12 ms·
Physical gold might have value in situation where financial institutions and markets start to lose any trust in themselves. Either by manipulation, government c
by Ekaros 3y ago
Physical gold might have value in situation where financial institutions and markets start to lose any trust in themselves. Either by manipulation, government confiscation or fraud.
But, things will be pretty bad at that point from every viewpoint. As essentially global markets are crashing. On other hand, in even bigger crisis gold won't be that valuable at least for a while. If food and fuel are first priority people are unlikely to trade them for shiny metal...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _8j50 3y agoShiny metal is better for trade than bartering because it is rare and easy to break down into smaller chunks. Its value is that people other than the persons trading with it are also willing to trade with it. Guns and ammo sound like a better alternative but their rarity is unknown and unpredictable and even less people might be willing to trade with them on a regular basis unless it's a literal warzone. Food perishes and it's rarity is also an unpredictable.
- sambazi 3y agopaying with a gun seems like a perfect recipe to get hold up for the things you just bought.
- bombcar 3y agoWhen society gets to that point looters and robbers get bullet. There’s a class of crime that can only really exist in a rule-of-law situation, without that people just get summarily executed.
- _8j50 3y agoBut what if the looters are all armed? Their power in numbers means if you shoot one the resr will overwhelm you so they can expect to not be shot for that reason alone. In reality, the looters become gangs you pay for "protection" and they will be your "police" against others
- _8j50 3y agoYou don't load them with bullets and you load your gun (not the one you are trading) and be ready to fire it western style.
- e63f67dd-065b 3y agoI don't understand why people keep thinking that a financial meltdown means societal meltdown. There's plenty of places where the economy is or has already melted down even right now -- Sri Lanka, Argentina, Venezuela, etc. We can observe what happens when political institutions completely and utterly collapse, because it's happened multiple times already. What happens is not immediate apocalypse where people riot and society breaks down; it's mass protests, shows of solidarity, people help each other out, etc. The prepper scenario of "I've gotta defend myself against mobs out to raid for food" really doesn't happen. If we stretch it back a few decades we see things like the Wiemar republic, complete anarchy during the Russian civil wars when blacks, whites, reds, etc all marched across the countryside, Chinese civil war, or even just recently we have Yemen, ISIS, Ethiopia, and in none of these cases have a zombie apocalypse-style "have to defend myself with my gun and ammo" societal breakdown occured and people bartered with gold. It turns out that people organise very quickly, and a every-man-for-himself-style situation like in stories just doesn't happen. Maybe a civil war breaks out, maybe there are food shortages, but for the most part if violence breaks out, it's organised, mainly in the form of civil wars or local power struggles. One guy with a gun is not gonna help. Food protests are common, but rarely end violently. People keep thinking that "this time is different", and they're wrong every time.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> The prepper scenario of "I've gotta defend myself against mobs out to raid for food" really doesn't happen. > Maybe a civil war breaks out, maybe there are food shortages, but for the most part if violence breaks out, it's organised, mainly in the form of civil wars. If a war breaks out, the tradition is that the armies will raid you for food. The issue was never that other locals would do it. A war breaking out is what people are afraid of.
- e63f67dd-065b 3y agoAh yes, my gun and my gold will protect me against the organised army out to raid for food. That's what I meant -- people get organised very quickly. In Rwanda, people quickly formed armies and militias, the same in Ethiopia, Columbia, and literally every other time this has happened before. One guy is not gonna accomplish much. Civil war is also, by most measures, the least likely outcome. Usually civil war causes the breakdown, not the other way around. Usually it's really a deterioration of state capacity that leads to a powerless central government (see Venezuela, Yemen, Syria), or repeated coups that lead to unstable governance (all of west africa basically). Things are mostly stable, by and large.
- satellite2 3y agoYou don't need to lose trust in the system as a hole. Only in the fact that the system serves you. Bank accounts gets frozen all the time and for a variety of reasons.
- cpursley 3y agoLike supporting the free speech rights of some truckers (now matter how misguided and annoying they might have been). De-banking people for wrongthink is absolutely terrifying, because any of us could be next depending on the mood of the current government.
- Dylan16807 3y agoDefine "supporting the free speech rights"?
- cpursley 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_2_of_the_Canadian_Charter_of_Rights_and_Freedoms https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_2_of_the_Canadian_Ch...
- Dylan16807 3y agoThat's the rights, I'm asking about the supporting. I heard about freezes for people doing the protesting (including organizing). But that's an extremely different thing from supporting the free speech rights of the protesters.
- didntcheck 3y agoOK, the government debanked people for organizing peaceful protests against them. That's hardly reassuring
- Dylan16807 3y ago
- msla 3y agoIf things have collapsed far enough where physical gold is the only currency, physical gangs will be out there confiscating said gold from physical corpses not in said gangs. The word for a catastrophe where middle-class people survive without being press-ganged into a military or otherwise being placed under the thumb of a strongman is "contrived" or, perhaps, "fictional". If you want a collapse, look at what happened in Russia in 1917, or Cambodia in 1970.
- eloisant 3y agoYes, I don't understand why people think that gold has some sort of intrinsic value. It only has value because we collectively agree it's valuable. But in itself it's not super useful, yes there are some industrial applications where it's better than other metals but if it was only valued on this basis it would be worth much, much less.