7 ms·
The “Do Something About It” Club
- romesmoke 3y agoHow about doing stuff outside consuming Internet content? Then you are forced to interact with the real world, where taking action is the default. Take it from somebody very recently recovered from the digital loop: I have lost tons of time ruminating while life flowed out the window, screen, etc. By the way, is spawning new tabs while waiting for a website to load in order to keep oneself occupied really a thing?
- goddessoflists 3y ago> How about doing stuff outside consuming Internet content? Then you are forced to interact with the real world, where taking action is the default. That is the goal. Consuming stuff on the internet is just one of the things I do throughout the day and even there I've minimised it as much as possible: I've deleted almost every social media, I use LinkedIn with a timer (browser blocks in automatically). I'm subscribed to a limited number of newsletters and even then I don't immediately read them--hence all the bookmarks. > Take it from somebody very recently recovered from the digital loop: I have lost tons of time ruminating while life flowed out the window, screen, etc. This is why I recently started using my laptop and phone with a timer: I give myself a total of 4 hours to use both screens (although I don't count listening to music while doing chores as screentime--we're all big music lovers in our family). Of course, I can do this because I'm a freelancer and not the breadwinner of the house. All people I respect have told me that when I have this advantage, I should use it. Funnily, having a timer has helped me get more work done than I did when I took laptop use for granted: I'm almost done with the second issue of my magazine in less than 4 days when the first one took 2 whole weeks. > By the way, is spawning new tabs while waiting for a website to load in order to keep oneself occupied really a thing? I used to do this a lot until I recently started applying the principles of slow living and doing one thing at a time.
- boredemployee 3y ago>> I have lost tons of time ruminating while life flowed out the window, screen, etc. Agree. And also I think the same about the working hours that companies makes us to commit.
- aktenlage 3y ago> the real world, where taking action is the default. That seems overly simple, I don't think it is a solution per se. I can think of a million real world things, where taking action is not the default. > By the way, is spawning new tabs while waiting for a website to load in order to keep oneself occupied really a thing? Yes, sometimes. Particularly HN is a good intermediate, because it loads so fast.
- c22 3y agoIf a website is taking so long to load that I get bored I just close it.
- brokenmachine 3y agoI check if it's on the internet archive...
- LoganDark 3y ago> By the way, is spawning new tabs while waiting for a website to load in order to keep oneself occupied really a thing? You have no idea. Absolutely no idea. I'll usually open 3 or 4 tabs before a single one finishes loading. You, have, no, idea. ADHD is insane.
- TheHappyOddish 3y agoAgreed. Something I like about Orion (and other browsers will do it with a plugin). Aside from vertical tabs showing the full title (very useful), you can close the whole tab tree once done with the subject. I've gone from 600+ tabs open on average to 80-100.
- LoganDark 3y agoSurprisingly, I don't have issues with having way too many tabs open. Right now I have 6 normal tabs open, 4 always-open tabs for email, spreadsheet, calendar and Discord, and one extra Discord tab open in another profile because DID. So 11 in total. It's because I close old tabs all the time, but I constantly need to open more because otherwise I get extremely extremely bored.
- _lvbh 3y ago> By the way, is spawning new tabs while waiting for a website to load in order to keep oneself occupied really a thing? Definitely. I open up 8-20 tabs at once and go to the one that finishes loading first
- samsquire 3y agoWhat do you want to see or to exist? I journal every day and I try build experimental software projects what I think is valuable or interesting. Person's idea of what is valuable or interesting or observations or conclusions is different. I recognise that it takes a lot of work to create something. You can't just know 1 thing or be good at 10 tasks to produce something to high quality, you have to do 1000 tasks you've never done before. For example, I love goodness, positivity, light and think on these things and reject what is not these things. So I try do things that are valuable to me and share them with others. Note: I want a zero effort platform similar to Repl.it that lets me be webscale with minimal devops. I am interested in ScrapScript and Val Town.
- goddessoflists 3y ago> I journal every day and I try build experimental software projects what I think is valuable or interesting. > For example, I love goodness, positivity, light and think on these things and reject what is not these things. > So I try do things that are valuable to me and share them with others. I really like your perspective! We're very similar in that regard. > I recognise that it takes a lot of work to create something. You can't just know 1 thing or be good at 10 tasks to produce something to high quality, you have to do 1000 tasks you've never done before. I recently discovered the idea of a minimum viable product and the whole "fail fast, fail better concept." It was a comment on HN that gave me the idea for The Metronome and I ended up launching the magazine in less than a month. I've never done something like it, but I wanted this thing to really exist, so I did what I new and put it out--and the response to it has been overwhelmingly positive. The second issue will go out tomorrow; I learned from my difficulties while making the first one and ended up needing less time to create the second one. Perfectionism is a terrible problem, so doing things and getting better as you go is better than trying to be better before you actually do the thing, I believe.
- Semaphor 3y ago> I journal every day and I try build experimental software projects what I think is valuable or interesting. I have 4 or so abandoned habit-tracker projects, and 7 "follow book" (essentially "following" a book series or author for release announcements/notifications) projects, all in different early states before I lost interest. I wish I could follow through with projects I’m not getting paid for ;)
- aktenlage 3y agoThe author has a good point here. But how actionable is most information out there? It probably also varies on what information individuals are able to (and want to) take action. I feel like some social media thing should probably already exist, where people find each other to take action together. Anyone knows of such a forum, group, subreddit, channel, mastodon instance, or whatever?
- goddessoflists 3y ago> But how actionable is most information out there? I think it depends on our individual information diets. I've gradually curated my internet diet to avoid receiving and reading stuff I can't do anything about, so the stuff that does land in my inbox is often actionable. Might not be true for everyone. > feel like some social media thing should probably already exist, where people find each other to take action together. What I'm noticing is that the people who do take action are all connected locally and/or offline so I'm trying to focus my energy there. Meet people, take action outside the screen, offline.
- calderwoodra 3y agoI can't quite tell if you're being sarcastic but that's exactly what hackernews is to me!
- sailorganymede 3y agoMy hunch is that this club won’t work because it fundamentally is just another distraction from the goal here: which is to actually do something. Just do it. (Digression) “One of the realizations has been that I read too much, take too many notes, yet don’t really do anything with this new information.“ I feel the underlying reason for this is due to years of the education system drilling into our heads the value of notes and memorisations for the purpose of exam taking. But once you are out of the system, this technique becomes useless as it excels at one type of thing. However, it’s also ironically the technique that brings success as cause you did well in your exams / interviews, you can do the job . I think once you “do things” though it’s a whole different ball game.
- goddessoflists 3y ago> My hunch is that this club won’t work because it fundamentally is just another distraction from the goal here: which is to actually do something. Just do it. Hi, as I wrote in the comment above: I was in a hurry when I posted this so didn't notice that the obvious point was missing--that we meet to find solutions and implement them. I've added the edit. And, yes, the solution is to actually do it--which I realised only because I had an idea for launching a magazine and then actually did it in less than a month. It was the first time I'd ended up acting on an idea so soon after having it, which is what inspired the line of thinking that ultimately led to the idea of the club. > I feel the underlying reason for this is due to years of the education system drilling into our heads the value of notes and memorisations for the purpose of exam taking. I was educated in India, so I don't blame the education system (for this particular habit). I'd been the topper in school and was fond of note-taking. I still keep a commonplace book because it's my primary hobby. I love collecting beautiful passages from books and the internet and notes help me simplify concepts for others--I've been tutoring kids for years and I like being able to take information and simplify it for others. But the habit has gone out of hand when it comes to online note-taking, as I discussed in a different post: it's very-easy to copy-paste stuff, add a million tags, and feel good about it. I've since switched to taking notes by hand ONLY--and because that takes effort, I only take notes on the things I really want to remember. And they're succinct because then I copy just the gist, which is what's truly needed 90% of the time. > I think once you “do things” though it’s a whole different ball game. I started doing this sometime near the end of August and I couldn't agree more--a lot of good things have happened since. Oliver Burkeman's writing helped me get there: https://www.oliverburkeman.com/justdo https://www.oliverburkeman.com/justdo
- kookamamie 3y agoIronically, there's also the danger of getting a mental reward for describing something you'll going to do. I.e. the mind crosses off the actual doing part as "solved", as it's only the "mundane part of execution" that is left to do. Might as well leave that as an exercise for the hearer/reader...
- goddessoflists 3y agoI fell in this trap often, so to avoid it when I decided to launch a magazine, I also took an action at the same time, one that would make it difficult to back out: I sent emails to experts asking for an interview, telling them it was for a magazine I was launching. It worked for me, but not every project might have such an action to go with it.
- _puk 3y ago"I don’t want the mere discussion of ideas to give me satisfaction". I'm struggling to find a reference, but I very much subscribe to the concept I read somewhere that discussing an idea releases a similar dopamine hit to actual execution. There's room for validation of an idea etc., but (over)imagining what completion looks / feels like prior to execution can rob that drive to execute.
- goddessoflists 3y ago> There's room for validation of an idea etc., but (over)imagining what completion looks / feels like prior to execution can rob that drive to execute. I think pairing sharing an idea with an action can help because you've already gotten the ball rolling. It's what I did with my magazine: wrote on my blog and also sent emails to the experts I wanted to interview.
- soared 3y agoSimilarly can’t find it, but it’s something with when you set a goal if you tell people you have that goal you are less likely to achieve it, rather than if you didn’t tell others about it.
- goddessoflists 3y agoI've tried both telling and not telling, and it hasn't made a difference. I've told people and not achieved the goal, told and achieved it, didn't tell and achieved it, and didn't tell and didn't achieve.
- helij 3y agoI saw this written and told by various people but never saw it confirmed in real life.
- arrowsmith 3y agoMaybe you're both thinking of this TED talk by Derek Sivers? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NHopJHSlVo4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NHopJHSlVo4
- soared 3y agoI really enjoyed the time and writing style of this! I had a bit of a laugh when the author described how they read and think too much and wanted to take action - then the solution is a club who who .. meet to talk about taking action :) I propose a different club rule: You can write/post/meet up/etc but for every one thing you do talking/thinking, you have to have already taken that action in real life! IE read a book about going to the gym? Don’t meet to talk about it, but go to the gym and talk about it after!
- goddessoflists 3y ago> I really enjoyed the time and writing style of this! Hi, author here. I'm glad you liked it--I don't get to hear this often. :) > I had a bit of a laugh when the author described how they read and think too much and wanted to take action - then the solution is a club who who .. meet to talk about taking action :) I wrote this post in a hurry because I'd have broken my streak otherwise and so didn't really spend much time on it. I just made a quick note and posted it online because I've recently started treating the blog like an open notebook rather than thinking that everything that goes on it has to be something I've thought about for ages and then executed perfectly; that helps with ignoring my perfectionism. I didn't think it would make it to HN. (I was hoping that would happen to a different post.) All of this to say that: when I had the idea, I imagined us doing things and reporting on them, but I forgot to mention it in the post. I've added the update after seeing your comment, so thanks for pointing it out!
- hodgesrm 3y agoBy the way your idea sounds a lot like how the Royal Society started. [0] You are following in the footsteps of giants. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Society https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Society
- goddessoflists 3y agoOne can dream :)
- 3y ago
- vitiral 3y agoFor me I've come to realize two truths: 1) there is no value in putting energy into that which you have no control, and MOST things you can read about on the Internet fall into this category 2) almost all good or beautiful things are either personal and happen either in their natural course (relationship, family, the sunset) or they require a lifetime of distillation or creation of that _something_ that is missing from the world. For me personally I've chosen to focus on my family and job, and spend the rest of my time in pursuit of a large life-long goal (civboot.org). It's gone quite well so far, but I'm only 3 years in
- goddessoflists 3y agoAuthor here. These are also things I believe in, although it took several years of climate anxiety and therapy to understand that one person alone can't fix everything. So I've started focusing on doing some good every day--most days, it's the small things, like doing extra chores, babysitting the neighbor's kid, tutoring a little girl who lost her father recently, etc. These won't change the world, but at least I'm adding some good to it. > MOST things you can read about on the Internet fall into this category This is why I deleted almost every social media and am very selective about the content I consume, so the stuff that does land in my inbox is stuff that has scope for taking action--I unsubscribed from everything that talked about things I couldn't do anything about personally.
- vitiral 3y agoHey thanks for the article. 100% agree on social media and doing the small stuff. HN is about the only one I use and i try to take month long breaks regularly
- roughly 3y agoI think this is basically true. We’ve got a tendency towards hero culture as a society, in which we expect one person to solve the problem. That fails on almost any problem of reasonable size and impact - you yourself cannot solve, say, climate change - and it leads us to feel like we’re not doing anything if we’re not doing everything. I’ve come to think of it more like I’m on this boat with everyone else - I can’t do anything on my own, but taking my turn at the oars contributes to the journey. You can’t do everything, so at least be a net positive - be the kind of person where if everyone acted like you, it’d make the world you want to live in.
- m3kw9 3y agoLovely article pointing out the waste generated from reading too much but doing little with it
- m3kw9 3y agoI’d start a discord or something, is t that better
- goddessoflists 3y agoI considered that too, but I'd like the group to exist offline as much as possible; talking about ideas isn't the same as acting on them. I really didn't think very deeply about the whole thing before writing it; I was trying not to break my blogging streak. After looking at the comments though, I have a clearer idea. Might write about it today :)
- m3kw9 3y agoMaybe corollary to this is that if you can’t do any immediate action with it, skip the read. The issue to solve is to know when not to read everything for entertainment, which your brain can consider it “useful”.
- goddessoflists 3y ago> Maybe corollary to this is that if you can’t do any immediate action with it, skip the read. This is what I do. I've been curating my internet diet a lot over the last four years or so. I guess it's a downside of the curation that what does land in my inbox is stuff that I can do something about.
- swayvil 3y agoConsider An esoteric subject. Hard experiments. Lots written though. So you get a group of "enthusiasts" who like to read. Write about what they read. And argue over the meaning of the cryptic writings. But never actually examine the subject matter firsthand. And then, through a combination of literary cherrypicking, convoluted logic, and debate, they come to the conclusion that real experimentation is impossible. And anybody who says otherwise is either lying or a fool. You see it a lot in religious groups. An airtight circle of scripture consumption, excretion and reconsumption.
- mistermann 3y agoIt's also very common among secularists and their "consensus facts" (derived from a presumptive ideological framework), a form of scripture itself. A big problem with humans is that they find it very easy to see faults in the members of their outgroups but not in the members of their ingroups, and teaching about this phenomenon seems to have little effect.
- swayvil 3y agoI know, the secularists do it too. It's a human thing. But I never met anybody who said you can't do your own chemistry experiments at home. I suppose the point is moot though, if you have the opportunity to see for yourself, but don't. And as for what's actually going on there. I think there's a human inclination to live inside a bubble of dreams. Dreams supplied by solid authority/consensus/tradition but dreams all the same. And challenging the skin of that bubble is something that most of us are allergic to. And seeing for yourself, and challenging the skin of the bubble, is something that only special people are allowed to do. And special basically means not you or me.
- ysavir 3y agoThe author seems to have things backwards. They want to read/learn something first, then figure out, with a group of people, what they can do to apply that newfound knowledge. They might appreciate their efforts more if they instead decided to take action on a thing, and then found material to learn that can help them take that course of action.
- goddessoflists 3y agoHi, author here. I think it can go both ways. You learn there's a problem, then try to solve it, then go back to learn more to come up with a better solution. Or you can do something, find out it's not working, then learn more about it to fill the holes in your knowledge. > They might appreciate their efforts more if they instead decided to take action on a thing We also need to know that there's a problem before we can do something about it. You can't fix a problem you don't know exists.
- jmanjmanjman 3y agoFor me, I identified as a person who loved learning. And then, I started viewing my need to learn random stuff as . . . A way to distract myself. Now when I feel the tug to set a learning goal, I step back and feel what’s behind it. Is this goal really the best use of my time? Or is there a big fear I’m avoiding or pull toward validation that I’m seeking in this moment? I’ve learned so much from not reading :)
- goddessoflists 3y ago> I’ve learned so much from not reading :) Same here! Since realising that, I've not been so worried about reading everything I've saved, or even thinking that I have to read everything I come across just because "you learn something new every day." I graduated a year ago and have done lots of work and reading since. How different would my life have been if I'd applied even 10% of what I learn? I still love learning stuff, but now--unless it's required for work--don't go looking for things to learn. I am doing much more as a result and I'm happier than I was when I simply spent my days learning.
- russelldjimmy 3y agoThis seems relevant to me. I also identify as a person who “loves learning new things”. Playing an instrument was a hobby I used to pursue with passion. Now it seems like it’s running its course and I’m not feeling as passionate about it as I used to. This has been happening for a while but a part of me didn’t want to admit this, and I’d force myself to pursue it even when I didn’t feel like it. Of course, I didn’t make the same progress at getting better as I did in the first few passionate years. I am now in a phase where I am letting things take whatever course they have to. No longer am I trying to achieve an objective of getting “better” and being ok with knowing that if I don’t feel like it, I needn’t pressure myself to pursue it. I realised that I was trying to prove myself to other people. That if I get better at the instrument, people will be wowed and will like me more and that will give me validation. So I realised that at least a part of the motivation was public approval. Meditation and therapy have helped me realise that my craving for validation cannot be fixed by more validation. And this has made it easy for me to let go. Who knows what comes next? I can only accept myself and go with the flow :)
- Lyngbakr 3y agoThe premise of the article really resonated with me because I've noticed myself doing the same. My shelves are full of books on various programming languages that I read enthusiastically. But how many have I actually built anything nontrivial with? Very few. I find my motivation ebbing away when it comes to sitting down and writing code. I think the hardest part is just getting started, so I'm scheduling time each day to write something. It doesn't have to be fantastic, just something to get me moving forward.
- goddessoflists 3y ago> I think the hardest part is just getting started, so I'm scheduling time each day to write something. It doesn't have to be fantastic, just something to get me moving forward. You'll like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIDAWrUyjM4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIDAWrUyjM4
- hutzlibu 3y agoIt is quite simple. Do you want to build something? Then go build it. You notice you lack information while building? Go read it. Not the other way around. Unless you want to read for the sake of reading/learning, which is also fine. It improves your general knowledge. But if you want to get something done, then of course, there is no other way except doing it. But of course, if it is something bigger, than thinking before doing it make sense. Take a pen and paper and make sketches and todo lists - and then implement them.
- goddessoflists 3y ago>It is quite simple. Do you want to build something? Then go build it. >You notice you lack information while building? Go read it. >Not the other way around. >Unless you want to read for the sake of reading/learning, which is also fine. It improves your general knowledge. But if you want to get something done, then of course, there is no other way except doing it. I have nothing to add except that this is a beautiful comment that sums up my post way better than I could have myself. :)
- bsnnkv 3y ago> I’m tired of this. I think we overvalue thinking and undervalue taking action on that thinking. It’s easy to discuss ideas, which is one reason I think I’ve done so much of it and used to find it appealing. > Lately, though, simply reading or thinking about ideas feels inadequate, even a waste of time. It feels wrong to me, because it goes against some of the things I value deep down–things which don’t have a specific word for them (that I’m aware of, with my non-native knowledge of English). > It’s the value that seeks to do things, see the results of doing those things. Ideas made tangible. This resonated with me a lot. I've written before about how I ditched over-the-top all-in-one bookmarking, highlighting, annotating and read-it-later platforms for a single fuzzily-searchable database of highlights I take from anywhere (comments, articles, books, blogs etc.) and how much this has improved my life flow in general. I don't think it's a coincidence that since that mindset shift, I've gone on to create a modest-but-profitable SaaS, a category-defining piece of open source software with a vibrant and active community, and that after a lifetime of watching from the sidelines, I have finally learned to dance to the level that I'm regularly referred to as a "good dancer" (still working on being able to accept this compliment, though)
- goddessoflists 3y agoThis! I used to spend ages on organising notes and documents because I believed that would help me work better. I recently gave that up and now focus only on taking action, and I've gotten a lot more work done as a result. Connecting meticulous organisation and having a "second brain" to productivity, I realised not long ago, has made us all focus on the wrong things. I understand that for some people, having things organized actually helps them function better but I wasn't one of them. I only thought I needed to be super-organized but I'm a perfectionist--what I needed was to just do things.
- jackthetab 3y ago> I've written before about how I... Got a link for that? I'm trying to do something similar and I'm still doing far too much "bookmarking, highlighting, annotating and read-it-later"-ing
- 3y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI find I learn best, by doing. I also like to always be working on stuff that ships. That said, my expertise misses some of the stuff that can only be discovered in a purely academic workflow, and not all “do somethings” are good[0]. [0] https://littlegreenviper.com/miscellany/problems-and-solutions/ https://littlegreenviper.com/miscellany/problems-and-solutio...
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoInteresting article about something they might do, or we might do, or maybe would improve our lives. Zero chance of me joining the club. Too lazy, too content, too old. I wonder if the author is doing more than writing about it. Or is that 'doing something'? I suppose so.
- goddessoflists 3y ago> I wonder if the author is doing more than writing about it. I was frustrated with how little, proper and useful information there is out there about studying psychology and making a career in the field that goes beyond "study this, then this, then do this internship or that course, and get that credential" etc. So I started interviewing psychological professionals and launched a magazine. The second issue goes out tomorrow. It's the first time I've had an idea and acted on it so fast, which is what inspired the idea for the club--I was riding the high of actually having done something that other people found useful.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoExcellent! I will try to emulate your good example.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoA fence appeared which blocked my path to the grocery store. So I started taking my screwdriver to the grocery store so I could dismantle the fence enough to slip though. Six months later, there was a gate there. I only had to dismantle it maybe four or five times. Direct action works.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoG.K. Chesterton smiles
- umutisik 3y agoIt doesn’t need to be a club. You can do something about it as an individual, including recruiting others when needed.
- goddessoflists 3y agoDefinitely. The thing is, I'm already doing things whenever possible as an individual, but I've spent so long alone that I'm really craving the company that a community provides. I want to start and be part of offline spaces, hence the club.
- kunalgupta 3y agoGrass is greener. I don’t read very much because I prefer learning through trial and error when doing because I’m certain most ideas on the internet are wrong anyway (especially regarding programming). This is a limitation, and a middle ground approach is probably actually optimal. Which maybe I do because I still read extremely highly recommended things referred by people I know
- gosenx 3y agoI think that what really makes us not take action after we read something is this notion of "I will get back to it later" that we get after highlighting or writing notes about it. You have to be deliberate. If you think something is worth exploring and applying, put it in you calendar or todo list to dive deeper into it in day you have time. Only write notes for things that a nice to have, for the crucial ones take action and write about your experience with it. Here is how I go about it: I have a file named on-my-mind.md where I write a short sentence over something I was thinking or thought was interesting. I keep it short. I also have a current.md with something I'm focusing on now — I it read everyday. If I'm reading a book, I make sure to do the exercises before marking as complete and re-read each chapter after before going to the next. If what I'm learning can improve my work or life, I put it on-my-mind.md. I consult on-my-mind.md a lot during the day, it's like a state machine for me. If I thought something was interesting, but don't have the time budget to commit, I will put it on calendar for some day in the future so I can dive deep then. I basically send letters to my future self, and I have this contract of always acting on what I put on the calendar and/or todo list, so it has to be important before it goes there.
- goddessoflists 3y agoI used to collect ideas to act on later too. I still have several documents full of them, not to mention notebooks. Recently, I'm trying to stop looking for more and do something about an idea instead of thinking, "not now." I'm using the rule of "do it now or delete it." It's quite a harsh rule, but life is short and I can't do everything, so I'm focusing on the things that will bring me the most joy and satisfaction of having done something good for others.