9 ms·
Desalination system could produce fresh water that is cheaper than tap water
- mint2 3y agoTitle makes no sense. It says tap water is cheaper than tap water
- bilekas 3y agoNot a water expert here but surely all tap water is not desalinated.. That would be just outrageous expensive with current pricing and technologies.
- mint2 3y agoOnce desalinated, it becomes what is known as tap water. (Except only a few liters per day per unit) But yes. You’ve hit on the one of the absurdities of the headline: drinking water costs vary wildly based on a large number of factors including the source and treatments.
- selimthegrim 3y agoNew Orleans could use this right about now.
- mdhen 3y agoThe researchers estimate that if the system is scaled up to the size of a small suitcase, it could produce about 4 to 6 liters of drinking water per hour and last several years before requiring replacement parts. At this scale and performance, the system could produce drinking water at a rate and price that is cheaper than tap water. This seems like it would be extremely useful if it pans out.
- dylan604 3y agoscale up to a small suitcase...how small is it now?
- Kon-Peki 3y ago… and what is preventing them from scaling up to a small suitcase?
- imbusy111 3y agoOr a large suitcase? Or a thousand large suitcases?
- Animats 3y agoThat's a very good question. We see these articles all the time, and they somehow don't get scaled up. You'd think they'd at least scale this up to the size of a typical rooftop solar panel before issuing a press release. So what's the problem? Uses some expensive material? Hard to fabricate at scale? Doesn't actually hold up in bright sunlight? Go back and read their previous "breakthrough announcement" from 2020.[1] That has more useful info. That system used some expensive aerogel. The process is a bit clearer, During the daytime it evaporates salt water and condenses the vapor. During the night it back-washes the wicking material. Whether this can actually work with some simple device floating in a pool of salt water is not clear. The experimental systems all have plumbing, pumps, and instrumentation. If this is for real, please scale it up to at least kiddie-pool size before turning on the PR department. [1] https://news.mit.edu/2020/passive-solar-powered-water-desalination-0207 https://news.mit.edu/2020/passive-solar-powered-water-desali...
- dylan604 3y agothese premature announcements always make me think of a little kid desperate for attention to have mom/dad hang their drawing on the fridge. it's cute from a developing child, but as grown as adults, it's just sad really. oh, you had a clever idea, but can't do anything practical with it? here's your gold star. now go have some milk and cookies and get ready for your nap.
- trey-jones 3y agoInstead of a gold star, they probably would like to have some funding.
- Someone1234 3y agoSounds interesting. Seems like it uses energy from the sun, but also requires a location with ocean currents. So finding good installation locations along the shoreline where it is both deep enough to work while being shallow enough to maintain may be a limit on how much capacity you could have. Hopefully they are able to try a scaled up version in a LESS controlled environment to see if additional problems arise.
- NegativeLatency 3y agoHow destructive is hot dense brine (the waste from) desalination systems? Seems like it would sink to the floor and create a dead zone.
- SoftTalker 3y agoIf it's discharged with household sewage, it should be close to original salinity, assuming most of the household water usage eventually goes out the sewage pipe.
- JackMorgan 3y agoThat's.... remarkably clever. But I think the system loses quite a bit due to evaporation.
- DoctorOetker 3y agoand gains quite a bit due to rainfall
- gooseus 3y agoIt's not good, desalination plants have to mitigate this with long diffusers that regulate the rate and concentration of the brine that is being put back into the ocean. Here is one for sale: https://www.jains.com/Pipefittings/JainPEPipes/spacial%20fittings/DIFFUSER.htm https://www.jains.com/Pipefittings/JainPEPipes/spacial%20fit...
- Robotbeat 3y agoSounds like it’s easily solved with a diffuser.
- mywittyname 3y agoIt's a very difficult problem to solve at human scale. And getting it wrong can have catastrophic impacts. Even if 100% of grey water runoff is mixed with the brine, the resulting concentration is still high enough to cause a localized collapse in the ocean if it isn't properly regulated.
- mixedmath 3y agoThis sounded pretty strong to me, so I did a quick napkin-math check of feasibility (in short - it passed the napkin check). On a sunny day, total solar energy hitting the top of the atmosphere gives about 1360 watts per square meter (source - top result from google, something something NASA). It takes about 4.184 joules to raise one ml of water by 1 degree celsius. Let's suppose that the "suitcase" proposed in the article has 1 square meter of space (a pretty large suitcase) and is able to capture 100 percent of solar energy (unreasonably effective). Then pure solar energy-wise, there is enough energy to raise 325 ml of water by one degree of celsius per second in a square meter. If the water is, say, at 16 degrees (the temperature of the ocean near me), in would take 84 seconds to bring 325 ml of water to boiling temperature. To transform boiling water to steam, each ml of water takes an additional 2257 joules. In 540 seconds, the 325 ml of water is now converted to steam. In total, it has taken 624 seconds to steamify 325 ml of water (under very optimistic circumstances). Morally one could do this almost 6 times in an hour, giving approximately 2 litres of water per hour. (Edit): Looking a bit closer, I see that the article's description of their work suggests that they recapture some of the energy from condensing the steam back into water. I didn't account for this. Even a moderate amount of recapture changes the math very favorably. This makes me suspect that their claim of 4-6 liters per hour would require a rather large "suitcase"-sized device, but is within the ballpark of reason.
- grandchild 3y agofurther down the article: > if each stage were scaled up to a square meter, it would produce up to 5 liters of drinking water per hour so 1m², times the number of layers.
- lta 3y agoI think the layers are on to of each other if the total surface is a square meter, it doesn't bring any more solar energy to stack layers, right ?
- o0banky0o 3y agoI don't think they are boiling it. It read to me like they're just evaporating the water in some efficient way, rather than boiling. What would the math look like if they aren't necessarily going to boil?
- nomilk 3y agoFor most cities, the cost of the water infrastructure (building and maintaining pipes) is much more expensive than the cost of the actual water. In Melbourne, Australia, since tap water mostly comes from catchments in national parks, water requires very little treatment (some fluoride and chlorine is added), so it works out cheap: ~$25 AUD per million liters. Desalinated water, by contrast, cost about 24 times more (~$600 AUD per million liters).
- eikenberry 3y agoAre you saying that the water is so cheap that switching to desalination will be a non-issue OR are you saying that this will make the water a large enough portion of the cost to make it significant?
- bsder 3y ago> Are you saying that the water is so cheap that switching to desalination will be a non-issue For human consumption: this is pretty much true. Desalinization works just fine for people. The biggest issue is where to put the extra salty waste products. When people talk about the "water crisis" in the US, for example, it's always about big agribusinesses doing farming.
- genewitch 3y agoany time there's a fish storm in the atlantic, just dump the salt in that area?
- yencabulator 3y ago> The biggest issue is where to put the extra salty waste products. The U.S. has "salt farms" where they evaporate water to produce salt. Sounds like colocating near the desalination plant would make those cheaper to operate.
- grecy 3y agoMelbourne is the perfect example of "what are we going to do when the water runs out". Remember when the storage was down to single digits?
- mcpackieh 3y ago"Cheaper than tap water" is an inane meaningless claim. Cheaper than tap water where? Tap water isn't one price, the price of fresh water is hyper local. I doubt this technology will make water cheaper even for most people living along a coast. > From these tests, the researchers calculated that if each stage were scaled up to a square meter, it would produce up to 5 liters of drinking water per hour So 1) They haven't yet tried this at the scale of one square meter. So this is a lab project that is nowhere close to commercialization but that doesn't stop them from making grand vague pronouncements about its potential. Classic MIT tbqh. 2) 5 liters per square meter per hour is trash. An average American uses a bit more than 300 liters of water a day, so you need 60 square meters of this to support one average American. So you'd need more than 5000 square kilometers of this to provide water to NYC. Does this sound like it's going to be cheaper than the tap water they already have?
- nonfamous 3y agoI guess one problem is that by definition, sea water is at sea level, and any desalinated water would have to be pumped to deliver it anywhere. Pumping costs. By contrast, isn't most fresh water delivered by gravity, for free?
- addaon 3y ago> 5 liters per square meter per hour is trash. An average American uses a bit more than 300 liters of water a day, so you need 60 square meters of this to support one average American. Unit check. 5 liters per hour is 120 liters per day. So you need 2.5 m^2 per American (ignoring whether the hourly rate is sustainable, just correcting units). This is about a third of the projected area of a typical car, so in terms of surface-area-per-person we're at about half that of cars (given about 2/3 of a car per American).
- mcpackieh 3y agoGood catch.
- terramars 3y agoyou can only account for 6hrs of sun per day, so it's more like 30liters per day. that gives you 10m^2 per American. however serving Americans is not a practical use case. i agree these kinds of systems are not going to be competitive with large scale PV driven RO (i build medium scale solar RO plants in africa and they're pretty good and surprisingly affordable). however having a mobile one you can put on a vehicle or deploy in a small scale distributed manner with little to no expertise would be extremely useful in low population density or nomadic context.
- pfdietz 3y agoA simple evaporation system without heat recovery would use about 100x the energy of reverse osmosis per unit of fresh water produced (which is somewhere around 5 to 8 kWh per cubic meter of fresh water.) PV-driven RO, even without energy recovery, is going to produce much more water than this scheme.
- galangalalgol 3y agoDon't RO systems need regular maintenance, and have consumable parts? It sounds like this was designed to work unmaintained for years. That could balance out the efficiency.
- jjk166 3y agoAny system that has saltwater flowing through it is going to need regular maintenance to deal with buildup and corrosion.
- galangalalgol 3y agoI also think that seems likely, just reading their announcement though they claim eddies prevent buildup and the thing looks like a glass solar still, so the brine may not contact anything it can corrode. Even normal countertop distillers come out cheaper per gallon than an RO system depending on your electricity prices, though that is not with saltwater for either.
- xkcd-sucks 3y agoMore that the important wear component in a RO system is a membrane that depends on access to sophisticated manufacturing, while plumbing is relatively easy to DIY in the field, and the big innovation in this system is 2.5mm perforated polyurethane which can also be remade with simple tools (and access to polyurethane of course but that's simpler to make or salvage than RO membranes). Kind of analogous to ICE vs electric cars; electric cars are simpler in principle but the most important components require access to advanced semiconductor and battery manufacturing, while all the components, in theory, of an ideal "ICE car" can be recreated with early 20th century machine shop technology
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoA naïve question but genuine. Reducing atmospheric pressure reduces boiling point, so would a pressure pump mixed in with heating be beneficial? Relatedly, Howard energy efficiency be affected if you didn't heat the water to be desalinated, but just evaporated it using low pressure? Would it be less, more, or equally efficient than using heat alone?
- Gibbon1 3y agoI think the energy needed to vaporize water goes up slightly as you reduce the pressure. To condense the vapor you need to remove energy and that represents a loss in a single stage system. You can use multiple stages each at a lower and lower pressure to increase the efficiency. Using the heat of condensation to vaporize the water in the next stage.
- AlexandrB 3y ago> The resulting water vapor can then be condensed and collected as pure, drinkable water. Article doesn't mention how this part would work. Peltier cooler? Heat pump? Is that included in the "suitcase sized" concept? What powers it?
- jjk166 3y agoNowhere in either this article or the paper is an estimate given for cost, nonetheless an analysis justifying the estimate. Desalination has a fundamental energy cost, and solar energy is fundamentally limited by what is received. The real question is whether it is cheaper to set up a solar-thermal desalinator, or set up solar panels that can power more efficient desalination methods. Solar panels are cheap and getting cheaper quickly as there is an incredible economy of scale. While desalination systems could likewise be mass produced, there will never be as large a demand for that one specific application of solar power as for general solar power. Further, photovoltaics are reasonably simple solid state devices which are well suited to mass production. I am highly skeptical a priori that a solar thermal system could compete on economic terms. Perhaps in a space confined situation it makes sense, but it's tough to run out of space in the ocean.
- PaulKeeble 3y agoA Solar thermal system will definitely out perform using solar panels to produce heat. A typical commercial solar panel is only 23% efficient whereas solar heaters are above 95%. With 4x the energy for the same area and a lot less sophisticated technology there is little doubt heating the water directly is better. But like with all desalination its a relatively slow process that leaks a bunch of material behind that damages everything and the costs will be dominated by all those other aspects not just where it gets its energy from.
- jjk166 3y agoYou get 4 times the energy per unit area, but if it costs more than 4 times more per unit area, the photovoltaics win. The cost per square meter of solar panels is currently around $40. Is a square meter sized solar thermal desalinator currently less than $160? In 10 years when photovoltaics are $15 per square meter, will the solar thermal desalinator be less than $60?
- mongol 3y agoPractical Engineering recently had a video on the topic "Why is desalination so difficult" https://youtu.be/mxqOPdEUNTs?feature=shared https://youtu.be/mxqOPdEUNTs?feature=shared
- puzzledobserver 3y agoI like the videos posted by Practical Engineering, but I found this one unsatisfying. Both distillation and reverse osmosis are energy expensive, but this doesn't answer whether this is because these are poor techniques or because desalinating water is fundamentally+physically difficult. Are there thermodynamic limits to how efficiently water can be desalinated? Doesn't this feel like a problem where a Carnot-like argument can be made?
- tomcar288 3y agothere's one big problem. It looks like they're creating distilled water. The WHO has stated that distilled water without the minerals that they normally contain puts people at increased risk of health problems. and you can't just get minerals from another source: that's not the problem. the problem is the water itself lacking in minerals creates problems for the body.
- jl6 3y agoPerhaps stir in some mineral powder before serving?
- kortex 3y agoCitation needed. The best source I could find (in 30s) suggests the WHO neither recommends no discourages drinking distilled water. https://svalbardi.com/blogs/water/distilled-safety https://svalbardi.com/blogs/water/distilled-safety A casual application of math to the concentrations of minerals in tap water would show you that simply eating vegetables would provide much more in the way of minerals (namely calcium and magnesium). If you drink 2L of 60mg/L Ca and 25mg/L Mg, that's only 12% daily value. "Unsafe to drink DI water" is a myth. If your diet is that marginal that +/-12% matters, take a supplement.
- tomcar288 3y agohere's the citation: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/readersblog/ezhil/dangers-of-reverse-osmosis-ro-water-24279/ https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/readersblog/ezhil/danger...
- DoctorOetker 3y ago> there's one big problem. Bombastic. > It looks like they're creating distilled water. "distilled water" can mean many similar things. It is not a binary property of water: Consider a water still that has 3 ports: one intake port of seawater, an output port of brine and an output port of water with a lower salt concentration than seawater. Distilled can in this case refer to the water exiting the third port, even though it still contains some salts. Distillation and purification in general is a process with diminishing returns: to get ever lower ppm's of mineral content requires ever more patience or energy. In the context of seawater desalination, "distilled water" typically means water with sufficient salt removed to be now potable. Either way even if the third port was effectively Sigma-Aldrich 100% pure H20, the simple fix would be to dilute a tiny amount of the brine into the distilled water to restore the mineral content to potable levels. You did not reference the study or page of the supposed WHO conclusion. When I was studying at university I recalled the concensus basically being that the adverse health effects are a myth, since 95% of our salt intake comes from food. Remember sailors have been drinking distilled water for over a hundred years. Steamboats needed the ability to desalinate water anyway. It is quite conceivable, that this myth starts as a counter-myth for a prior myth. Scientifically different types of desalinated, deionized and distilled waters are closer to pure H2O than normal waters. Linguistically pure is the antonym of impure. The mere existence of distilled or pure water in the scientific literature conceivably caused purity zealots to opt for drinking distilled waters, falsely claiming health benefits. Just like taking 10x vitamin C doses will not make you 10x healthier, neither would drinking distilled water. But it "sounds" purer. In order to counteract obsessions about drinking distilled water, and to counter the false and disinformative claims of health benefits, some started opting to use the same tactics and weapons to stop the "pure water zealots", and the countery-myth is born. That was my interpretation at university. So it surprises me to learn that WHO would recommend against drinking distilled water. Of course only drinking distilled water would not be healthy indeed: you also need to eat, breathe, etc. So I first did the easy check: wikipedia. On wikipedia the same vague statement of the WHO concluding something along the lines of it being unhealthy is reiterated, but with a [citation needed] appended. Recall anyone can edit wikipedia. Such citation was never provided. So next I tried to find the source myself, and downloaded the 312 page Drinking Water and Health: Volume 4 1982. What page am I supposed to be looking at? As I said at the start, its a non problem, because adding back in some mineral salts to the desired ppm is easy to do.
- gwbas1c 3y agoSo 1 suitcase-sized device can generate about 1-1.5 gallons of water an hour. (A gallon is a little less than 4 liters.) The average American uses 82 gallons of water a day. Assuming 10 hours of sunlight, that requires 8-12 of these per American. I wonder how practical that is?
- yurishimo 3y agoHow much of that is shower water though? Drinking water, I think is probably closer to 2-3 gallons (on the high end) per day for most Americans. We also shouldn’t forget that after disposing of the water, the local municipality can recycle it! For island nations, a few strategic water reserves could be cleaned and stored for future use. And then obviously, for more developing nations, they already use a lot of grey water for daily activities, so this becomes a source of consistent clean drinking water.
- Yeul 3y agoYou underestimate how cheap tapwater is. I'm paying €1.21 for 1m³ and that includes taxes.
- npunt 3y agoMaybe where you are, but the true cost of water in many important regions is very high and running out. The Colorado river basin is on the brink of drying out completely and that's the best agricultural land in North America as well as the source of tens of millions of people's water.
- danw1979 3y ago> The researchers estimate that if the system is scaled up to the size of a small suitcase, Go on then. Yet another MIT paper on desalination jumping the gun and announcing a breakthrough, that could be scaled up to modestly useful sizes if only they had the time and the meagre budget to do so. Here’s[1] a previous announcement from Feb 2022 of a device that could produce water for a small family for only $4 of materials, that they didn’t bother building. [1] https://news.mit.edu/2022/solar-desalination-system-inexpensive-0214 https://news.mit.edu/2022/solar-desalination-system-inexpens...
- npunt 3y agoI mean they're researchers, not builders. If this all checks out, they've done their part and this should inspire builders to run with it and commercialize or open source a printable design. Specialization is great, glad someone is focused on continually pushing the research and improving the designs, and this one supposedly improves on last year's design. There are others who are better at scaling & commercializing, and those types are probably a lot worse at basic research. Every inventor and researcher doesn't need to start a startup.
- danw1979 3y agoWouldn’t you consider “validating that it works beyond the chip-sized proof-of-concept” as part of research, especially considering the claims are that it will scale to a modest briefcase-sized unit ? We’re not talking about something that requires mass-manufacturing scale here …
- nico 3y agoThis reminds me of the first ever solar desalination system, which was built by a Swedish engineer, for the saltpeter mines in Chile, over 100 years ago It would be great if they can scale it up and make it widely available
- jack_riminton 3y agoYou’d think for such a breakthrough they’d at least provide a video. I couldn’t find one elsewhere, has anyone else?
- awei 3y agoAwesome! It should even be cleaner than tap water with heavy metals and other contaminants removed by the evaporation. Just need to add some minerals back into it afterward.
- jedberg 3y agoUsually the problem with Desal is not the energy, it's the fact that there just isn't enough coastline. California could cover every inch of coastline in Desal plants and not have enough fresh water. If they could build platforms in the ocean with some way to get the water to land, maybe this could work, but the Western US is screwed unless we can find other ways to save water, even if this tech were totally free.
- jeffbee 3y agoShow your work? Urban Californians use 6.6e6 acre-feet/year and that implies we would need about 100 of these tiny little facilities. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Claude+%22Bud%22+Lewis+Carlsbad+Desalination+Plant/@33.1403311,-117.3372201,1825m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m14!1m7!3m6!1s0x80dc725db498ce85:0xc0f4a073da2cb9f2!2sClaude+%22Bud%22+Lewis+Carlsbad+Desalination+Plant!8m2!3d33.1385349!4d-117.3347139!16s%2Fm%2F09k70w6!3m5!1s0x80dc725db498ce85:0xc0f4a073da2cb9f2!8m2!3d33.1385349!4d-117.3347139!16s%2Fm%2F09k70w6?entry=ttu https://www.google.com/maps/place/Claude+%22Bud%22+Lewis+Car... That's only if you intend to supply 100% of water from desal, which nobody is suggesting.