13 ms·
9/11 in Realtime
- mhh__ 3y agohttps://youtu.be/9tKbZJ-NENo?si=RUe1-2n6Fw2sVOw0 https://youtu.be/9tKbZJ-NENo?si=RUe1-2n6Fw2sVOw0 D-day Radio broadcasts in real time.
- causi 3y agoIf you want to get a handle on how the War on Terror started and how everybody felt about it, I highly recommend listening to some of the live radio shows from that morning, such as the Howard Stern show. You look back now and question how we could've let it get so out of hand, but watching people react to it in real time takes you right back to the emotions it triggered. I don't think I've ever felt that degree of collective fury before. That week, many of the people I know would've been happy to launch nuclear weapons at every population center in Afghanistan and the capitals of every nation that'd so much as looked at the United States funny in the previous ten years.
- swozey 3y agoI don't have the time to dig around for examples but reading IRC logs (which I mention in another comment) is really ... interesting. I haven't read them in years but I remember the vitriol toward Muslims being absolutely astonishing. But it was ye olde 2000s..
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoIt never went away. The religious right in the US and others discovered a wellspring of motivational energy (for their regular causes) that they could get out of people by pointing fingers at Islam, and they have never really let it go. It comes and go in waves, but it's pretty crazy what an appeal to an old bogeyman can get you; at the time, George Bush talking about a "clash of civilizations" and appealing to old Crusades era mythos of east vs west, orient vs "western civilization" etc. was incredibly "successful" at accomplishing the goals that Rumsfeld and Cheney and others had set out for their regime. The Bush/Cheney regime inherited a largely liberal, tolerant, and centrist populous from the Clinton years. The general zeitgeist and political atmosphere from back then looks so civilized and calm compared to now. And they leverage 9/11 to stir up a whole different scenario afterwards that has never stopped accelerating. The xenophobic far right has been in steady ascendancy ever since. To this day, if there's a shooting in a mall or whatever, you'll hear people immediately jump to the jihadist explanation, even when it's clear that the bulk of terrorist type violence in North America doesn't actually take this form -- it's usually far right / white supremacist in inspiration, just as it was before 9/11 (e.g Timothy McVeigh, etc.) I'm an atheist and no lover of any organized religion, including Islam, but it was dark and depressing to watch at the time and it continues to be depressing to see people manipulated on these terms.
- havblue 3y agoMany speculate that groups need a common enemy to maintain their identity. Obviously, communism and terrorism are recent examples. But what are our common enemies now? The New Atheists decried religion for years but frankly, I think the religious right is dead. Many consider new atheism movement to be dead as well. So we currently only have the other party to blame.
- civilitty 3y ago> I haven't read them in years but I remember the vitriol toward Muslims being absolutely astonishing. But it was ye olde 2000s.. Not only has the vitriol not gone away, the targets have vastly expanded. Go read the worldnews subreddit coverage of the war in Ukraine, for example: lots of talk about "Russian scum" and other dehumanization of the enemy upvoted to the top.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoI also see it from the other line -- lots of people who've taken the bus so far to the right that they talk about Putin as a hero fighting against our "degenerate" western leaders. It's pretty dark out there in popular discourse right now.
- sneak 3y agoIt seemed like overreactions to me at the time, and it seems like overreactions to me now. I was 18 at the time and I was already old enough to know that you don't make big decisions when tired, angry, or stressed. What's the point of checks and balances and the rule of law if they all go out of the window as soon as an adversary does something bad enough to make enough of us sufficiently angry? Those aren't laws and rules or balances (or values) if they get tossed aside simply because of a spike in anger or fear or both.
- ilaksh 3y agoThe reasons we engaged in those extensive Middle East campaigns were strategic, just like they have always been for hundreds of years. The events of that day were (coincidentally) the perfect motivation for the campaigns. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Game https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Game
- bufordtwain 3y ago"Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth." -Mike Tyson
- sneak 3y agoCall me crazy, but if our entire machinery of government can't function well enough to control itself internally to preserve human rights better than Mike Tyson, maybe we should toss the whole thing out and start over.
- shepherdjerred 3y agoThe purpose of a government has not historically been to preserve human rights
- seanw444 3y agoWe literally wrote a document explaining what the government is not allowed to do, for that reason. Yet they still do those things anyways. Not enough people care, either.
- next_xibalba 3y agoWell said. I was a sophomore in high school at the time. Sometime in the late morning, after both towers had been hit and it was clear that it was a terrorist attack, all the classroom TVs were turned on and tuned to the news. I distinctly recall the palpable fear and fury. A fellow student said to me, in a fit of gallows humor, "Get your gun, son. We're going to war." It did feel as though there was some legitimacy to Afghanistan (of course, even that ended up being folly), but Iraq, which didn't happen until the Spring of '03, always felt tenuous. Of course, all of it turned out to be a catastrophe, most especially for Iraqis and Afghans. My personal pet conspiracy theory is that the U.S. leadership realized that the U.S. homeland was not defensible against asymmetric attacks of this nature. They needed to create an external beacon for the jihadists–a theater in which the U.S. military would be the target and the aggressor, not soft targets. And so they chose Iraq, with its dormant sectarian divisions being a perfect cauldron to which those enemies would be drawn.
- civilitty 3y ago> My personal pet conspiracy theory is that the U.S. leadership realized that the U.S. homeland was not defensible against asymmetric attacks of this nature. They needed to create an external beacon for the jihadists–a theater in which the U.S. military would be the target and the aggressor, not soft targets. And so they chose Iraq, with its dormant sectarian divisions being a perfect cauldron to which those enemies would be drawn. Interesting conspiracy theory! Especially considering that the resulting mess caused a massive refugee crisis and a spike of terrorism in Europe. Even if it didn't keep the terrorist mired in the Middle East, it redirected the violence towards our allies, thus maintaining the general casus beli.
- sanderjd 3y agoI still think the initial campaign in Afghanistan was not a mistake. But I think after that, we let the military continue running the show there for way too long and never took the diplomatic mission seriously enough.
- causi 3y agoYou can't change the soul of a people by force or even by diplomacy. If you look at every nation whose culture reformed after, say, losing in WW2, their behavior during and leading up to that war was relatively different from their norms. Germany's genocidal imperialism was a result of the first world war and the terms of the treaty which ended it. Japan turned imperialist because European colonialism made them decide it was either become an imperial power or get swallowed up. Both nations could revert to relative normalcy after the war. Afghanistan has been a tyrannical theocracy that uses religion to treat its citizens like dirt while being repeatedly invaded by outsiders for damn near eight hundred years. There is no fixing that, especially not in a couple of decades.
- ilaksh 3y agoThat was the intended effect. This is the context: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda War is strategic. But soldiers won't kill for strategic reasons. They will fight when given an ethical basis. The objective truth never provides this.
- mc32 3y agoYou can feed them hashish or whatever and turn people into berserkers. Also, in mercenaries people do it for other reasons. Anyhow, when you look at the elated reaction from people in some areas of the world when it happened, one can see why people might react to that reaction with seething vengeance in mind.
- enterprise_cog 3y agoYou can see the ignorance of the people in this country from that anger. Those people celebrating were on the receiving end of American terrorism abroad.
- mc32 3y agoSometimes —but in many cases people in areas unaffected directly by American policy were celebrating as if they felt a tribalistic attachment perhaps to the aggrieved. You're arguing that two wrongs make a right and in such argument the stronger party will win.
- enterprise_cog 3y agoI’m not arguing that two wrongs make a right. I’m saying actions have consequences. And how could you possibly know those people celebrating we’re not affected by US policy and military exploits?
- adrianmonk 3y agoIntended by who? Are you saying the US government knew it meant war and had the foresight (and bandwidth) to arrange a coordinated propaganda campaign on the spot? People just being naturally angry seems like a simpler and perfectly sufficient explanation. We humans are pretty much hardwired to respond like that: when we believe we've been wronged, a special brain mode kicks in that pushes us toward taking action (ideally a constructive one, but brain hardware doesn't enforce that).
- pjc50 3y agoIt was obvious to me, a Brit, that there would be massive American retaliation against whichever country was linked to this - and I said so in the office where we had all broken off work to crowd round the TV or refresh news websites. Then a second plane hit. (I incorrectly guessed it was the PLO responsible) > That week, many of the people I know would've been happy to launch nuclear weapons at every population center in Afghanistan and the capitals of every nation that'd so much as looked at the United States funny in the previous ten years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_for_the_New_American_Century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_for_the_New_American_C... There was (and still is in some quarters) a huge desire for revenge against Iran. A side effect of Republicans going full Qanon is that they no longer care about the middle east at all, and the PNAC lot fade into history.
- no_wizard 3y agoI remember talking about PNAC at a debate session of all things in high school. Our debate club was pretty big and well known in our school The teachers that ran it shut me down, saying I was peddling conspiracy theories about PNAC influence and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, this was 2008/2009. I'm still, based on research I've done since, convinced that PNAC had a huge influence on George W. Bush and Dick Cheney in particular, and the white house at the time more generally. Ultimately I believe this is why they pursued the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, was due to the ideas espoused by this group
- pjc50 3y agoYou were absolutely correct; it was as close as possible to publishing a manifesto saying "here's how we're going to launch a war in the middle east" and then doing it as you'll ever see. The same clearly identifiable people were involved all over the place.
- peterleiser 3y agoExactly. PNAC wasn't conspiracy theory at all. It wasn't even an "open secret": They had a website, the signatories were public, many of the signatories were in the Bush W. administration. PNAC was discussed often on all the talking head political shows. It became the plan after 9/11. I think some people a decade or so later thought it was a conspiracy theory because they thought it implied 9/11 was done, or allowed to happen, on purpose in order to begin the regime changes outlined in the plan. But with PNAC this was their world view and plan, and 9/11 allowed them to move forward. Wrong plan, right time.
- havblue 3y agoHoward Stern is definitely a cautionary tale for how an irreverent anti-establishment hero just becomes exactly what he would have hated starting off.
- sanderjd 3y agoI remember the feeling extremely clearly. And I still remember that feeling extending to the beginning of the war in Afghanistan, which I thought seemed justified and right. But I just as clearly remember how confused, frustrated, and just so disillusioned with the wisdom of my elders (I was still a teenager at this time) I felt when they were all so gung ho about invading Iraq, which clearly at the time had absolutely nothing to do with 9/11. The debate nowadays always seems to hinge on this question of whether they lied about the WMD thing or were "just" mistaken about it. But from my perspective living through that time as a young person, that WMD thing was not the problem, the problem was this mass fearful hysteria that our leaders (either cynically or because they were themselves in the grips of that hysteria) were able to use to get overwhelming popular support for an unrelated invasion, essentially just out of peoples feelings of righteous anger and spite. It isn't just ugly in hindsight, it was ugly ugly ugly then, in the moment.
- cout 3y agoI know next to nothing about geopolitics, but I always figured the the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan had something Iran since it's sandwiched between them.
- peterleiser 3y agoYes. Search for the phrase “Everyone wants to go to Baghdad. Real men want to go to Tehran” to see what folks were saying at the time .
- peterleiser 3y agoI encourage people to read about Project for the New American Century (PNAC). 9/11 gave PNAC and the neoconservatives the optimal opportunity to implement their stated objectives.
- sanderjd 3y agoWhat makes you think I didn't know / read about it at the time? All the comments here mentioning the neoconservative desire for regime change in Iraq predating 9/11 seem to imply that it was an obscure thing that people weren't very aware of at the time. But that isn't true at all. It was broadly understood and frequently discussed. It's just that people were so generally scared, pissed off, and ready for vengeance against whoever, that nobody cared. (Not literally nobody, but I think I recall that the war had like 70% or 80% support, with strong majorities in both major parties.) This is why I started out my adulthood libertarian-curious, because both parties and huge majorities of voters seemed insanely interventionist to me. But things have reordered a huge amount since then. (Basically everyone came around to my view of the war, in hindsight.)
- shanghaikid 3y ago[flagged]
- DrBenCarson 3y agoIs it meant to be?
- nickthegreek 3y agoWhat is trying to be funny?
- swozey 3y agoThis stuff is so difficult for me to watch again, I was a senior in HS. Reading IRC logs from back then is also really interesting. And Nanog had a really interesting slideshow/powerpoint deep dive on the infrastructure outages that occurred. And of course the SomethingAwful thread that's been posted before. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7990991 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7990991 RE: this specific site.. interesting UX/UI choice. I was hoping I could click the times in Timeline of Events and be sent straight there but it seems like I have to put times specifically in the Controls section. Anyway, this is neat.
- glawre 3y agoDo you have a source for the Nanog powerpoint? That sounds really interesting.
- swozey 3y agoI've dug this up 2-3 times since 2001 and I always have a nightmare of a time finding it. I'm not finding it anywhere right now. I'm pretty sure it was a Nanog report but I could be wrong there, it was very thorough and a lot of slides. Best I can do right now is the Nanog mail list that day/week... https://archive.nanog.org/mailinglist/mailarchives/old_archive/2001-09/threads.html#00540 https://archive.nanog.org/mailinglist/mailarchives/old_archi...
- keepamovin 3y agoI relate: was also a senior. I had an English final that morning, I think. Earth shifted. It was an overwhelming experience seeing it happen on TV.
- sanderjd 3y agoI was a junior. I went to a boarding school and one of those weird memories that sticks with you is that I was unsure whether or not to go to my classes. No cell phones and pretty primitive email system, so it just wasn't clear. I went to one at like 9:30 (central time) and nobody was there, so that was when I realized "oh this is one of those nothing-is-normal-now things".
- hattmall 3y agoThe best I've heard is the Howard Stern broadcast.
- dave84 3y agoI'm a bit lost, changing the timeline doesn't seem to correspond to the events or coverage of them. Anyone know what I'm doing wrong?
- keepamovin 3y agoI think you need to "start it off" by pushing "Go" on the Controls window after you set a time. That seemed to then line everything up. Note that the Menu Bar time widget does not reflect the Timeline time tho!
- dave84 3y agoOK, the menu bar was throwing me off... makes no sense. Thanks.
- tobr 3y agoI think some of the time stamps, but not all, are adapted to the local time zone. Very confusing user interface overall, it’s trying something very ambitious but not succeeding on the execution.
- rconti 3y agoyeah, I have no idea what's going on with the time. There is a 2 hour delta between the time in the box where I hit "go" and the "current time" on the menu bar. I'm on the west coast so it would make sense if it was a 3 hour difference, or a 0 hour difference, but 2 makes no sense to me. Unless it was a DST change? But the 2007 change only happened for the start in March.
- alkonaut 3y agoDon't get it either. But setting a time and hitting "go" seems to adjust the streams to the right time. But it doesn't "tick" when playing for some reason.
- yreg 3y agoI don't understand why there's static noise instead of broadcast all the time. Is it a buffering animation and does the server have troubles keeping up?
- keepamovin 3y agoThat's incredible! What an amazing project. The classic Macintosh desktop is also very well done. Does anyone know the source code for the desktop used? I found the projects in the "About" open source notices section of the desktop. It uses: - https://github.com/robbiebyrd/platinum https://github.com/robbiebyrd/platinum which itself is based on: - https://github.com/npjg/classic.css https://github.com/npjg/classic.css - https://github.com/ticky/classic-scrollbars https://github.com/ticky/classic-scrollbars for the scroll-bars
- mdaniel 3y ago> The classic Macintosh desktop is also very well done Two things, in my opinion: trying to be whimsical and "fun" for such a grave topic is disrespectful, and I don't understand what value appropriating Apple's logo and the "finder face" in the corner add to the 9/11 retrospective experience So, fine, maybe I'm just not happy-go-lucky enough to appreciate why this needs to be a classic Macintosh theme, but I am 100% positive that this experience doesn't need those branding elements to reenact 9/11 anythings
- gnicholas 3y agoIMO this doesn’t seem disrespectful, more like an attempt at authenticity. For those who used computers at that time, it will remind them of what it was like, and for younger people, it helps communicate the era (before you were born, but post-GUI) that 9/11 happened in.
- nobody9999 3y ago>IMO this doesn’t seem disrespectful, more like an attempt at authenticity. For those who used computers at that time, it will remind them of what it was like, and for younger people, it helps communicate the era (before you were born, but post-GUI) that 9/11 happened in. I mostly agree with you. However, I visited Las Vegas and stayed at the New York, New York casino hotel a few months after the towers came down and noted the "memorials" people put up on the outside of the casino. Which, as a native NYer who worked across the street from the WTC (and walked through it pretty much every work day for many years beyond that) for more than three years, really pissed me off even though I realized that people wanted to show their support -- I found it a disgusting display. I still live in NYC and to this day I avoid the area around ground zero whenever I can. Not because I'm afraid, but because it's still painful to think about all those dead people in a place that was so familiar to me. As such, I understand GP's feelings. The events of that day shouldn't be made light of given all the innocent people (and not just in NYC, but in Washington, DC and Shanksville, PA as well) who died needlessly. And each of us processes/deals with that differently.
- bloomingeek 3y agoI'm retired from American Airlines, September 9th,2001 we were vacationing with our children in Florida. I tried to talk my wife into staying an extra day and fly home on the 11th. Thankfully she talked me into going home on the 10th as planned. We got home late from the airport and everybody slept in on the 11th except me. I was messing around in the garage when my wife hollers at me to come look at the tv. At first we couldn't figure out if it was real, then it sunk in. I called a co-worker who was on shift, he said everyone was in shock. I started feeding tapes into my VCR, about eight of them. I've never watched them.
- antomeie 3y agoThank you for sharing your story! It is always interesting to hear different perspectives from these events. Regarding your VCR tapes. I understand it may be difficult for you to watch, but I encourage you to get them digitalized soon, while you still can. Perhaps even upload them in full length online somewhere for other people to look at.
- jcranmer 3y agoIf what is recorded is a news channel, the Web Archive already has the major news channel's coverage of 9/11 available for free: https://archive.org/details/911/day/20010911 https://archive.org/details/911/day/20010911
- antomeie 3y agoThank you for this! Really interesting. I'm having a look at it now. Although my initial thought was that it would be great if there was a way to watch the entire day (for one news station) in one clip, rather than have to click on multiple 30 seconds videos.
- Someone 3y agoThat’s what this site is, isn’t it?
- ramoz 3y agoPretty cool. FYI The upper right clock seems off by 1 hour (using the time control seems to work or I don't understand how time works)
- settrans 3y ago@rsync's story from 9/11 is an excellent illustration of the event and absolutely worth the read: https://web.archive.org/web/20041208005336/http://www.cultdeadcow.com/cDc_files/cDc-0396.html https://web.archive.org/web/20041208005336/http://www.cultde...
- Aeolun 3y agoThat was indeed a really good read.
- davidw 3y agoUgh, once was enough for me. Remembering it is important, reliving it is too much. This quote from Lincoln is pretty pertinent to some things that have happened since: > At what point then is the approach of danger to be expected? I answer, if it ever reach us, it must spring up amongst us. It cannot come from abroad. If destruction be our lot, we must ourselves be its author and finisher. As a nation of freemen, we must live through all time, or die by suicide. Commonly reported as "America will never be destroyed from the outside. If we falter and lose our freedoms, it will be because we destroyed ourselves"
- falcrist 3y ago[dead]
- 542458 3y agoWow, this is wildly stressful to watch, even all these years later.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoDamn, yeah, I gave it a shot and it's rough. I just happened to be home a bit later than usual and was watching the morning news just like this that day, so this is pretty much how I experienced the towers being hit live. Eerie.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoSome previous discussion from 2021: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28492719 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28492719
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- blamazon 3y agoThere are so many incredible stories of heroism from this day, but, I will highlight that of Rick Rescorla. [1] After 1993, before 9/11: > Feeling that the authorities lost legitimacy after they failed to respond to his 1990 warnings, he concluded that employees of Morgan Stanley, which was the largest tenant in the World Trade Center, could not rely on first responders in an emergency and needed to empower themselves through surprise fire drills, in which he trained employees to meet in the hallway between stairwells and go down the stairs two by two to the 44th floor. Rescorla's strict approach to these drills put him into conflict with some high-powered executives, who resented the interruption to their daily activities, but he nonetheless insisted that these rehearsals were necessary to train the employees in the event of an emergency. He timed employees with a stopwatch when they moved too slowly and lectured them on fire emergency basics. On 9/11: > When a Port Authority announcement came over the P.A. system urging people to stay at their desks, and before United Airlines Flight 175 would strike the South Tower at 9:03 A.M., Rescorla ignored the announcement, grabbed his bullhorn, walkie-talkie and cell phone, and began systematically to order the roughly 2,700 Morgan Stanley employees in the South Tower to evacuate, in addition to the employees in WTC 5, numbering around 1,000. > After successfully evacuating almost all of Morgan Stanley's 2,700 employees, he went back into the building. When one of his colleagues told him he too had to evacuate the World Trade Center, Rescorla replied, "As soon as I make sure everyone else is out." He was last seen on the 10th floor of the South Tower, heading upward, shortly before its collapse at 9:59 A.M., 56 minutes after being struck by United Airlines Flight 175. A total of 13 Morgan Stanley employees died in the September 11 attacks, including Rescorla, his deputies Wesley Mercer and Jorge Valezquez, and security guard Godwin Forde, who had collectively stayed behind to help others. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rick_Rescorla https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rick_Rescorla
- Lord-Jobo 3y agoA true, no bullshit, hero. I was never a boyscout, but 'be prepared" is a motto I try to stand behind.
- sanderjd 3y agoThank you for that story. Do you know of a book that covers the event from this angle? I'm totally tapped out on the usual treatment of the event focused on geopolitics before and after it, but I would like to read in long form about the actions of the actual people there and nearby that day.
- self_awareness 3y agoI appreciate the overall Mac look and feel, but I don't understand what's going on in this UI. I'm clicking some video, but it won't start, something else starts playing, Picture in Picture starts up, I need to close it, clicking Play won't play the video, instead it starts automatically 10 seconds later, then it stops, snowy screen pops up, etc.
- midasuni 3y ago[flagged]
- btown 3y agoHere is a compilation of recordings of the moment the second tower was hit - by which time both news cameras and amateur cameras were focused on the towers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7YLm3pkAiJQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7YLm3pkAiJQ So much of the world as we know it now can be traced back to this day, and perhaps this moment above any others - the moment we gained an innate knowledge that something sinister was going on, a deep feeling of fear, anger, and vulnerability awakening in the American populace with an immediacy that had perhaps never been felt in the country's history. I vividly recall being a middle school student, seeing friends being pulled out of the classroom one by one, knowing that something horrifying was happening, not knowing details, not knowing whether I would be next, eventually understanding with dawning horror that some of my classmates had family members who would never come home. An entire generation felt this pain. It's really important that projects and video archives like the OP exist so people understand not just the statistics, but the fundamental shift of people's worldviews that happened that day.
- workfromspace 3y agoThere's a newer version from the same channel with 50 different views: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7hApRZ_7v2A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7hApRZ_7v2A So shocking and heartbreaking...
- gigatexal 3y agoI was there. Not in NYC but as I was eating my Honey Nut Cheerios before early morning (530-6ish am pacific time) JV basketball and watching the news (cuz I was a nerd in high school) I watched it all go down in real-time. It’s still a harrowing experience to this day.
- ilc 3y agoI was working in the airline industry when this happened. My girlfriend (now wife) and I had just started on the way into work, we signaled each other over to the side of the road, and talked for a few moments... and I headed in to work. I was in shock for weeks. I was ontop of the towers but 2 months before that, and possibly one of the best pictures of the two of us was taken there. ... I've been there. I know that place. I have roots in that city. But I wasn't surprised as many Americans were. I knew this was very possible, though most of the scenarios I'd heard were far more grizzly than what happened. (Involving nuclear material and small planes.) I always thought the Iraq war was a pile of shit, as were most of the actions taken quickly after that day. Taking off our shoes, and the TSA are an awful legacy of an awful day. The terrorists did win. They encouraged us to give away our freedoms for safety theater. So we did. This site is proof... they won.
- elromulous 3y agoThey encouraged us to give away our freedoms for the illusion of safety.
- ilc 3y agoUpdated my comment to reflect that. I agree with you.
- blackfawn 3y agoTechnically we have Richard Reid, the "shoe bomber" to thank for having to remove footwear, from an attempt which happened later the same year: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Airlines_Flight_63_(2001) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Airlines_Flight_63_(2... But your point is still valid!
- ilc 3y agoAlas, they decided the underwear bomber was also a big threat... Thus the MM wave machines where they can see your privates. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna38561251 https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna38561251 is a good example. The TSA is a bad idea done badly.
- tfandango 3y agoI was laid off at the time so I watched this happen live on TV. Later I delivered meals-on-wheels while listening on the radio and discussing with all the folks I was taking meals to that day. So surreal. I remember thinking it was a terrible accident until the other tower was hit, then total disbelief that they fell. Then a month later I went to work in a quarter-scale (I think) replica of one of the twin towers (BOK Tower, Tulsa, OK) and one of our clients was almost completely wiped out on 9/11. The few remaining employees were trying to rebuild the company and we were trying to help them by hosting the little thing we had sold them. All of their backups were also in the tower. Really sad.
- jihadjihad 3y agoI haven't seen this site before, this is very well done. I was in middle school at the time at a camp away from school, so I never saw the broadcast until later in the afternoon. Extremely stressful to watch the time period between the coverage of the damage from the first plane and the second plane hitting the South Tower. It really captures that nearly extinct feeling of switching between channels frantically to keep up with the coverage.
- caseysoftware 3y agoI didn't find out this story until years later but still amazes me every time I see it.. regular people stepping up and saying "I have to help" Tom Hanks narrates the epic story of the 9/11 boatlift that evacuated half a million people from the stricken piers and seawalls of Lower Manhattan. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=18lsxFcDrjo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=18lsxFcDrjo
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bayesianbot 3y agoI just love these real time real life retrospectives, yesterday I thought I'm not going to spend time watching these again but here I am.. Any other good ones around? I've watched the Estonia[0] a few times (easier as a Finn), I think I've seen one about the 2004 Tsunami one but can't seem to find it (or might remember wrong), and Apollo 13[1] as well. edit: On second thought I don't think the tsunami one might make that much sense, probably was just a collection of videos and news captures. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5tbah19qo8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5tbah19qo8 [1] https://apolloinrealtime.org/13/ https://apolloinrealtime.org/13/
- Mobil1 3y ago[flagged]
- Mobil1 3y agoOnce upon a time on September 11, 2001, a dedicated journalist named NJ Burkett found himself at the heart of one of the most tragic events in modern history—the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center in New York City. NJ Burkett, a seasoned reporter for ABC7 New York, was known for his expertise and compassion in delivering news to the public. On that fateful morning, he, along with his talented photographer, Marty Glembotzky, were assigned to cover the breaking news near the Twin Towers. As they rushed towards the scene, little did they know that they would soon find themselves in the midst of chaos and devastation. With cameras rolling and a sense of urgency in their hearts, NJ and Marty began reporting from just below the burning towers. The initial shock of the situation radiated through NJ as he absorbed the enormity of the unfolding events. However, his professionalism kicked in, and he focused on relaying accurate information to his viewers, fully aware of the immense responsibility he held. But as fate would have it, just as NJ was delivering his report, the unthinkable happened—the first tower began to collapse. The once towering icon was now crumbling down before their eyes, spewing debris and smoke into the sky. In an instant, the scene turned into a frenzy of panic and confusion. NJ and Marty, with their journalistic instincts, quickly grasped the severity of the situation. With bravery and determination, they managed to make split-second decisions that would save their lives. In the midst of the chaos, they navigated through the smoke-filled streets, struggling to breathe, their hearts pounding with adrenaline. Embracing their training and experience, NJ and Marty found a way to safety, escaping the collapsing tower just in the nick of time. Although physically unharmed, the emotional toll was immeasurable. NJ Burkett and Marty Glembotzky had witnessed firsthand the sheer devastation of the attacks and the tragedy that befell countless innocent lives. In the years that followed, NJ Burkett continued to report on the aftermath of 9/11, covering the stories of resilience, healing, and unity that emerged from the rubble. His dedication to journalism and the compassion he showed towards the survivors and victims' families exemplified the spirit of hope in the face of unimaginable tragedy. The events of 9/11 forever changed the lives of those who experienced it, including NJ Burkett and Marty Glembotzky. Their bravery, resilience, and commitment to delivering accurate news became a testament to the strength of the human spirit in the face of adversity. And so, their story remains a reflection of the countless individuals who demonstrated courage and humanity on that unforgettable day—reminding us of the importance of journalism in providing a voice and telling the stories that matter most.
- linsomniac 3y agoI had a fairly weird 9/11 realtime experience. I had pulled an all-nighter and ended up going to sleep right around the time this all started happening. So I went to sleep blissfully unaware, and then was woken up by my wife. Within 30 seconds of being woken up I learned: "4 planes were hijacked. They were flown into the World Trade Center. The WTC collapsed." I kept waiting for the punchline, but then realized it wasn't coming...
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoSomething similar from my side. Was in college, on the West Coast, and had no early classes so I was still asleep. It wasn't until the girlfriend's family called her and woke her up - that we found out something was wrong. They were on the East Coast and her father was flying that day (just ended up grounded and stuck for a few days). But I don't think we woke up until 8 or 9am PST, Noon East... so by the time we were awake it was "over". Totally surreal to wake up to something like that. I don't think anyone at the entire College did anything but watch the News channels, even though there wasn't anything "new", for the next 2 days.
- sophacles 3y agoOne of my college housemates barged into my room and woke me up with "dude you need to turn on your tv". "What channel?" "It doesn't matter...". TV warms up in time to see a replay of the second plane hitting. I was groggy and said "woah good effects... what movie is this?". The guy (who was rarely serious) looked me in the eye and said "this is real". The world changed that day, in ways we're still figuring out.
- bowsamic 3y agoDoesn't seem to work for me in any browser
- suckitsam 3y agoThere was a video I saw once several years ago that claimed to sync up ATC audio and flight radar of commercial and military traffic, but I haven't been able to find it since despite a couple cursory searches here and there. IIRC, it was a custom animation/overlay like they use in documentaries and newscasts, not a screenshot of FlightAware or anything. Any chance anyone knows what I'm talking about and has a link?
- jihadjihad 3y agoI'd be interested in seeing that as well. The only thing I can think of that is similar is the interactive Apollo 11 in Real Time: https://apolloinrealtime.org/11/ https://apolloinrealtime.org/11/
- civilitty 3y agoI was in elementary school on the West Coast at the time so by the time I was getting ready for school, one of the towers had already collapsed and I woke up to apocalyptic scenes on television that I first thought was a massive earthquake. In class, no one said a single thing about what had just happened which made me feel like I was going crazy. It still makes me feel sick to this day what happened afterwards. I was too young to really understand the implications but even as a child, the march to war felt so very wrong.
- sanderjd 3y agoI wouldn't say "even as a child", I would say "especially as a child". In my experience, this was a far more common experience among those of us who were not yet adults at the time, than among the adults. I have long felt that it is the greatest generational dividing line in the US. I was about half way through high school at the time, and the prevailing perspective of the march to war seems to be very different among even those just a few years older and in college at the time, than among myself and people near my same age and younger. I do think I understand it better now that I have my own children. I can imagine my fear for them driving me to supporting things that struck me as mindless vengeful insanity at the time. I hope I'll never have to find out how I would react now to a tragedy like this.
- marssaxman 3y agoI was 25 then, but it seemed like mindless vengeful insanity all the same. The entire national character seemed to change, almost overnight, in a bleak and awful way; I felt like I was standing in the surf while a powerful wave receded, water and sand and gravel all rushing away around me, while I remained in place. I have felt like a foreigner here ever since, still a citizen but no longer an American.
- sanderjd 3y agoYeah. But would you say that your view was the prevailing one among people your age? Or, as I think you're implying, that you were more the odd one out, including amongst your peers? Because unless I'm assuming wrong, I think your experience is in line with what I said. My experience was different than yours though. It wasn't until I started mixing with more "grown ups" during college that I realized that actually the prevailing view among people even just a little older than me seemed to be in favor of the war, whereas the view I was familiar with from my own crowd of people my age was the opposite. And as I have talked to more and more people over time, I have continued to feel that this is basically correct about the prevailing view by age at that time.
- Olphs 3y agoHmm the times are somehow all messed up, current time shows 4:xx PM, the timeline shows things happening from 2:xx AM, and the controls show 8:xx AM
- novia 3y ago"Real time" but they don't have it in the EST timezone...
- tekla 3y agoI was a kid living in the Bronx that day. I remember parents picking their kids up for no explained reason, the fucking TV cart showing the news, and going outside and seeing the smoke plume and the air smelling like burnt shit. Several kids in my class had parents who died on 9/11
- wizerdrobe 3y agoThe TV cart… That’s probably the memory for many (most?) grade schoolers, isn’t it? Was in a gifted and talented class that morning, we had the budget for a dedicated TV in the corner that stayed on all day with a global map showing the time and the position of sunlight moving over the globe. The administrators had a master controller that switched all the TVs in all the classrooms over to the news at the same time. Have little memory of the actual news but do remember having an old, stern southern lady (the kind that would paddle you if she still could) suddenly crying quietly as we watched the news that day. That and our similarly elderly main teacher setting time aside the day before the invasion of Iraq to talk about the seriousness of going to war and what it meant for families. How she remembers her town before Korea and Vietnam. With hindsight I wonder why Afghanistan just didn’t get talked about in the same seriousness as the invasion of Iraq. Afghanistan just kind of quietly happened, but the build up to Iraq just held more weight.
- mrguyorama 3y ago>With hindsight I wonder why Afghanistan just didn’t get talked about in the same seriousness as the invasion of Iraq. If you weren't for war you were violently shouted down as unamerican and undemocratic and unpatriotic. It's a simple as that. This applied to US senators just as much as it applied to average americans. "Our country is under attack and we are at war" was the hammer used to suppress any argument, especially the one talking about how Bush clearly wanted a war even before the attack.
- lacoolj 3y agothis is a very educational and well-made retelling with compiled live events. I'm glad someone has done this
- alwinaugustin 3y agoNo idea how to use this site. It is showing some random footage.
- epiccoleman 3y agoI was in 4th grade when this happened. A relatively normal morning quickly turned into a bunch of kids sitting in class watching the news. My memories of the day itself are hazy. I was too young to really understand, of course. It's pretty harrowing to watch the footage up to the second impact. The sudden change in tone from somewhat detached coverage of something we were yet to understand is really something. The shock of the newscasters when that second plane hit. Crazy how easy it was to see that second impact with all the cameras turned on the building. I didn't expect my heart to pound the way it is from watching this. Chilling stuff.
- mrwnmonm 3y ago[dead]
- zug_zug 3y agoThere's something so emotional and compelling about the spectacle of shared tragedy (even smaller ones like oceangate). However there's always a reminder in the back of my mind that what makes our heart leap is very poorly correlated with what things ought to scare us. I don't know if it's possible to "Reprogram" one's heart to worry less about very high-visibility low risk things (like air travel, or terrorism in the US) and care more about statistically probable ones that SHOULD scare us (heart disease and such), but I wish it were. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DwKPFT-RioU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DwKPFT-RioU does a great job of giving a sense of what the proportions are of relative tragedies in terms of loss of life.
- konschubert 3y agoTraffic deaths
- postalex 3y agovery cool site, thank you. I didn't have TV that day, all I knew was from cnn and nytimes and fevered word-of-mouth, but years later I had a chance to dive into the various digital archives (including https://archive.org/details/911)—and https://archive.org/details/911)—and what a remarkable time capsule they are. one result of that was this, a channel-browsing glimpse of America just before it happened https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMVTB2aVUg0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMVTB2aVUg0
- HumblyTossed 3y agoThe US was so complacent in their idea that nobody would ever attack them that even commentators live on air speculated that some sort of navigation error might have caused it. Even after the second plane hit.
- afavour 3y ago> The US was so complacent in their idea that nobody would ever attack them I don't think that's true. There was an attempt to bring down the WTC in 1993 after all! Authorities were taken by surprise by the method of attack. Hardly surprising since it hadn't been done before. Up until that point a hijacked flight almost always meant a ransom attempt, so you didn't shoot the plane down, you got them to land and began negotiations. It's really easy to look back in hindsight and say authorities should have done X but there really was a great deal of uncertainty. It's not even clear what could have been done about the second plane.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoNone of that is even what I'm talking about. The people watching it, in real time, commenting on it, didn't even speculate that it could be an attack. Even after the second plane. That's complacency.
- snypher 3y agohttps://youtu.be/2ZwwCNoPa1w https://youtu.be/2ZwwCNoPa1w Possible terrorist attack was mentioned by on air reporting before the second plane hit.
- jihadjihad 3y agoIt's not complacency, it's professionalism, and there are several counterexamples to your claim on the linked page.
- mariojv 3y agoIt's a little shocking how different the pre-9/11 mindset was. At 9:07am on CNN, the reporter speculates that perhaps there was an issue with electronic navigation equipment that would have led two planes to hit the towers.
- afavour 3y agoFor anyone in or near NYC, I can recommend a trip to the 9/11 museum. I expected it to be some flag wavey exercise in "patriotism" but there's a section inside where the events of the day progress as you walk through. Even as someone who knows all about the events it was absolutely chilling to walk through.
- flir 3y agoThere was a piece of footage shown on British TV. Street scene, camera tilted slightly upwards, and something flashes across the screen from top-left to bottom-right. Fast, just a few frames. Never saw it again (admittedly I didn't look very hard). Don't suppose anyone knows what I'm talking about, do they? Would be nice to know it's not a false memory.
- jve 3y agohttps://youtu.be/wmweNhFtHQY?si=logloz89r6tlLl6Y&t=550 https://youtu.be/wmweNhFtHQY?si=logloz89r6tlLl6Y&t=550
- anshumankmr 3y agoI was four when this happened, and what I remember is being in my grandparents house watching it unfold on the news while being on the other side of the world, not sure if it is a real memory or a figment of my imagination, but my parents did tell me the attack did profoundly disturb me. It truly does feel weird that people a few years younger than me didn't watch it happen live and even I was one of those people who was too young to truly comprehend what the hell was going on, except for developing a massive feeling of anger against the perpetrators.
- Balgair 3y agoAdding my memories: My little brother woke me up that morning. Said that the Twin Towers were falling down. It was just the start of my sophomore year in high school in the SF Bay area. My first real indication that everything was going bad was that the T.V was on. Mom never allowed it on in the mornings before school. I managed to get out of bed and get downstairs in my underwear and was just able to see the second plane hit. Mom's face went grey. Dad was in the kitchen. Mom said the magic word that told everyone in the family that things were officially bad: "Oh ... fuck" Mom never cursed. I remember looking at my siblings, we were more in shock that Mom even knew curse words. Then we all got pulled into the kitchen too. It didn't help that Grandpa was dying in Tuscon. Lots of strokes from years of smoking. Mom and my aunt were planning on going that day to Arizona, but, very obviously, we knew that wasn't going to be by plane now. There were a lot of calls back and forth on the landline in trying to figure out how they were going to get down there. The T.V. was reporting all kinds of crazy stuff too. The pentagon, something in Pennsylvania. We just watched and tried to eat breakfast. Mom and Dad, bless them, had no idea what to do either. So they managed to get all the cash and valuables in the house and split it up five ways, a portion for each of us. It was a lot of money and jewellery. I remember getting a solid silver elephant, about three inches across, that Dad had gotten for Mom some year. I never did bring myself to actually counting it. Dad shoved all the cash into our backpacks. We figured that going to school wouldn't be a bad idea. My High school and my sibling's schools were all around the same place, right next to the police station. Dad brought me into the garage, gave me his 1911 and a spare loaded magazine. It was so heavy and cold. He showed me how to turn the safety off. How to press the magazine release. How to slide it back to cock it and pull the bullet out. I remember thinking that those bullets were really big. Told me: "You're a man now. Whatever happens, you are responsible for your siblings. Don't use this unless you have no other choice." We put it in the bottom of my backpack with all the cash. I remember thinking that I was a real gangster now. We all agreed that we'd meet up in Tuscon at my Uncle's place in exactly one year if everything went to hell. I had no idea what the address was, but I said I'd get my siblings there no matter what. We said goodbye to Mom. She went and pick up my aunt and and they drove to Tuscon. Managed to see Grandpa just before he died that day. They must have driven crazy fast to have made it in time. School was a blur. Mostly just watching the TVs on carts or up in the corner of the room. Some teachers tried teaching, that was pointless, we all knew it. But we had no better ideas either. Dad picked us up from school that day. Another strange event, it was always Mom that picked us up. He said we were going to have apple pie and hot dogs for dinner, because that was more American. We only had hot dogs because Dad can't bake. I don't remember giving Dad back the pistol, but must have. Went to scouts that night with the whole family. A lot of people brought the whole family to scouts that night. I remember one of the kid's Dads talking about his friends in NYC. He started to well up, but fought it back. We all knew it was because he thought that us kiddos couldn't be seeing him cry too, needed to stay tough in the chaos. It was alright though, we all understood. Later on, one of his sons, a few years younger than me, joined the Marines. He died in Iraq. They said his head exploded like a Gallagher watermelon when the sniper's bullet hit. Another kid in the troop, about the same age, 'cleaned his gun wrong' on Paris Island because he couldn't handle the Marines. Lost a few people in my graduating class too. My best friend's cousin died in Afghanistan. The family have always blamed Bush for that. I remember Grandpa's funeral. He was a colonel or somesuch in the Air Force. So we got to have the funeral on the Air Base there in Arizona really soon afterwards. I remember all the guns pointed at our heads as we drove on to the base. Having to weave through all the barricades. He manged to get a spot in Arlington, one of my uncles pulled some strings and got Grandpa a place. I didn't go to the internment, but there was a 14 gun salute, my Mom said. A real honor, I'm told. One of my older cousins on my Mom's side decided to up and drive to Ground Zero to help out. He was helping dig through the debris for a while. He never talked about going out there and helping though. My Uncle, the one that pulled the strings for Grandpa's internment, was near the Pentagon that day, had to walk through the smoke to get back home. He said it was really bad smelling because they used horse hair for insulation in the Pentagon. I always put up the flag on 9/11, for Grandpa and for everyone else and for all my friends that died because of what it kicked off. It's not much, but it's something. I don't know how to end this. I just wanted to share some of what happened to me that day and in the time afterwards. Thanks for reading.
- somsak2 3y agotimestamps at right need to be clickable.
- yabbs 3y agoWhat about the part where afghan, I mean Iraqi, I mean Saudi passports come fluttering down. 22 year old long con.
- 37469920away 3y agoSo cool. An episode of I Dream of Jeannie is on WTTG at 11 AM.
- qingcharles 3y agoDoes anyone else remember how the Internet died that day? There was so much traffic from everyone trying to check the news that every major news site went practically offline. The only way to find out what was happening was to find a TV. Lucky I was working with a friend to install a touch-screen PC in his car. We'd added a TV tuner to the system too. We raced to the underground car park and pulled the car out onto the street and sat there watching the news unfold on his 7" widescreen.
- sunnysidedown 3y agoI was on my way to my eighth grade civics class that day, in northern Virginia. I remember before class, a lot of people started talking about the Pentagon exploding (many kids had parents working there) and that's when it started to get out exactly what happened. People left school early, getting picked up by family members, etc. I distinctly remember someone asking my civics teacher, "who could have done this?" and she said she would bet her life it was Osama Bin Laden. That was the first time any of us had ever heard that name or understood what terrorism actually meant. We were all too young to remember any other bad things happening in America, besides perhaps Columbine and had been pretty convinced America was invincible after finally "beating" communism in 90's and Desert Storm. Over the next year or so, we talked about it so much and were inundated with so much coverage that I became almost completely numb to these sort of events, and eventually extremely depressed. It's taken me becoming a parent to reconnect with the horror of what happened and now I have a hard time sitting through coverage of Ukraine as it relates to its impact on children.