10 ms·
Heat pumps show how hard decarbonisation will be
- Footkerchief 3y agohttps://archive.ph/5P9Qj https://archive.ph/5P9Qj
- triyambakam 3y ago> Green policies had seldom required private citizens to roll up their sleeves and make big, disruptive changes to their lives. Now they are starting to, and many people do not like it. This is the problem. Putting so much of the burden on the consumer and hardly any on the manufacturers, companies and so on. Consumers contribute just a small percentage of the problem but are being asked to account for much more.
- cvccvroomvroom 3y agoSolving huge geoengineering problems require full lifecycle participation, not a fight or passing the buck. We can't individually recycle or plant trees our way out of this with significant CC&S that must be done with economies of scale.
- rayiner 3y agoConsumers are ultimately the ones that account for all of the problem. Not a drop of oil gets pumped from the ground without the consumer demand. And the thing about climate change is that consumption is much more equal than financial wealth. A Wall Street banker doesn’t have a carbon footprint that much higher than a regular person. Maybe even less.
- pharmakom 3y agoCarbon consumption is still highly skewed.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe average net worth of someone who flies private is $190M, and flying private has an outsized carbon footprint. Okay if we tax those miles and pay Climeworks (direct air carbon capture is currently the only legitimate carbon offset mechanism) to suck the CO2 back out of the air? This is not even hard, we can bill based on their ADS-B broadcast flight track. Agree that the problem with the investments of the wealthy driving climate change is consumer demand that needs to be destroyed (EVs, heat pumps, solar, factory farming protein, etc). https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/04/carbon-footprint-gap-between-rich-poor-expanding-study https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/04/carbon-f... https://www.oxfam.org/en/press-releases/billionaire-emits-million-times-more-greenhouse-gases-average-person https://www.oxfam.org/en/press-releases/billionaire-emits-mi...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DennisP 3y agoI think that's a great idea. But taxing private flights won't do that much on its own. From googling the other day, flying is 2% of total carbon emissions and private jets are about 1% of that, for 0.02% total.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe problem is there is no one single solution, but a bunch of them executed in parallel. Which makes sense when everyone globally is treating the atmosphere like an open air burn pit for combustion.
- alanfranz 3y agoThere’s no single activity that accounts for 50% of carbon emissions. And if there was, we probably all contributed to it. We need to shave co2 off everything, as if we were doing weight reduction to a bicycle.
- lukas099 3y ago> direct air carbon capture is currently the only legitimate carbon offset mechanism Source and/or explanation?
- Spivak 3y agoYes and if you change what's on offer you'll see the demand change. Consumers are good and service takers, the only person that can stop releasing carbon is the person actually releasing the carbon. You will never move a river by asking each drop, you build a dam.
- laserdancepony 3y ago> A Wall Street banker doesn’t have a carbon footprint that much higher than a regular person. Found the millionaire coping with his excessive consumption. No really, I don't own a car, don't fly, don't go on cruises, don't go on vacation three times a year any other way, live in a 50 sq m flat without anything but the most basic amenities. And you know why? Because I'm poor, that's why. Like most of Earths population. So don't try to tell me my carbon footprint is the same as Gordon Geckos, it simply can not be true.
- ericjmorey 3y agoThe US military is by far the largest consumer of oil.
- throwaway894345 3y agoConsumers don’t demand “products manufactured from fossil fuels”, they demand products (full stop). Indeed, I suspect most consumers have an environmental bias which isn’t reflected in the market for lack of transparency (how do you tell if a product is green or merely green washed?) and also because fossil fuels are and have long been heavily subsidized.
- morsch 3y ago> A Wall Street banker doesn’t have a carbon footprint that much higher than a regular person. Maybe even less. That is just not true. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/04/carbon-footprint-gap-between-rich-poor-expanding-study https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/04/carbon-f... There are many other sources.
- godelski 3y ago> Consumers are ultimately the ones that account for all of the problem. You got this backwards. It's like trying to clean up a river by only picking up trash at its mouth. You're not going to do a great job. Consumers can only buy what's available. Most people are too poor to make choices other than that on price. Capitalism can work great for price reduction but one way to do price reduction is quality reduction. If the whole non-luxury market is focusing on price reduction and the easiest way is to achieve that is quality reduction then guess what happens. On the other hand, if quality has to hold constant -- which happens when consumers are less price sensitive and won't go for a slightly cheaper option when competitor tries quality drop -- you have to research and build better and/or cheaper. BUT if most major players try the same strategy of quality reduction at the same time then consumers never get the chance to indicate to the market that they value quality. > A Wall Street banker doesn’t have a carbon footprint that much higher than a regular person. Maybe even less. Maybe don't guess and check first. We're on the internet, you don't have to respond immediately and state something that is verifiably false. While we don't have good refined data on specific jobs, there is strong correlation with wealth levels and specifically consumption rates. But if you're modeling a Wall Street banker as someone who works all day, takes the subway, sleeps, and never takes vacation then sure, that's lower. But don't confuse the mean and the median. Edit: Taking our analogy from above: if all producers simultaneously have to do "x" then all consumers automatically also choose "x". This is where regulation can play a role since you can do things like "all cars must get at least 50mpg" or have a more market driven approach like "$100 fee per ton CO2eq" and use that fee to perform such actions like sequestration and/or research to make sequestration effective and cheap.
- tonyedgecombe 3y ago>Consumers can only buy what's available. We live in an era of unprecedented consumer choice. Especially for the rich who you rightly pointed out are the source of the problems we are trying to ameliorate.
- godelski 3y ago> We live in an era of unprecedented consumer choice. In some ways yes, in some ways no. Markets aren't exclusively driven by consumers and such framing is incredibly naive. You can't buy the fruit that doesn't exist.
- jabradoodle 3y agoSorry but this is insane. I want electricity, or more accurately I want to heat my home, wash my clothes, etc. It is not my consumption that has caused us to continue subsiding oil and not investing properly in renewables for over half a century.
- solardev 3y agoWhat do you mean? Aren't consumers usually on the trailing end of these sorts of things? In the US at least, and especially the West Coast, things like SEER (HVAC efficiency) and CAFE standards (car fuel economy) have been steadily rising, at least until Republican officials push back. Building codes include better and better rules for renewable energy production, insulation, etc. In the private sector things like LEED encourage buildings to utilize better materials, passive heating and cooling, water management, etc. Those are all constraints on the manufacturers and companies. Where consumers are encouraged to change to newer appliances, grants usually help cover the costs of new fridges, LED lights, HVAC equipment, sprinklers, etc. Heat pumps as a consumer phenomenon didn't even catch on until very recently, decades after regulations spurred market innovation. Maybe it works differently in Germany, but here at least it seems like we go way out of our way to incentivize consumer behavior over decades instead of forcing through overnight changes. Could it be a marketing issue, where governments and manufacturers making these iterative changes don't really broadcast them to the public at large, such that when the changes finally hit the average homeowner, they are still caught by surprise? To them it might seem like a sudden change even though it's been happening behind the scenes for years?
- michaelt 3y agoIt depends on how you want to attribute carbon emissions. If Brits want to hear a Taylor Swift concert, and Swift's private jet crosses the Atlantic twice emitting 700 tonnes of CO2 emissions in the process - are those Swift's emissions? Or have 900,000 concertgoers each emitted 7kg of CO2, equivalent to driving 2 miles? What about if, instead of Taylor Swift tickets, we consider electricity? More consumption directly increases the power plant's emissions - but consumers can't control whether coal, gas, nuclear or solar supplies their power. If you take the view that corporations' emissions are attributable to the corporation, not their customers - then corporations are much, much less green than consumers. And we'd need to focus more on emissions by giant corporations, and less on plastic straw bans.
- solardev 3y agoI get what you're saying, but I think it's less about assigning blame in a "us vs them" situation and more of a "how can we clean up the whole system lifecycle" question. The CAFE model seems to work for that. It doesn't really matter whether it's the driver or the car manufacturer, taxpayers front the regulatory research and costs, manufacturers moan and whine then eventually comply to some degree, consumers buy cars with slightly better mileage each year, over time things get better. Then Tesla comes around and makes electrification a reality, etc. Similarly with the solar market, subsidies spurred investment and research and deployment and helped foster growth, until there is so much of it that (say) California's grid can hardly keep up, China saw the market and took it over, etc. These days it's a commodity. Government carrots do work, is all I'm saying. You can create demands and markets through planned public investments. Sometimes, though, we do blame fossil fuels companies, whether they're using tankers or oil rigs or pipelines. Sometimes those controversies can help spur better protections and safety regulations and whatnot, but at the end of the day your point stands: from a climatic standpoint the emissions are there whether we attribute it to a single company or a million individuals. Maybe the accounting is different and helps different political players, but the atmosphere doesn't care how we divvy it up. IMO Taylor Swift flying in a private jet isn't that different than, say, OpenAI making a bunch of CO2 for a product that millions of people end up using, or Larian spending a bazillion CPU and GPU hours to make Baldur's Gate, or some politico flying back and forth to attend climate meetings. At the other extreme, Greta sails low impact and has great marketing, but that only goes so far. We still need everyday solutions that mid size companies and governments can implement on actionable timescales. That typically means low hanging fruits like more solar, more batteries, occasionally nuclear, incremental standards, etc. Is it enough? No, not nearly. But I think it's more than we've gotten from, say, Greenpeace or PETA. People generally respond better and faster to carrots than disciplinary punishments...
- paulcole 3y ago“Consumers contribute just a small percentage of the problem” is only true if you believe 100% is a small percentage. This is the attitude that shows that “fixing” climate change is doomed. Everybody can find somebody else who’s “worse” to blame the problem on and so they justify doing nothing themselves.
- callalex 3y agoThe whole “corporations are the real polluters” is absolute political nonsense that people lie to themselves about to justify their own lazy resistance to change. It’s not like Shell pumps oil out of the ground because they think it’s fun, they do it because people buy the oil to transport themselves and heat their home. It’s not like coca-cola wakes up every morning and thinks “wow I wish there was more plastic litter” they make beverages that people purchase and drink. It’s not like steel companies just really get their giggles from turning rocks into liquid by using a ton of energy, they are making washing machines and stoves and trains that people use to live their life.
- paulcole 3y ago100% correct take and it’s no surprise you’re downvoted with no replies. I understand why people cry that “corporations are the problem” but I can’t believe that deep down they believe it.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoIt's not that surprising. Not only do they absolve themselves of any blame but they also get to point the finger at somebody else.
- akamaka 3y agoThat’s not taking into account that there is a vast difference in how much pollution is emitted by different oil producers during extraction and refining. Some companies have invested into cleaning up their operations, while dirtier oil sources emit a full 1/3rd of their total pollution before the fuel even arrives at the gas pump.
- jabradoodle 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExxonMobil_climate_change_denial https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExxonMobil_climate_change_de...
- whelp_24 3y agoThe personal responsibility theory of pollution was made up by these corporations you are defending. The reason that companies make products is to sell them yes. But the reason the products are made in polluting ways and with essentially unrecylable materials is cost cutting. Regulate industries to use the more expensive but less impactful production methods, and you find that pollution will actually go down in a way that matters. Tell individuals to stop buying plastic bottles and you'll get a subset of the middle to upper class to somewhat comply. Make plastic bottles illegal (or at least mandate that the company buy them back to really recycle) and the problem becomes moot, it's not like individuals can make plastic. Same for fuel, waste disposal, etc, etc. The only thing consumers could do is buy less, but life makes that rather hard. The companies that you are trying to absolve lobby to make that harder.
- Glench 3y ago> This is the problem. Putting so much of the burden on the consumer and hardly any on the manufacturers, companies and so on. Between space heating, transportation, water heating, and cooking, about 42% of energy-related emissions are things that consumers have some control over in their homes. We have to decarbonize both the supply side (which is happening super rapidly with wind/solar) as well as the demand side (which is much harder because it requires coordinated action across millions of people). And we have to do this incredibly swiftly to keep a livable climate. Source: https://www.rewiringamerica.org/pace https://www.rewiringamerica.org/pace
- MattGaiser 3y ago> for the 60% of European properties that are old and leaky, their installation must come with extra insulation. Shouldn’t this be fixed no matter the heat source?
- bafe 3y agoI'd also think so. Better insulation should mean lower energy demand for heating (and cooling, but as you might imagine residential AC is almost non-existing in central Europe)
- laserdancepony 3y agoIn my experience this has been a source of problems as well. Tacked on insulation tends to keep moisture in, ruining the walls over time.
- c0pium 3y agoIf you do anything wrong then it can cause problems, sure. Is that what we should base our decisions on?
- MaxMatti 3y agoIt's always easier to choose the option that costs less to install but more to use. That's why lots of homes have poorly insulated pipes and lots of people use cheap printers that require expensive ink.
- lazide 3y agoHeating with gas doesn’t cost more to use (at least now), and doesn’t require the insulation either. Thermal heat from gas is cheap, even when gas is expensive. Gas has a LOT of btus. Furnaces are also far simpler to make and maintain than heat pumps, which is why they are still so popular. Boilers can go either way.
- bhewes 3y agoYeah as far as residential building tech rehabs Europe is at least 50 years behind. To go into a use an infrared camera and plug it with insulation is easy. There are also geothermal heat pumps that work fine. Edmond, OK incentives geothermal installs in homes as its lowers the city's peak electricity costs. That said Edmond's average household income is $108k for a 31k households city in one of the cheapest metros in the country so they can afford it.
- jdadj 3y agoSeems like the article is addressing two orthogonal issues — home insulation and heat pumps. They are suggesting that heat pumps depend on improved home insulation. Why? Is the idea that heat pumps don’t pack enough punch to replace boilers on their own, and they need to be combined with a more efficient building envelope in order to be sufficient?
- morsch 3y agoGas heating in old construction heats up the water to 80+C. Heat pumps typically result in lower temperatures. This is not an issue in new construction, which often has floor heating or special radiators. But old construction has radiators that struggle to heat up the interior at these water temperatures -- unless you improve the insulation, which is sensible anyway.
- jibbit 3y agoYes that’s correct. The heat pump is more expensive to run than the gas boiler it replaces, and can’t match the output.
- chii 3y agowhich begs the question - why would anyone switch from a gas boiler to heat pump then, if they only consider economic utility, and none of the externalities?
- pretendgeneer 3y agoThat's not true. Heat pumps are cheaper to run than gas heating, I removed my old single room gas heater for a ducted split system total cost reduction was 30% even before Russian invasion caused gas prices to spike. And house is much warmer. Gas boilers generally produce much hotter water, so the radiators they use tend to be small. Heat pumps gain more efficiency if you can reduce the output temperature. So running a heat pump at max efficiency through radiators designed for a gas system, won't put out as much heat into the room. So you have two options, increase the size of the radiators or increase the insulation. It's better to increase the insulation as you gain the benefit of both warmer room and less energy required to heat a room.
- solardev 3y agoSomething I don't quite understand about the article: Why is insulation tied to the heating source? In any given house, per unit of heat generated is going to leak out at the same rate no matter how that heat is produced, no? Whether that heat comes from a gas boiler, a heat pump, or a resistive heater shouldn't matter...?
- eisa01 3y agoUK and Germany has a hang up that they need to reuse the existing radiators, so you sometimes need to do extra work But it’s quite stupid: In both countries you need AC, so why not install a mini split heat pump+AC system like the Nordics and the US? It also doesn’t help that they don’t tax fossil gas like electricity, hence you often need subsidies to make it worthwhile to switch
- laserdancepony 3y ago> But it’s quite stupid: In both countries you need AC, [...] Almost no residential building in Germany has AC, and I'm unsure what you mean by "need". Also the buildings are built to last, so no remodeling every few years like in the US. That means one is stuck with most of the utility built into the house from the start. Remodeling a regular central European brick-and-mortar house to accommodate floor heating or duct vents is difficult and expensive.
- bafe 3y agoSpeaking from Switzerland: most building until recently were clearly built for cold winters, not hot summer. They are often insulated quite well and well heated, but recent summers showed that they aren't suitable for hot weather: they lack AC, rely simply on open windows for ventilations and frequently have too many large windows that can't be darkened enough, hence letting a lot of heat in
- RamblingCTO 3y agoI agree with that take. Being like "look at Germany, we don't need ACs" is outdated bs. I absolutely suffer for almost 2 months a year because I don't have an AC including lack of sleep etc. We will see a rise, even though some people feel like that's the wrong thing to do with the climate change. There's a fine line: if you have green energy, why would you care? Consuming more green energy actually improves the overall situation, as more money is available to build out green energy in the first place (especially with things like Green Planet Energy). It's just the need for moral superiority for some folks that's stopping AC distribution in central Europe imho.
- mperham 3y agoI don’t get the point? They point out two issues: picking an installer and adding insulation to the home. How are these hard or disruptive? We switched to a heat pump last year and couldn’t be happier. It was quite expensive but Federal subsidies are now available with the Inflation Reduction Act in effect. The real issue here is that the HVAC industry is quite conservative and still commonly recommends against heat pumps. This is the real political difficulty to overcome and the IRA’s buckets of money will do it. Europe needs the same.
- brightball 3y agoThere’s a company in Australia making a coating that increases efficiency of heat pumps by 40-50%. Going to be interesting to see the impact. https://graphenemg.com/thermal-xr/ https://graphenemg.com/thermal-xr/
- solardev 3y agoIs that really the bottleneck, though? They are already dramatically more efficient than combustive or resistive heat. But they are usually not drop-in replacements, and it's harder to retrofit older single family homes with them, vs a smaller apartment where you can just drop in a mini split and take out the old furnace.
- Ekaros 3y agoIsn't that basically increasing the surface area? It makes sense at scale, but couldn't you reach same effect with 50% bigger area anyway? And I would expect that the surface area is already optimised to be close enough to what is needed. So for residential I wonder if there is any real gains there.
- Angostura 3y agoHow expensive? I live in a old terraced house in the UK (no cavity wall, wooden floors open to cellar below). Adapting the house to be suitable for heatpumps is going to require cladding the whole of the house, redoing the floors, replacing the external front door and replacing all the radiators. It's going to cost tens of thousands of pounds.
- oergiR 3y agoIsn’t the main problem the cost of heating? In the UK at least a kWh of electricity cost 4 times what a kWh of gas costs. Even if a heat pump is twice as efficient as gas heating, the cost of heating is still twice as high.
- theGnuMe 3y agoThey could incentivize it by subsidizing a heat pump use rate. There’s technology to identify these remotely I imagine.
- foolfoolz 3y agoi bought a gas water heater this year. my old one was leaking with no way to stop the leak without turning off water to the house. to put in a heat pump water heater ($5-6k) and get the subsidies ($4-5k) i would also need to hire an electrician. and get permits. to run a high voltage dedicated line. this would have taken weeks to schedule and complete and cost nearly $10k upfront with maybe half getting paid back later. not exactly a good solution with leaking water i paid $2700 and had it done the same day
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoI am now getting the impression that any collective action in the West, that is harder than downloading an app, gets called 'hard', 'impractical', etc.
- acumenical 3y agoI doubt anyone here has planted a tree. We talk of action and do nothing. Every time I mention trees, I am told that instead we need expensive contraptions made out of mined materials, that usually require an external source of power. Instead of putting a tree in the ground and letting nature do its job, we have tricked ourselves into thinking that nature doesn't know enough. In our hubris and delusion we will end our species and the rest of nature will scratch its head and wonder why.
- ricardo81 3y agoFair point. I've donated to a few local forest trusts. My personal pet peeve about biomass is the use of artificial grass.
- jquast 3y agoI only own a half acre of property and it’s chock full of them. I live in the United States, there isn’t any land that I would plant on in my county that isn’t owned public or privately, that the gas and oil or electricity companies won’t cut down, much less the commercial timber industry which takes up about 50% of the land, anyway, I’d love to plant trees but what would you recommend, trespass on private company and hope the owner doesn’t clear it out?
- jquast 3y agoAlso it’s more than just planting, they need careful tending for the first few years, whether fertilizing or fighting aphids or disease, I don’t want to just volunteer to plant trees in some far away place nobody tends to, lots of those “plant a million trees” programs become “maybe a hundred thousand survived” stories, especially if care is not taken to use an appropriate tree for the conditions it is planted. Anyway I’d just like to know what you think about “gorilla growing” because very few people own more than an acre, and, especially where I live, people are very hostile about trespassing, it could get you killed
- sgt 3y agoI planted an oak tree, but that darn thing is really taking its time!
- tzs 3y agoA practical problem with heat pumps is that they keep changing the damn refrigerants. I've got an old heat pump and the refrigerant it used, R-22, stopped being using new systems about 10 years ago, and production was banned a few years ago. It is still legal to sell existing stock and to use it in existing units, but the price has skyrocketed. I'd like to replace it, but the refrigerant that replaced R-22, R-410a, is now being phased out. Manufacture and import was banned starting this year. It is being replaced with R-454b. Systems cannot be retrofitted to use R-454b, so getting an R-410a system means getting a system with an already doomed refrigerant. If I buy a new system in the next year or so, when R-454b systems become available, is that a refrigerant that should remain available new for the lifetime of the unit, or is it too going to get banned in 10 years?
- Kirby64 3y agoR22 was banned from new HVAC units in 2010, and was only banned from import in 2020. R410a isnt even banned from new HVAC until 2025, and they've stated they'll permit importing until 2037 for maintenance purposes. Seems pretty straightforward that you can easily/cheaply service the unit for at least 10 years, then after that you're going to need to potentially pay a lot more.... which seems entirely reasonable, given that the service that requires lots of additional refrigerant is exactly the problem the EPA is trying to solve: refrigerants leaking into the atmosphere. Honestly, I'd be much more worried about being able to find parts for the complicated heat pump systems (electronics, mostly) 10+ years down the road than I would about being able to find refrigerant.
- wkat4242 3y agoYou can't keep getting consumers to buy new equipment though. It should be lifetime approved. The same way old cars don't have to meet new environmental standards.
- Kirby64 3y agoIt is, though. You're free to continue using an HVAC system with R22 today. You can even refill it with R22, albeit at the expensive price of current R22. This actually just like a car. At some point maintenance cost exceeds the value of the car and it is no longer feasible to continue keeping it. So you scrap it, or sell it to someone else. If you're frequently refilling an old HVAC (R22 or otherwise) it means that it has a leak. And that's precisely the thing that the EPA wants people to not do, since it's damaging to the environment. HVAC units should never leak, ever, if they are working properly.
- ricardo81 3y agoPart of the problem is getting the right advice, the right people to do a job and the cost. Lots of UK houses are built <1930 and have suspended floors. I was told in various quotes for floor insulation because of tongue and groove floorboards, they'd get damaged when lifted and would have to be replaced. I managed to keep them having insulated the floor with 300mm rockwool just this past month. Not only is there the benefit of heat retention, but hopefully it will kill a lot of draught entering the house also. The wholesale gas price spike meant this would have paid for itself in around 5 years (I have a combi boiler), but will perhaps be closer to 10 now. Cost all in: £400 for insulation, £1000 labour, £800 flooring replacement £200 various. If I'd went through an accredited installer I could've received a Home Energy Scotland grant of £1500. I'd still need to insulate my (600mm whinstone solid) walls for an air pump to be economical.
- atoav 3y agoJust be aware that insolution moves the dew point of your walls. You might have to ventilate more (or even add active ventilation).
- ricardo81 3y agoIndeed. We have also replaced doors/windows, the latter having trickle vents. Floor has a permeable cover holding the insulation up and goes over the joists. I think for the walls it'll be PIR boards. I can't insulate outside as it'd be out of character with the street.