9 ms·
‘Friends’ and ‘Seinfeld’ knew the cure for loneliness
- houseatrielah 3y agoHappy to see I'm not alone and someone else is complaining about our sad parks, "What we call parks look like parking lots with some grass on them, perhaps a baseball diamond. That's not the kind of park that draws people in," Tayana Panova, a researcher who studies the built environment's effects on mental health, told me. "We need parks that have amenities and assets that make it desirable for people to go there." A third space of dreams isn't a barren field. It also includes pools, benches, art, fountains, playgrounds, and food stands — things people gather at.
- hgsgm 3y agoSounds like regular parks in my city.
- mrguyorama 3y ago>It also includes pools, benches, art, fountains, playgrounds, and food stands — things people gather at. Can't have those, the homeless might use them to avoid suffering for a few minutes and be visible, and that makes people angry.
- dpkirchner 3y agoAround these parts it's more like a few hours to a few days but it is still a fair point. One answer would be to build and support more places, enough for everyone to enjoy.
- mrguyorama 3y agoNah, better for it to be a crime to be homeless in public
- Supply5411 3y ago>avoid suffering for a few minutes Not sure where you live, but where I've lived, they form camps, do drugs in the open, scream at people, and vandalize their surroundings. They make a good environment hostile to everyone. That's what most people are angry about.
- datavirtue 3y agoIn Ohio we have professional hobos. People that hang out with signs, know all the laws, dress a certain way, make themselves up all dirty, and beg for money. They do quite well with the fools here. You can see them change out for shifts. Whole families cycle through the shifts or work in a group with their children on display.
- dopidopHN 3y agoI guess they are entertainer then ? I’ve seen that described several time here on this forum. I’m skeptical that those people really do “well for themselves”. But I’m open to it? I doubt they have sick day or that they’re saving for retirement. But who know? Who you say they make more than a service industry worker for instance ( per hour )
- brnaftr361 3y agoThat's only half of the story. A lot of those people are mentally ill. There are also a lot of "hidden" homeless people who live diverse lives. I knew some travelling kids that rode freight around the country, they were typically sheltered by friends. They did odd jobs and could busk, and yes they did drugs, but they weren't shitting in the street and boofing heroin in plain sight. There's people that are down on their luck, and there's people who just gave up the rat race - and there's a good chance they aren't slamming meth, but they can turn into drunks fast.
- mrguyorama 3y agoNah, the "camps" around here are a bunch of tents where people just want to be left alone. The only violence happens to other homeless people, so it's "contained" in a way. The best part is that the city keeps throwing away everything these people physically own, so they have no hope of improving their situation and ever escaping homelessness, and all the social workers struggle to keep in touch with the homeless community because they keep being jerked around and screwed with for no benefit. Tell me, if you are homeless, where are you supposed to go when the sun goes down? As far as I can tell, it is a crime to not be in a bed you have paid for. Why have we made it a crime to be alive?
- autoexec 3y agoIdeally, you'd have a bit of both. A large open space is needed for a lot of sports and hobbies. In cities I see a lot more parks that are nothing more than a bit of run down looking playground equipment and a couple benches than large open fields. The parks with more amenities tend to have things like fenced off areas, nets and marked courts for ball sports, bright overhead lights, buildings, and actual parking lots. Busy outdoor entertainment centers are nice, but open green space is important too.
- afavour 3y agoThis is one of the reasons that, despite the immense cost, we're trying to stay in NYC as long as we can. Two small children in an apartment definitely has its tough moments. But we live by a giant park packed with playgrounds, when we go we frequently bump into friends from school, meet friends of friends, etc. Everyone can go get an ice cream, head home happy. We have dozens of museums an easy subway ride away. etc etc etc It's not like it's a perfect life but for this moment in life I really wouldn't trade it.
- icepat 3y agoWhy is this a New York specific phenomenon? Living in a large town/small city in Europe, I find the same effect plays out here. A very few number of times my social activities have been actively planned. Most occur after bumping into someone at a local venue, concert, or other event.
- The_Colonel 3y agoI guess it's quite rare within US.
- hypeit 3y agoIt's actually not, every city in the US has packed parks and stuff to do.
- afavour 3y agoI am talking from a US perspective. There are few cities in the US that offer this, though NYC is by no means the only one.
- hypeit 3y agoYou should really get out of NYC sometime. Pretty much every city and even mid-sized town in the US has what you're describing. A lot of it is far easier to navigate than Brooklyn as well.
- hypeit 3y ago> We can see this shift everywhere. The characters of the biggest shows of the '90s — "Friends," "Seinfeld," "Cheers" — spent the overwhelming majority of their time hanging out at the café, diner, and bar, and work was either an afterthought or a running joke. These were television shows, not reality. Even in the 80s and 90s you couldn't spend all of your time in a Manhattan coffee shop or a bar (unless you were a drunk). I think our concept of what a "friend" is was heavily shaped by 20th century sitcoms and not realistic, setting up a couple of generations to be very lonely and very disappointed that life doesn't turn out like TV.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoYou don't need to spend all your time somewhere for it to become a decent third space. You just need to go regularly, at a similar enough time that you start building rapport with the people who also go at the same time. If you go to the gym or bar for an hour or two after work every weekday, for example, you'll quickly notice that the same people are there with you. Interact with them enough, and these people form the outer ring of your social life. Then you need to have explicitly social gatherings. For example, I've got a biweekly game night that an old friend and I alternate hosting. We invite our friends and the occasional acquaintance from our outer rings, and some start coming regularly. Typically somewhere between 4 and 10 people show up, BYOB, and we play some board games into the odd hours. Often random subsets of the group will grab dinner together before hand. Then you have your close friend maintenance regimen. People you're not seeing regularly anymore in the context you used to (whether it was school, and old workplace, etc), but that you want to maintain a relationship with. If you spend at least 1 weekend night a week grabbing dinner and some drinks with one of these people, you'll be able to maintain your relationships with up to a half dozen or so people (in addition to the ones that are in your more active group). Mix in some larger gatherings/parties a couple times a year, and you've set yourself up a healthy social life.
- brailsafe 3y agoNailed it.
- legerdemain 3y ago
- gumby 3y agoCities in Europe, Japan, and Korea still have vibrant and central "third place" cultures, perhaps because the apartments tend to be smaller. Loneliness in Europe IMHO seems more to occur outside cities where density is lower, though even there people our "out and about" more than I see in the US suburbs.
- dopidopHN 3y agoFrance is recently obsessed with “tier lieux” in rural place. Coffee place, book exchange, brewery, shop-postoffice-coffee, second hand shop and the mix of all the above. I go there every year or so, this year the “tier lieu” is what striked me as strong trend. It’s not new, but it’s on everyone lips.
- cafard 3y agoAmple pay to hang out with your friends, and skilled editors?
- xrd 3y agoWouldn't it be ironic if the current worry in the US about public spaces (i.e. homeless and/or drug addicts) were two sides of the same coin: the goal is to isolate yourself in a massive home in the suburbs to protect yourself from the homeless and drug addicts. And, if you fail at that goal, you then have no choice but to become what everyone fears.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoThe more people succeed at isolating themselves the bigger the problems of social isolation including homelessness and drug addiction.
- CaffeinatedDev 3y ago[flagged]
- CaffeinatedDev 3y ago[dead]
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/RAOw9 https://archive.is/RAOw9
- b_f 3y agoI... does anyone else have issues with the captchas used on this site? I never previously questioned my humanity but I can't seem to satisfy its definition of bridges and motorcycles.
- rashkov 3y agoIt’s because you use cloudflare dns. Switch to another dns provider. Seems to be a spat between the author of archive and cloudflare about what the proper dns protocol requires. Can read more about it if you search through hacker news
- appleiigs 3y agoI don't know if you need a third place. Home will do fine, just invite people to hang out to watch sports games, movies, BBQ, whatever. I lived separately, but I had a few friends living together and it was an open door policy like Seinfeld and Friends... just walk in. Another point is a lot of my friends, who have trouble meeting other friends, don't have hobbies. During the summer, I say "I'm going hiking every weekend this summer, whoever wants to come can join". If no one else goes, that's fine my dog still has an awesome time. Sure enough, friends show up, sometimes with their coworkers or their hair barber. These friends are closer than the beer, coffee crowd because we already have the hobby in common. EDIT: the main commonality between the open door policy and hiking example is consistency. Any time not busy, people will just default gravitate to the house or hiking meetup.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoI think it's good if you have a home where people can meet and gather, but many times, that is not ideal, especially for anyone who is in a lower socio-economic class, or has significant family members or roommates there. Having people come over is a whole thing of "playing host" or "entertaining guests" which means that you might need to clean up some, you're going to offer food and beverages, you may need to determine a program of entertainment, whether it's movies or cards or conversation. That's a burden, and it can drain the host's resources. Someone's home is also non-neutral territory. It's guests coming into someone's owned living space. That creates a unique dynamic. The reason third spaces are popular is because none of those burdens apply. The restaurant, or coffeehouse plays host to us, so the cleanup is on them, the menu is theirs, and we know the bounds of activities that can be done. Third spaces are neutral spaces; none of us live there, and we are all essentially "guests" on the same footing, so it's comfortable, especially if a man and woman are alone together, the third space is a public meeting place where things are much less likely to get weird. For decades, especially while I was homeless and living on the streets, I enjoyed third spaces with my friends. We were safe and climate-controlled in the coffeehouse, and we had hours of diversion while we played card games. Street urchins and our church friends would come and go as they pleased. We could tank up on beverages or a little pastry. There was a convenient bathroom, and oh, the people-watching potential! We were downtown in a college town, and the nightlife never stopped! My circle of friends was down to a tight-knit three people, and I was the youngest among them, and we played card and board games right up until the pandemic hit. At that point, our third spaces were all decimated. Our favorite teahouse closed forever. We scattered to the four winds. One of us is just too old to keep going out, and the other lady seems rather paranoid of COVID-19 that she won't do social outings. We really don't have a third space to go, either. Well, there's a little place across the street, with an extraordinarily surly owner and two weird dogs. Recurring, reliable activities are great. You would always know when to meet us downtown for cards. We would go to evening Mass and then proceed to the coffeehouse, like clockwork. That's important. We could count on getting mostly the same baristas on shift and seeing the same people each time. I thought about advertising on meetup.com or something, you know, just to get some visibility beyond our local circle. But COVID-19 has changed the landscape.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 440hz 3y agoI go to the gym every day and what I can say is that if it used to be a third place, now it has become more of a non-place[0]. Nobody talks to anyone anymore. People don't look at what's around them and are glued to their smartphones all the time while they rest. If you approach someone to ask something, and if they are also wearing headphones, make sure you repeat what you want to say, because inexplicably these cheap knockoff headphones have perfect sound isolation. When we talk about the increase in loneliness, I can't help but associate it with the launch of the iPhone and the social apps. I wonder if the benefits brought by this device really outweigh its cons. Furthermore, every month I organize a meetup with people who want to practice English (I live in Brazil) and usually 10 to 15 people attend. I think people want to connect with other people, but technology isn't helping them find those opportunities. I use meetup.com, but the person has to download the app or go to the website. I think most of my potential audience don't even know it exists because it's a very US thing. [0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-place https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-place
- doublerabbit 3y agoThe gym has never been a social place. Everyone is there for a reason, normally to get fit. We however do live in a very fearing world. With the stories that are spewed out daily, there is always a worry of "Is this person I'm going to meet going to X". So it's safer to judge based on online social imagery, where the true creep holds. Meetup / group sites while have an advantage point in meeting the tech they introduce are flawed. They are difficult to navigate, and again it falls symptom to the likes where AirBnB where anything worthwhile is normally berried at the bottom and you need to sieve through to reach the others.
- datavirtue 3y agoThe repeal of the fairness doctrine was the final nuke. Boy has that come home to roost.
- nradov 3y agoThe fairness doctrine only ever applied to broadcast media. It was never a thing for online services, cable TV, or print media.
- footlose_3815 3y agoIt's depressing when all the third spaces are bars full of miserable people
- dagurp 3y agoMy third place is disc golf leagues/tournaments. The great thing about the sport is that it's easy to pick up and tournaments are usually set up in such a way that you can choose a group that suits your ability. The social aspect is great and you get to spend time outdoors surrounded by trees.
- smcameron 3y agoMy third place is the local hackerspace. This has been the case since 2010, except, perhaps surprisingly, for the few years when I lived/worked in silicon valley. Weirdly, hackerspaces don't seem to work the same in silicon valley. Everybody is too busy at their tech job to have any energy left to spend free time building stuff purely for fun, and real estate is too expensive to allow for affordable memberships. When I went to the local hackerspace, the few people there were busy working on their own startup and nobody was talking to anybody, they weren't there for fun, they were there to work. Noisebridge and Ace Monster Toys were better, but too far away (SF and Oakland, respectively) to be convenient. In other places I've been (Texas, Virginia) hackerspaces seem to work a lot better as third places and be more fun oriented. I chalk this up to less intense work environments and cheaper real estate.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoCommunity is showing up. Go somewhere every week and see what happens.
- dopidopHN 3y ago> In Germany, they have a term for the beer you drink as you walk to the next bar, a "wegbier." The US has that too, but in New Orleans mostly. It’s called a too go cup and it’s mighty convenient. Also, New Orleans is full of third places and so tiny that a bike is plenty to move around
- spidersenses 3y ago>In Germany, they have a term for the beer you drink as you walk to the next bar, a "wegbier." There is a humorous pun on “Wegbier”. It is sometimes called “Fusspils” (foot beer) which is a homophone of “Fusspilz” (athlete’s foot).
- spicyusername 3y agoNew Orleans is such a treasure. One of the few "European" cities in the U.S.. It's a real shame it's going to be taken by the sea.
- dopidopHN 3y agoYeah, there is still some good time to be had in the meantime. I can picture the last days of the city already. It will be a drunk brass band on a Cajun navy boat, parading into oblivion.
- JackMorgan 3y agoLast year I moved to the downtown of a small progressive college town (definitely not a party school). I joined the volunteer fire department, and then 2-3 times a week I walk across the street to local coffeeshop for breakfast. I do all my grocery shopping for two days at a time at the small bodega across the street and just carry my groceries back. I go to a bunch of local theater shows. There's a community center, so I go to events at that. There's a train station if I need to go into the big city, but I rarely even use it now. I hardly use the car at all anymore. A year later, I know dozens of people. I know the mayor and half the city counsel. I cannot walk anywhere without getting waved at by 2-3 people. For the first time in my life since college, I feel like I have a community. There's very real cons: it's more expensive, I've got no private yard, and my apartment is hot and tiny. But I really enjoy the sense of community. It definitely helps me feel connected.