15 ms·
School surveillance tools are harming kids, report finds
- uoaei 3y agoWe learned this from Soviet Russia: it doesn't really matter what you're looking for, if people know they're being watched, they develop pathologies and complexes around that which stunt their development and actualization. Kids are people too.
- marcodiego 3y agoLong time ago I talked to a friend about cameras in classrooms. I commented about how many problems it prevents. He explained a definition of moral: moral is the non physical limitation that bars you from doing something you want but harms another person even if you won't be punished. It was then explained to me that children who grow in over surveillance have a tendency of not exercising moral. They will do whatever they want once they are confident that nobody will know. It is the same thing with excess of punishment: if people know something is legal and won't be punished, they won't care about moral. I tried to ask about the good side of having cameras but he said it was not worth the price of growing a generation of amorals.
- waynesonfire 3y agoHere is the good side, recent article headline, "Shocking video shows special needs school worker slamming autistic, nonverbal toddler to the ground then dangling him upside down"
- jprete 3y agoWhat this does is create an entire generation conditioned to believe the camera is the reason they shouldn’t do that.
- throwawaysleep 3y agoPeople have long been doing whatever no matter whether it is moral or not.
- csydas 3y agoYes, I think this part is incredibly important to understand; it's similar to laws where the penalty is a fine; devastating for many people if they get caught, but for those with wealth, it's just the cost of business to do whatever they want. Same with the idea of persistent surveillance -- it's only as good/useful as those who control the surveillance. In the case of authorities who are willing to abuse their power, surveillance does not make you more safe with these authorities, it just means that there is surveillance data they control, and it works for them, not not for you unless they decide to allow that. Recordings get deleted "accidentally" all the time, and for most regulated businesses, at worst it's a small fine and some forms and mandatory training, none of which would make me feel particularly better if the "accidentally deleted" video was the only proof of the authority figures beating me to a pulp. It's the same reason government backdoors can never be a tool "for the good guys"; once it's there, anyone able to pass a correct secret to the backdoor gets in, regardless of their intent or right to be. Surveillance doesn't make us safer by default; it is a tool like any other, and it has it's legitimate uses and illegitimate uses. I don't feel safer if a stranger runs at me in an alley wielding a claw hammer just because I know that claw hammers are usually for construction work; I'm very much so aware that while a nail might survive the impact, my flesh and bone will not fare as well. Same with any surveillance -- I do not see how it's making _me_ safer, it's instead making someone else's job easier to monitor me, and I have no idea who that might be or why they're monitoring me. This isn't to say it's always morally imperative wrong to have some sort of surveillance; I think a closed circuit recording system in a store is maybe frustrating, but I also don't have to go into that particular store I suppose. This does become a problem though once surveillance is everywhere, and even worse, when it's non-secured surveillance tech, so anyone might get at it.
- paul_funyun 3y agoThat's the beauty of widespread surveillance and easy bulk storage - there's no reason to give any of the surveilled parties the power to control the data. Camera records the footage and sends it to a centralized storage facility, where it is automatically deleted after 5 years or some other length of time. As long as there's enough storage space for the relevant time frame's worth of footage, there's no reason any person needs to be able to delete it. If it's on a server hundreds of miles away what can some petty bureaucrat do even if they wanted to?
- endominus 3y agoOn the other hand again, an anecdote from my own middle school; one kid shoved another down as they were running through the halls. The person who got shoved fell and broke a tooth. School refused to punish anyone without evidence of wrongdoing (despite the testimony of everyone around at the time). There was a camera in the hallway but conveniently "it was off" and school refused to investigate further. Seeking justice by apportioning more power to those with the incentive to abuse it does not result in a more just system.
- ethanbond 3y agoThe good side is what? Now we have salient imagery of an extremely rare occurrence so we can breed into our culture more fear of extremely rare occurrences? There are billions of people on this planet, you can pick any atrocious act and find enough footage to convince a tribe-scale monkey brain that once in a million people event is a Big Problem that we need to be solving. I could imagine there being special carve outs for kids who are unlikely to know something bad is happening or to report it. Doesn’t mean every child needs more surveillance around them.
- atoav 3y agoExactly, you don't want your children to need surveillance. And in the grand scheme of things even if they misbehave when unsurveilled, who gives a damn? The collective damage of them not learning to say "no" to immoral behaviour because they want to is way bigger than anything the surveillance ever could prevent. If the US is really about "freedom" why do you try to educate your kids to be on the receiving end of an authoritarian dictatorship?
- dartos 3y agoIf the kids had more money, they’d be more free. That’s the American way.
- caturopath 3y agoCan you expound upon this? What's the alternative way, and why are kids free-er in it? How do kids vary in wealth and how does this affect their freedom? (For current kids? For American kids at different times?)
- Y_Y 3y agoObviously they exchange labour for capital and are rewarded commensurately by the free market.
- polygamous_bat 3y agoThinking about the freedoms of the chimney sweeping children in the free markets of historical England almost brought a tear to my eyes, thank you.
- suckitsam 3y agoThey were perfectly free to go work in a textile mill or coal mine if they didn't like being a chimney sweep!
- mistrial9 3y ago
- beebeepka 3y agoIn my experience, there is no one definition of moral. Your own anecdote is a great example of this. Personally, I find it disgusting because it only applies to a "person", which as far as I understand, means a human. Edit: wow, the human superiority crowd doesn't like my comment
- dividedbyzero 3y agoI have no idea what you're alluding to. What non-human non-person entities would you expect to find in a classroom?
- wussboy 3y ago...and would have a moral responsibility...
- axus 3y agoThe government!
- beebeepka 3y agoI challenged the stated definition of morals. Didn't say anything about classrooms
- TeMPOraL 3y agoIt's not a useful challenge. Sure, morals are relative to particular brain architecture and causal history of a particular kind of monkeys on a particular ball of dirt spinning in space. But those particular monkeys are also the entire scope of concern. Your objection will become relevant once we build human-level AIs or meet and start mixing with some space aliens.
- beebeepka 3y agoI said that with living things in mind, not AI. Nobody understands me:(
- deleted 3y ago
- jprete 3y agoKnowing you’re always being watched means that you can never figure out who you actually are because you’re continuously putting on a performance for the cameras.
- chaostheory 3y agoSocial media?
- halfcat 3y agoSeems like a child that believes “god is always watching” might have the same effect?
- lacrimacida 3y agoSomewhat but if that God is not drilled on a daily basis it tends to drift out of the mind, as well as the personal view of how God judges you, how God may ignore some small bad acts. A camera’s physical presence is a constant reminder you’re being watched and everything is being recorded, there’s no escape or respite.
- indymike 3y agoGod seems to notice a lot less bad behavior than the school resource officer.
- suckitsam 3y ago
- throwawaysleep 3y ago> they won't care about moral. Does he believe current generations do? > They will do whatever they want once they are confident that nobody will know. To me, this is just how people tend to behave, no matter their age.
- nvy 3y agoI don't litter, even if nobody's watching. Do you?
- vharuck 3y agoCounterpoints: 1. Lost and found stations at events. People find stuff, people nearby don't claim it and often don't care if it's taken, but the finder still makes the effort to give it to lost and found or staff. Everytime I've done this, there've been a lot of unclaimed items. Each of those is evidence of, if not altruism, at least morality. 2. The vast majority of people don't shoplift, even at stores that put goods out front with no employees watching. 3. Charities, soup kitchens, anonymous donors. We should be careful to not mistake cynicism as wisdom.
- throwanem 3y agoNobody's better than a cynic at mistaking cynicism for wisdom.
- pixl97 3y agoCounter-counterpoint(?): the difference between high trust society and a low trust society is not the number of 'bad' people, but the number of apathetic people when they witness the actions of the bad actors and do nothing.
- mvnuweucxqokii 3y agohttps://twitter.com/whyvert/status/1704313887074488540 https://twitter.com/whyvert/status/1704313887074488540
- retrac 3y ago> To me, this is just how people tend to behave, no matter their age. One of my favourite studies is just random virtue testing of strangers. Will they return lost property? It's easy, cheap, and frequently replicated. The researchers "lose" a bunch of fairly typical wallets in discreet-but-obvious places, with some cash inside. The people who find the wallet have the opportunity to take the cash in the wallet, or just the whole wallet. In most countries, the majority of wallets are returned to their owners, with the cash intact. In countries like Sweden or Japan, you can reasonably expect your wallet to be returned - rates are over 80%. Most people are good. Or at least, they don't want to be a thief. Given the opportunity to get away with stealing a small amount of money, most people opt to go out of their way, even if it's just a few minutes of their time, to help the person get their wallet back. https://www.npr.org/2019/06/20/734141432/what-dropping-17-000-wallets-around-the-globe-can-teach-us-about-honesty https://www.npr.org/2019/06/20/734141432/what-dropping-17-00...
- Viliam1234 3y ago> children who grow in over surveillance have a tendency of not exercising moral Sadly, so do many kids growing up without surveillance. There are many kids bullied in schools, some of them to the point of suicide. Should we feel happy that their suffering provides to bullies the precious opportunity to reflect on their actions, which they would be deprived of in a safer school environment with cameras? What's next? Abolish police, so that the adults can learn to live in peace without the external threats? Sounds great in theory, you probably wouldn't want it to happen in your city today.
- ethanbond 3y agoSchools have been ~fine without cameras forever though? I don’t think the lack of enforcement around bullying is addressed by cameras, it’s due either to lack of caring by the administration or lack of levers to do much to stop it (kids basically have a right to go to school, it’s very tricky to take that away or to isolate them without taking it away).
- polygamous_bat 3y ago> Schools have been ~fine without cameras forever though? I believe the person you are replying to is emphasizing the "~" in your comment. Yes, it's not like half the kids will commit self harm because they are bullied, but a very small percent will. How do we, as a society, weigh their suffering against those who are being surveiled without ever having done anything to trigger it?
- ethanbond 3y agoStep 1 is just actually punish and/or separate kids who are known to be bullies. Lack of surveillance or of “knowledge” of who the bullies are isn’t the inhibitor. Not to mention obviously cameras won’t successfully police online/out of school behavior, to which also the solution is not more surveillance. Teachers, students, administrators, and often parents already know who the bullies are. The question is what to do about it.
- endisneigh 3y agosorry but your friend's argument is easily disproven by example. look no further than any inner city school, most of which do not have cameras everywhere.
- pfisherman 3y agoI mean this is a great perspective on the failings of the panopticon. Thanks for writing it. If you think about it, a lot of children’s stories and religions rely on this concept of the panopticon to inspirei moral behavior. Santa knows if you’ve been good or bad. God is always watching, and will reward or punish in the afterlife. Your soul will be reborn according to karma. Et cetera. So is the use of constant, omniscient surveillance actually new to incentivize moral behavior new? Or have the methods / technology just gotten better?
- awesomeMilou 3y ago> If you think about it, a lot of children’s stories and religions rely on this concept of the panopticon to inspirei moral behavior. If you raise your child on media from the last century that is. Modern childrens television shows emphasize empathy over crude means like surveillance. Bluey is a great example.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoBluey is contemporary entertainment. It's not old enough to be part of culture, which is what GP was talking about. Last century media isn't either. We're talking folk tales and religion here. Bluey is also one of the handful, perhaps single-digit number of, decent kid shows. Modern children television shows emphasize superstimuli, obnoxious behavior, and/or push merch. I am grateful it exists, because the space of children entertainment is much worse today than it was 30+ years ago.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoWhich children shows from a century ago emphasized surveillance?
- K0balt 3y agoThe superstition of just recompense / Karma is fundamentally different, in that it is , in concept, omniscient, even of your thoughts. Also, it’s justice will be meted out by “fate” so the mind automatically equates outcomes with causes based on your moral compass, establishing a state of perceived equilibrium which you are incentivo used to balance in your favor, as “good things come to good people”. Surveillance is blind to minor transgressions, supporting the idea that you can slight people and be a crappy human without consequences, and it is also far from omniscient, and can be specifically blind under circumstances that you may control. More so it can be wielded against other people by creating “scenes” that promote a narrative that harms them. It is not an judge of character, but rather of appearances. Of course the fox is to install a strong moral character in the home, by way of teaching rather than training, but unfortunately many parents give similar attention to their children as they would a beloved pet, so that is not at all something that can be expected.
- kardianos 3y agoMy children are minors. They need their time curated. I would rather instruction not have ANY access to the internet (I'm fine with using computers as a tool). I see zero legitimate reason to access the internet to learn a predefined curriculum. Your moral problem you pose, has no bearing on the legitimate needs of education. I would encurage reading "The Power of Culture" by Birbalsingh who runs a school in the UK that topped the "Progress 8" charts recently. That school works, the reason is they truly teach and they don't give in to these silly "moral" arguments. The most moral thing a parent or teacher can do is to ensure students learn so they are prepared for the future. End of story.
- beej71 3y agoI haven't read the book, but the synopsis talks about high expectations and teaching responsibility, which I completely agree with. Limiting what students can do and forcing them into rigid, limited curricula seems contrary to these goals...?
- logicchains 3y ago>The most moral thing a parent or teacher can do is to ensure students learn so they are prepared for the future How much of what students learn in school actually helps them in future? Personally the only thing I learned in high school that I ever actually use is mathematics. I didn't learn anything about how to manage my finances, how to handle emotionally challenging situations, how the economy works, how to start a business, how to avoid toxic people/relationships, how to drive a car, how to eat healthy, how to exercise with good form, how to pay (or minimise) taxes, how to invest, how to save money, how to cook healthy food, how to sell/market products or myself, how to analyse ethical issues from multiple perspectives/philosophies, how to negotiate, how to wear a tie. The vast majority of things that actually contribute to someone having a healthy, happy and productive life are not taught in schools (or at least the schools I'm familiar with), although they certainly could be.
- c22 3y agoDo you have kids? I once felt as you, that school was pointless and uninformative, but watching my kids develop key skills that we all take for granted from the focused instruction and practice provided to them by the public K-12 program changed my mind. I've been able to spend my time with them teaching those topics you laid out (some of which are quite opinionated) and not drilling the basics.
- pwdisswordfishc 3y agoA moral is a teaching you obtain from reading a story. That’s what the noun means.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- omoikane 3y agoA related concept is shame versus guilt cultures: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guilt%E2%80%93shame%E2%80%93fear_spectrum_of_cultures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guilt%E2%80%93shame%E2%80%93fe...
- philwelch 3y agoIt depends on the school but I would argue that public schools are not in the business of instilling morals. Maybe religious schools or boarding schools can instill morals, but a public school is not going to overcome whatever bad influences a child has at home. On the other hand, public schools can and should take measures to control the specific behaviors that happen inside that school.
- dividedbyzero 3y ago> 19% of students at schools that use filtering technology say they were even aware of students who were “outed” for LGBTQ+ as a result of the filtering. > Around two-thirds of teachers surveyed said they’d seen students disciplined at school as a result of AI-powered monitoring software. Shockingly, 38% of teachers said they were even aware of a student who was contacted by law enforcement as a result of the monitoring. So US schools are becoming bigoted panopticon prisons for real, yet kids still can't be kept safe from getting shot there? I don't know what that does to a child, but I'm sure it can't be good.
- caturopath 3y ago> 19% of students at schools that use filtering technology say they were even aware of students who were “outed” for LGBTQ+ as a result of the filtering. I am very skeptical this 19% should be taken at face value.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smogcutter 3y agoEh, idk about the percentage, but the idea sounds plausible to me. Teenagers find dark corners to make out in like water finds a crack. It’s not hard to imagine an automated system flagging contact between students as potentially inappropriate.
- bitcurious 3y agoIt’s a fuzzy statistic. It can happen once but be viral enough for 19% of students to have heard of it.
- watwut 3y agoWhy? This is about students hearing about such case. Rumors go around fast and far. One kid like that may easily mean good half of the school heard about the situation.
- mistrial9 3y ago
- rgrieselhuber 3y agoRead John Taylor Gatto.
- donatj 3y agoIf I have learned anything in the last 20 years, it's that "The Chilling Effect" is very real. We're building nothing but a culture of fear. People come to expect and even desire to be watched. A couple years ago, they installed cameras in our office ostensibly to "lock the doors in case of a gunman" shortly after a gunman had broken into a nearby office building. For that to even be remotely possible though, someone literally has to be constantly watching those cameras and the gunman has to be clearly brandishing the weapon. It's at best security theater and no one is watching, and at worst a horrible privacy violation. I see no upside. Talking to coworkers I was seemingly the only one with any concerns, and it feels like I'm taking crazy pills.
- wkjagt 3y agoMy 9 year old recently said "why are there only cameras outside the school. They should also put them in classrooms for when the teacher has to go to the bathroom"
- perihelions 3y agoMainland China is already trialing that. They have classroom cameras pointed at students, with some sort of primitive ML that classifies their "attentiveness level" and generates reports. https://futurism.com/smart-eye-china-facial-recognition https://futurism.com/smart-eye-china-facial-recognition - "Here's how it works. Every 30 seconds, three cameras installed in the front of the room scan each student's face to determine their expression: surprised, sad, antipathy, angry, happy, afraid, or neutral." - "The cameras also record each student's actions throughout the class, noting whether they are reading, listening, writing, standing up, raising hands, or leaning on the desk." - "Smart eye then notifies the teacher in real-time if it notices that a student appears distracted. The teacher can also view a report at the end of the class that provides an average of each student's expressions." - [embedded tweet] "What else can surveillance cameras do in classroom other than exam supervision? High school in #Hangzhou uses camera to identify students facial expression for class performance analysis and improvement pic.twitter.com/bXolAE7Ev8 — People's Daily,China (@PDChina) May 16, 2018" https://nitter.net/PDChina/status/996755673093292032 https://nitter.net/PDChina/status/996755673093292032
- mistrial9 3y agoin other news, phones and too much screen time are Very Hurting Kids
- jdjdjdjdjduuuu 3y agoIn other news, the US Government is trying to keep all citizens scared so it can do whatever it wants.
- GuB-42 3y agoThe article is a mess, mixing surveillance, filtering and generative AI. In fact, their main argument about potential harm is that filtering makes it hard to find information. They also say that surveillance is used to discipline kids (obviously, that's what surveillance is for). And that students are using ChatGPT for their homework (sure but that's another topic). Then they throw in LGBTQ+ and children with disabilities again without much coherence. There are links to other article but none of them are about how school surveillance is harming kids. Where are the studies? The numbers? Overall poor article that doesn't really help its cause.
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- erulabs 3y agoIronic about the other reply to your post - generally studies here are totally dismissed or not required - it’s supposed to be “common sense” when it comes to “the children”. It’s so strange how whenever things are most important we tend to totally throw out scientific rigor. See SF abolishing math with zero studies or the way we construct school buildings with zero architectural appeal or the way schoolbooks are procured. Methodology is a thing for nerds to use to build airplanes - at least that’s the attitude I get when asking other parents / teachers about data to back up their “overhauls”.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoIt's lack of trust. I too tend to be dismissive by default when it comes to school decisions backed by "studies", because I don't trust an average social science study, I definitely don't trust those that become trendy, and I don't trust school administration to be able to comprehend even a valid study, much less implement it fully in a hostile political and parents/school relationship environment. Hard sciences are easy, soft sciences are difficult. When you follow a bogus physics study and fuck up your airplane design, your mistake will be immediately apparent. When you follow a bogus social sciences study and fuck up the K12 curriculum, your mistake might be apparent after you retire, if it'll ever become apparent at all.
- politician 3y agoWould someone knowledgable explain the mechanisms by which teachers are held accountable for their actions in their classrooms, and how parents and voters have access to that mechanism of accountability? Cameras in classrooms seem like they would be a key part of that process.
- caturopath 3y ago15-30 eye witnesses?
- endisneigh 3y agowhat happens when there are contradictions?
- caturopath 3y ago*gestures at all the legal system things*?
- lotsofpulp 3y agohttps://www.scientificamerican.com/article/do-the-eyes-have-it/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/do-the-eyes-have-... I imagine humans have a lot more cognitive biases that affect their memory than a video camera, even groups of humans.
- caturopath 3y agoEyewitness testimony might be less valuable than we intuit, but I'm not sure where this puts us in this conversation. Should we just surveil everywhere?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIt looks like that is where we are headed. Once the cost of storage and cameras is lower than the cost of litigation, it becomes a simple money saving measure.
- Simulacra 3y agoI have three kids. I think cameras in the classroom that can give parents a view into what's going on is a great thing. Especially in classrooms with children who have disabilities. But surveilling them on their phones, putting cameras in the bathroom, that's a step too far.
- tpmx 3y agoI saw a video yesterday about some AWS conference that had an interesting insight that I feel should apply here as well. "If you’re going to attend a talk, bias for Chalk Talks. Those are not recorded and they’re given by experts, many of whom work at AWS. And because it’s not recorded, they don’t feel the all-seeing eye humorless AWS PR and legal review on them quite as strongly, so they’re going to be a lot more direct about what they’re trying to get across. And some of the people you meet are just fantastic." So the idea is that by the mere act of recording (or publishing, even if it's limited) you limit the quality and candor, because people know that everything can and will be misunderstood. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drHqaJgy8CA&t=333s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drHqaJgy8CA&t=333s)
- em-bee 3y agoi would not want other parents to be able to see what my kids are doing in school. despite the best intentions some actions are going to be miss-interpreted and i fear parents will look at how much attention the teacher is giving to their child compared to others. this will only encourage the few karen-type parents out there to make a noise in detriment to everyone else who don't care or don't have the time to watch. parents should stay out of the classroom and trust the teachers to do their work.
- ejb999 3y ago>>parents should stay out of the classroom and trust the teachers to do their work. ...and we should never question the police, we should just trust them do their jobs ...and we should not be allowed to question politicians, we should just trust them to do their jobs ...and we should never question drug companies, we should just trust them to do their jobs
- User23 3y agoMeanwhile the homeschooling revolution continues. Few people realize what an absolute state of free fall American public schools are entering. You know all those annoying “Karens” who show up to the school board and PTA, who volunteer for the clubs, and generally act as a forcing function that keeps educational quality at least adequate? Yeah they’re pulling their kids to homeschool in record numbers, I mean millions. Meanwhile the public schools are left with the least engaged parents. And anyone who has ever talked to a teacher knows how vitally important parental engagement is for educational outcomes.
- keiferski 3y agoGoing to school in the 2000s, I feel like I was a part of the last generation that will "get away with stuff." Nothing terrible, just the typical shenanigans that teenagers get up to and have gotten up to since the beginning of time. Half the school would have been expelled and marked for life if they acted that way today.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoNot that I go around bragging about it but my introduction to adult erotica of various sorts was through a school computer connected to the internet. I was eventually caught after 4 years, and the consequence was my access was turned off. No one told my parents, no disciplinary issues, no police, nothing. Not the best judgement in my life, but the consequences were appropriate. Now I can’t imagine how it would have gone.
- swayvil 3y agoSchool or prison? Have you seen that? A series of pictures. Click a button. Is it a prison or is it a school? Hard to tell. Funny stuff. https://www.maristane.com/school-or-prison/ https://www.maristane.com/school-or-prison/
- bparsons 3y agoGetting them ready for a lifetime of delivering Uber eats.
- endisneigh 3y agowhat a terrible article lol. where to begin... oh, how about the fact that it's mixing up several different topics.
- ejb999 3y agoyea, but they thru in the 'disproportionately impacting the <insert non-white- male group of your choice>' - so that is really all that is needed these days to qualifies as journalism.
- baz00 3y agoFrom experience of having kids at school for the last 20 years, they are little enclaves for authoritarian cults. Now we invented software and technology to enable this further. All that needs to come along is a matching political ideology and there’ll be a fresh supply of adherents ready to roll.
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- kardianos 3y agoOkay, I read this article. This is BS. As someone with several kids who use chromebooks, it became much better for the kids when more active monitoring and blocking came in. Just as a practical basis, they were less likely to get distracted or wander into areas where they shouldn't, when they shouldn't. Okay, so if it blocks something that is potentially useful? Don't care. At school they should be learning the curriculum presented by the teacher. Want to learn something specific? Go to the library or do it at home. Seriously. This article is extremely messed up and weak.
- beej71 3y agoThank God I went to school in the 70s and 80s. Not only were there fewer online distractions, but there was a greater expectation of independence and responsibility.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoIn the 80s a bully broke my friend's arm and only failed to break mine because of a thick coat. Teachers were busy chatting it up and didn't believe he was truly hurt. I however left a mark on the bully when I bit him. My friend suffered in pain the rest of the school day. I got a stern talking to. AFAIK the bully was treated as a victim, even after my friend came back the next day in a cast. Also got to witness a classmate getting spanked on his bare ass by a teacher. The 80s weren't so great for safety in school. Not sure if indoor cameras are the answer, though I wouldn't mind if they tried at my kid's school.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI chose a daycare because they have cameras in every room and offer streaming video. I am not confident that there exists enough funding for enough staffing to properly monitor teachers, nor do they get paid especially well to attract the best candidates. I see cameras as an inevitability, and if I were a teacher, I would want them for my own liability.
- beej71 3y ago
- ed-209 3y agoSmall sample size and undocumented sampling methods. Also this message brought to you in part by Amazon, Facebook, Microsoft, and Apple [1] - somehow I don't think they're against the surveillance part. Catchy title though! [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Center_for_Democracy_and_Technology https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Center_for_Democracy_and_Tec...
- JTbane 3y agoI'd take it a step further, virtual aids are largely useless. Taking notes via pen and paper aids in retention.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoTbh, that’s only true for some people depending on their learning style. I never found notes helpful. I found virtual aids helpful, as I focused on listening and imagining questions and the topic in class rather than transcription of the words. The virtual aids provided the later reference material, which was much more useful since I had focused on understanding vs rote retention of language. However some people definitely find note taking to help. But those people definitely seem to see a homogenous world and are fairly forceful in insisting their way works for everyone.
- uconnectlol 3y ago> Though school administrators will argue these tools are necessary to ensure kids’ safety online, newly released data shared with Gizmodo highlights numerous privacy concerns and unintended consequences caused by their rapid deployment > newly released data shared I imagine a monotonous voice with no tenses on words when I read this. why would I need data to know that it's actually indeed perfectly safe for a kid to use the internet (or the previous equivalents like read books or listen to music). that's not to say i'm not also scoffing at the elephant in the room
- ignorethefacts 3y agoConfusing correlation and causality is probably the most effective form of viral propaganda. Most people don't know what causality is and even when they do they can't easily spot when it's proven or inverted. For example in this article, let's take the numbers and statements that provide at face value. The article claims: there is a rising number of LGBT+ individuals being outed because of technology. The claim of course carries forward the lie that LGBT+ has always existed naturally in the same proportions over time and therefore concludes that the rise of outings must be because of the technology. No need to consider any other possibilities because the article doesn't even make it sound like there's any doubt. Propaganda payload successfully delivered. The claims that LGBT+ individuals are being targeted specifically is absurd in any case, because schools in the Western world have been force feeding the LGBT+ agenda with vigor as of late.
- iamnotsure 3y agoOr rather, perverted adults are harming kids, using clandestine means.
- indymike 3y agoI agree with the headline, but for a very different reason: Kid's online activities are criminalized when schools snoop and hand that information over to the school resource officer. I don't ever want a visit to the wrong website to cause my family to be sucked into the legal system. So, I provide my kids hardware, and refuse to allow spyware to be installed and that includes browser extensions. Every year I have at least one of the three schools my kids are at try to force us to let them install something, and they find out: 0. The spyware they are using is creating a lot of network traffic to unexpected (and often unwanted) places and is much more intrusive than parents are led to believe. 1. Government, and that would be a public school, does not have legal right to surveil my kids without a search warrant. 2. They have no right to install stuff on a computer they do not own. 3. Public schools cannot deny education to my kids because we opted out of surveillance. The final resolution is usually the district's lawyer telling the head of IT they have to stand down on the issue.
- edrxty 3y agoThis is interesting, I'm surprised you can push back on this. Usually even if it's not legal people will just blindly force the issue because they don't fully understand and can't be told otherwise. Has anyone attempted to force you to allow your kids to use a school laptop full of spyware?
- indymike 3y ago> Has anyone attempted to force you to allow your kids to use a school laptop full of spyware? Every year. The back-off point is usually when I ask for a meeting with the superintendent and suggest the school bring their lawyer.
- edrxty 3y agoWell you're a hero for fighting back against this stuff. Keep it up. I remember being in grade school. Kids do weird shit and it's easy for adults to wildly misinterpret their actions resulting in absolutely insane reactions and all hell breaking loose for parents.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoAnother set of entries for my /etc/hosts: 127.0.0.1 gizmodo.com # G/O media 127.0.0.1 kotaku.com # G/O media 127.0.0.1 jalopnik.com # G/O media 127.0.0.1 jezebel.com # G/O media 127.0.0.1 qz.com # G/O media > On June 29, 2023, G/O Media decided to implement artificial intelligence-generated content on its websites, in a move similar to BuzzFeed and CNET, as a "modest test". The move sparked backlash from GMG Union members, citing AI's track record of false statements and plagiarism from its training data. No need for politically motivated, time wasting, AI generated bullshit. I left the Onion unblocked because it's the only one that's honest about it being fake.
- _lvbh 3y agoI just got into university and they tell you to install a root certificate authority to connect to the network. Literally allows them to MITM HTTPS traffic without causing SSL warnings