5 ms·
> I will bet you that, in practice, they simply avoid collecting against anyone who demonstrates ability and financial resources to enforce their rights. This i
by eru 3y ago
> I will bet you that, in practice, they simply avoid collecting against anyone who demonstrates ability and financial resources to enforce their rights. This is one for the history books of borked equilibriums. We devoted substantial efforts to pro-consumer legislation to address abuse of (mostly) poor people. We gated redress behind labor that is abundantly available in the professional managerial class and scarce outside of it, like writing letters and counting to 30 days. (People telling me they were incapable of doing these two things is why I started ghostwriting letters for debtors.) We now have literal computer programs exempting heuristically identified professional managerial class members from debt collection, inclusive of their legitimate debts, so that debt collectors can more profitably conserve their time to do abusive and frequently illegal shakedowns of the people the legislation was meant to benefit.
That is such a common pattern. Growing up, I saw the same happen with the German welfare system: there's enough of a social safety net in that country that no one would have to be homeless. But, to access the social safety net, you have to navigate some minimal amount of bureaucracy and paperwork.
That bar isn't very high, but if you have at least that minimal skill with paperwork literacy, you are also much more likely to have a job and much less likely to need the welfare.
So all in all, Germany still has homeless people, despite welfare programs generous enough in principle that no one needs to be homeless.
Addendum: Singapore has an ingenious system to ration the amount of subsidies you get on hospital bills without any bureaucracy. The basic idea is that when you go for a hospital stay, you get to pick how much etxra creature comforts you are getting, like your own private room vs an open word with many beds. The copay for the fancier options rises 'progressively' enough, that the absolute amount of government subsidy goes down. People tend to self-sort voluntarily.
The medical care you receive is the same for any of the options.
I can imagine an argument that this is somehow against the dignity of poor people to put them into comparatively crowded wards, and that everyone should get the same treatment (like eg the British NHS does, modulo the option to go to a private hospital for enough money). But I suspect many of the poorer people are happier to put up with that 'indignity' than with paperwork and privacy-invading bureaucratic means testing.
In total, adding up private and public expenditures, Singapore spends about half as much on healthcare as a proportion of GDP than the UK does, which spends about half as much as the US. Medical outcomes are no worse in the cheaper systems.
- nico 3y agoThis is the same with tax collection in the US (seen different versions of this done by IRS, California’s BOE and SF treasury) It goes something like this: they send you a scary looking letter telling you there’s something off about your taxes, you then need to call them (because they don’t do email and mailing anything will go over the time limit to comply), then they tell you more in detail what the problem is and push you to amend your return forms, once you do, you’ve legally accepted liability for whatever extra taxes they convinced you you owed (and will have to pay) What most people should actually do: they send you a scary letter, you tell them to audit you, usually they’ll stop here, if they audit you and make a final assessment against you, you tell them you want to go to court, they’ll almost definitely drop it at this point, unless you actually owe them taxes and it’s such an easy and big case that they are willing to go through the trouble Most people will just amend their return forms and pay, because it’s just too scary to even think of going against these agencies
- lokar 3y agoThis happened to me. I sent the letter to my CPA, he realized he made an error and in fact the IRS owed me a bunch of money, which they returned.
- charlie0 3y agoTo the IRSs credit, I once got a letter saying there was a mistake in my tax form and I overpaid. They sent me a check.
- nradov 3y agoPerhaps you have had a different experience but the IRS has always been polite and helpful in the few cases where I had income tax disputes. The key is to follow the process instead of trying to argue with bureaucrats or treat them as enemies. Compliance deadlines are measured in months. You have plenty of time to mail responses. Usually they'll put a hold on collection activities while you have a dispute pending.
- 3y ago