3 ms·
Why have desktop UI’s gotten so bad lately? My theory is that before we had UX experts, they had to hire, like, actual graphics designers.
by bee_rider 3y ago
Why have desktop UI’s gotten so bad lately?
My theory is that before we had UX experts, they had to hire, like, actual graphics designers.
- api 3y agoI think a lot of it is the other way around: graphics design driven by branding rather than UX. I also think the death of native development has a lot to do with it. The web is now the UI layer of desktop, but that means there is no consistent design language across the system.
- simulo 3y agoThis is very similar to what Grudin suggests in his HCI history "From tool to partner": Apple used to be very usability and research focussed in the 80s and early 90s, but turned away from it with Jobs and went more look-driven — and had great success with it. Other companies followed. (Which does not mean that companies ignored graphic design before, but it was the more utilitarian parts of graphic design that were important focussing on distinct shapes, readability etc.)
- api 3y agoTrue but I don’t think this gets it quite right. The big problem with classic Mac was the cooperative multitasking weird OS and the unstylish and clunky hardware. The UI needed polish and modernization but was not fundamentally bad. The complete loss of OS coherence has a lot more to do with the web than anything else.
- jwells89 3y agoFrom my perspective as a dev, this is what happened: UI designers who had been trained on usability, who had a good grip on what was/wasn’t feasible technically, and knew to take content variability into account were almost wholesale replaced with more generalist print/graphic designers who were great at pumping out pretty branded PSDs, but not so great at producing usable UIs. My guess is that this happened because real UI designers are harder to come by and cost more, while generalists are more common and cost less. I’ve not hired for these positions though so I don’t know for sure.
- api 3y agoIt can also just be a result of oversupply of certain college degrees. Back in the late 90s to early 2000s there was a big trend of graphic design degrees at universities probably far in excess of available jobs for that specialty. I knew a bunch of these and many went into web design, and now I’m sure are doing UI design now that the web engine is the de facto standard UI engine everywhere but mobile. (Even on mobile it has an increasing presence.)
- dotnet00 3y agoThere's also the perverse incentive created by having dedicated UX people. At some point the UI is at a good point and doesn't need significant improvement, but the UX person needs to justify their existence, so changes happen just for the sake of making changes. To me, Discord's UI - especially on mobile - exemplifies this perfectly. They change the image upload process every few months, alternating between various levels of decent and terrible design. First it used to be one tap, then they put it in a submenu, now it's back to one tap but uploaded images get grouped together requiring tapping on them to scroll through, so we're forced to upload them one by one to have them show in the more convenient old way, making it still strictly a step back. Add in the managers who think that not having large UI changes every few years is a sign of stagnation regardless of reason.
- deeg 3y agoI think this largely explains it, along with a desire for the UX designers doing something new and "modern". This explains a lot of user-unfriendly changes in other areas, too. I worked for a prominent travel web company and the army of people in marketing were constantly looking for new sources of "incremental revenue" to justify their work. This led to pop-unders and pages packed with more ads than content.
- internet101010 3y agoSpotify has made a lot of changes in the last 2-3 years and most of them have been bad. A couple of instances come to mind. The first was with CarPlay. They went from list of thing (playlists, podcasts, etc.) that you click on to get to a new section to a home page with a row of useless tiles and a "view all" that is difficult to get to if using something like a scroll wheel in a BMW. Thankfully the feedback was so bad that they reversed the decision. They made the mistake of thinking that everyone with a touchscreen in their car uses it. The second is everything related to podcasts. Podcasts and music need to be completely isolated from one another because the method of browsing and maintaining are completely different. To this day there is no way to simply view a list that has all episodes for podcasts you follow and sort by recently updated. There is a "new episodes" thing that exists but if you click on something and back out it gets removed from the list. This assumes it is even updated, because clicking into loads from cache rather than doing a refresh. The only safe way to get an updated list of episodes is by hard closing the app and then re-opening it.
- tjpnz 3y agoIn the past many involved in frontend design might've had a background in human factors or ergonomics, they would also have some knowledge of how the brain perceives what's in front of them. I would view this knowledge as quite fundamental but it's increasingly rare to find such expertise in the field now. In my mind it explains a lot in terms of how many UIs are an incoherent mess and why accessibility is considered an afterthought, if at all. Doesn't matter who developed it either. FAANG are just as adept at flubbing basic design principles as anyone else.
- dgb23 3y agoMy theory is that UI has the exact same problem as programming: We don't know what we're doing. - Corporate interests lead to enshitification and chasing after local maxima. - We never learn from the past, new blood comes in faster than seniority can deal with. - Trends and fashion give us comfort and a superficial feeling of (faux) improvement. - Preferring change over stability. - Vague methodologies and adages that sound good, instead of dry, actionable quality metrics. - Proliferation of bureaucracy and marketing. - Productization instead of standardization leads to a lack of foundations that can be relied upon.
- pseudalopex 3y agoUX replaced HCI. Graphic design replaced science.