8 ms·
Germany went from envy of the world to worst-performing major developed economy
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- strict9 3y ago>The loss of cheap Russian natural gas needed to power factories “painfully damaged the business model of the German economy,” Kullmann told The Associated Press. “We’re in a situation where we’re being strongly affected — damaged — by external factors.” I would argue that betting the farm on a single unreliable (at best) partner for cheap energy and future development is an internal factor and not an external one.
- ljlolel 3y agoAnd moving away from reliable nuclear
- worklaptopacct 3y agoAnd the same people who celebrated shutting down nuclear now put the blame on cars and block streets preventing working class people from getting to work. And as such, the far-right party polls at a record high right now.
- tomschwiha 3y agoI'm not sure what you intend to say. Nuclear supporters are far-right? Vote for a Nazi-like party because roads are blocked? Shutting down nuclear makes sense, we have much safer ways nowadays to generate (transform) energy. Storing the nuclear waste is a unsolved issue that is passed on to our children.
- alienicecream 3y agoIn the real world, safety is not the only factor. Cost, reliability and availability also count. And nuclear is very safe anyway.
- tomschwiha 3y agoWhat to do with nuclear waste? From what I know nuclear energy is not really cheaper than other sources. Also Germanys energy was 2021 only 12% nuclear.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- User23 3y agoThere is no Nazi-like party in Germany. The AfD's platform of reducing immigration (not even eliminating it or repatriating!) is a far cry from the Third Reich's atrocities and trying to draw a comparison is obviously cheap and nasty rhetoric.
- tomschwiha 3y agoThe leader of the AfD is using Nazi-speech in his talks. The party is considered being a right-wing extremist group.[0] Sounds for me they are very much Nazi-like. [0] https://www.dw.com/en/afd-politician-h%C3%B6cke-charged-with-using-nazi-slogan/a-65830762 https://www.dw.com/en/afd-politician-h%C3%B6cke-charged-with...
- VK538FY 3y agoFrom my point of view, the biggest problem with the AfD is that there is a lot of variability in the political currents that it contains. Most of them are pretty normal and reasonable. Some of them make me a bit uncomfortable. All based on my personal views of course. However I'm also sceptical of taking random comments as proof that a guy has a shrine to the Führer in his finished basement.
- deaddodo 3y agoI...do not understand this mentality in the West. Until we have a clean reliable alternative, Nuclear is the best we have. Do I think it's amazing or perfect? Not at all. But I much prefer it to burning non-renewable and cancerous petrochemicals/carbons. So, it's the best we have until we have for now.
- jupp0r 3y agoWe do have a clean reliable alternative (wind, solar, batteries), it's just a matter of making the investments to roll it out.
- inparen 3y agoIsn't it temporary ?
- pesho 3y agoI guess, but in this instance it wasn't the Russians that shut off the gas, the pipelines were blown (by idk who).
- okr 3y agoIMHO the gas transfer was stopped before the pipeline was blown up. And as far as i remember, there was drama about a generator before that.
- VK538FY 3y agoMy understanding is a bit different. Gazprom and or the Nord Stream operator insisted on fulfilling its contractual obligations for delivery but the situation became overly complicated for the reception of payment and some foreign to be repaired turbines were stuck in Canada or Germany because of sanctions against Russia. Then boom.
- red75prime 3y agoCorrect. From Wikipedia [1] "On 2 September 2022, the company announced that natural gas supplies via the Nord Stream 1 pipeline would remain shut off indefinitely until [...] compressor station [...] was fixed [...]. Gazprom justified this by claiming that European Union sanctions against Russia had resulted in technical problems". From CNN Business [2] "On Friday [September 2 2022], shortly after the G7 announcement [of the oil price cap], Russian state energy giant Gazprom said it would not resume deliveries through the Nord Stream 1 pipeline on Saturday as planned." On 26 September 2022, NS1 and NS2 pipelines were damaged ending any possibility of Russia using them for political pressure or profit. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nord_Stream_1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nord_Stream_1 [2] https://edition.cnn.com/2022/09/02/business/russia-oil-price-cap-g7-intl-hnk/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2022/09/02/business/russia-oil-price...
- iammjm 3y agoThey blackmailed Europe with stopping the gas-deliveries in case of continued support for the Ukraine long before Nordstream was blown up
- alienicecream 3y agoIt wasn't unreliable, and what alternative did they have? Do you know of one where they can get the same amount of energy at the same cost? Because Germany would love to know, quick.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI'm definitely no fan of Trump, but if you separate the messenger from the message here, he's actually totally correct here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I Cheap Russian energy was the drug that Germany got hooked on. Every viewer of after-school specials knows you shouldn't get hooked on the drug dealer's freebies.
- alienicecream 3y agoThe whole world buys oil from Saudi Arabia and goods from China, singling out Russia as some particular evil that it would be a mistake to do business with is nonsensical. Trump wants Germany to drop Russian energy inputs because it benefits the US geopolitically and economically, it's not so clear that it's a benefit to Germany.
- nradov 3y agoNatural gas isn't just a source of heat and power. It was also an essential feed stock for much of the German chemicals industry. That industry is now rapidly downsizing and migrating to other countries with cheaper gas.
- Arnt 3y agoUnreliable, at best. Could you explain why you think so? The historical record since the current contracts were signed (in the seventies): The Soviet Union delivered reliably throughout the eighties conflicts about short-range nuclear missiles, etc. Delivery continued reliably when the Soviet Union split up. Delivery was reliable when the transit country Poland had what amounts to a revolution. It continued reliably through Germany's reuinification. In the fifteen years following, Russia's economy half-died but delivery continued without change. These were wrenching changes to every country involved and one fairly substantial conflict. If this record indicates unreliability, what would it take to indicate reliability?
- tharmas 3y agoDon't forget geopolitics as the rationale. The USA sees German and Russian cooperation as a threat.
- VK538FY 3y agoYes, but also the rationale of the Anglo-Saxons in general. Idea born in England that is a truly understated root cause of the present conflict. People will stuff their fingers in their ears and swear it isn't true.
- m0llusk 3y agoAnd it was fun, fun, fun until Putin took the fossil fuels away.
- diogenes4 3y ago[flagged]
- gwervc 3y agoThere are major developed economies outside Europe...
- cm2012 3y agoIts also comparing it to USA, CA, Korea, Japan, all the countries at high GDP per capita levels.
- happytoexplain 3y ago"Major" and "developed" are not some kind of sneaky euphemisms. They're perfectly reasonable simplifications. They are more descriptive than "rich", and simply do not mean "European" at all.
- snapcaster 3y agoUS, Canada, Korea, Japan, UK
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Fervicus 3y agoIt's weird how MSM and thus everyone else forgot about the Nord stream pipelines so quickly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mikhailfranco 3y agoGerhard Schroder, Chancellor of Germany (1998-2005), Chairman of Nordstream. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerhard_Schr%C3%B6der https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerhard_Schr%C3%B6der Bad policies for energy security, richly rewarded.
- croes 3y agoHartz IV was worse
- jupp0r 3y agoThe article credits those reforms with kickstarting a decade of economic prosperity.
- croes 3y agoGDP grew, wages not so much. Similar to the current situation in the U.S. where profits are rising but workers are not benefiting much. Economic prosperity seldom means higher wages.
- tharmas 3y agoYes, this exactly. I wish the media would cover this more. But we know why they don't.
- freilanzer 3y agoFor whom?
- freilanzer 3y agoWhat happened? Corruption, stagnation (CDU and Merkel), neo-liberalism, privatisation of profits and nationalisation of losses, slow internet, horrible public transport, massive bureaucracy, dismantling of social services, ...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FFP999 3y ago[dead]
- danwee 3y agoFrom my limited perspective (non-German software engineer working in Germany), Germany is still a great country for people like me: - prices are not that expensive like in the nordic countries. If you cook at home most of the week, you can easily spend only around 350-450 EUR/month eating healthy food - renting is still hard (it's not so easy to find an apartment), but you can get a decent place for around 1.5K EUR/month (or less). I pay 1.2K/month for a 80 sqm (not city center, but not outside of it neither) - if you have > 10 years of working experience, you can definitely reach the 100K EUR/year (not FAANG). It's not easy, but not insanely difficult. Reaching 80K EUR/year is even more standard. This puts you on the top 10-5% of earners in Germany, so you get to save a lot of money per month - electricity/gas bills are getting more expensive, but still you won't notice with your kind of salary - health insurance is good enough - public transportation works just fine (not the best, but surely good enough). Tons of options (bus, tram, trains, bikes) - big cities in the west are welcoming to people who don't speak German Compare this with the situation of other european countries like France, Italy (a bit cheaper than Germany in general, but salaries are way lower in IT: around 30-40% lower) or even the Netherlands (not cheaper than Germany, and salaries are usually ~15% lower in general for IT). So, if Germany is doing bad, I cannot imagine how other EU countries are doing. The only thing Germany needs to fix is the winter time (you cannot expect to have healthy people when the sun sets at around 3-4pm in winter). P.S. And I love the work culture: "9-5 -> work. Outside of working hours -> don't even bother reaching me, I won't answer"
- shtopointo 3y ago> Compare this with the situation of other european countries like France What's the problem in France?
- danwee 3y agoI didn't mean that there is a problem with such countries. I meant that prices are generally more or less the same (e.g., in the supermarkets, the price of an iphone, cinema tickets, etc.) but salaries are lower (at least in the IT industry, I see that one gets around 30% less in countries like France, Spain and Italy compared to what I could get in Germany, but definitely the cost of living in Germany is not 30% higher than in such countries).
- cjbenedikt 3y agoThe next time someone tells you how Germany is again the sick man of Europe, smile, make eye contact, and then say this: "German real per capita GDP is up 13% since 2007, France is up 6%, Spain is flat and Italy is down -4%. How exactly is Germany the sick man of Europe?"
- croes 3y agoLike the comparison with the US GDP which ignore debt completely
- fonkyyack 3y agoWell you can look at the money but environmentally it's a disaster. Closing nuclear power plant was a mistake, reopening coal power plant is another. But I guess what's important is the economy...
- klaustopher 3y agoIf you look at the real data, you see that the loss of nuclear has nicely been covered by wind and solar: https://energy-charts.info/charts/energy/chart.htm?l=en&c=DE&chartColumnSorting=default&legendItems=101111111111111111110&interval=year&year=-1&source=total https://energy-charts.info/charts/energy/chart.htm?l=en&c=DE...
- kuchenbecker 3y agoEnergy is fungible
- abenga 3y agoIf you close a nuclear plant while a non-zero number of fossil fuel plants are still online, you don't care about emissions as much as you claim, regardless of what you replace them with.
- mx20 3y agoPrices are up 100% compared to 2007 easily. So GDP being up less than that is a colossal failure.
- shtopointo 3y agoYes - the Russian gas spigot was turned off.
- croes 3y ago>Jobs were plentiful, the government’s financial coffers grew as other European countries drowned in debt, That BS,Germany lived on the substance, the infrastructure was driven on wear and tear, important government agencies were cut so that experts were missing to avoid something like the odyssey of the Berlin airport, thanks to tax-free company sales and the introduction of Hartz IV, investors were able to make big profits while the workers could not participate in the rising profits but sometimes even had to accept wage cuts. All that because Germany was once called the sick man of Europe
- standardUser 3y agoGermany is facing a minor recession after a once-in-a-generation energy shock and a once-in-a-generation spike in inflation. And they've had, what, a year and a half to adapt to the new world order? This sounds more like a best case scenario than a cause for alarm.
- Ekaros 3y agoIt is amazing they are doing worse than UK...
- woodpanel 3y agoGee, one wonders how this could have happened? Importing 1-2 Mio people into the German welfare system, or was it caused by purposefully driving up energy costs massively? Is it that both things are a double whammy for housing costs? We might never know! (because the answer is - as always - absolutely racist)
- adventured 3y agoIt's hardly fair to pick on Germany in this regard. Most of affluent Europe has seen between zero and negative real economic growth for 15 years, basically since the great recession crashed everything. The standard we'll compare to is the US (it has tended to have a gradual upward sloping economic growth, somewhat consistent). Going with per capita figures, as that is almost always more important than the total figure. US 1990: $29,000. US 2000: $36,000. US 2007: $48,000 (peak before great recession hit). Today: $80,000. $48k in 2007 is $73k today (painful inflation). The US per capita figure is up roughly 10% since the great recession, in real terms, which is not a great outcome (if you want to know why the US population is so restless, this is one reason; in real terms major costs (healthcare, education, housing) have skyrocketed over the past ~16 years and the economy has not). Since 2000 per capita GDP has increased by a bit over 20% in real terms ($65k to $80k). Since 1990 the US has added around 85 million people (close to a 1/3 increase). The UK 1990: $19,000. The UK 2000: $28,000. The UK 2007: $50,000. UK today: $46,000. Since the year 2000, the UK has added 10% to its population and their inflation adjusted GDP per capita has contracted by almost 10%. Since the peak in 2007 their GDP per capita has dropped by 1/3 inflation adjusted (!) - $50k in 2007 is $75k today. That's a massive erosion over what will soon be two decades. In 2007 the UK briefly had a higher per capita figure than the US, now it's approaching half the US. Germany 1990: $22,000. Germany 2000: $24,000. Germany 2008: $45,000 (peak before great recession). Germany today: $51,000. $24k in 1990 is around $43k-$44k today (via the BLS inflation calculator). So Germany has seen a bit under 20% real growth over 33 years, which is exceptionally poor by most any standard (but at least it's growth). Since the peak in 2008, they have seen more than a 20% drop ($45k in 2008 is $65k today). They are lagging behind, however there are clearly worse outcomes in Europe, including the UK. France 1990: $22,000. France 2000: $22,000. France 2008: $45,000. France today: $44,000. Their population has increased by around ten million (~58m to ~68m) in 33 years. Since the year 2000 their per capita output has grown by a real 10% roughly. They're in the same boat as the UK, with a 1/3 drop in their per capita GDP since the peak in 2008. Italy 1990: $21,000. Italy 2000: $20,000. Italy 2008: $41,000. Italy today: $37,000. $41k in 2008 is equal to $60k today. So Italy has seen a near 40% drop since 2008 in real terms. Obviously far worse than Germany. Spain 1990: $14,000. Spain 2000: $15,000. Spain 2008: $35,000. Spain today: $31,000. $35k in 2008 is equal to $51k today. Spain has seen roughly a 1/3 decline since the 2008 peak in real terms. Netherlands 1990: $21,000. Netherlands 2000: $26,000. Netherlands 2008: $58,000. Netherlands today: $61,000. $58k in 2008 is equal to $84k today. Nearly a 1/3 drop in real terms since the 2008 peak. And so on it goes for most of Western Europe. The exceptions are the Baltics and Ireland. Figures are rounded to nearest thousand.