11 ms·
Google settles account settings lawsuit less than one week after being filed [pdf]
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoIn the event title gets changed, here is the original title: Google Settles Account Settings Lawsuit Less Than One Week After Being Filed [pdf] (ca.gov)
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agohttps://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-announces-93-million-settlement-regarding-google%E2%80%99s https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bont...
- 20after4 3y agoThanks, this link is better than the text of the complain, since it includes the details of the settlement. Sadly the settlement seems pretty weak. Minor extra disclosures and a tiny settlement.
- oblio 3y agoAh, don't get me started about these dark patterns. Google Maps, the native Android phone app, behaves like a crappy website in navigation mode. Google really wants to push the assistant, there isn't a way to completely disable it in Android, disable all shortcuts, basically make it go away. So, in Google Maps, there's a Assistant bar at the bottom. That only pops up when you're in navigation mode, and "conveniently", slides up when you switch apps. So if you're in another app and decide to exit navigation using the X at the bottom left of Google Maps... the Assistant button slides up and you accidentally press it.
- buro9 3y ago> there isn't a way to completely disable it in Android This is not true, as there is... just disable the Google app. You will need to replace the launcher with the Nova launcher in the process, and will likely replace the search box with Firefox search. But the Google app and Assistant will be totally disabled and unavailable anywhere in the Android experience. If you find a link to it, it will ask to enable which you can decline. I found this out by Google having placed me in some experiment earlier this year where my Pixel 6 Pro went from 24h battery life down to about 3h battery life. The battery was being drained by the Google app exclusively, and so without any fix or published workaround I set about disabling the Google app. Overall this has been a huge improvement, my battery under near identical usage is now closer to 36h... and the Assistant not being present I have since viewed as a bonus (at the time I thought it a negative). I believe the issue is probably now fixed, but why would I go back when this is a better experience with more battery, disabling the Google app was like upgrading my phone.
- tempodox 3y ago“just”
- blackoil 3y agoThis is what Competition law is primarily about if I want/have to use App X, App Y should not be forced upon me. It was the problem in Windows/IE or Android/PlayStore ... Google, Apple, MSFT are abusing "monopoly" in one area to extend their reach in other areas.
- snide 3y agoHighly recommend the above. Moving to a launcher, defaulting to Firefox (yay adblocker), and replacing the default search with Kagi creates a near distraction free experience on Android. Unfortunately the Reddit / X changes this year should remind us these sort of 3rd-party workarounds will only exist for so long. I know it's a dream, but I'm looking forward to simple Linux phones. Moving to GNOME / arch on my Desktop lets me do what I want to do and somehow, magically plays any game from Steam without a hitch.
- kwanbix 3y agoWasn't Nova Launcher acquired by a very shady company? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32150092 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32150092
- FireInsight 3y ago
- liquidpele 3y agoUsed to love google maps, but I’ve switched to Apple Maps it’s been so bad lately. It’s taken me in literal circles, decides I need to do 2 uturns while sitting at a traffic light, gives instructions that are unclear or too late, etc. I noticed Waze got worse lately too, I guess they’re integrating them more :(
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoGoogle assistant randomly fires off for me in my heavily de-googled 2017 LG phone. It is so frustrating. I hate that app with passion, yet I can't disable it in android.
- iggldiggl 3y agoI've got no idea whether this still happens in more current Android versions or not, but on my phone I also discovered the weird phenomenon whereby force-stopping the Google app resets the selected assistant app back to Google instead of whatever else I might have chosen.
- 20after4 3y agoThat sounds like straight-up malware behavior. One process protecting the other so you can't kill them both permanently. This should be explicitly made illegal when it's done without the user's consent.
- alberth 3y ago> ”don't get me started about these dark patterns” Here’s another dark pattern for you in a totally different context. So Google use to have all of it various services on a separate subdomain (eg maps.google.com). But they moved to having everything under www.google.com. You know why, it’s because when you allow Google Maps to geolocate you (which is totally appropriate for a Maps use case) … now ALL of Google services get geolocation data about you from Search, Gmail, etc since they are all hosted in the same www root.
- user3939382 3y agoNice benefit is the elimination of tons of CORS requests.
- pc86 3y agoNo end user has ever been inconvenienced by a CORS request, so not sure that's a "benefit" for anyone other than Google.
- tsunamifury 3y agoSorry I find the ability to not allow geo for google.com for more than a day annoying as hell and a stupid feature where apple is over reaching.
- pc86 3y agoWhat does that have to do with cross-subdomain CORS requests?
- alexvitkov 3y agothat's actually pretty cool in a very fucked up sort of way
- tomComb 3y agoI’m not sure the correct way to approach The problem is, but it’s more widespread than just the big guys. Chess.com is annoying me by changing my settings every 1 to 2 months to put them back to what they want. This sort of thing is really common
- footlose_3815 3y ago>Google really wants to push the assistant, there isn't a way to completely disable it in Android This is why I switched to LineageOS. Google, the biggest ad company on the planet, is not to be trusted with something so personal as a cell phone.
- ryukoposting 3y agoHuh, you can't disable Assistant anymore? When did that change? My phone is old.
- RuggedPineapple 3y agoI can on a Pixel 7 pro. Did for a while before deciding it was useful and wanted it but didn't like it trying to pop up, so I went from disabled, to off by default but callable by dragging from one of the bottom corners and requiring me to press the mic button for it to listen. Kind of the best of both worlds, it stays asleep until I need to change whats on the chromecast.
- tmerc 3y agoIf you open setting in maps, you can disable driving mode, which gets rid of that bar at the bottom. I then couldn't figure out where to turn it back on. There's still an assistant button but in a less intrusive location.
- lucb1e 3y agoLittle protip: if you sign your phone up with Google, it doesn't force the assistant on you at all. Don't remember having to disable it, you just have to not consent to their terms. Side effect: you can kiss access to the monopoly on apk files goodbye unless you want to use third party hacky methods that use a pool of random people's accounts to talk to the google apk servers... Using one monopoly to gain market share in another :) The pattern is everywhere with google. I keep wondering why the competitors like TomTom haven't gotten them banned from the country with antitrust suits. Instead, TomTom just cut their losses, threw in the towel for their own map (which has surprisingly good worldwide road coverage for a Dutch company from the noughties), and is starting to use OpenStreetMap as a base layer. I'm not complaining about OSM use, but they were in the prime position to force Google to open the data they funneled from their original monopoly
- oblio 3y agoWhat's the amount?
- jkaplowitz 3y agoAccording to the California OAG press release: $93 million, plus injunctions which seem to be more about disclosures to users and internal oversight than actually allowing users to opt out of (or requiring opt-in consent before) tracking location. Not the most user-respecting outcome to say the least, though it could certainly have been worse. Disclosure: I worked for Google more than 8 years ago, but not in any role related to this news story. I have no relevant inside information and I am certainly not speaking for Google here.
- gdprrrr 3y agoSo, That's around 0,3% of the 280bn quotes in the PDF. The equivalent for Person with an income of 100k would be $3. Yes, you reading that right.
- ocimbote 3y ago100000 * 0.3/100 = 100000 * 3/1000 = 100 * 3 = 300 0.3% of 100k is 300. Unless you meant "an income of 100k cents" but that would be quite unusual.
- zoky 3y agoNo, they made an order of magnitude mistake. Fairly common, it happens. However, in this case it has taken it from “ordering bacon and avocado on my burger” to “two tickets to my local sports team including beers and chili cheese fries”. So not enough to be exactly punitive, more like a mild inconvenience. The point still stands.
- robertlagrant 3y agoPayment could be in the form of a Chromebook!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Garvi 3y agoGoogle has the power to shut down my business if I express the wrong opinions on social media sites like HN.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TrendyCPU 3y agoThe power Google has over small, local businesses is ridiculous. I work for a small local business. We've been struggling to get rid of the "lead generation" spam from the Google Maps listings. This is costing us on the order of thousands to tens-of-thousands a month in work. (That's significant for our business, on the ~10-15% of monthly revenue.) I dug into these listings. I discovered the company behind them, a marketing firm in Hawaii. I uncovered a network of 80+ listings across the US they operate. I even discovered their recruiting websites where they pay people to create the listings for them and go on to pay people for 5-star reviews. I provided all of this information to Google via their "business redressal form." Nothing. It's been months. I keep reporting the listings. Nothing. We're losing work. Other local contractors are losing work. And Google twiddles its thumbs. What good is it for Google to have a policy if they're not going to uphold it when their inaction is harming others?
- froggertoaster 3y agoDo you have links handy to other articles about this issue? I've never heard of it and I'm curious.
- TrendyCPU 3y agoThe most famous case is locksmiths.[0] Google recently went after another company using the "rank and rent" scheme.[1] The company which is causing us issues is also using the "rank and rent" scheme. They're running listings for everything from pool resurfacing to concrete driveways to tree services. The company recruits people via Craigslist with an offer to pay them $50-100 to setup a Google Business Profile and receive the post card with a code for verification. They also offer $20 for a 5-star review.[2] I am thinking about going to the FTC and the media at this point. I've also discovered that there's a small community but poorly connected that goes after this type of spam. 0. https://searchengineland.com/googles-locksmith-spam-problem-hits-the-new-york-times-85026 https://searchengineland.com/googles-locksmith-spam-problem-... 1. https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-lawsuit-rank-and-rent/489666/ https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-lawsuit-rank-and-... 2. https://archive.ph/SWNEU https://archive.ph/SWNEU
- marymkearney 3y agoThis complaint is one of the clearest, most concise pieces of legal drafting I've ever seen. It's only 7 pages! The small inline graphics in the pleading are innovative and effective. Great lawyering, kudos to the AG's office. This is likely a big reason behind the quick settlement.
- amelius 3y agoHmm, did they use an LLM to make it this concise?
- pierat 3y agoAnother nasty pattern is with Google Translate. You want text translations from 1 lang to next? Cool. It works. You want an image text-> translated text? You MUST install and have Google app installed. No real reason other than to re-enable more spyware and garbage.
- Kokouane 3y agoI always wondered whether there was a purpose for that. It probably is just spyware. Also the Google app is required for many other apps, like to use Google Podcasts.
- jwells89 3y agoHas this perhaps changed recently? Tried navigating to translate.google.com on both Android and iOS and the image translation features appear without issue.
- gniv 3y agoI think GP was talking about the Translate _app_ needing the Google _app_. Translation can be done without a network connection.
- hot_gril 3y agoThis truly sounds like a technical limitation and not some scheme to get more spyware onto the phone. Like in theory the Translate app could do it without the Google app, but that would've taken extra changes that they didn't consider worthwhile.
- degenerate 3y agoIf you want to disable Google location history (AND/OR) limit data collection to 3 months, you can do that here: https://myactivity.google.com/activitycontrols?settings=location https://myactivity.google.com/activitycontrols?settings=loca...
- lucb1e 3y ago[flagged]
- bradrn 3y ago> using capital i as roman numeral lookalike (instead of unicode) theirs At least that much is correct. Quoth the Unicode Standard: > For most purposes, it is preferable to compose the Roman numerals from sequences of the appropriate Latin letters. [from https://www.unicode.org/versions/Unicode6.0.0/ch15.pdf https://www.unicode.org/versions/Unicode6.0.0/ch15.pdf] Note that Unicode has a lot of characters like this — compatibility forms which are present to allow lossless conversion to/from other character sets, but shouldn’t be used in any new text.
- gundmc 3y agoHonestly I had no idea there were Unicode characters for Roman numerals separate from the letters they are composed of.
- whatamidoingyo 3y agoSame. You learn something new every day, eh?
- lucb1e 3y ago> separate from the letters they are composed of I didn't actually realise they're letters. To me it's distinct symbols just like 0 is a distinct ascii symbol from O. Now that you mention it, I realise that I knew that five is V and M is a thousand or something, but the symbol for one/1, is that actually defined as a capital i and not just a line of some form? Since surely the digit for one came before the latin script
- janc_ 3y agoLatin (and ancient Greek) didn't have dedicated symbols for numbers, but at sone point the Romans started using a shorthand system based on existing alphabetic symbols, which we now call "Roman numerals". It's quite possible the "I"s started out as just a line to mark one item before the shorthand was developed, but certainly over time it became identified to capital "I".
- aaronmdjones 3y agoNow if only they could get to fixing my account settings. https://support.google.com/accounts/thread/222903183/u https://support.google.com/accounts/thread/222903183/u > This question is locked and replying has been disabled. Oh, nevermind then.
- joeframbach 3y agoIt likely sensed your hostility in the phrase "what the hell" and auto-locked.
- dandare 3y agoReminds me of how google moved maps.google.com to google.com/maps so that they can ask for location permission in your browser for the whole google domain.
- whyenot 3y agoSo I guess they have gone a full 180° on that "Don't Be Evil" thing. For Google employees with a moral compass, that must be a little confusing/upsetting.
- autoexec 3y agoI'm not sure there are Google employees with a functioning moral compass. If there are, they must have learned to just ignore it. Can you work directly for an evil company, knowing that it's doing evil, and still consider yourself moral? Especially when you're got the skills to easily get highly lucrative employment elsewhere?
- gnu8 3y agoGoogle should move maps to a subdomain so they can request location permission for only that app!
- turtles3 3y agoUnironically this? It might violate gdpr to get consent for the purposes of maps but then use it in more contexts. I guess they might include all purposes when the user is asked, and at that point it boils down to whether the user is being asked consent for overly broad purposes or whether it is legitimate to bundle all the Google apps together. It's internet explorer all over again.
- rootsudo 3y agoWow, that is sneaky. I didn’t even notice, the dns record is a redirect. Wow.
- deleted 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- benburleson 3y agoI wish Google could have decided to stick with their “Don’t be evil.” ethos. Instead, I find myself continually extracting their products from my life.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aa_is_op 3y agoBecause it was a slap on the wrist. Pretty sure big tech companies have their own people in power positions in the states they operate from. Especially California. You don't build a trillion-dollar empire and leave it to chance.
- diogenes4 3y ago> Pretty sure big tech companies have their own people in power positions in the states they operate from. Not really necessary when service providers have such massive ability to dictate the contract you sign to use the service.
- dragonwriter 3y agoWhy does the HN headline link to the lawsuit complaint and not settlement information, since the headline is about the settlement? https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-announces-93-million-settlement-regarding-google%E2%80%99s https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bont...