11 ms·
Georgism
- dools 3y agoFun fact: Monopoly was originally called The Landlord’s Game and was created by a Georgist Feminist to illustrate the problem of rent: https://www.stmarys.sa.edu.au/women-in-stem-elizabeth-magie.html https://www.stmarys.sa.edu.au/women-in-stem-elizabeth-magie....
- klabb3 3y agoThat’s fun and perhaps strangely more relevant than ever. It seems like most capitalist players today strive for playing monopoly games instead of traditional market games (like providing a better price and/or higher quality products). Especially in tech, nobody wants to make merely a better product, but rather a “platform” or “marketplace”, where controlling access is the goal. Sure, sometimes we get a totally cool new product or VC subsidized pricing for a while but the end goal is more often that not that the company sells you permission to access some service that you’ve come to rely on. This is true both if you pay with money or you trade your personal information in exchange for your attention (ie ads). In some cases, there are legit reasons for middlemen to exist and provide some reputational or safety function. But it feels to me like we’re seeing an unnatural bend towards this model, even for things that serve no such purpose at all (like most iot crap, heated car seats, drm ink etc etc).
- Biologist123 3y agoFunny, Monopoly in my childhood invariably ended with a massive fight between siblings. It’s still a ‘sort-of’ family joke.
- distances 3y agoIn my opinion Monopoly is one of the worst possible options to choose for a game night, and has turned countless of people away from board games. It's a real shame that this abomination is so often the default choice when there are literally tens of thousands of better games around. * Current BGG rank 25002
- throw0101b 3y ago* https://boardgamegeek.com/browse/boardgame https://boardgamegeek.com/browse/boardgame * https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/1406/monopoly https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/1406/monopoly
- afiori 3y agoIt was indeed literally created as a model of a terrible dynamic. The intended result was to come out of the game thinking "this was terrible, we should never get close to anything like this again"
- kazinator 3y agoBig LOL here, Hackernews. Reading through this article, this thought popped into my head: hey, that Monopoly game is basically Georgist, isn't it! So I head over to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_(game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_(game) "[..] created by Lizzie Magie in the United States in 1903 as a way to demonstrate that an economy that rewards individuals is better than one where monopolies hold all the wealth[1] and to promote the economic theories of Henry George" :)
- jonasdegendt 3y agoExcept the way the game is played doesn't implement Georgism, or am I not getting it right? It goes buy once, seek rent forever. If Monopoly was Georgism you'd be paying taxes representing the potential value of your color/land e.g. every lap, regardless of if you put a bunch of hotels on there or not, or if someone landed on it or not.
- zer0tonin 3y agoThat's the point, the game is pointing out the flaws of the current system.
- jonasdegendt 3y agoI know, except the parent was saying Monopoly is like Georgism, which it isn't.
- tirpen 3y agoNo, they said it was Georgist. Not that the rules incorporated Georgism.
- jonasdegendt 3y agoWhat's the nuance between Georgist and Georgism that I'm missing here causing me to misinterpret what the GP is saying? English is not my native language but a Georgist would be a person subscribing to (or in the case of the GP, an object that implements), Georgism, or am I not seeing that right?
- trylfthsk 3y agoOne bit of historical fuzziness I'd hope someone could clear up: How do the Georgist Progressives tie into 1910's progressivism tie into modern progressivism? I recall a bunch of Midwestern georgist mayors were called progressives at the turn of the century, but I don't recall anything I've read on the progressive era explicitly noting any georgist influences.
- larsiusprime 3y agoYou should read this book: https://www.press.jhu.edu/books/title/12372/land-and-liberty https://www.press.jhu.edu/books/title/12372/land-and-liberty Basically, the Georgists weren’t actually part of the 1910’s progressive movement, they were more aligned with the broader liberal movement. Chris England makes the case that the Georgists were actually kind of rivals with the turn of the century progressives who were all about elite expertise and top down, often authoritarian central planning steeped in eugenics and malthusianism. The Georgists on the other hand were more for bottom up reform and what we would now call classical liberalism; they distrusted expert central planners and rejected malthusianism. Re midwestern mayors — Tom Johnson was a key Georgist reformer, known as “the best mayor of the best run city in America” (Cleveland). A former streetcar monopolist, he was won over by Henry George to work against his own former business interest and went on to fight the streetcar monopolies and fight for municipal ownership of public transit and utilities. As for the connection to modern movements — Certain strains of modern progressivism (though not all) have carried on the Malthusian and central planning ethos — especially “degrowth” advocates. Georgists old and modern oppose this mindset. The libertarian movement was founded by, among others, Alfred J Nock, who was a devoted Georgist. The modern libertarian movement can be opposed to or quite friendly to Georgism, depending on various things.
- AdamN 3y agoCould one look at the Mensheviks and the Bolsheviks through a similar lens as you do with the Georgists vs the 1910s Progressives? The Mensheviks being more bottom-up (and willing to go slower if needed) and the Bolsheviks being top-down (in order to move faster) but both with the end goal of moving forward with Socialism?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- keiferski 3y agoThe main Georgist policy recommendation is a tax assessed on land value, arguing that revenues from a land value tax (LVT) can be used to reduce or eliminate existing taxes (such as on income, trade, or purchases) that are unfair and inefficient. If I am understanding this correctly, wouldn’t it result in a world where landowners put the minimum amount of investment into the land, and then move to cheaper land as soon as possible/when their current land becomes more valuable? The assumption here seems to me that land in NYC/wherever is inherently valuable, which doesn’t seem true to me. Especially in a remote working world increasingly detached from physical spaces.
- chipsa 3y agoThe value of the land in NYC is related to all the other stuff next to the land you’re valuing. Other people’s improvements make your land more valuable, because you’ve got the subway line nearby. And the pizza shop on the corner. And the bar across the street.
- keiferski 3y agoBut why would any of this continue to exist if landowners have no interest in improving the value of the land? Lower Manhattan today is worth billions, but 50 years ago parts of it were empty enough to be used as lofts by squatting artists. Let’s say land value taxes are implemented in New York today. Suddenly companies have a real incentive to leave and move somewhere with cheaper land values - way more incentive than today, as in theory they will be taxed mostly on land value, not revenue. What’s to stop Manhattan from slowly becoming empty again as people leave, jobs leave, corner stores close, subway maintenance worsens due to less revenue, etc.?
- thfuran 3y agoPeople don’t currently choose to live in New York City because it’s cheap.
- BirdieNZ 3y agoLand value taxes have existed and do exist around the world (along with variations on the theme, such as leasehold land that is leased from the government for a long time). They don't result in the behaviour you describe. Most land value tax proposals are also revenue neutral (e.g. lower income tax in exchange for higher land value tax), so the balance sheet should end up looking the same for companies and individuals, but with higher land holding costs and lower land purchasing costs.
- gardnr 3y agoNew Zealand had varying degrees of LVT over the course of 100 years. The main takeaway from this thesis[1] is that it is difficult to get all parties on board and that the concessions required prevented the tax policy from being effective. At a national level it was abolished in 1990. Some local councils continue to collect local rates using a tax on unimproved land value but this can't be described as Georgism. 1. THE USE OF LAND VALUE TAXATION IN NEW ZEALAND (1891 – 1991) By Dylan Hobbs https://researcharchive.vuw.ac.nz/xmlui/bitstream/handle/10063/9006/thesis_access.pdf https://researcharchive.vuw.ac.nz/xmlui/bitstream/handle/100...