4 ms·
> Women had less rights for a long time Women always had different kinds of rights, like expressing themselves more with emotions and clothing and cosmetics, e
by amelius 3y ago
> Women had less rights for a long time
Women always had different kinds of rights, like expressing themselves more with emotions and clothing and cosmetics, etc., and taking care of children. Men don't have these rights. A man working in daycare is frowned upon. A man wearing eyeshadow is frowned upon, a man sending heart ♥ emoticons in WhatsApp is frowned upon, etc. It seems fair that if women claim more rights, then men can claim some of these "soft" rights too.
- clipsy 3y agoMen have the rights to do all of those things.
- PaulHoule 3y agoBut you sure can get your head stuffed in a trash can in some places for it.
- clipsy 3y agoBy whom?
- PaulHoule 3y agoYour fellow man.
- clipsy 3y agoFrom the post I originally replied to: > It seems fair that if women claim more rights, then men can claim some of these "soft" rights too. So it seems the argument is that because men prevent other men from exercising their rights, women deserve to be stripped of rights? Interesting logic. If men are stopping you from exercising your rights perhaps you should listen to the folks talking about toxic masculinity -- which is exactly what you're describing -- rather than trying to punish women.
- PaulHoule 3y agoSomebody else may be saying something else in this thread but I am not saying anything about women, I'm talking about the burden of being a man and the way "the patriarchy" or whatever it is can very much kick your ass. That is, it is not a system that works to the benefit of all men but rather a system that privileges some men and uses violence to keep the rest in line.
- pixl97 3y agoWhere is assault legal in the US?
- PaulHoule 3y agoIt's not like the DC universe where you can launch a space shuttle off a commercial airliner and Superman saves your ass. There is plenty of violent behavior where it comes down to "he said, she said" and the police and legal system practically do nothing. For example at my undergrad school I made fun of some gay bashers so they came after me instead of going after gay people because this was the 1990s and they probably thought if they actually bashed gays they'd get AIDS or something. Their reign of terror against me and other people like the president of the paint pellet gun club continued for a year until they finally smashed somebody in the face with a rock at point blank range from a water balloon catapult in front of tens of witnesses. I am still sore to this day at the dean of students who made excuses instead of busting the people involved. A gay man and a lesbian women committed suicide when this was going and I blame that dean of student more than anyone because the key thing about bullying is how the whole institution rallies to the support of the bully (e.g. if the institution can't protect you from that kind of abuse it is showing you you are worthless, not just *telling you.) I heard the ringleader of that gang did time and if he got out and went "straight" and put his life together and stayed out of trouble I would want to shake his hand because I know how hard that is, but that dean of students is celebrated as a hero for all the good things he's done for that school and I think never held to account for his role in that incident. When I really think about it I felt that I belonged there much more than many places in my life but I have not given money, been to reunions, or anything like that.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoAlmost only if they are élite
- em-bee 3y agoin new zealand men can't get a job as a kindergarten or primary school teacher (not sure about middle or high school) because parents won't have it.
- foogazi 3y agoMale parents too ?
- amelius 3y agoI'm guessing that by far the majority of children in a typical year are from "traditional" families, which kinda makes this question irrelevant unless I'm misunderstanding.
- foogazi 3y agoThe article is about how men need help. Gp stated men can’t even get jobs teaching children. But men also participate in the decision to keep men out of schools Gender seems to cancel out here
- em-bee 3y agoi have seen families where the male parents absolutely didn't want to have anything to do with childcare. so i don't believe that it is a far stretch that some people come to the conclusion that this is normal and they shouldn't do childcare, and any man who is caring about children would be suspicious.
- foogazi 3y agoIt’s because of the fear of sexual abuse and the belief that no penis / no rape
- acdha 3y agoDo you have more information about that? I know there’s a big gender skew but that’s nowhere near as simple as “men can’t get a job” and has multiple causes.
- PaulHoule 3y agoI didn’t know you could get away with emoticons in HN comments at all. I do post the growing heart and broken heart emoticons all the time on Mastodon but I can’t really talk about my gender much but I am sure people would guess it right.
- muricula 3y agoThose aren't political rights, those are social norms. If a man does any of those things, it's frowned upon, but if a woman tried to vote in the 19th century she'd be thrown in jail. I'm totally on board with people wearing whatever, it's a free country, but equating political rights with social norms is a false dichotomy.
- breadbreadbread 3y agoit's not as black and white as you make it out to be. those social norms affect men's ability to endure hardship, find community, and empathize with the struggles of others. The article is not just talking about written rights, it is talking about achievement and happiness, which are emergent from a combination of written policy and social norms. I disagree with the headline that "the left needs to talk about it" because fundamentally we do every day. The problem is that men tense up when we talk about things like "patriarchy" and "feminism", despite every piece of literature that explains that patriarchy and traditional (toxic) masculinity are actively harmful for men too. So men aren't listening to leftist talk about these issues and need to be baby-fed them using different words.
- tenacious_tuna 3y ago> equating political rights with social norms is a false dichotomy. But one begets the other, no? See also all this noise from TN and FL about crossdressing being a sex offense. People are more okay with women looking masculine than men looking feminine, and now we're seeing laws that reflect that. Similarly, because men aren't viewed as nurturing or whatever, they're far more likely to lose custody cases in court. There's absolutely tight bindings between political rights and social norms, and similarly I think there's a lot to be learned from the contrast between men and women's distinct challenges.
- majormajor 3y agoAre any of those things what people care about when they talk about "men's rights" or higher male suicide rates, jobless rates, etc, and the resulting need for "traditional masculinity" though... they mostly seem like the opposite!