9 ms·
The equinox is not when day and night have equal lengths
- mitchbob 3y agohttps://archive.ph/K8VN4 https://archive.ph/K8VN4
- Waterluvian 3y agoOkay so it is what I think it is. Equal day and night. Just with a few equally fascinating pedantic details that make it not quite exactly true. I could go for more articles like this. In the little details that usually don’t matter are motes of fascination.
- digitalsushi 3y agoI was relieved it was what I thought it was, too. Learning equinox means 'equal night', and solstice means 'sun still' will remain stuck in my head for the rest of my life, though.
- Tao3300 3y agoIt seems I forgot enough Latin to not be misled.
- skfjeofh 3y agoThe article is missing the most disappointing fact of all, though. If there was a whole 24-hour period during which the sun was on the celestial equator, then 12 hours would be day and 12 night (going by the time the centre of the sun's disc rose and set). But the sun is always moving along the ecliptic, so the day we call the equinox is just the 24hr period within which the sun crosses the equator, which is an instantaneous event.
- didgetmaster 3y agonit: The sun is not moving along the ecliptic or crossing the equator. It is the Earth that is actually doing all the moving.
- mannykannot 3y agoOne can choose to pin a frame of reference to the Earth, it just won't be an inertial one (and quite noticeably not.) Perhaps you would accept phrasing the sentence in question as saying the Earth-Sun axis is doing these two things?
- spiderice 3y agoThe Sun and Earth orbit around a central point between the two bodies, which happens to be very close to the center of the sun. But that doesn't change the fact that they are both orbiting around each other.
- bmacho 3y agoThis is somehow more wrong than what you answered, which was already very wrong. (Wrong in an aesthetic sense, since both are ill-defined in physics, and only carry aesthetic value in Engilsh.)
- bagels 3y agoThe point is neither central, nor solely determined by the earth and sun. The moon and Jupiter influence the orbits of the earth and sun as well (of course as do all the other bodies to a much smaller degree)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 3y agoDepends on the inertial frame, the sun is flying through our galaxy :)
- dahart 3y agoIf I search for ‘ecliptic’, I get 2 different definitions: one is the “apparent path of the sun” (where the observer is the reference point), and the other is the plane of earth’s orbit around the sun (where the sun is the reference point). A good portion of the time, the plane of earth’s orbit is referred to as the ‘ecliptic plane’ and not just ‘ecliptic’. Maybe using ‘plane’ as a qualifier is a nice way to distinguish these ideas. Google’s chosen quick-definition, the one where it shows you the result without linking to a website, is the apparent-path definition.
- conductr 3y ago> On Saturday, September 23, at 6:50 A.M. UTC (2:50 A.M. EDT or 11:50 P.M. Friday PDT), the sun will be directly over Earth’s equator, which is how astronomers define the equinox. Article starts out by specifying the time of the event
- skfjeofh 3y agoAs has been noted in another comment, the article makes that statement, but skips over the implications of the constant apparent motion of the sun for the length of day. It gives the impression that, geometrically speaking, there is a day on (or near) the equinox which has equal darkness and daylight. Of course, this isn't guaranteed at all, and certainly not for every point on the earth's surface.
- o11c 3y agoSpeaking of pedantic details, I'm surprised it doesn't mention how the fact that Earth's orbit is an ellipse rather than a circle messes up the dates quite significantly (it's not February's fault). I expect the same effect on a smaller scale would also mess up "equal day and night".
- Waterluvian 3y agoIt’s all Kepler’s fault.
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoThat Copper Knickers guy has a lot to answer for too!
- franciscop 3y agoI agree with that, but I do not like the tone of "no you are actually wrong" from the article, in the way that a scientist could be explaining to you that a tomato is a fruit all day long and you'd still eat it with your salad.
- anigbrowl 3y agoThis sort of 'conversational journalism' has become endemic, and it's terribly obnoxious. Scientific American used to be a quality publication, but their editorial standards have sunk to the lowest common denominator over the last 2 decades.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoJournalism lost over 90% of its funding after classifieds were gone and tech companies gobbled up all the advertising money. The current low quality is a natural consequence of the economic incentives.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoThe article shared some interesting facts, but equinox is still basically what I originally thought. So IMHO the title is a bit clickbaity.
- Tao3300 3y agoWho the heck is SA writing for? Children know this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Retric 3y agoFor an article this pedantic they still miss several details. “If we measured the day starting and ending when the sun’s center breached the horizon, we’d be fine; day and night would be equally parsed.” It then list a few caveats but that’s not sufficient as the sun is going to cross the the equator at some random point in the day say 2:15:45 pm which means it’s not over the equator at sunrise and sunset thus distorting the day. The horizon is generally defined based on local terrain not the more abstract true horizon. Earth isn’t a perfect sphere rotating at a constant rate etc etc. It’s got some amusing bit’s of trivia, but I don’t think anyone’s definition is going to actually change.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- irrational 3y agoIsn’t that addressed in the first sentence? > On Saturday, September 23, at 6:50 A.M. UTC (2:50 A.M. EDT or 11:50 P.M. Friday PDT), the sun will be directly over Earth’s equator, which is how astronomers define the equinox.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Retric 3y agoThey mention it, but not the implications of it occurring at a specific time rather than a full 24 hour period.
- irrational 3y agoDo they need to mention the implications? I’d never considered it being a single moment (I’d always thought of it was being a 24 hour period), but I distinctly remember, after reading that sentence, saying to myself, “Oh, it isn’t a 24 hour period but a moment in time.”
- 3y ago
- furyofantares 3y agoI find it more satisfying and clearer to say it's when day/night are the same length everywhere on earth/for everyone on earth. For me that prompts thinking about the earth with its tilt in relation to the sun and the two points in its orbit where that could be true. Within that framework you could bring up pendantry how "definitions" of day/night mean this doesn't imply day and night are each 12 hours. Actually I find such pedantry more interesting in this framework; it's just clearer that we're saying globally there is always more day than night under this particular definition. It also IMO prompts the even more interesting pedantry discussed in this thread about it crossing this point at some random time during the day, we don't hover in that point of the orbit for 24 hours.
- kazinator 3y ago1. It's nowhere near night time the moment the sun sinks halfway past the horizon. It's around early evening. Only on a planet with no light-scattering atmosphere does night being at the completion of sundown. And even then, since the star is larger than the planet, more than 50% of the planet is illuminated: night is nevertheless shorter.¹ 2. Did you consider the poles? -- 1. Someone claiming to be a mathematician posted some calculations on quora.com claiming that 50.23% of the Earth is illuminated directly due to the relative size of the Sun and the Earth. https://www.quora.com/What-percentage-of-planet-earth-is-illuminated-by-the-sun-at-the-same-time-in-average https://www.quora.com/What-percentage-of-planet-earth-is-ill...
- wouldbecouldbe 3y agoHaha yeah his definition is from a perspective of need of structural consistency the rest of us wants the definition of day to be useful and represent when it’s light
- mmcnl 3y agoIt's my go to fun fact whenever the situation is suitable for it. People often have never realized this. (My other fun fact is that South America in its entirety lies East of Florida, and not below North America, most people memorize South America as being completely South of North America.)
- didgetmaster 3y ago>If Earth had no air, this wouldn’t be an issue (though there would be other uncomfortable consequences). They don't mention in the article what those 'uncomfortable consequences' are, but if you asked the average person what would happen if all the air around the earth suddenly disappeared, they would say 'we would all suffocate'. This is of course true, but we would likely succumb to the effects of suddenly being exposed to the vacuum of space before we died from the lack of oxygen. Having a scuba mask and tank on when the air disappeared would not prolong your life at all. Air pressure is something we tend to take for granted if we are not climbing Everest or in an airplane.
- topherclay 3y agoIf you genie-wished the atmosphere away in one instant, I wonder what type of explosion the oceans would do as the new at atmosphere emerges, from the gases and liquids that didn't count as atmosphere before suddenly find a new equilibrium.
- mormegil 3y agoThis is exactly the kind of question Randall Munroe answers in his What If <https://what-if.xkcd.com/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/>. Unfortunately, this specific one seems not to be answered there?
- ajkjk 3y agoWell they would boil instantly, basically. Presumably the result would be a lot like the old atmosphere, just... mostly water?
- avar 3y agoEven if we had no oceans (or other bodies of water, or ice) we'd instantly get a new atmosphere from the resulting vacuum-induced outgassing.
- manwe150 3y agoTo be a bit pedantic, the dangerous effect of the vacuum of space is the lack of oxygen and rapid suffocation, apparently within seconds: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effect_of_spaceflight_on_the_human_body#Vacuum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effect_of_spaceflight_on_the_h.... The other effects (like ebullism and freezing/overheating/sunburn come "much" later in minutes).
- sandpaper26 3y agoWhy would the author even make a point about the different seasons between hemispheres and then immediately get it wrong? He tells the reader to "reverse the seasons and add six months to the dates," but doing both of these operations cancels them out. "The summer solstice in June" becomes "the winter solstice in December," which is still the northern perspective.
- teo_zero 3y agoBesides, not all dates must be corrected. This one for example is true in whichever hemisphere you live: > On June 21 or so every year, Earth’s North Pole reaches its greatest tilt toward the sun.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoIs equinox a subsidiary of equifax? /s
- andsoitis 3y ago> southern skies are far better than northern ones yes they are, by far
- perilunar 3y agoTLDR: it is, but there's some interesting details. If you want a clock that shows this visually: https://sunclock.net/ https://sunclock.net/
- computator 3y ago> On June 21 or so every year, Earth’s North Pole reaches its greatest tilt toward the sun. When that happens, the sun’s path across the sky takes it the highest above the horizon all year, making for the longest days of the year and giving the sun maximal time to heat the ground. We associate this time of year with warmth and sunshine. The duration of daylight can't be the complete explanation for why summers are warmer because otherwise the North Pole and Scandinavia, having super long days, should be hot during summer. He forgot to mention that the angle of the suns rays, depending on where you are, is also a factor for the warmth, right? Now that I'm thinking about it, which is really the bigger factor in having a warmer climate: your angle to the sun (your latitude) or the duration of the day? (I realize that they are connected, but I'm trying to imagine separating them.)
- justnotworthit 3y agoI read somewhere that the hottest mix of the two is around 30 degrees.
- scruple 3y ago> around 30 degrees The Horse latitudes. [0] Having spent a significant amount of time ~at this latitude, I'm inclined to believe it. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horse_latitudes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horse_latitudes
- Zedseayou 3y agoIn the summer you have both effects - you have more direct sunlight (more vertical angle/less atmosphere attenuation) as well as the longer days. The higher apex of the sun in summer is a sign of the former as well as the latter.
- wcoenen 3y ago> which is really the bigger factor in having a warmer climate: your angle to the sun (your latitude) or the duration of the day? This graph from wikipedia might be a good start. It is showing the trajectory of the sun on different days of the year at 56 degrees north latitude (e.g. Edinburgh, Scotland). https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Solar_declination.svg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Solar_declination.sv... The horizontal axis is the azimuth of the sun, but it works as time as well. So that tells you the duration of the day. The vertical axis is the elevation angle of the sun. To turn this into a solar power factor, you would actually have to take the sine of the angle. But I don't think that would change the overall shape of the graph much. So you can think of the area under the curve as an approximate measure of energy delivered by the sun.
- ggm 3y agoCrying out for an animation. A recent (5y) BBC series on the seasons had a phenomenally good speeded up view of the equinoctial shifts and visually explained why the North and south don't get an equal deal in this (the orbit is an ellipse so their respective summer and winters take place at different distances from the sun)
- KineticLensman 3y agoThe thing that always gets me us that when we reach the shortest day (southern UK here) the latest sunrise and earliest sunset are actually several days apart. And this leads to the rabbit hole of how mean time varies from solar time, when considering noon
- croisillon 3y ago“a complete cycle of one day and night is called a nychthemeron […] I love odd words like that” I love them too! Lithuanian language has the similar concept of “para”, sometimes very handy and i don’t think i’ve seen it in other european languages.
- shakow 3y agoBy para, you mean a complete day & night cycle? If so, we have something similar in French, with « jour » being a 24 hour span, whereas a « journée » only designating the daylight part of it.
- bmacho 3y agoin English there is 'day' and 'daytime'
- kseistrup 3y agoIn Danish we have ‘døgn’ and ‘dag’.
- croisillon 3y ago“I stayed one day at Disneyworld” doesn’t mean i stayed 24 hours there
- dahart 3y agoUsing the verb ‘stayed’ does tend to imply you slept there and were there ~24 hours. If you had ‘stayed two days’ or more, that really would imply N 24 hour cycles approximately, and at least N-1 cycles certainly; any other number besides 1 in your sentence would mess up your example. You already know the word “day” has multiple meanings, and in some contexts (such as time codes and dates and time measurements, using “day” always means 24 hours). An example using one of the meanings is irrelevant, it does not contradict the other meanings.
- bmacho 3y ago
- simonbarker87 3y agoThe article says that southern hemisphere skies are better than northern? I’m interested in what way? Better stars? Bluer day sky? Less clouds? Better clouds? Anyone know what he was referring to?
- NKosmatos 3y agoThe southern sky has a better view of the Milky Way and there are more bright stars and constellations visible. Also the fact that the southern hemisphere is less populated means that the skies are darker (on average). See below for a more detailed explanation: https://www.skyatnightmagazine.com/advice/southern-hemisphere-cheat-sheet https://www.skyatnightmagazine.com/advice/southern-hemispher... https://www.lightpollutionmap.info https://www.lightpollutionmap.info
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoI grew up in the northern hemisphere and now live in the southern hemisphere. The night sky appears brighter and more starry in the southern hemisphere (after correcting for moonlight and light pollution, of course) due to the Milky Way, but it is harder to see constellations due to the low contrast. The most noticeable individual stars sit quite low in the sky. Here, the "background" behind the nearest stars is black, making them easy to see and seemingly brighter. I think it is no coincidence that the vast majority of named constellations occur in the northern hemisphere. In the southern hemisphere, people traditionally navigated by the Milky Way rather than by individual patterns of stars. Both hemispheres have a very beautiful and distinctive night sky. It is impossible to say which is "better" because they are so different from each other.
- simonbarker87 3y agoOh nice, thanks
- croes 3y ago>day and night would be equally parse Isn't it just day = light and night = no light, ignoring moon, stars etc.?
- nologic01 3y agoWe can fix the linguistic ambiguity by either having the Earth orbiting at much larger radius or spinning much faster around its axis. This makes the length of day/night less relevant. Ofcourse the strictly correct result is only obtained in the asymptotic limit of infinite orbital radius or infinite rotation speed. The first option seems problematic. While the rotational period becomes infinitesimal vs orbital, in the limit there is no orbital motion at all, not to mention that cosmological considerations come into play. But the second option brings other difficulties, like people being ejected into space from the infinite centripetal force. Its a tough one.
- asplake 3y agoConsider a spherical, no-atmosphere planet with a pointlike sun
- skeltoac 3y agoThe author is Phil Plait, Bad Astronomer. He is writing for an audience that is not as technically well-informed as most of HN, so it’s no surprise to see his writing called out as “pedantic” by… a bunch of pedants! He’s helping people understand the world a bit better and that’s a great thing to do. I recognized the style before I noticed his name. Phil was writing online as The Bad Astronomer at least as far back as 1999. I started reading his blog after it appeared on my WordPress “Blogs of the Day” ranking site in 2005. http://www.badastronomy.com/info/whois.html http://www.badastronomy.com/info/whois.html https://web.archive.org/web/20230922000000*/http://www.badastronomy.com:80/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230922000000*/http://www.badas... https://web.archive.org/web/20051212173430/http://blogsoftheday.com:80/?list=topsites.html https://web.archive.org/web/20051212173430/http://blogsofthe...
- mark_l_watson 3y agoMy wife has the equinox watch face on her Apple Watch, and she monitors the progress daily. We all need our own hobbies and interests. I forwarded this article to her.
- ftxbro 3y agotldr the sun is not a point