5 ms·
What is the rationale* for VAT? I have never, ever understood this. If you are an individual, you pay income tax on your earnings. Why should you be taxed on yo
by anigbrowl 3y ago
What is the rationale* for VAT? I have never, ever understood this. If you are an individual, you pay income tax on your earnings. Why should you be taxed on your spending as well?
* 'We want to use the money for worthy purposes' isn't a rationale. A rationale is a reason people should pay.
- causi 3y agoIt all seems rather geared towards funneling money upward instead of downward. Individuals pay taxes on gross income, while businesses only pay taxes on net profit. A poor person makes a big purchase in the form of a new computer or television and pays sales tax, while a rich person makes a big purchase in the form of stock, pays no taxes, and then when he sells it he only pays taxes if he sells it at a gain and if he sells it at a loss he gets to subtract the loss from his income for the year. Fucking imagine if you bought a car and when you resold it you could subtract the depreciation from your income taxes. No wonder the French decided public decapitation was the only solution.
- gruez 3y ago>A poor person makes a big purchase in the form of a new computer or television and pays sales tax Because if you're buying it for personal use it's presumably for consumption, and if you're buying it for business use it's for business use. In the latter case you don't want to tax it because that would hurt businesses with low margins and give vertically integrated businesses an edge. There's definitely abuse of this with small businesses, where someone buys a pickup truck for "business use" but uses it for personal use, but that should be fixed with better enforcement of the tax code, not changing the tax regime entirely. >while a rich person makes a big purchase in the form of stock Because VAT/sales tax are consumption taxes, not a transaction tax. Stocks aren't consumed, so they aren't taxed. >Fucking imagine if you bought a car and when you resold it you could subtract the depreciation from your income taxes. So what are you advocating for? Abolition of all consumption taxes?
- causi 3y agoFor the application of sales tax to all purchases including stock and the abolition of capital gains tax. give vertically integrated businesses an edge Why is that bad? Vertical integration allows the more efficient use of resources.
- gruez 3y ago> For the application of sales tax to all purchases including stock So you want to make financial transactions more expensive and make the market less liquid? What good can come of this? >and the abolition of capital gains tax. What justification is there to tax someone buying $500 stocks and later selling it for $1000 the same as someone buying $1000 worth of stocks and selling it for $500? Taxing buying $500 worth of TVs makes sense, because it's presumably consumed, but it doesn't make sense for financial instruments. >Why is that bad? Vertical integration allows the more efficient use of resources. Companies already reap the savings from vertical integration. I'm not sure why the government should give them additional incentive to vertically integrate. Suppose the tax rate is 10% and we have two supply chains, one that's vertically integrated and the other that's not vertically integrated. Suppose further that both are equally efficient (which is plausible, given that nimble firms can outcomplete big conglomerates). Why should the government penalize the non-vertically integrated supply chain to the order of 10%?
- anigbrowl 3y agoSo you want to make financial transactions more expensive and make the market less liquid? What good can come of this? Fewer stock market bubbles, less asset inflation.
- gruez 3y agoMarket bubbles aren't caused by stocks trading back and forth. They're caused by irrational exuberance and macroeconomic factors.
- 3y ago
- carlosjobim 3y ago> Fucking imagine if you bought a car and when you resold it you could subtract the depreciation from your income taxes. Don't look up the accounting term "depreciation" for business taxation, or you're going to have a heart attack.
- yohannparis 3y agoVAT is not a tax on spending, but on the added value your business is producing. Which is not related on income, etc. for more info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value-added_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value-added_tax
- anigbrowl 3y agoOf course it's a tax on spending, because consumers have to pay it when they buy things. Just defining it as 'a tax on added value' is meaningless. Why should we wish to tax value, which is something we all seek? To be sure, businesses often just mark up the price of things, and we can in turn tax the profits of the business same as individuals are taxed upon their income.
- Roark66 3y agoYes, it is a tax on spending done by normal people, but for VAT registered businesses it really is a value added tax. For example, let's say you buy a widget for $1000 + 20%vat = $1200, you record you spent $1000k of your money and you "earned" a $200 vat credit(you actually paid $1200, but the government "kinda owes you $200"). Then by the magic of your sales technique you sell the same widget for $2000(+20% vat). You get paid $2400. $400 of this is VAT, you take back your $200 and you pay the remaining $200 to the tax man at the end of the month/quarter. Therefore you really paid 20% on the value added ($1000). Your client, if not VAT registered paid 20% on the entire value.
- anigbrowl 3y agoI'm aware of this (although thanks for taking the time to make a succinct explanation). Thing is, I am not operating a business; as a consumer I just see that I am being charged a significant premium on the money I spend (and a smaller but non-trivial one on the cost of VAT administration up and down the chain). It's not clear to me why 'value added' needs to be taxed in the first place, as opposed to business profits or dividends.
- 3y ago
- lmm 3y ago> What is the rationale* for VAT? I have never, ever understood this. If you are an individual, you pay income tax on your earnings. Why should you be taxed on your spending as well? > 'We want to use the money for worthy purposes' isn't a rationale. A rationale is a reason people should pay. I could equally say "You pay VAT on your spending. Why should you be taxed on your earnings as well?". Ultimately governments need taxes and take them where they can find them. The benefit of VAT is that it's a tax that's harder to evade, because the rebate system means everyone is reporting on everyone else. A high VAT rate is also a way to do stealth protectionism without falling foul of the WTO rules - domestic producers can pay de facto higher salaries (because the VAT revenue allows you to reduce income tax) whereas the full VAT rate gets paid on foreign-produced goods.
- charlieyu1 3y agoThe huge downside is that VAT is taking money from businesses regardless of whether profit is made or not. Cooperate Tax is fair; it is taxing on profits made. VAT, on the other hand, is not. We should not tax a transaction where a struggling customer is paying a struggling business.
- lmm 3y ago> The huge downside is that VAT is taking money from businesses regardless of whether profit is made or not. Cooperate Tax is fair; it is taxing on profits made. VAT, on the other hand, is not. We should not tax a transaction where a struggling customer is paying a struggling business. Why not? It seems like you're arguing for a tax break for struggling businesses, but those are the ones that most need to be subject to capitalism's creative destruction. If business A is making a lot of product and consuming a lot of resources, but that product is barely worth buying, and business B produces less but does so more efficiently, it seems to me that business B is more socially beneficial and it's better to tax business A.
- charlieyu1 3y agoAnd yet everyone complaining about places closing down. And I would argue that this eliminates competition and therefore not socially beneficial.
- patmcc 3y agoWhat's the rationale for income tax? It makes no more sense to tax income than spending. I agree it's unpleasant to be "double taxed" but until the policy makers start listening to the economists it'll continue.
- crazygringo 3y agoThat it's progressive. It's easy to tax a higher percentage if you make more in a year. You can't really do a progressive sales tax or VAT, logistically.
- patmcc 3y agoEh, you can, just not easily at point of sale. You can give credits/rebates (either to all in the form of a UBI, or targeted by income) to offset the amount people will pay in VAT, or you can have different rates for e.g. "essentials" vs luxuries. See https://www.oecd.org/tax/reassessing-the-regressivity-of-the-vat-b76ced82-en.htm https://www.oecd.org/tax/reassessing-the-regressivity-of-the... - lots of countries that have implemented VATs are able to make them somewhat progressive. Wish we'd just bite the bullet and move towards a land value tax though.
- csomar 3y agoThere is no rational. The government will try to tax every way possible and as much as they can possibly squeeze out of every tax payer. It's just how governments work.
- aidog 3y agoI'm not a fan of taxing consumption. It's hard to believe that Japan did not have this for a very long time and now we are at 10%. It's especially questionable since older people consume less, but usually have more savings.
- scotty79 3y agoIt's "value added tax". If you do some business activity that increased the value of something then that increase is taxed. The benefit is that with long production chains involving multiple business entities you tax the places proportionally to how much they earn from that production chain. It's like income tax, but harder to dodge because you can't easily hide the sale.
- grotorea 3y agoI'm not sure about the present justification, but VAT is an alternative to sales tax, which has existed for a very long time, while Wikipedia says income tax as we know it started in 1798, so there may be an aspect of historical legacy. Although both VAT and income tax require states with extensive administrative capacity so I guess if there was political will to do income tax only it could be done. Maybe it is the politics of progressive vs regressive taxation? Or just that doing income tax only would mean very high income tax and high tax evasion?