5 ms·
Note the absence of tax policy changes that favor manufacturing. Here are a few: * A tax on financial transactions. This is sometimes called a "Tobin tax". The
by Animats 3y ago
Note the absence of tax policy changes that favor manufacturing. Here are a few:
* A tax on financial transactions. This is sometimes called a "Tobin tax".
The US financial services sector has doubled in size as a fraction of the economy. It's currently around 12%. That's an overhead cost, and a big one. Could be half that.
* A tax on advertising. The tax deductiblity of advertising as a business expense should be limited. No more than a few percent of the cost of a good or service should be advertising. Domestic US advertising is almost zero sum, anyway, because Americans are spent out. All advertising does is move consumption around a bit.
* Standards for imports. If it plugs into AC power, it has to have UL certification.
No more fires from power supplies, including small electric vehicles.
Anything medical has to be sample tested after import. Criminalize willful violations.
Hold resellers (i.e. Amazon) criminally responsible.
- jwells89 3y agoBig agree on UL certification of electronics imports. So much dangerous stuff is coming in and getting sold in places like gas stations where customers probably won’t suspect safety issues.
- namibj 3y agoIs it currently legal to just sell your DIY power supply to US consumers? Or is there still like FCC certification required? Assuming, say, a USB-C charger.
- systems_glitch 3y ago"It depends" mostly on how DIY it is. PCB + parts kit is usually fine for most things that would have FCC or UL requirements, but selling something that's "assembled in USA" like tractors (wheels bolted on here, everything else done there) would probably still need certified.
- punkybr3wster 3y agoThe problem is design and tech companies and cloning resellers sling stuff direct to consumers via ungodly amounts of facebook ads. Because they’re direct shipments so many of those products are not safe or certified and many clones are labeled as certified but aren’t because they’re cheap knock offs made to look like the originals.
- systems_glitch 3y agoEven at the small end, it's hard to produce something that's even a bit popular and not have it cloned/ripped off/your chosen license violated. We have that issue with a number of our products, both open-source hobbyist stuff and non open source.
- twoodfin 3y agoA financial transaction tax is a terrible idea. I own a 100 shares of Apple. Tim Cook goes on CNBC and says he’s all in on printers. So I want to sell my Apple shares and buy Microsoft, where Satya Nadella is pushing Cloud and AI. I’m being a smart investor, moving a small bit of capital allocation intelligently. Taxing this decision discourages making it—even if only marginally—and makes capital markets dumber and less efficient.
- yurishimo 3y agoYou can have transaction taxes without penalizing small/micro investors. It’s criminal how the people who trade stocks for a living get away with paying less taxes as a percentage than their janitors.
- polygamous_bat 3y ago> Taxing this decision discourages making it—even if only marginally—and makes capital markets dumber and less efficient. Or it encourages making longer term investment decisions rather than trading like a jittery cocaine addict (which by no small amount of irony a nonnegligible number of traders are already.)
- twoodfin 3y agoWhat you’re suggesting is that markets are more efficient when they’re less liquid. That’s both intuitively and empirically wrong.
- mindslight 3y agoI don't see that taxing financial transactions would cause a phase change. Each financial transaction already has an associated cost of the people employed to create it, and yet complexity still grows. The real problem is that the financial industry has access to extreme amounts of cheap leverage, which forces everyone to play (aka the "everything bubble"). Witness all of the crying about interest rates having gone up a modest amount. Interest rates need to be held at least where they are long term, which is still lower than they were before they were dropped to distract from the needless and destructive conquering of Iraq. I would say that eliminating tax deduction for advertising expenses is the wrong way to go about things as well. Adverting is a bona fide business expense, so it makes sense as a deduction. Rather, a direct tax should be levied on advertising, to account for the externalities of us all having to suffer the cacophony. This could even be done state-by-state rather than federally (a la sales tax). Wholeheartedly agree on the certification. It blows my mind how cavalier people are about plugging Amazon's gensym branded products into mains power - especially given how shoddy even NRTL-tested products seem to be built!
- ramblenode 3y agoCapping tax deductions for advertising and progressively taxing it is a good one. Indeed, most advertising past a certain budget seems to be a zero-sum game and should be discouraged, not encouraged.
- seizethecheese 3y ago> Domestic US advertising is almost zero sum, anyway, because Americans are spent out. All advertising does is move consumption around a bit. This is only true when productivity between firms is constant. Advertising helps direct consumption toward more productive firms.
- ramraj07 3y agoNo one said ban advertising, just penalize excessive spending on them.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 3y ago>A tax on financial transactions. This is sometimes called a "Tobin tax". The US financial services sector has doubled in size as a fraction of the economy. It's currently around 12%. That's an overhead cost, and a big one. Could be half that. What reason is there to believe that this is an overhead cost? As I mentioned in another comment, over the past ~10 years or so, US median earnings have grown remarkably fast compared with other large countries: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=0xDEAFBEAD https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=0xDEAFBEAD Hard to argue with results. Taxing financial transactions intuitively seems like the sort of thing which would put a drag on economic growth. And manufacturers need to transact just like any other sort of business; I don't see how taxing transactions encourages manufacturers relative to other firms. I like the tax on advertising though. I would tweak it so the tax only kicks in once your spending on ads exceeds, say, $10 million per year. That way innovative new products can advertise to customers tax-free. This method also encourages big monopolies to spin-off individual product lines, which could reduce monopoly power.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> tax on financial transactions This is a tax on the middle class. Plenty of countries have stamp taxes on trades, for example. The wealthy structure to avoid a books-and-records trade. The average person can’t do that and so pays. If you’re upset about the size of finance, just tax that directly.