12 ms·
Leaked screenshot shows Amazon now tracking individual employee attendance
- RadiozRadioz 3y agoAre there companies who don't track individual badge-in rates? I thought that was common practice.
- philipov 3y agoMaybe your sample is biased towards companies that track individual badge-in rates.
- RadiozRadioz 3y agoPossibly, but then I think to all those thousands of companies still on timecards. That must surely make up a healthy portion.
- mathgeek 3y agoTimecards are generally used for hourly employees rather than salaried (although not universally).
- wil421 3y agoIf you have to badge in it’s tracked somewhere. If they generate reports or even access the data is another story. The buildings access control system knows what badge ids opened the door or gate.
- philipov 3y agoSaying someone is "tracking attendance" doesn't mean "there is hypothetical data out there that could be used to track attendance." It means they are generating those reports and using them. The "another story" is the entire story.
- mathgeek 3y agoI would assume that most companies are not large enough to need badges, but also that the smaller number of large companies have a higher percentage that do.
- avidiax 3y agoAre there countries where the police don't track where you are at all times? There is a qualitative difference between "could, with a valid reason and manual effort, track" vs. "automatically tracked and shared with your management chain". Any company with badge readers has an access log. In the before-times, that log would only be used for a legal or HR investigation, after the fact, when there are other performance problems. This is going to be used to punish employees, semi-automatically, probably even if they are otherwise performing well.
- hef19898 3y agoIn fact, in Germany hour-booking is independant from access-badging. And employers are forbidden to cross-reference those systems.
- lnsru 3y agoAny source for such a bold claim? Our Betriebsrat is absolutely fine when managers check our attendance by looking at hour booking entries and associated locations.
- hef19898 3y agoHour bookings and locations are dine, as in you saying at which location you clocked in and out. Referencing badging to enter and exit a location to cross-reference clocking in and out data is, usually, a complete no-go. Unless, of course, a specific employee is suspected of cheating. But then I assume it depends on the BR as well, but each and every BR I encountered so far was strictly oppossed to this kind of data cross referencing. Unless, of course, entering and exiting a location is used for clocking in/out, because then there is no data to cross reference.
- hotpotamus 3y agoI remember when the CEO of a company I worked for stepped down and I encouraged a friend to run for the position saying I'd vote for him. I thought it was amusing, but I've always found it funny that centrally-planned dictatorships are seen as a terrible form of government, but also essentially how every private company is run. (In the US at least - I have a vague notion that workers get seats on company boards in other countries at least.)
- fastneutron 3y agoAt places I’ve worked, they were logged, but only ever audited in cases of suspected time fraud or other legal infractions. Anonymized statistics were also sometimes used for covid tracking. There was never somebody actively sifting through the data and taking attendance.
- dfadsadsf 3y agoWhile I am sure there was database somewhere with badge-in data, up until now I have never worked at a place that looked at that data or made it available to managers or employees. Exempt status (non-hourly worker) in US essentially prevents company from controlling hours worked for individual employee.
- buffington 3y agoI worked at a company that used badge-in data to determine how many people to expect for lunch (which the company provided). Given the terribly ancient tech that system ran on, I'm certain that around 11AM every day the person responsible for producing lunch would import a CSV file into Excel and tally the list, all in plaintext. Granted, that's probably an odd exception to the norm, but your comment reminded me of how badge-in data presented a clever solution to a problem, even if I shudder to think of how that data could have been used for harm.
- varispeed 3y ago> Are there companies who don't track individual badge-in rates? I thought that was common practice. It's interesting that when a spouse does it, it is called abuse, but when employer does it, it is okay?
- envsubst 3y agoFamily relationships are much closer and have more trust than relationship between employer and employee.
- varispeed 3y agoSo if a husband doesn't trust the wife, it is okay to have them clock in and out of the house and wear a tracker?
- buffington 3y agoMaybe? Not my cup of tea, but if I didn't trust my wife, and she allowed me to track her, maybe that'd solve whatever hypothetical problem we were having. Very unlikely, but I don't think the idea itself, doomed to fail or not, is a problem if both parties consent. Which is what you do when you work for an employer that wants to track your entries/exits into their buildings. You consent to allowing systems to be put in place that serve as placeholders for when trust isn't yet or won't be established.
- envsubst 3y agoWhat are you talking about?
- cobrabyte 3y ago> I thought that was common practice. It is.
- treesknees 3y agoDepends on how you mean 'track'. At our company, of course we always had badges and therefore there's some auditable trail of access somewhere. But it was never a tool that my management chain regularly used to check up on employees outside of an occasional anomaly. It wasn't until a 3-day office mandate that managers started receiving badge-in reports.
- Zealotux 3y agohttps://archive.ph/spV5h https://archive.ph/spV5h
- jessriedel 3y agoThese links never work anymore for me and many others because of an infinite captcha loop. Wayback Machine works for me tho: https://web.archive.org/web/20230929092330/https:/www.businessinsider.com/amazon-forced-rto-tracking-employee-office-attendance-2023-9 https://web.archive.org/web/20230929092330/https:/www.busine...
- notamy 3y ago> These links never work anymore for me and many others because of an infinite captcha loop. 1.1.1.1 does not work with archive.ph and the related family of archive sites, due to choices on the archive.* end of things. See ex. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36970702 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36970702
- jessriedel 3y agoThanks. As a non-expert, I found the blog post a bit easier to follow: https://jarv.is/notes/cloudflare-dns-archive-is-blocked/ https://jarv.is/notes/cloudflare-dns-archive-is-blocked/
- martinald 3y agoThanks for pointing this out. I was so confused why this was happening on only one of my machines.
- VWWHFSfQ 3y agoAre there companies that don't keep track of whether or not their employees are showing up for work?
- pftburger 3y agoA lot of firms optimise for work done, goals achieved, milestones met etc. (some) labor detached from Value = Hours worked a long time ago, but people love to beat that poor dear horse. Shem, poor horsy climbs onto soap box Step right up ladies and gentlemen and hear the benefits of renting access to your skills vs selling your labor!
- wizerdrobe 3y agoLots of firms do use a “results oriented” model, I work for such a firm and really try to work only at firms with those values. But we’re very much out of the broader societal norm here. Amazon checking that employees show up to work is very much a societal norm, and probably a global one for those working at a business. Harping on standards and practices like this too hard risks making one appear out of touch with the average worker, bit of an “let them eat cake” type of statement. The average, non-HN type would see that headline and think “so what, my boss expects to physically see me daily” and has done so my entire life.
- zeta0134 3y agoI guess I'm more surprised that these were anonymous at some point. That seems like a pretty normal thing to track when you pay employees hourly. Were they in the building when they claimed to be working? Like I realize this is charged up by the work from home discussion, but I'd expect any building with a badge to get in the door to be tracking those events, at the very least to detect unauthorized access, but also to detect folks claiming to be working when they're not even there. Basic fraud prevention stuff really.
- civilitty 3y agoI didn’t think anyone wanted to open that Pandora’s box with respect to hourly workers lest people start suing for unpaid work using badge in time as evidence. As long as they don’t track it too closely they have a lot more plausible deniability for wage theft. Once they start tracking it, the lawyers can start manipulating juries.
- 26fingies 3y agoDoes presenting evidence count as manipulating a jury?
- pixl97 3y agoThe old "Objection, this evidence is damning to my case" ploy.
- Qem 3y agoAs it's often said, what's sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander. If you're going to watch closely people on the hours done, also make sure to pay them properly for any excess hours. Wage theft is the worst kind of theft.
- lm28469 3y ago> That seems like a pretty normal thing to track when you pay employees hourly. We need eye trackers and brain implants to make sure the workers aren't looking at something else or thinking about non work related tasks too. I don't want to pay these parasites a single cent for idle time /s
- JCM9 3y agoMy high school used to track attendance on if we showed up every day or not. Was I supposed think this was odd? People can debate endlessly over the benefits, or not, of working in an office but it’s a perfectly reasonable thing for a company to want its workers to show up at an office and reasonable to measure if they actually do. This is a non story.
- saagarjha 3y agoPeople who work at Amazon are not high school students.
- whynotmaybe 3y agoRight, and I always have the same question to anyone complaining about this. "If you hire someone to fix the plumbing in your house and you pay him by the hour, would you check that he worked what he's asking or do you pay blindly?" Yes "Amazon bad" and whatnot but in the end it all boils down to the same thing, we live in a society where you want what you pay for, whether you're an individual or a company. And as a plumber, if you don't want to be checked or followed by some annoying customer, you ask to be paid for the completed job, not by the hour.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 2023throwawayy 3y agoA more relevant discussion for this crowd I think would be, if you hire a consultant and pay them hourly, do you expect to be able to monitor their screen remotely while they work? Because I’ve been a consultant hired hourly, and I would never agree to that kind of surveillance. If you don’t trust me, don’t hire me. The output of the work should be all that matters. Back to your point, if the plumber fixed the problem for what seems like a reasonable amount of time, why would I need to follow them around?
- zeckalpha 3y agoIf they do that sort of thing, it may violate the definition of the contractor status for tax purposes, and you may be reclassified as an employee.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jmartrican 3y agoIf there is a story here, it's that the employees have access to their own badge access history.
- Zetobal 3y agoWe have it in germany it's so we can check and validate how much overtime/pto etc we have. It's rather standard tbh.
- NBJack 3y agoAmazon doesn't pay overtime to salaried employees in the states. They already have an internal PTO tool, which allows oversight from your manager. This is just a numbers game.
- mercwear 3y agoSeems like basic management to me, if I was operating a company of Amazon's size I would 100% want to have some form of attendance tracking, hourly or not.
- Aeolun 3y agoYou don’t think “do they get the job done” is a more valuable indicator of whether you want to continue paying them? “Were they in the office” seems a much lower quality signal.
- jasonlfunk 3y agoSure, but "were they in the office" is /much/ easier to measure at scale. And I'm sure you'd throw a pretty big fit if your pay was docked because the company didn't think you did a good enough job, even though you were in the office.
- skywhopper 3y agoAlas, “this metric doesn’t track what we care about, BUT it’s easier to collect, so let’s use it” explains a lot of really bad policies and practices in our world.
- richardfey 3y agoLet's start measuring keys typed per hour next! It correlates, thus will work even better at scale.
- yreg 3y agoInteresting thread for me, since usually it's the US that has practices that are a pain in the butt for employees. Well, this time it's apparently the other way around. In my country (Slovakia, EU member) it's standard for corporate jobs to track fixed salary employees via badge readers. I've never worked such a job and always thought it's weird but the practice is ubiquitous. Depending on the management, in some (most?) companies you get into problems if you spend far less than 8 hrs a day average in the offices. Only now, with remote work, I think the practice is slowly going away.
- Leherenn 3y agoI think the expectations are different for salaried workers in the US and (most?) EU countries. In the EU, salaried workers are usually contractually required to work a certain amount of time, unlike the US where it is more "do the work asked of you". If you have finished your task faster than expected, then you're supposed to get a new task and work on it until you've worked the contracted hours. Conversely, if you've done your hours, then see you tomorrow. In that regard, it makes more sense to track how much time you actually work since it is a breach of contract not to work them.
- 3seashells 3y agoBadge data is not available in all other western nations due to tracking it beeing illegal.
- varispeed 3y agoYou need to keep your cattle in check. Are they going to tattoo workers next?
- infamouscow 3y ago[flagged]
- vjust 3y agoEmployee surveillance under a different name. Pick your poison, i.e. sell your soul to a big player, or a toxic startup, or someone with a size in between. It also depends on how you think about it. What's agreeable for you is toxic for someone else. I'd bristle at this but that's me. This market does not reward an ethics-first organization - rather, is it even possible to be an ethical organization.
- P_I_Staker 3y agoHonestly, this is the kind of surveillance I can tolerate. Track when I punch and even for "signs of life", ie. if I just don't use my laptop/vpn for 2 months.
- fourseventy 3y agoOh noes, a business tracking employee attendance, what a novel concept.
- mcbrienollie 3y ago[flagged]
- workfromspace 3y agoI'm not seeing any screenshot in the news article. Is it just me?
- llm_nerd 3y agoEvery badge system obviously logs activity, and always have. This information has always been available to the employer. The story here is that the badge data is being published on employee portal pages as a way to basically gamify their in-office rate.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI disagree the story here is the badge info is being published to the managers employee info portal to manage people out based on attendance.
- darkwater 3y agoFrom TFA: > "We're providing this data to help guide conversations as needed between employees and managers about coming into the office with their colleagues," said the memo, obtained by Insider. The HR-speak / corp-speak really rubbers the wrong nerve with me, most probably because at $DAYJOB this started to be more and more a things in the last 18 months. I understand that an official company statement has to use a certain tone and wording but constructs like "help guide conversations" just means "your boss will scold you for this in your next 1:1". This probably means it's high-time for me to go back to a smaller place.
- smarmgoblin 3y agoMy theory is that they need attrition, and they need managers to be managing out employees at a higher rate than they’ve historically been comfortable. So they won’t typically fire someone directly for attendance (yet) but they will give the managers permission to do so. That’s what these memos are meant to convey. Maybe we’ll see something similar from other big tech cos in the near future, since they all use the same consulting firms for these decisions.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThe reality is they need office attendance to meet tax agreements with the cities they’re located in. All the “culture” hand waving is certainly a factor, but something so fuzzy wouldn’t fly at Amazon. It’s when data is presented that decisions get made typically, and they have no data that shows in office collaboration improves productivity - quite the opposite - I’ve seen the data collected by other megacorps I’ve worked at where we had these discussions. The only real data is the many millions they’re getting in tax agreements with seattle and other cities they’re located in. Attrition is probably also a part of it. However, I’ve heard there’s a strongly negative bias working again Amazon in that attrition where only top talent is attriting and they’re loading up on bottom quartile who are coming into the office every day to try to cling to their job.
- aeze 3y ago> The reality is they need office attendance to meet tax agreements with the cities they’re located in. Why don’t they just come out and say that?
- karaterobot 3y agoPeople in this thread seem to be focusing on whether or not a company can track attendance; of course it can, that's not the story. The more interesting thing about this story is that Amazon said it would only track aggregate, anonymized statistics, but it has been revealed (in a shocking twist) that they were lying to their employees and the public about it.
- Eumenes 3y agoIf they didn't have badge data, they could monitor instant message/email and a million other metrics. I have no empathy. Engineers at Amazon actively work on products that track and monitor users. Its a bit ironic. This isn't some civil rights violation - its part and parcel when working for an international big tech corporation.
- hammock 3y agoIf you don’t like it, work somewhere else. I don’t see much in the comments about voting with your feet. I’m sure I’ll get downvoted for this. I do empathize, and a productive reaction is to map what leverage you have and what you don’t, and use that. Complaining online isn’t it
- NBJack 3y agoThis isn't a viable option for many visa holders in the U.S.
- hammock 3y agoVisa holder…wanting a remote job…???
- NBJack 3y agoOriginal article refers to office attendance. Even hopping to a remote position with a visa (i.e. a H1-B) can take weeks to get approved, and it is not guaranteed. Many rightfully argue those holding one while working on site is, in many ways, a legal form of enslaved.
- hammock 3y agoI guess my (possibly naive, definitely oversimplified) point was that if a foreigner wants a job where they don’t have to come to the office, why are they trying to get/maintain a visa in a place that might require them to come in? Seems they could seek most of those attendance-not-required US jobs from their home country (no visa required)
- gumballindie 3y agoAt this stage, wanting to work in tech, let alone at companies such at amazon, is just silly.
- RecycledEle 3y agoHow did tracking your employees' attendance become controversial? Am I the only one here who ever punched a time clock?
- tantalor 3y agoTime tracking is highly unusual for full-time employees. It's only needed if you are paid by the hour. Time tracking for pay has nothing to do with "tracking attendance".
- gmd63 3y ago[flagged]
- johnbellone 3y ago[flagged]
- ryandrake 3y agoAssuming the employee is performing his duties and producing the expected output, and not sharing confidential company info, then how is this a problem? CEOs lead multiple companies, and often sit on the boards of other companies, and it's OK. Retail workers can work two or three jobs to hustle and make more money and that's admirable, but somehow when a white collar office worker manages to do it successfully, it's a huge problem?
- johnbellone 3y agoIn my cases, the employees weren't performing the expected output, which is what led to the discovery that they were working multiple jobs. Retail workers aren't working multiple jobs at the same time. In general, it is a straightforward transactional relationship with hours worked. That's not the case with a salaried job.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- GreedClarifies 3y agoDirectors have been getting a weekly report based upon this data from within a couple of months of the start of the pandemic.
- supergeek133 3y agoWe recently went back into the office mandatory 3 days a week. Our offices are generally small, so people hold the door for each other and that kind of thing. I told everyone.. scan your badge at door/lock swipes every chance you get.
- max_hammer 3y agoTailgating is serious security treat.
- supergeek133 3y agoIn a small office without turnstiles and just sometimes badge swipe doors, this is what happens.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoAmazon and a lot of places either have tailgating detection in the turnstiles or at some locations airlock style turnstiles. One place I worked people would scan in, log in, then jump the turnstile out to not track the badge out, then go back home and work.
- supergeek133 3y agoAnd as long as companies keep using these types of methods to "track work" or "attendance" people will keep finding ways around it.
- max_hammer 3y agoIt's a very common policy in Indian IT companies to track hours. I started my career with Infosys and we have to maintain a daily average of 9.15 hours. Never worked in a company that tracks hours after that. Amazon aspects workers to be available for on-call 24x7, it's very difficult to provide this level of support of you have to commute to office 3 days
- barelysapient 3y agoA few thoughts: 1. This is probably just badge-in and not badge-out data. I'd be surprised if you have to badge to exit the facility. 2. This may contain badge data when accessing other areas of the campus; such as elevators, executive offices, etc. I'm curious how they're handling expected OOTO scenarios. E.g., a worker traveling on company assignment for several months, gets fired for not badging in frequently enough. The enforcement spectrum on this is probably pretty broad, and probably felt most in areas where the company believes there is systemic under-performance; or in areas where the company wants to un-invest without explicitly coming out and saying it. Fragmented teams will be reorganized and the process continues some underlying business metric, such as the labor component of SG&A, hits the desired corporate target.
- DiggyJohnson 3y ago> E.g., a worker traveling on company assignment for several months, gets fired for not badging in frequently enough. Presumably they don't auto-fire employees without any human intervention in the process.
- barelysapient 3y agoPresumably, but in an organization that size, I can easily imagine a manager with a large number of direct reports, perhaps scattered geographically too, where the employee's actual assignment or expected work location is completely opaque. Especially if that employee is independent or soft reporting into another team.
- plusplusungood 3y agoFor 1, it depends on the building. Early Amazon buildings did not require badging out. I'm my experience, they've been switching to badge out turnstiles over time. That said, I don't think they're using that data in the reports yet. I know of people who simply badge in and go home. For ooto, they are not tracking this correctly. I received one of the nastygrams when I was on vacation. I forwarded it as my notice of resignation.
- nuancebydefault 3y ago'Tracking individual employee attendance'. This was perfectly normal 4 years ago for almost every single company around the world. Today it seems to be hot news. Wow, how rapidly changed, the world.