6 ms·
The Eddie Murphy rule and information embargoes
- cempaka 3y agoA fun read along these same lines, about the origins of the Zimmerman Rule (which says that profits from improperly funded trades accrue to the broker): https://chicagoreader.com/news-politics/busted-6/ https://chicagoreader.com/news-politics/busted-6/
- ksherlock 3y agovia the August 30th Money Stuff, that sort of thing still happens: "The SEC's complaint alleges that, between July 1 and 6, 2022, Anthony opened a new brokerage account using a fraudulent application on which he overstated his personal income and then made $1 million in bogus deposits from his bank account, which held only nine cents at the time. The complaint also states that, before Anthony's deposits reversed for insufficient funds in his bank account, he used "immediate access" credit extended to him by his broker-dealer to purchase $199,956.65 in securities. According to the complaint, Anthony's broker-dealer discovered the scheme before Anthony could make any profits, froze his account, and liquidated his holdings." https://newsletterhunt.com/emails/37239 https://newsletterhunt.com/emails/37239 https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/lr-25816 https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/lr-25816 https://www.sec.gov/files/litigation/complaints/2023/comp25816.pdf https://www.sec.gov/files/litigation/complaints/2023/comp258...
- jakeinspace 3y agoSeems reasonable. Then again, what happens if someone robs my house, takes the cash he finds to the casino, and wins a million dollars before getting caught? Knowing how much political power casinos have, I wouldn't be surprised if the action itself violated their rules and meant they could repossess the winnings.
- underlipton 3y agoIIRC, the liquidation actually did yield $2k more than he'd paid for the securities. He just didn't profit.
- justin66 3y agoDan Aykroyd does not get the respect he deserves and the title of this article is just one example.
- steveklabnik 3y agoThe title comes from the name of the rule. The rule is named after Eddie because his character is the one that came up with the idea. I agree Dan is fantastic but I think the rule is correctly named.
- jedberg 3y agoActually it was Jamie Lee Curtis who comes up with the idea, and Dan who explains the logistics of how it will work.
- steveklabnik 3y agoI do think this is debatable, but we find Dan, readying a shotgun, saying "well do you have any better ideas?" and Eddie says "the best way you hurt rich people is by turning them into poor people." It is true that Jamie Lee then sees the news about the report, and they all kind of have a collective realization about it. I think it can be argued that they all played a role, but if you have to pick someone, I'd argue that Eddie's line is the beginning of the idea. Actually, reflecting on it further, I think that if this were real life, I would personally give them all credit, but it being a movie, I give Eddie's character the most, if not all, the credit.
- jedberg 3y agoI honestly think OP is right, it's just called that because Eddie was the most famous person in the movie at the time as his career was on fire, and he's most closely associated with it. The movie doesn't really show whose idea it was. But now you got me thinking about another question -- who actually delivered the crop report to the USDA? Beeks was locked in the cage, so someone had to actually deliver the real report. Who did that?
- Terr_ 3y agoIt seems like these attempts to enforce fairness/impartiality often hinge on making the information-release as simultaneous as possible... But I can't help but feel dissatisfied with that, it feels like a cheap-and-dirty fix. It just shifts things from "free money to whoever has the best spy-network or paid preferential access" to "free money to whoever builds a system to place orders milliseconds faster than others."
- pixl97 3y agoIt turns out that the speed of light its the limit to causality and your 'closeness' to the source is always going to matter. Lets imagine it on a planetary scale, you have planets in this particular layout currently. A - B - C If planet A releases news, planet B will get the news and be able to reply to it before planet C and there no way to do anything about it unless you come up with superluminal travel. Now, some number of months, years later as the planets orbit you can get A - C -B in which planet B would be left out.
- matthewaveryusa 3y agoYou could try to make it fair by having planet A encrypt a payload to B and a payload to C such that the transmission time and decryption time from A - B is the same as A - C. You could need encryption that feeds the previous block to the next (so CBC), and some trusted computing solution such that additional compute cannot be added to accelerate the decryption.
- pixl97 3y agoThis depends if you're doing full cycle trips of two way 'trading' to planet A. You not only have the time for full information to get to planet C, you have to withhold information from B until planet C's reply is already in flight back to planet A.
- Terr_ 3y agoI think this is more about which activities (ex: industrial espionage) ought to be economically rewarded and which should not. It's true that "Being Much Closer On A Closer Planet" might someday be part of that debate, but I think we've got plenty of closer non-spacetime issues to tackle first.
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoThe SEC and other regulators try to make markets fair and avoid corruption because otherwise people would sensibly stay away, and then the money would dry up. That's how I understand it. And it feels like a leaky dam with fingers stuck all over it. What are the major, huge, "no-one will go for that" changes that might simply replace the dam? If we apply a Tobin Tax? If we time box trades to every five minutes? If we end trading on margin? Place derivatives under insurance law ? Or is it that experienced players have a huge incentive to fleece inexperienced players and that's just the way of the world, and the casino needs to have really good pit bosses, or there is no casino?
- batmansmom1 3y agoTime box for trades is a very interesting idea that I've never heard of before. Would probably equalize the playing field by a lot, reducing the advantage firms have simply by being close to the market. Have there been serious discussions about this in the past? I wonder what the downsides would be, besides that it would hurt the bottom line of market makers
- steveklabnik 3y agoNo matter what time box you choose, someone is not going to be able to react to information for longer than the time box. It introduces complexity for dubious benefit, IMHO. And yes, this has been talked about endlessly. Heck, some people have proposed even further restrictions; for example, in practice, the first and last hours that the exchange are open tend to have the highest volume, so why not only keep the exchange open for those two hours?
- Dylan16807 3y ago> No matter what time box you choose, someone is not going to be able to react to information for longer than the time box. It introduces complexity for dubious benefit, IMHO. If releases like this were scheduled for 30 seconds into a 5 minute box, basically any trader that cares would be able to react inside the box. We could say 99.9% for the sake of argument. I can't exactly state whether it's a good idea overall, but the idea that it might not catch literally everyone doesn't really matter. It's an extreme example of letting the perfect be the enemy of the good, when it comes to this single aspect.
- ipaddr 3y agoWhat if you disclosed private information on twitter before trading. Would that still break the law? "Just heard jelly bean futures are going down. Going to sell now"
- gmane 3y agoYes, it would break the law because the law is written based on how you got the information, not based on if the information is disseminated. The law is that you can't use misappropriated government information.
- jabroni_salad 3y agoYes, since you are using insider information. And before spitballing further, consider the 'good faith' rule. Are you acting on the insider information in good faith? If not, do not do that thing.
- cmcaleer 3y agoLet's make it a bit more interesting and say the Twitter account is a paid subscription for $1MM/mo. I was following his Twitter account and knew that he seemed to have a good instinct for when things were going down, but it can't be proven that I knew that the account was disclosing non-public government information. Should I be expected to know that was information improperly obtained, particularly because of the massive premium cost of the subscription implies that it's possible that something improper is going on?
- bluGill 3y agoMaybe. If a "reasonable person" would figure it was insider information then you are in trouble.
- bluGill 3y agoHow long before. There are often rules that you have to disclose such data a specific amount of time before you trade - often a week or two. There is an exception for trades you scheduled far enough in advance that they couldn't have been insiders (ie if you want to pay your kids' Harvard tuition you can schedule the trade months in advance - you won't have insider information anyway) If everybody expects you to disclose that information in twitter than you are okay. However if the information is supposed to be disclosed on a SEC form (8k, and 10q are the most likely) than putting it on twitter first could get you in trouble even if you don't trade at all since someone who watches the SEC filings will not see your twitter notice)
- batmansmom1 3y agoSeems like there isn't really an issue being raised in this article. There clearly needs to be close scrutiny on the journalists being given the information in advance, but given the fact that its provided in a "lockup room" it seems like that's the case. If everyone can access the information at the same time, even if its via these journalists, I don't really see an issue.
- steveklabnik 3y agoI don’t think the article intends to raise an issue. It simply explains various ways that the rule is dealt with. That the lockup room exists is exactly for that purpose.
- Mizoguchi 3y agoReminds me of Ep 123 of Darknet Diaries.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThere’s one thing that’s a guarantee in life: As long as it keeps the rich getting richer it will be implemented and become the law
- motoboi 3y agoInformation is where Money and Relativity meet.
- chollida1 3y ago> (They followed the basic prototype for selling short. That just means you sell high before you buy low. How? First you borrow and sell. Then you wait for markets to drop, buy, and return what you borrowed.) Minor nitpick here, but with futures you aren't shorting in that you never borrow. You are simply writing a futures contract which makes you the seller. So when you write the contract you are obligated to sell/deliver at that price on the futures delivery date. this is a bit different from options in that a futures contract buyer has to take delivery and the seller has to deliver. Where as for an options contract the buyer has the right but not the obligation to exercise it. You then cancel your obligation out by later buying a contract that obligates you to take delivery on the delivery date. In this case since you bought the contract later when the market crashed you are buying delivery at a lower price, thus fulfilling your delivery obligations and locking in a profit. No shorting or borrowing happens in this instance. A few random fun facts about futures. 1) there aren't insider trading rules like there are for equities. This makes sense when you consider that McDonalds can move the market if they chose to create a new product. Not allowing McDonalds to trade in the futures market would mean they can't hedge their input needs. Similarly oil companies use futures to hedge their selling prices for oil. If you had insider trading laws like we do with equities they couldn't trade as they have insider knowledge of their market moving needs. 2) A few years ago oil traded negatively for a month, this meant you actually got paid to take delivery of oil. This happened not because oil was worthless( it was still worth the market rate) but because you need to take delivery of the oil on the delivery date. And oil can't just be stored in the your garage. You need to have pre arrange storage in Cushing, Oklahoma or arrange for a rail car to ship your oil out on that exact date. As you would expect oil storage being heavily regulated is finite and rail cars are expensive and booked months in advance so once the storage and rail delivery options were full you'd have to pay someone else for their prearranged storage or rail delivery. And the holders of these storage and shipping options were able to charge a ransom for them as contract buyers had to take delivery and thus had to arrange storage or shipping. More than a few retail investors got hosed on this buy buying futures when the price dropped to half of what a barrel was worth not fully realizing that a) they'd need to pay for storage and b) not fully realizing that the price of oil didn't have a floor at zero, it could infact go negative.
- 3y ago
- petercooper 3y agoI've read books about high frequency trading and the like, but what is the mechanism by which information from an audio feed "a few seconds" in advance of another is turned into profitable trades? Is a human involved? If so, do they prepare trades to suit both directions and then hit the right button as soon as they hear the right thing on the feed?
- steveklabnik 3y agoHere is an article about the events mentioned, that has some more detail: https://www.ft.com/content/17bc0ef6-2282-11ea-92da-f0c92e957a96 https://www.ft.com/content/17bc0ef6-2282-11ea-92da-f0c92e957... > up to 10 seconds before live comments were broadcast on television or internet streams Ten seconds is a long enough time for your "if so," which is what I would guess happens in this specific circumstance. I am an amateur in this space, but in general there are a lot of misconceptions about HFT, because the details are highly technical. See the debates over "paying for order flow," for example. I think it's hard to characterize these systems because, well, they are proprietary. In my understanding, most HFT folks rely on a combination of fundamental and technical analysis, more than sentiment analysis. HFT is more of a game of "make a small amount of money trading all the time" than "wait until some news breaks and reacts to it."
- alberth 3y agoIt’s amazing to think that Eddie Murphy was only: - 20 years old in 48-Hours - 21 years old in Trading Places - 22 years old in Beverly Hills Cop And only 19 years old on SNL and hugely famous.
- phendrenad2 3y ago- 40 years old in Shrek
- greenthrow 3y ago(2019)
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]