9 ms·
LARPing and Violent Extremism
- aleph_minus_one 3y agoHonestly, based on my life experience, I disagree with quite some criteria that the FBI uses here to distinguish between LARP and Violent Extremism: Audience: "Spectators accepted or desired" vs "Secrecy demanded" Quite some LARP people who want to avoid spectators, since quite some conservative or religious people tend to associate some fantasy stuff to be "satanistic" or "sacrilegious". Thus, to avoid really annoying discussions, they prefer no spectators. Components: "Features of organized gaming (e.g., rules, character sheets, scenario scripts, in- and out-of-character designations)" vs "Absence of documented rules, character sheets, scenario scripts, in- and out-of-character designations; all “characters” are frontline fighters or operational support personnel" There exist LARP system where there exist many rules, but also those where such things are handled in a more "loose"/"spontanous"/"improvisatory" way. Relationship with law enforcement: "No concern with law enforcement in out-of-character life" vs "Demonstrated concern with law enforcement and prosecutions of similar criminal behavior" Of course, those who distrust the law enforcement (often for good reasons) are suspicious to be extremists - that is what the FBI claims ;-) . Seriously: there likely exist LARP players with about any possible stance concerning law enforcement. Equipment: "realistic prop weapons often discouraged in the rules" It depends on the LARP system whether these are discouraged or encouraged. Personal grievance: "No personal grievance toward out-group(s) outside the voluntary, fantasy world" vs "Personal grievance toward out-group(s) believed to pose an imminent and existential threat, requiring violent action" and Mood: "Euthymic and joyful; anticipatory fantasy to enjoy the event" vs "Dysphoric and angry; anticipatory fantasy to harm or kill the target(s)" This depends a lot on the setting of the LARP: of course some cyberpunk, horror or dark-fantasy themed LARP will be much more dark than, say, some high fantasy or utopic science-fiction setting.
- seanw444 3y agoI believe this is referring to military LARPing.
- assbuttbuttass 3y agoYes, the FBI is reading your shitposts
- 2devnull 3y ago“Live action role play is an old theatrical behavior and a new excuse. The concern that this label can be used as a defense for planning and preparing a targeted attack on a public official, democratic government, or anyone else is a real one.” Boy is it. I’m gravely concerned the threat LARPing posed to our democratic government.
- Woshiwuja 3y agoThanks FBI i will now stop trying to get the world into an anarchy state
- sjducb 3y ago> Role players will not discuss law enforcement concerns on social media or provide guidance to each other if confronted by an officer. Also, they will have no demonstrated interest in criminal cases involving claims of LARP. I disagree with this bit completely. As a practitioner of a weapons based martial art I had to be very familiar with the law to ensure that I didn’t break the law by accident. Ignorance of the law is not a defence.
- Octo-Shark 3y agoIt sounds like the beginning of a South Park episode.
- kobalsky 3y agothey did make the sons of witches episode. they were larping as witches.
- seanw444 3y agoExcellent writeup, redcoats. Did everyone forget that the US only exists because of treason and insurrection directly sparked from individuals refusing to allow someone else to determine whether they can arm themselves? Probably. Public school doesn't like to focus on the details anymore. If Sam Adams existed today, he'd be on an FBI/ATF watchlist.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 082349872349872 3y agoCosplaytriots attempting to use LARPing as an excuse is reminiscent of: > "Never believe that [they] are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. ... They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert." — JPS
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Tao3300 3y agoSartre on Anti-Semites
- fortran77 3y agohttps://www.goodreads.com/quotes/7870768-never-believe-that-anti-semites-are-completely-unaware-of-the-absurdity https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/7870768-never-believe-that-...
- econorew 3y ago[dead]
- flangola7 3y agoOnce you realize many individuals see written language not as a means to share ideas and have mutual constructive discussion, but as just another weapon to achieve their ends, a lot of human interactions (especially online) make a lot more sense. It's very dangerous since many of us (myself included) instinctively assume good faith and approach conflicts as possible misunderstandings or opportunities for constructive common ground finding; but the other person (regardless of how they present themselves) isn't interested in any of that at all. They would just as quickly hit you over the head with a club.
- kens 3y ago
- lelandbatey 3y agoSome key context, provided if you read the article, is that this exists to outline the difference between LARPing and Violent Extremism, especially as some violent extremists have claimed that their plans of violence were only "LARPing" and not bona-fide terrorism. The exact differences they point out, such as "spectators being welcome" vs "secrecy is paramount" are clear, universal, well thought out, and interesting to read about and consider.
- slavboj 3y agoIt's not like there isn't a robust history of law enforcement "spectators" trying to railroad participants based on absolutely nothing, including in literal role playing scenarios. Privacy rights exist for a reason. http://www.sjgames.com/SS/ http://www.sjgames.com/SS/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pseudalopex 3y agoThe article had many good points. But many claims about LARP were not universal or not clear. Some performances are private. Some LARP is solo. The article acknowledged small groups but the table did not. People in many hobbies discuss law enforcement concerns, guidance to each other if confronted by an officer, and criminal cases where the hobby is mentioned. Role players have confirmation bias like other people. Some theatrical presentations have real antagonists.
- Y-bar 3y agoI did not read the article as being that black and white, rather as a set of rules of thumb. Such as if enough boxes are ticked the investigator should maybe consider that it is not a real LARPer, but rather someone who tries to hide behind a veil of LARPing.
- pseudalopex 3y agoThe comment I replied to called the differences universal. The article said LARP is always group-based. Possibly the authors intended the other claims to be rules of thumb. Certainly their intended audience included people who tend to think in black and white. And several claims I contradicted were faulty rules of thumb.
- bawolff 3y agoThe, "its just a joke, bro" defence applied to an organized uprising.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AmericanOP 3y agoSchrodinger’s bullying
- giantrobot 3y agoStochastic terrorism.
- Jensson 3y ago> The foremost distinction between LARPers and violent extremists is that genuine role players will not care whether others are watching. They may even embrace third-party observation, such as nonplayer characters or a general audience. After all, LARP is a performance. > Conversely, violent extremists or terrorists want secrecy. This desire may contribute to the sense of clandestine excitement that surrounds them and their preparation on a pathway to actual violence.9 What is this? Why is the FBI writing stuff like this and publishing it?
- Y_Y 3y ago[flagged]
- bediger4000 3y agoQanon. Anons use this kind of defense all the time, but the ideology itself continues to inspire violence.
- 0xcde4c3db 3y agoI've heard that there's a scattered body of (amateur?) scholarship analyzing QAnon as an ARG [1] that the "players" don't realize is fictional. I've only briefly dabbled in "playing" ARGs, so I'm far from an expert, but the dynamic does seem strikingly similar. A few people allegedly even believe that QAnon originated as a legitimate attempt at an amateur ARG and was then hijacked by real-world political interests, though I don't understand how the ARG would have worked given the venue and content of the original "Q drops". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternate_reality_game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternate_reality_game
- jeffbee 3y ago"""The Bulletin provides a forum for information exchange throughout the criminal justice community. Readers consist mostly of midlevel to executive managers in agencies of various sizes worldwide."""
- Jensson 3y ago
- kr0bat 3y agoThey used the term LARP a lot more literally than I expected. Although the history of LARP as a legal defense is narrow, the authors share the concern that it may soon become commonplace. Early attempts at such a strategy have been made by a defendant acting alone or in loose cooperation with members of a fantasy group who knew each other only in the virtual world, claiming “artistic expression” to excuse threatening language. I can see this being a big problem with memes in the immediate future. Does the FBI have a page where they attempt to distinguish edgy memes from genuine calls to violence? This is a relatively benign example, but there are TikToks where users pretend to have fantasies about taking officer's service weapon. Sure they're all jokes, but modern internet humor is deeply ironic; I'd imagine there are plenty of genuinely violent people making seemingly ironic memes. I'd also imagine that there are nonviolent memers disseminating genuine violent ideas and vice versa.
- faeriechangling 3y agoWell fuck the feds for snooping on all our conversations honestly. When we don't have privacy, people collectively engaging in edgy irony to the point you can't distinguish the signal from the noise provides people with a level of free speech.
- pixl97 3y ago"Posts on a public site...Complains about privacy" What the hell you are going on about man. If you post something like "Hey, lets shoot some cops", or hell "lets start shooting ____" online you are giving up your right to privacy. Yes, the US legal system has means of taking the 'evidence' you posted online in front of a judge and getting a warrant. Via the warrant system nearly complete dismantling of your privacy can be compelled. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
- parineum 3y agoNeither of those things would be a basis for something like a search warrant because the threat is not specific and credible. It's not a crime to say, "Hey, let's shoot some cops". It would be a crime to say, "Hey, let's hang out in front of the local police station and shoot some cops tomorrow morning. Bring your guns."
- pstuart 3y agoI get the appeal and why it's happening, but FFS, this is a huge threat to the United States (and other countries), and it seems to be growing day by day. It's easy to dismiss ("it's just LARPing with real guns, dude") but we need to address it head on. Because this is deeply intertwined with "politics" it becomes radioactive to discuss in polite society (e.g., HN itself), but we'd be well served to find a way to have some dialog.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoDoes it seem to be growing and is a huge threat in numeric comparison to other negative outcomes because the quantity is actually rapidly increasing or because the media and government are beating a drum about this issue louder than about other issues, regardless of quantitative changes in risk and absolute risk?
- RelativeDelta 3y agoIt's both. VEs are increasing in number and sophistication over time because the social contract of the United States has been cleaved. On one side you have individualistic capitalists who don't want to be told what to do and don't want to subsidize the existence of others. On the other you have communal idealists who recognize the scale advantage state actions and programs can have and want to deploy them. The later are winning and the former do not have a political exit that does not involve secession. That's the fundamental base. The heightened media attention being paid to instances of the above are in response to the general understanding that those fundamentals are now in place.
- pstuart 3y agoWe tried secession before and it didn't work out too well, and I don't see anything indicating it would be better this time. Edit: my understanding is that the leading idea is not secession but something called Project 2025. Depending on how you look at it, it's either a "rightsizing" of government or a coup.
- tuckerpo 3y agoAlso see: in Minecraft.
- zen928 3y agoa phrase used to evade being suspended from advertiser-friendly media platforms by "changing" the intent of your statement from a potential threat to an expression of emotion (express anger at them in a game) also as equally useless of a defense as 'just LARPing' if any of your other behavior shows different intentions and inconsistency with the group that would use these phrases, i.e. you don't play videogames it's always felt off that someone genuinely believes that changing their phrasing would fool other people of their intent, like something that an actual child would come up as a legal defense
- tuckerpo 3y agoIt's also always felt off that people's right to freedom of expression (modulo threatening violence, of course) needs little-kid-esque suffixes slapped onto them to appease feds online.
- dnd_was_evil 3y agoRemember when DnD was the cover for a nation wide cult that murdered children by the dozen? Congratulations you're as out of touch as our parents were. >Individuals can engage in such activity informally or as part of an organized group. Presumably, the earliest formal LARP group was Dagorhir Battle Games, founded in the United States in 1977. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1913_Gettysburg_reunion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1913_Gettysburg_reunion Now if only these experts could use google leaping for 30 seconds before writing an add for their consultancy services. >Ms. Amman is a retired FBI supervisory special agent, certified threat manager, and private threat assessment management consultant in West Des Moines, Iowa. Dr. Phil Saragoza >Dr. Saragoza is a forensic psychiatrist, adjunct clinical assistant professor at the University of Michigan, and threat assessment consultant in Ann Arbor, Michigan.
- woodruffw 3y agoI think it's worth reading the linked page more closely: the distinction scheme it describes appears to be designed to handle the exact problem you've identified. (That's not to say that it's good, or that the FBI will apply it effectively or correctly, only that it isn't as simple as "the FBI believes in the DnD cult conspiracy.")
- dnd_was_evil 3y ago[flagged]
- crazygringo 3y agoI was definitely confused by this article at first, thinking it was some silly guide for law enforcement which can't tell the difference between criminals and LARPers...?? But no -- it's actually about terrorists and criminals trying to claim in court that their criminal planning wasn't that at all, but just LARPing: > For example, after Kaleb Franks was arrested in October 2020 for plotting to abduct Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer, he told the FBI he and his compatriots were only LARPing. Franks later pled guilty and testified that this was a lie. So this document is for investigators to ensure they have a specific framework for being able to collect the appropriate evidence to use in court that prevents a defendent from using a LARPing defense. Which actually makes a tremendous amount of sense. When armed militia members claim all of their organizing/preparation is just recreational, and totally unlinked to violence that members do eventually commit, it's important to have delineated standards to be able to refute that.
- parineum 3y ago> When armed militia members claim all of their organizing/preparation is just recreational, and totally unlinked to violence that members do eventually commit, it's important to have delineated standards to be able to refute that. I think the delineation between the members to that eventually commit violence and the ones who can successfully use the "LARPing" defense is whether or not they committed any crimes. It's pretty simple to me. This sounds, to me, a lot more like a guide on how to convict people who committed no crimes associated with the criminals who did.
- hef19898 3y agoAnd there I was, assuming someone else sees all those militia types and tacticools as LARPing out their war heroism and combat fantasies as adults, only with real weapons instead of wooden ones. That being said, my wooden "E-11 replica" is still around at my uncles place, 30 odd years later.
- ferfumarma 3y agoIn that context, the table they describe is a disaster. If a group of actual LARPers doesn't want spectators, isn't part of a larger LARPing community, doesn't have rules/character sheets, is concerned about law enforcement (!) then they look like terrorists, based on this guidance. The problem is that they've commingled a handful of objective facts with a handful of mental states and motives that are only known to the individuals. The only reliable factor is if they are using live weapons and ammunition. Sadly, law enforcement is likely incapable of using that single, obvious factor to judge the legality of what is otherwise creative expression, and therefore leans into the pseudo-forensics provided here.
- YeBanKo 3y agoIt is very scary to read such an "opinion" pieces on fbi.gov domain. First, they make it possible to connect any organized activity to "violent extremism". And then this: > Meetings may entail impassioned rhetoric and rehearsal of tactical operations for the ultimate future apocalypse when citizens will overtake the government or institute their own community policing. This quote is fucking insane, imo. "citizens will overtake the government" – aren't citizens already supposed to be in charge of the government? A very strange choice of words. What about all that "We the People" stuff. And second, "or institute their own community policing" - it is how the policing in the US works. Local police forces account for the majority of police force in the US according to National Sources of Law Enforcement Employment Data [1]. [1] https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/nsleed.pdf https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/nsleed.pdf
- ethbr1 3y agoThe article also contains >> [recommendations to probe and challenge] motives during an interview (e.g., “If you were just LARPing, why did you need live explosives?”)
- cronix 3y agoThe answer is probably the same as why Hollywood uses them in movies. For realism.
- dnd_was_evil 3y agoIf you're just larping why do you need a cannon? https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXtswMYlBd0&pp=ygUPQ2l2aWwgd2FyIGNhbm9u https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXtswMYlBd0&pp=ygUPQ2l2aWwgd2F...
- shmde 3y ago> In the modern era, as extreme beliefs (e.g., anti-government or anti-law enforcement movements) Fbi quietly putting psyops telling anti- government is extreme belief lmao.
- falcolas 3y agoIt always has been for the FBI. They have long treated any outspoken anti-establishment or anti-authority with suspicion and - especially when combined with a minority race - hostility. See how they treated anybody who believe socialism was good back in the cold war days. How they kept detailed files on people who spoke against the powers held by the authorities.
- RelativeDelta 3y agoIt is because they are tasked with the preservation of the United States as a political entity. Anything or group that threatens the power of the state becomes their target - those targets evolve with time.
- pseudalopex 3y agoSocialism did not threaten the preservation of the United States as a political entity. Or the power of the state. It threatened specific interests.
- RelativeDelta 3y agoFrom the perspective of the executive branch it very much did. Arguably still does, depending on your political persuasion.
- pseudalopex 3y agoAnti socialists claim socialism gives the state too much power. Not too little. Inarguably mixed economies are dominant and stable. Inarguably almost all countries with any history of self described socialist government persist. And American governments have an established history of acting on less than existential interests.
- Racing0461 3y agoWe were just larping in minecraft your honor. teehee.
- slavboj 3y ago"Role players will not discuss law enforcement concerns on social media or provide guidance to each other if confronted by an officer. Also, they will have no demonstrated interest in criminal cases involving claims of LARP." Your resistance proves your guilt. Insisting on your fourth and fifth amendment rights? Noting other cases where innocent hobbyists were threatened and trying to avoid the same? Seems like violent extremism.
- seventytwo 3y agoOh come on… it’s a hueristic, like anything else.
- slavboj 3y agoI have a heuristic that guidance that amounts to "assertion of rights is a sign of guilt" is presumptively invalid.
- seventytwo 3y agoYou understand the difference between correlations and causations, right? Because that’s what this boils down to.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoI didn't interpret it that way at all. I interpreted it as having familiarity with cases of actual terrorists using a defense of claimed LARPing suggests you researched this to make up a cover story.
- PixyMisa 3y agoMore like the FBI created a huge splash when it funded, planned, and led the Whitmer kidnapping plot.
- jrflowers 3y ago> Insisting on your fourth and fifth amendment rights? This is a good point. When I am in character as a LARP law enthusiast that’s LARPing as a violent extremist, my in-character explanation of why I am not criminally liable for my OC’s OC’s behavior to police are a violation of my rights.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoAlthough the history of LARP as a legal defense is narrow, the authors share the concern that it may soon become commonplace. This is a reasonable concern. I will note anecdotally not all role players are playing with a full deck -- though I am more familiar with role playing gamers, not LARPers (granted: not entirely separate groups). Some are mildly cracked, sometimes harmlessly -- the guy who exclusively played female characters and might have identified as trans had he been born later -- and some not so harmlessly -- the gal who forged her own sword which she took with her everywhere, even the mall, by concealing it under a cape, and genuinely believed she was the last special warrior of some sort from a fictional series.* She believed she was female to signify she was the last. So that may complicate sorting out who is just playing games from who is a genuine threat of planned violence. * https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elric_of_Melnibon%C3%A9 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elric_of_Melnibon%C3%A9
- throwaway128128 3y agoThe FBI is concerned more with the militia-like "tacticool" style of LARPing.
- hock_ads_ad_hoc 3y agoI thought there was a “has difficulty differentiating LARP persona from real identity” criteria on the list. Seems like that should come into play in the situation you described.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoThe closest I can find is this: On a psychological level, LARPers temporarily enter a fictional world with characters who reside within it and are separate from day-to-day reality; there is no discomfort in distinguishing between the two. It implies the opposite -- that violent extremists may have trouble distinguishing -- but doesn't seem to say it outright.
- 0max 3y agoThe most common form of LARPing I can think of is Civil War reenactments in Virginia
- and0 3y agoAs someone who lived in Northern Virginia for a bit and knew some reenactors, I heard some interesting stories about how many issues it caused during the DC Sniper attacks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D.C._sniper_attacks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D.C._sniper_attacks. Lotsa 911 calls when they would start firing, it took a while for them to be able to ease back into it. Tangential, but still an interesting intersection of law enforcement vs free expression. Thankfully I think that all parties just politely agreed they should just stop while the suspects were still active and at large.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoI had to scratch my head for a moment to see if it was an April Fools' joke (it was posted 4 days later). Regular police investigative techniques can disambiguate intent of (an) individual(s) by searching their items and questioning their plans. Someone LARPing isn't going to play act with live ordinance, contagious pathogens, or actual firearms. They may well carry swords, but then they'd also be wearing padded armor. I think it's up to a judge or jury to decide if the Free Staters of Terrorism were committing terrorism or not in highly-suspicious, ambiguous circumstances. Leaping to the deep-end of paranoia about mostly innocent play would create a society with a corrosive, suspicious attitude. Now an awful thought: Although it seems a weird and terrible idea, I could imagine a group of kids going somewhere hopefully unoccupied and unlikely to be patrolled by police LARPing as terrorists, school shooters, or any other taboo archetype. For the record, a dying (and now late) friend of mine was once violently arrested in a parking lot for playing Ingress in Los Altos, CA.
- caeril 3y ago> Someone LARPing isn't going to play act with live ordinance, contagious pathogens, or actual firearms. Huh? normal people LARP with actual firearms using live ammunition all the time on tactical training sets. Most of them pay legitimate, taxpaying corporations thousands of dollars for the privilege.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bitwize 3y agoI think what we most have to be concerned about is when FBI agents LARP as violent extremists in order to entrap some hapless boob so they can meet their terrorist arrest quotas.
- weswilson 3y agoMost of us here probably think of LARPing as fantasy-genre LARPing, but I think this is more pointed toward Mil-Sim LARPing. These are hardcore airsoft guys who go buy comms, night-vision, IR, with airsoft weapons that function like real weapons. There are multi-day events with NATO vs RUS forces. Look up "milsim west" on Youtube and you can get a sense of it. There's a good amount of folks that just like to have fun, but there is a subset that use it as a type of militia-esque training.
- kramerger 3y agoThe crazy/normal ratio among milsim larpers is EXTREMLY high. Just listen to the language they use in YT videos to describe other participants and general public There is this odd thing about the human brain that as soon as it is in a group and have tools of violence at hand it will often start planing to take over the society
- H8crilA 3y agoLuckily individual soldiers without heavy equipment (at least some artillery) are more or less useless in a proper military showdown. Has been the case at least since WW2. ISIS was a good example, they were being quickly defeated by pretty much everyone involved in the Syrian conflict.
- langsoul-com 3y agoI think you should look into the middle east a bit more. Taliban are still around and now control the place. Individuals might not have heavy weapons to start. But with enough time, weapon destructivness reaches a parity.
- H8crilA 3y agoYes you can wage guerilla warfare for extended periods of time if the conditions are right - i.e. if you have local support of the population, and someone outside is getting you the guns to harass the official administration / occupants. Now think about whether either of those conditions apply in a particular scenario, then remember you need both. Afghans obviously hated being invaded and helped "their guys", they also had Peshawar.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- GauntletWizard 3y agoA ton of this rings true, but this does not: > To prepare for a violent attack, terrorists possess and practice real weapons and live ammunition. LARPers would have no need for such destructive instruments when preparing for their event. Nobody loves guns more than LARPers. I know more people into pyrotechnics that play wizards in larps than pretty much any other category of weirdo, and I know a lot of weirdos. It's a power fantasy, but it's one that they love to live out in a small way, and range-shooting is one of the most common expressions of it.
- seabird 3y agoA lot of people here, and the original article, don't seem to realize what people that use "LARPing" mean when they say it. It's a disparaging term used to describe when somebody isn't going to actually pursue or follow through on something. Somebody with a bunch of tactical gear that's constantly running shooting drills and talking about joining a war in the Middle East or Eastern Europe, but never actually does, is "LARPing". Somebody that acts like they're getting lots of money and women when they're not, is "LARPing". There's no connection with actual LARPing other than it being the butt of the joke, and anybody saying it about themselves is basically just saying they're a bullshitter trying to pass themselves off as doing something or preparing to do something they never will, which isn't a criminal defense.