be spent on compliance (which maybe a good thing for traditional, corporate software!). But, it's not something your average open source developer is falling all over themselves to have anything to do with.
- PixyMisa 3y agoWell, it never has in the entire history of humanity, but sure, whatever.
- lijok 3y agoSo compliance officers don't exist, or am I misunderstanding what you're trying to say?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoTwo-person startups don't have a full-time compliance officer, so who do these economies of scale benefit?
- lijok 3y agoThat's interesting. Every startup I've ever worked at, the chief compliance officer & mlro was one of the first 2-3 employees to get hired (as far as I can recall).
- 3y ago
- cinntaile 3y agoRegulatory capture is a well-studied phenomenon.
- carapace 3y agoWell, I think that soon most software will be written by machine, in something like Idris or Lean, and merely guided by humans via a linguistic interface. With any luck, within a decade or two, the idea of buggy insecure software will be as anachronistic as baking one's own bread.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoFirst, I have no idea what you are talking about. Bad open source software has never hurt me, best I can tell. Your claims seem farcical & ladden with over importance. Second, the level of entitlement in display here is revolting. Why do you think you are owed perfection? Why do you imagine that software developers possibly could foresee every possible issue that might arise? How could they project & comprehend every way their library might be misused by another? There's nothing less hackery than those so polarly demanding hard fast answers to alleviate & end the hackerly search for meaning. We must thrive with uncertainty, must learn progress & advance, with eagerness & inquiry; to demand that we have only certain assured things is a sad folly of weak spirits. The ask is impossible; no creatures nor artifice on this earth are so perfect. Thise who are close to the machine know that the fathomless depths of computing rapidly go beyond what any mind might imagine, and it is absurd & pompous, an insistence of those who don't get it at all, to demand everything be perfectly concieved & known. We are still learning so many mysteries of the universe. Demanding that no more mysteries ever be created, demanding only certainty from here on our; that is so far askance from the bravery of what has risen up thise species & what continues to improve it. We flourish by struggle, by going forwards, and letting progress be forever snubbed by fear is the enemy.
- carapace 3y agoYour opening paragraph seems so "farcical & ladden with over importance" that I didn't bother to read the rest of your reply. Good day.
- SoftTalker 3y ago> Bad open source software has never hurt me, best I can tell. You may not think so but here is a likely scenario: Some startup uses an open source library in their app. You install the app. It gathers some information about you. Due to weaknesses in the library, a data breach occurs. Your information is part of that.
- carlosjobim 3y agoBeggars can't be choosers.
- coolhand2120 3y agoI’m guessing you don’t really write anything meaningful if you are able to just call it a hobby and dismiss it. There are among us people like myself who dedicate large percentages of their lives to working on FOSS. I want nothing to do with government regulations and I suspect neither do my millions of users. How would the governments, who have shown they not only know nothing about cybersecurity, but actively work to undermine it all the time, help me with the security of my projects? Nobody can say, because like all else the government does. It is simply theatre to make well meaning busy bodies think the government cares. Meanwhile corrupt politicians in the government will surely further poison the law by figuring out how to enrich themselves by giving preferable treatment to the worst offenders (as usual). I don’t know why people don’t put in their heuristics hat more often when analyzing these things.
- carapace 3y agoSo government is broken and therefore shipping broken software to "millions of users" is okay?
- SoftTalker 3y agoAnyone else who makes any kind of product available for public use is held to some standards of responsibility and liability for any harm that it causes. Why should software be any different?
- jcadam 3y agoSo, we may need to add a "Not for use in the European Union" clause to open source licenses?
- uxp8u61q 3y agoNo, but you may refuse to provide paid support to EU customers if you don't want to deal with your product's cybersecurity (risk assessment, vulnerability reporting, etc).
- MaxBarraclough 3y agoI suspect such a licence would be rejected by the OSI, and by the FOSS community. Criterion 5 of the OSI's Open Source definition: [0] > No Discrimination Against Persons or Groups > The license must not discriminate against any person or group of persons. To my knowledge this hasn't been tried in a licence before. FOSS licences generally state something about accepting no liability, and this seems to work pretty well even across jurisdictional differences. Presumably the legal situation changes if the software is sold, e.g. with enterprise Linux distributions, but of course FOSS is not typically distributed on that basis. [0] https://opensource.org/osd/ https://opensource.org/osd/
- seeknotfind 3y agoWell, who made them the gatekeeper? OSI bought a domain, they are not open source. Regional licensing is pretty standard in general though. Especially for things under copyright. Or "No use if use implies X constraint". There are surely ways to word it that focus on how using it impacts the software, without having to mention a specific group.
- MaxBarraclough 3y ago> Well, who made them the gatekeeper? OSI bought a domain, they are not open source. The broader community puts a lot of stock in the licence-approval work done by the OSI, the FSF, and the Debian project. One concrete consequence is that the Debian repositories won't accept your package. (Debian's requirements are much like those of the OSI. In practice, the 3 bodies almost always agree on whether a licence is acceptable.) Less concretely, in terms of adoption and community-building it can be really bad news for a project to be almost truly Free and Open Source.
- bell-cot 3y ago[Sigh\] If humans could live on red tape alone, the EU could feed the world.
- stavros 3y agoIf humans could live on laissez-faire capitalism, the US wouldn't have 11% of its population living below the poverty line.
- s1gnp0st 3y agoIt's reassuring that Europe has managed to solve poverty as an example to us all.
- stavros 3y agoRight, because unless you're going to completely solve poverty, you shouldn't bother trying to do anything about it at all. How does someone even make the argument that 11% poverty in the US is exactly the same as 0.4% in Denmark?
- mrighele 3y agoAccording to [1] the rate of poverty in the US is 15% compared to 6.5% in Denmark ( and 10.9% of Germany, 14.2% of Italy, and 8.4% of France, the three strongest economies of EU). [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/233910/poverty-rates-in-oecd-countries/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/233910/poverty-rates-in-...
- CamperBob2 3y agoBy pointing out the countless differences between Denmark and the US? That said, one great thing both Denmark and the US have in common is that neither country will shoot you at the border for trying to leave.
- cocacola1 3y ago
- messe 3y agoOriginal article title is "The European Cyber Resilience Act", but OP has editorialized it to "European Legislation Could Create Liability for Free-Software Developers".
- belter 3y agoI am the OP and also not like when titles are editorialized. This is how it is as in Leading items - LWN.net Weekly Edition for September 21, 2023 "The European Cyber Resilience Act: an overview of proposed European legislation that could create liability for free-software developers." Which one do you think is the most informative?
- Aachen 3y agoA combination of both would be best, but might be too long. I know of the act, and was assuming that it would be about that act, but it doesn't say so one needs to click. On the other hand, the original title is even worse because it tells you nothing about why it's interesting. Choice of two evils? I think your choice was the better of the two, unless it can be made to fit both
- uxp8u61q 3y agoA lot of straw-grasping. The whole thing "commercial activity" thing, for example. The legal guide says: > on a case by case basis taking into account the regularity of the supplies, the characteristics of the product, the intentions of the supplier, etc. In principle, occasional supplies by charities or hobbyists should not be considered as taking place in a business related context. And apparently the author decided to ignore everything but "regularity of the supplies" and decided that a widely used product that makes regular releases is commercial activity. Sorry, but I'm absolutely not convinced. "Characteristics of the product" and "intentions of the supplier" is already very broad and you could easily argue that a non-commercial open-source project is, well, not classified as open-source according to the regulation. The author also truncated the paragraph about open source from the regulation. Here it is in its entirety: > In order not to hamper innovation or research, free and open-source software developed or supplied outside the course of a commercial activity should not be covered by this Regulation. This is in particular the case for software, including its source code and modified versions, that is openly shared and freely accessible, usable, modifiable and redistributable. In the context of software, a commercial activity might be characterized not only by charging a price for a product, but also by charging a price for technical support services, by providing a software platform through which the manufacturer monetises other services, or by the use of personal data for reasons other than exclusively for improving the security, compatibility or interoperability of the software. It is absolutely clear that the EU has thought about open-source software and is intent on not harming the ecosystem with its regulation. But it is stating the obvious: if you write free, open-source software, but you charge for support, then yes, you're engaging in a commercial activity! You cannot have your cake and eat it too. You want to take money from EU consumers? Abide by the EU rules and ensure that the products you distribute comply with the regulations. You don't want to deal with that? Don't take the money. It's as simple as that. Every single link to a reaction from a foundation or developer in this newsletter is in that vein: complaining that they want to continue taking money for support or a platform but avoid falling under the "commercial" category. That just doesn't work. Sorry for the rant but I'm genuinely upset. The EU wants to protect me, an EU customer, from vendors who sell software or software support contract but don't take cybersecurity seriously. They've recognized that OSS is special and even went as far as making special exceptions for it - but without allowing loopholes where vendors hide behind open-source to avoid liability. And yet, what do we get? EU bashing. Because apparently the only good regulation is no regulation. I don't want to live in a libertarian hellhole. If you do, don't force it upon me, and abide by the local law if you want to do business with me.
- transfire 3y agoI think its time to start questioning statements like “While it aims at a worthy goal”. Does it though? I think the goal is not what you think it is. You want secure software? Require it all to be open source.
- marcosdumay 3y agoIt's time people internalize the systems theory rule that the goal of a system is what it does. The maximum number of people that can hold a goal is 1. More than that, and there's no goal.
- lijok 3y ago> There is a reason why the open-source world has concerns: the legislation indirectly defines who is responsible for the security of open source and who should pay to improve the current state. In addition, it puts the responsibility on individual developers and foundations hosting open-source projects instead of the manufacturers of goods embedding the software. Why is this a concern? If you are unable to produce high quality, safe software, then don't make it publicly available for use. If you make something publicly available for use, you should be liable for maintaining it and any damages that software causes due to bugs. No different than if I were to make some crappy fire extinguishers and hand them out to people for free. No different than if I were to build a little bridge over a river.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoWhat a horrible statement. Who is ever certain? How certain are you? How willing to endure false claims are you, even if miraculously you have convinced yourself the work is flawless? This is insulting beyond words. We think together with open source. Ideas are shared. The world iterates forward & we learn & improve, together. Saying we cannot open our mouths unless we have only the voices of the angels is a demonic silencing. Hard disagree.
- lijok 3y ago> Who is ever certain? How certain are you? How willing to endure false claims are you, even if miraculously you have convinced yourself the work is flawless? If you're not certain and unwilling to fight false claims, just don't publish it for public use. It's kind of that simple. > We think together with open source. Ideas are shared. The world iterates forward & we learn & improve, together Indeed. And we have, and continue to produce plenty of resources for that. > This is insulting beyond words My sincere apologies that I insulted you by stating you shouldn't be allowed to hand out home-made fire extinguishers to the public and expect no repercussions
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoI have the hardest time imaging what it would take to develop software we are certain of. Developers of greatest talent are experts at finding doubts and potential weaknesses. They see accrued depth of complexity far beyond what the minds of simpler beings floating only on the surface of interface see. They can imagine all kinds of complex interactions. And they are never certain. That doubt is a doubt they work against, guard against ad best they can, but live with. It feels like such a ridiculous silly alien voice, such absurd naivety, to say, oh, just be certain. Just make it flawless. Whatever happens, it must be perfect. It's a juvenile fantasy, that only one ignorant to the complex nature of reality, unthinking of the combinatorial explosions of possibilities that happen as layers of systems & libraries intersect, unseeing of the absurd misuse by users of technology, that any and all difficulties could be conquered by just demanding someone making something make it perfect or never ever share it with the world, never allow users.
- layer8 3y agoPrevious discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36783445 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36783445 (34 comments, 2 months ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35914013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35914013 (122 comments, 4 months ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35637556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35637556 (97 comments, 5 months ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35011108 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35011108 (200 comments, 7 months ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33594440 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33594440 (203 comments, 10 months ago)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tkiolp4 3y agoNot sure why the burden is put on the shoulders of the authors of open source software. Would make more sense to say “Companies that use open source software to sell their own software must comply with the following security practices…”
- bhelkey 3y agoThis would penalize paid software when compared to ad supported software.
- EPWN3D 3y agoI'm sure all the free software cheerleaders who were lauding the EU for requiring that Apple support side loading will be thrilled. Sauce for the goose and all that.
- jaythvv 3y agoIt really won't. It's targeted at corporations, especially big tech, not open source where there is no money. If anything, it will likely toss more resources to open source by those very same big tech companies, to protect their liabilities
- layer8 3y ago> If anything, it will likely toss more resources to open source by those very same big tech companies, to protect their liabilities I don’t think that's how it will work. The moment the big company ships an open-source library as part of their commercial software, they will be liable for it (but not the original non-commercial open-source authors, if any). As soon as it's used as part of a commercial product, being open source or not won't matter for the liability.