10 ms·
Bloomberg Is Throwing $500M at Efforts to Shut Down All U.S. Coal Plants
- tomp 3y ago@dang the title is wrong. should be Michael Bloomberg Is Throwing $500M at Efforts to Shut Down All U.S. Coal Plants (to avoid confusion with the company)
- SCSIfloppy 3y agoHe is the company, it's his corporation. He's the founder, owner, and CEO. It's correct to associate anything he does with his company, while in law they're not the same entity, in truth, they can be treated as such.
- dylan604 3y agoBut if the money is coming from the company accounts vs his own personal accounts makes a huge difference. What an individual does with their money is up to them as they decide. What a CEO does with the money of a company is very much not theirs alone to make. The board might not like it. Other banking rules come into play. Employees not getting a raise might have something to say. How you can even try to conflate the two as being the same is just short sighted.
- akhosravian 3y agoBloomberg is privately held, and Mr Bloomberg holds 88% of its shares. In this scenario the board works for him, not the other way around.
- dylan604 3y agoDo you honestly believe that the money used to operate the company comes out of his personal bank accounts? Are you just this unaware of how things work, or are you being a troll?
- SCSIfloppy 3y agoThat’s not what that person said though. Bloomberg, the company, is an asset of Bloomberg the man, a tool he uses to accomplish… whatever he is up to. It’s a legal fiction under his direct control, money in the bank.
- fatfingerd 3y agoIf he decides he'll need 500 million more for his personal goals he does a dividend amounting to a reduction of 568 million in Blomberg's money on hand, presto! Huge difference there because it spent some time in his account, if you are his accountant or if you are Bank of America, but for the rest of us the distinction is largely a waste of time.
- jjtheblunt 3y ago> while in law they're not the same entity, in truth, they can be treated as such contradiction?
- SCSIfloppy 3y ago[flagged]
- barelysapient 3y agoThe first line of TFA makes it clear, that he, Michael Bloomberg, is personally doing this. > "Billionaire, philanthropist, and former NYC Mayor Michael Bloomberg announced this week that he will invest $500 million into his campaign to shut down coal plants and halve gas use by 2030."
- tbcj 3y agoTechnically, he’s not the CEO of Bloomberg LP
- gabrielsroka 3y agoTechnically, the title is "Michael Bloomberg Gives $500 Million to Shut Down Coal Plants"
- draw_down 3y ago[dead]
- ben_w 3y agoInside me there are two wolves[0]; the optimistic one says this is fantastic and applauds the effort, the cynical one thinks this was going to happen on this time scale anyway and is therefore a waste of money. Which is right? [0] well, I am a furry :P
- KerrAvon 3y agoNo. The eradication of pollution sources, even coal, is not at all inevitable. Remember that there's an active and large pro-pollution element in US politics right now. it Any money spent in a positive direction is useful to help avoid or win fights to push things in the wrong direction.
- ars 3y ago> an active and large pro-pollution element in US politics right now No, there is not. Rather there is a Democratic strawman that they enjoy attacking. What there is, is an element that doesn't want energy disruptions, and isn't willing to compromise on that. Look at this table: https://www.fool.com/research/renewable-energy-by-state/ https://www.fool.com/research/renewable-energy-by-state/ and notice how with the exception of California, all the states with high renewable percentages are conservative leaning.
- screwturner68 3y agowho knows maybe in Bloombergs old age he's trying to grow a soul. He's realizing that he can't take it with him and he's been a shit steward while he's been on earth, maybe he's trying o to correct the error of his ways...or he's afraid he's going to hell.
- somenameforme 3y agoOr he wants to run for president next year and getting his bonafides in order.
- n2d4 3y agoBloomberg has been known as a philanthropist for decades, he donated over $14 billion in his lifetime
- htss2013 3y agoDoes Bloomberg also have a plan to replace them with something else that will serve as reliable base load? Otherwise this is just a plan to turn the US into South Africa with perpetual brown outs.
- elzbardico 3y agoPeople here extensively drank the kool-aid, and they don't even have the beginning of the required understanding of the economics and the physics of grid scale electricity production and distribution. Maybe they will understand when they pay the same for energy as in Germany.
- nicole_express 3y agoIn the US it generally seems to end up being natural gas; still a pretty big emissions improvement but not zero carbon by any means.
- robotnikman 3y agoI'm hoping nuclear power makes a comeback in the future. The new reactor opened in Georgia this year seems promising.
- tstrimple 3y agoWhat about 7 years late and $17 billion dollars over budget is promising?
- purpleflame1257 3y agoEven replacing those power plants with LNG would be a net benefit.
- zamalek 3y agoSouth Africa stopped investing in energy infrastructure. This is $500m investment. That is a substantial difference.
- thelastgallon 3y agoConcentrating Solar-Thermal Power (CSP) is rapidly getting cheaper: from 9.8¢/kWh (2018) to 5.0¢/kWh (2030) [1]. With 14 hours of storage, this can take care of baseload. [1]https://www.energy.gov/eere/solar/articles/2030-solar-cost-targets https://www.energy.gov/eere/solar/articles/2030-solar-cost-t... From Endnotes: All costs quoted here exclude benefits from federal or state tax incentives, such as the Investment Tax Credit.
- tomohawk 3y agoCan you point to a single csp installation the produces equivalent power to existing coal plant 24/7? Would it work in the US Midwest or North East?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gsk22 3y agoAs far as I understand, most of the Midwest is actually pretty conducive to solar generation. As a cherry picked example, Minneapolis has roughly 200 more annual sunshine hours than Houston. Obviously somewhere like Phoenix blows those numbers out of the water, but solar is still very economical in the Midwest. I see new utility scale solar farms popping up here all the time.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y ago> Minneapolis has roughly 200 more annual sunshine hours than Houston. That's very interesting because what I recall from about 15 years ago is that Minneapolis was slightly behind Houston in that regard. I wonder if it's just variation within the error band or it's been impacted by climate change? Regardless, here in rural MN I see a lot of new barns/sheds going up with solar panels on the roof whereas 15 years ago they would either have used generators or paid to have AC power run all the way out there.
- tomohawk 3y agoDays in Minneapolis are indeed longer in the summer time, but far shorter in the winter time. Electric heat is quite challenging in the winter, when a plant such as this would be at a fraction of its output. The link in the parent post contains a map that would indicate most suitable location by far for such an installation would be in the South West. However, without an installation with a proven track record, this seems kind of like pie in the sky thinking.
- thelastgallon 3y ago21% of least efficient and most polluting form of coal-fired power stations are in US: https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2015-03-18-world%E2%80%99s-most-polluting-coal-plants-are-identified https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2015-03-18-world%E2%80%99s-most-po...
- vuln 3y agoWhere’s the data to back up the claim. The site doesn’t appear to link to the data.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAnother argument is that only one coal fired plant in the US is cheaper to operate than replacing the rest with renewables, Dry Fork in Wyoming. https://archive.ph/BBmOP https://archive.ph/BBmOP | https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jan/30/us-coal-more-expensive-than-renewable-energy-study https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jan/30/us-coal-more... https://www.gem.wiki/Dry_Fork_Station https://www.gem.wiki/Dry_Fork_Station https://web.archive.org/web/20230921183659/https://energyinnovation.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Coal-Cost-Crossover-3.0.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20230921183659/https://energyinn... > This report finds 99 percent of the existing U.S. coal fleet is more expensive to run compared to replacement by new solar or wind. Replacing coal plants with local wind and solar would also save enough to finance nearly 150 gigawatts of four-hour battery storage, over 60 percent of the coal fleet’s capacity, and generate $589 billion in new investment across the U.S. Our report provides policy recommendations to facilitate a just transition through the Coal Cost Crossover. (obligatory "base load is a myth", you overbuild renewables in order to make up for firm generation shortfall, you'll see some fossil gas generation uptick until firm renewables and more batteries drive out fossil gas generation, etc)
- ipaddr 3y ago4 hour storage will deplete quickly. You can't get away from base load generation unless you want periods without power
- boringg 3y agoI mean $500M is something but not that much when it comes to shutting down all coal plants and replacing it with renewable energy. Thats about 500-650 MW of production -- half the size of a standard Nuclear facility (1GW). It certainly helps though. And I bet that he's getting a pretty sweet tax break ;)
- voisin 3y agoThis is a billionaire tax break I can get behind.
- Greenieee 3y agoI mean, look at what they are spending it on: Apparently not directly on power plants if i follow the article linked. It indicates to me that we talk about an investment with multiplication possibility: "The financing is intended to support research, including studies and analysis to deliver accurate data to partnering organizations and officials for better decision-making. It will also fund local policy and advocacy, along with litigation brought against power companies." Which will lead to even more and faster and better green energy through more investment and more focus and more acceptance and therefore more investment and more research and further cheaper prices for everyone. I will buy this year a little bit of PV too for the first time.
- ipaddr 3y ago[flagged]
- multiplegeorges 3y agoTry reading? > Bloomberg has successfully helped shut down about 70% of all coal plants in the U.S. He can fly around in a coal powered jet for all I care, he has done more to improve emissions than maybe anyone alive?
- Clubber 3y ago>Bloomberg has successfully helped shut down about 70% of all coal plants in the U.S. I find that hard to believe. Did he help shut down 70% of coal plants or did he help shut down 70% of the coal plants that were shut down? If the former, where did the replacement energy come from?
- akira2501 3y agoWhy not spend the money building better power plants? Wouldn't that be a better way to "push" decision makers into newer technologies? According to their own success stories, most of the agencies that "stopped" using coal were going to anyways. I'm not at all clear on how this money was used and why the amount spent was correct in any way. It really looks like more "green washing" purely to the benefit of the "Bloomberg" brand.
- snewman 3y agoThe development of better power technologies is ~necessary, but not sufficient, to eliminate coal (and other carbon-emitting energy sources). There are all sorts of friction effects which can delay a migration to clean power even when the economics are favorable, so direct efforts to push the decision forward are an important piece of the puzzle.
- akira2501 3y ago> The development of better power technologies is ~necessary, but not sufficient, to eliminate coal Why? Are there not other plant technologies already in existence that can pick up the base load and produce less pollution? > There are all sorts of friction effects which can delay a migration to clean power Okay, so what are those? This article and it's backing material don't go into that at all. What did this money accomplish that would not have happened on it's own? > so direct efforts to push the decision forward are an important piece of the puzzle. As I stated, the backing material makes it clear these decisions were happening anyways. So, again, what is this money actually doing? I get that there are issues, but I'm concerned that we're actually addressing them and not just green washing. Do you want to address that specific point?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Why? Loss and risk aversion in the communities where the plant’s workers live, inertia and stupidity. > the backing material makes it clear these decisions were happening anyway I’m in Wyoming. There is emotional resonance to saving coal jobs here that transcends the data.
- username332211 3y ago> The financing is intended to support research, including studies and analysis to deliver accurate data to partnering organizations and officials for better decision-making. The cause itself notwithstanding, that's some impressive spin doctoring.
- multiplegeorges 3y agoWhat's the issue here? There is a TON of disinformation from the coal industry (and energy industry, generally) to counteract. If the data this effort produces is grounded in decent research, it's a net positive for everyone.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Cyber_Explorer 3y agoI would say that's a pretty good thing to be 'throwing' money at, to paraphrase the author of the article
- SkipperCat 3y agoI have no great love for billionaires, but if they're gonna do stuff, it may as well be this.
- WillPostForFood 3y agoReplacing coal with cleaner energy is great. Shutting down coal, blocking natural gas, and ending up with energy shortages and blackouts is terrible.
- runako 3y ago> Shutting down coal, blocking natural gas, and ending up with energy shortages and blackouts is terrible. Is anyone suggesting this as a policy direction?
- ars 3y agoYes! Tons of people. "Don't allow new drilling, no new natural gas plants, shut down the trans mountain pipeline." These are all popular policies. The only good policy is build new energy sources cheaper than oil/gas/coal and let the world switch naturally and without drama.
- travisporter 3y agoWhat timeline?
- ars 3y agoThere are 2 main things blocking this: Zoning issues. A lot of states have restrictive zoning that makes energy installation hard[0]. And money. (Although he Inflation Reduction Act will help[1], at least for windmills.) Since the 2nd problem is money, Bloomberg could have helped here - all he needed to do was invest all this money into buying and installing windmills. But he didn't. [0]: https://www.pnnl.gov/sites/default/files/media/file/Restrictions%20in%20Local%20Zoning%20-%20Memo%20-%20Jul22.pdf https://www.pnnl.gov/sites/default/files/media/file/Restrict... [1]: https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/clean-energy-manufacturing/us-wind-manufacturing-makes-a-comeback-thanks-to-inflation-reduction-act https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/clean-energy-manufactur...
- supportengineer 3y agoWhich side of the effort are they throwing money at?
- xyzelement 3y agoMike Bloomberg is pretty well known for his environmental philanthropy....
- ipaddr 3y agoThe pr side it seems
- joenot443 3y agoThis is a nice little example of a funny American tendency I've observed - if someone from the Wrong Team is associated with something you agree with, the immediate assumption is that there's some way in which this is secretly bad. In this case, u/supportengineer is in fact implying that Bloomberg spent $500m to keep coal plants _open_. A laughable notion to anyone familiar with Bloomberg outside of his 2020 run, but this what happens when your brain perceives the world in Red and Blue.
- Dylan16807 3y agoOr... just people that don't remember him! If I just hear some billionaire is spending tons of money on something like this, I need more information. Not that it makes it a good comment, since the answer is right there in the article. But the question isn't automatically stupid tribalism.
- karaterobot 3y ago> According to a press release from Bloomberg Philanthropies, this push to shut down coal-fired power plants will push officials to invest in renewable energy and clean jobs. On one hand, it's better if we get rid of coal than if we don't, and we should do it now. On the other hand, people who work at coal plants and lose their jobs will not turn around and become solar panel installers or wind turbine maintenance technicians. The most likely outcome is life will get worse for them. We've seen the consequences of this already from the manufacturing sector, and it's not pretty. Drugs, poverty, violence, depression. I'm not saying we should not close down coal plants, I'm just saying there will be consequences and "they'll all work for clean tech, and live happily ever after" is not a responsible plan.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> people who work at coal plants and lose their jobs will not turn around and become solar panel installers They could. They won’t, because of loss aversion and inertia. But a smart community could tell Bloomberg they’ll close their plant if they get a subsidy for a battery plant or a very large concentrated solar power plant. It’s a prisoner’s dilemma. And I don’t know if there’s a solution for the mines. But the tragedy is that the populations surrounded by coal aren’t selecting for long-term decision makers.
- duskwuff 3y agoMoreover, this is not a huge group of people we're talking about here. The entire US coal industry employs about 55k people, from top to bottom. It's not that big.
- jandrese 3y agoHe could directly pay each one about $9,000 for getting a new job. This probably doesn't sound like much money, but a lot of these coal jobs are in extremely poor areas of the US. It's a life-changing amount of money for many of them. Of course the real problem is that most renewables are too efficient. They don't need that many people. Once the wind turbine, solar panels, or batteries are installed they don't need someone out there every day working on them. Not the way that coal miners have to keep digging coal. It's the kind of job that puts itself out of business over time.
- RobotToaster 3y ago"The financing is intended to support research, including studies and analysis to deliver accurate data to partnering organizations and officials for better decision-making. It will also fund local policy and advocacy, along with litigation brought against power companies." So it's not actually going to help replace all that energy with carbon free energy from nuclear &c? Who is going to pay to replace all those coal plants? I expect that will cost orders of magnitudes more.
- frenchman99 3y agoAdding more clean energy will not stop fossil fuel, history thas shown that energy sources stack on top of each other, they do not replace each other.
- Clubber 3y agoI think you're right about renewables. You at least need fossil fuel as a backup or during surges, low wind, cloudy conditions and whatnot. I think nuclear is the only thing that can completely replace fossil unless someone comes up with a better way to store electricity.
- dylan604 3y agoit's also the renewables that get turned off first when demand is lower
- babypuncher 3y agoI feel like this is a much better use of his money than running for President.
- datavirtue 3y agoAll this just highlights the fact that none of this is going to work out for us. We halt climate change: economic collapse. We don't halt climate change: economic collapse. Forget climate change, natural resources are already stretched to the point where the cost of living is sky-rocketing. We were distracted by the pandemic...it is/was not the main problem. Billions of people trying to live the industrial life is the problem. Natural resources and land are the bottleneck. Overnight, the price of automobiles increased by 30%. Healthcare, housing, and energy are the root cause right now (been soaring for decades). By the time you figure those out you won't have enough bauxite or some shit.