7 ms·
Uber was supposed to help traffic. It didn’t. Robotaxis will be even worse
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoOne word: deadheading. Any time you share a vehicle in time but not in space (only one rider per trip) you've increased congestion due to the trip out to fetch the person. Net loss every time.
- Nifty3929 3y agoWow, that’s a great point I hadn’t considered before. Thanks!
- MBCook 3y agoSadly the robotaxis are already doing it. They circle around SF because it’s ‘free’ since they don’t have to pay for parking. Taking up road space and causing traffic with no one inside because it’s cheaper to the companies even though it makes things worse for everyone else.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThey could be going to pick up their next fare, or driving towards where they predict their next fare to likely be. Same as a normal manned taxi actually.
- fragmede 3y agoIf we define deadheading as any segment on a route a transit vehicle is empty (which is at odds with the definition for deadheading from my flight attendant friends, and my friends who are fans of the greatful dead), and eliminate that, a lot of bus lines are going to become very short, especially late at night.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3np 3y agoBuses take more passengers and can still be a net-win by reducing taxi traffic (besides secondary reduction in congestions due to less accidents from intoxicated and tired drivers).
- vkou 3y agoDeadheading at night doesn't create traffic, and if you don't do it, the rest of the network becomes worthless.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoBuses typically make several runs along their route in both directions, until they need to go back to the barn for refueling, maintenance, or mileage. So any deadheading they need to arrive or return from that route tends to be a fractional part of the mileage they make on that route. Also, the route taken to and from the barn can be a lower-traffic route than that which the bus covers on its scheduled route. It's also a defined endpoint; if we see these robotaxis meandering around town with nowhere to go, except sometimes a random supercharger port, that is not deadheading, that's lollygagging.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoA lot of buses will run empty going the non-demand way during rush hour. Like the D-line in Seattle where I live, if you try to catch a bus into downtown around 5 PM, one or two out of service empty buses will pass you by first since I guess metro thinks they are better off getting back to downtown more quickly than servicing off peak demand along the way.
- nytesky 3y agoYeah nightmare scenario: everyone owns a robotic car, no one wants to pay for traffic. Car drives to work, then you send it home rather than pay for parking, and then summon car to pickup from work. So basically dual direction rush hour that stretches for twice as many hours.
- nytesky 3y agoWasn’t the point of taxi medallions to limit traffic in the first place?
- brutusborn 3y agoI think the point was artificial scarcity to increase local government revenues and to gain political support from taxi unions which are often very powerful. If the true purpose was to limit traffic, why would it be limited to taxis?
- mike_d 3y agoTaxi medallions were introduced to enforce a monopoly for the wealthy taxi company owners. Take Las Vegas as a prime example, you can't get a medallion unless you are part of a taxi company. Of course you can't start a taxi company unless you are "mentored" by an existing taxi company.
- bsder 3y agoNo, medallions were not meant to limit traffic. Medallions were the answer to the race to the bottom that occurred (too many taxis, not enough fares, shady behavior from the taxis)--just like we are seeing again. Everybody seems to forget that laws that exist are there because there was a reason. The fact that medallions became perverted into entrenched monopolies was a problem that should have been solved rather than just throwing them out.
- Ekaros 3y agoThe biggest failure with medallions from outside perspective was that they could be transferred. Licensing for taxis does make sense, but those should not be transferable outside selling the whole corporation. And they should be returned in bankruptcy or retirement to a pool to be redistributed.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoIf robo taxies could be limited to running to and from transit hubs, they could provide a huge benefit in providing last mile service. I would love to call a taxi to get from the light rail station home (which is a 17 minute car ride or a 40 minute bus ride + 10 minute walk), I wouldn't bother just getting an Uber directly home from the airport anymore (taking lightrail and transferring to bus doesn't make sense).
- shuckles 3y agoUber was supposed to make hailing a vehicle easier. It succeeded at that. Congestion is a matter for traffic engineers and congestion pricing.
- dv_dt 3y agoI guess if fossil fuel companies can do it with CO2 why not Uber and congestion, sure just sign all us up to pay for the externalities.
- MBCook 3y agoThey’re already doing that. They don’t want to pay for the parking on the robotaxis, or move them further away when not in use, so they just drive in circles taking up space and making traffic worse without even carrying anyone. Who said having 90+ square feet of pavement to haul an average of around one person was a waste? Now we have the tech to average less than one! (Edit: sq ft corrected, was off by 10x)
- acdha 3y ago> Who said having 10+ square feet of pavement to haul an average of around one person was a waste? Now we have the tech to average less than one! Sadly you left out a zero: even a Toyota Camry is a hundred square feet so you’re probably at 150 when you allow space on the sides and buffer zones.
- MBCook 3y agoWow really? Oh dang. I was using a Chevy Bolt. Its footprint is basically 13k sq in. But I messed up the math. It’s not ~9 sq ft (which I rounded up). I lost a zero. It’s 90 sq ft. I’ll fix my post. Thanks!
- jprete 3y ago> They’re already doing that. They don’t want to pay for the parking on the robotaxis, or move them further away when not in use, so they just drive in circles taking up space and making traffic worse without even carrying anyone. I really expected them to wait for a little more secure of a political position before they started doing exactly the thing that proves that they're entirely out for themselves and don't give a damn about improving traffic or city life.
- BurningFrog 3y agoThe solution for too much traffic is well known and independent of robotaxis. "Road Pricing" means that vehicles pay for driving on congested roads. The price is set so that road supply and demand match, and traffic flows optimally. It also gives the road owner an income for providing important roads.
- brutusborn 3y agoDo you know of any good implementations of this system?
- loandbehold 3y agoSingapore?
- quietthrow 3y agoMore like “Singapore!”
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoSingapore taxis have a 25% up rate charge during rush hour, but they are still very affordable.
- MBCook 3y agoDoesn’t London have a congestion tax that has helped?
- pj_mukh 3y agoInteresting, this reads like a Land Value tax but for roads. I like it,
- brutusborn 3y agoI think that is an excellent comparison. The most congested roads often coincide with the most valuable land in city centres, so charging users (public roads) or owners (private toll roads) based on local land value could be useful. It is also advantageous in that it would be progressive.
- MBCook 3y agoIt’s almost as if robotaxis are solving the problem in a way that they can make money off of, not trying to be an actual solution. Why would investors do that? Oh right. Robotaxis are just an attempt to do Uber without having to pay drivers. They’re not an attempt at fixing congestion. Or safety (though I’m sure they claim it). Or bad public transit. They’re aiming for the local maxima. “Fix” taxis/Uber as they exist today and make money doing it. Similar technology could make self driving busses to provide more/adaptive routes. Nah.
- mortureb 3y agoNah what you luddite. You seem more concerned about maintaining artificial jobs and stifling progress to “prevent people getting rich off of it”. Having a 100% automated driving system will fix traffic. It will be better for the environment. It will give us back more time in our day.
- jprete 3y agoNo, it actually won't. There is nothing that a driver would do that an automated taxi would not, because both the driver and the automated taxi are optimizing for their ability to give as many rides as possible for as much money as possible. The main reason to think their behavior would differ is on the margins where drivers have to go home and sleep and robotaxis do not. But that really makes it likely that a robotaxi service will keep its cars out 24/7 except for maintenance. The other reason to believe drivers and robotaxis will behave differently is if you think drivers are leaving money on the table, or robotaxis will. And Silicon Valley simply does not leave money on the table. I'd be more ready to believe the drivers do. There's another other factor here: when you make cars more available and more convenient, people are more likely to take them. So robotaxis will probably increase, not decrease, road usage, if only because they never need to sleep, eat, or go to the bathroom. They will just repeatedly get a fare, drive the fare, and go do whatever they do to be idle. Which, in many cities, is going to be "wander the streets" or "take up parking spots in the city center". EDIT: I had responded to this without reading the OP article. The article has some good discussion of the kinds of secondary effects that are likely to cause robotaxis to increase road consumption.
- vkou 3y agoHow could anyone, even for a second, believe that flooding the roads with a bunch of private cars that occupy road space when when they are not carrying a passenger was going to help traffic?
- acdha 3y agoA lot of elites hate transit and bike infrastructure: it’s not something they’d use personally, benefits people who are poorer and browner than they are, and they’re usually old enough to see cars as a sign of freedom and status. Those people really wanted to believe self driving cars and deregulated cabs would allow them to justify not investing in transit because that frees up money to spend on the transportation mode they use.
- alex_young 3y agoUber Pool was so cheap it increased overall city travel: For every mile of personal driving it removed, it added 2.6 miles of people who otherwise would have taken another mode of transportation. Seems logical. So, why not automate the bus system and automatically introduce routes where demand is? Such a system would ensure that people can quickly get where they are going, not add vehicles to the busy parts of the system, and achieve the benefits of shared transportation.
- MBCook 3y agoNot as profitable or easy to get investors.
- jprete 3y agoThe prerequisite technology for an automated bus system is not the ability to take the driver out of the bus. The prerequisite is the ability to credibly signal to all the potential passengers what buses are going where they want to go, where they should get on those buses, and where they are supposed to get off. All of the automation of bus routes involved is simple computation and I don't see AI having anything fundamentally new to add to the solution. You don't need to actually solve traveling salesman or something to add value to the bus system. I say "credibly" because you really want the system to work almost perfectly right out of the gate. Otherwise passengers will shun it because the very baseline requirement of a transport system is to reliably get people where they wanted to go.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThat would work pretty well. Just hail a bus with your phone, it tells you where to walk and what bus to get on, and where to get off on that bus, and how to finish your trip on foot or by connecting to another bus. It could all easily be integrated into Apple or google maps. No more fixed bus routes, just a bunch of AI buses driving around filling needs dynamically.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ars 3y agoPeople want to move around. This is a fundamental fact. And once they learn how much they can move, they are unwilling to move around less (or slower). This is something all the "get rid of cars" people ignore, and it's why it will never work.
- acdha 3y agoThat works if most other people don’t have cars. Once they do, you’re not moving, you’re part of a traffic jam and the freedom promised in the car commercials is really the freedom to spend that time realizing much of your life, money, and health you’re spending to enjoy that quality traffic time. Similarly, people do want to travel but not endlessly - they want to meet their friends, spend time with family, work, shop, etc. Americans conflate those with driving long distances because much of the country was architected around that lifestyle, but millennials flocked back to the cities because they realized the advantages of not needing to travel so much. Time sitting in traffic kind of sucks compared to just about anything else, and living somewhere you can do the things you want on foot, bike/scooter, etc. is worth a lot.
- MBCook 3y ago> And once they learn how much they can move, they are unwilling to move around less (or slower) I think you’d find a ton of people willing to trade their car for public transit if it was a viable option. I’ve never heard of someone who enjoyed having a $733 monthly car payment (the average). Especially not $1200 (a full 15% now!) There are plenty of people in big cities, even in the US, who are happy without cars.
- Bluestrike2 3y agoI mean, we have pretty overwhelming evidence that people will alter their travel behavior based on incentives and available capacity. We add more lanes to a highway, and get induced demand with people choosing to drive more. Road diets restricting road capacity lead to reduced demand, with people driving less. There's a ton of research on both phenomena. When the 405 was closed for a weekend due to construction, Los Angeles was told to expect carmageddon. Public transit saw record-breaking ridership levels that weekend, and traffic across LA actually decreased as a result. Drivers routinely change their driving route based on traffic congestion, and it's not uncommon to choose a slightly longer route to avoid being stuck in a traffic jam. Sitting in traffic feels more stressful, particularly on a highway where everything about the road design is telling your brain that you're supposed to be moving fast but aren't. If we wanted to, we could build robust public transit systems that are more than capable of moving most people to where they need to go with minimal delay, convenience, and comfort and that a large percentage of the population would want to use. Instead, most of North America has anemic bus systems that couldn't be more antagonistic towards their riders if they actively tried. A bus stop sign on the side of a four lane stroad that lacks sidewalks--the very thing that would enable people to safely access said bus stop--sends a pretty clear message to riders "we don't care about you, and if you die trying to board your bus, well, that's just how it is." In any case, you're conflating the desire to move around with the desire to move around by car. They're not the same thing, even if seventy years of urban planning have assumed otherwise. Beyond that, we travel between places because we want to do something when we get to our destination. That's the goal, and the mode by which we travel there is simply a means to an end.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lobster_roll 3y ago> Cars are more convenient and comfortable I worry that this perspective alone oversimplifies the issue and doesn't consider that when riding an SF bus today one has to worry about: - Aggressive passengers - Stench from smoking / urine / body odor / people bringing in garbage into the bus - Being on guard in case of theft (can't pull out laptop and catch up on work) - Falling off seat due to aggressive bus driving - Sketchy happenings by the bus stop These aren't mild annoyances as the authors' wording might (unintentionally) imply, but real health and safety risks. More so if one is female or are physically disadvantaged. I'd love to see this concern being talked about more as part of the conversation.
- Jensson 3y agoYou would need to change your entire society to fix that. I don't have those issues where I live because people for some reason don't do those things.
- MBCook 3y agoThere are solutions to those problems other than robotaxis. Perhaps we should solve those issues directly instead of finding a way to ignore them by paying investors money.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]