14 ms·
Touch Pianist
- turtlebits 3y agoWishlist - As a piano player, the left and right hands really need to be broken up into separate rhythms (esp for grace notes), also it needs a sustain pedal. Maybe as an advanced feature.
- Ylpertnodi 3y agoMagic! Using velocity for accents, tapping out odd-time signatures on a regular piece is so much fun! #Zappafan
- ckocagil 3y agoRachmaninoff's Prelude (op 3 no 2) is incredibly fun to play!
- saaaaaam 3y agoAs my piano teacher used to say, “what did the piano do to you to make you hit it quite so hard?” This is known as the “Moonlight” sonata not the “thunder and timpani” sonata. It’s a great demo but the dynamic range of your piano robot is horrible. Oh! Can I adjust the dynamics based on where I touch? I take it back! Bad workman blames his tools etc.
- thruway516 3y ago"Thunder and Timpani sonata" sounds like it would be a fantastic piece especially if written by Beethoven
- broscillator 3y agoHis 17th sonata is know as the tempest, close enough.
- thruway516 3y agoWow! Thankyou very much! That was beautiful. New and genuinely good ideas are truly rare and I feel you've possibly discovered something here. I can just imagine the possibilities if one could also somehow vary the dynamics as well just with touch. Alas force-touch screens are probably not coming soon to consumer cellphones soon but now I can visualize a good reason for them. Edit- apparently this was from 8 years ago. The app does not appear to work on my modern iphone 2nd edit- it looks like I can vary loudness or softness depending on where I tap on my phone, at least on the website 3rd edit: Having way too much fun just playing the moonlight sonata at different tempi with different loud and soft passages. Tapping as fast as I can with 2 fingers is a new revelation of this piece!
- joshspankit 3y agoI immediately got OG iOS app vibes and wanted it on my iPad.. But the reviews... There are ads on top of in-app purchases? And the fact that there are songs for $0.99 (which let’s be honest are probably sourced from freely-available MIDI files and plugged in to the already-made engine). I’m going to heartbrokenly stick to the web version.
- A_Duck 3y agoBeware that at least on my iPhone 14 the app doesn't work — no visuals, which makes it impossible to use properly That aside, this is an amazing idea. Would happily pay for a working version
- drukqs 3y agoAs a professional pianist that's spent the past couple of years obsessing over questions of tempo, breath, phrasing, movement and musicality, this app really tickles my fancy. Some casual observations: - As someone who has delved a little in DAWs and working with MIDI, one thing that struck me is when controlling velocity with on a physical, linear scale, exactly how little extra velocity is needed to voice a melody properly. For example, playing Moonlight on my phone, I play the opening notes as quietly as possible and voice the melody by playing a few bare "millimetres" more to voice it. - It has really forced me to know the music in a different fashion, as a single, additive rhythm as opposed two hands with two independent rhythms. For example, the first few bars when the melody enters in Moonlight sonata: I wasn't sure if I keep the fidelity of the dotted-eighth rhythms verses the triple eighths, or if I turn it into essential a sextuplet. - I found that some quicker figures, such as the opening of Mozart's "Alla turca" are best achieved by using the actual fingering I would use in the original. At a certain speed, in order to achieve the rhythmic precision required, I had to use piano technique.... on my phone screen.
- notmypenguin 3y agoI like this. I feel like it conveys proportional relative intervals visually as well, so it’s teaching you patterns correlated in audio and visual geometry
- petarb 3y agoThis is incredible. Thank you for sharing.
- jacobp100 3y agoNo audio on the website. No audio or graphics in the app (except menus). iPhone 12 mini on latest iOS 16
- Kaibeezy 3y agoModel M piano is clicky
- Elias-Braun 3y agoMade my day : D
- clouddrover 3y agoIt's quite similar to this one: https://sunebear.github.io/Piano-Flow/#/pieces https://sunebear.github.io/Piano-Flow/#/pieces
- Waterluvian 3y agoI adore this because intentional or not it shows you how critical tempo and a bit of legato can be to giving the right piece the right mood. You have one singular job here and the way in which you do it drastically affects your interpretation of Beethoven.
- matiasfernandez 3y agoTempo rubato! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempo_rubato https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempo_rubato
- IAmGraydon 3y agoVelocity is also critical, but it’s doing that for you.
- gnrlst 3y agoI only noticed half way through you could adjust velocity depending on vertical touch. Really nifty! More expressive and fun than I expected. Bravo.
- Timpy 3y agoI noticed that too! This could be a fantastic learning tool, my music professor described how to crescendo into the tension and decrescendo into the release but being able to experiment with this tool could help you get an idea of what you want to do before your fingers have the right touch to do it.
- Condition1952 3y agoIt would be great if I could see the music script instead of some bubbles
- adzm 3y agoI was surprised I could recognize the song just from the bubbles without even having audio enabled
- franky47 3y agoI love how tapping an irregular rhythm (eg xx-xx-x-) gives Beethoven a progressive metal vibe.
- tgv 3y agoOr hitting four keys at the same time in a waltz rhythm (so a "one" that's slightly longer that two and three). I couldn't make this piece sound funky, though, probably because of the triplets that all move in the same direction. But try Rach's Op 39, no 6. You can play it like salsa/son.
- bowsamic 3y agoI don't really get it
- tomelders 3y agoIn music, the performer can either perform the music as written, or they can inject emotion into the piece by changing the velocity and timing of the notes. This app lets you inject the emotion through timing, even though you don’t actually know how to play piano. It also lets you focus entirely on the “feel” of the piece. I found it really fun.
- 7thaccount 3y agoWhat's the first song? Beethoven's what symphony?
- hackton 3y agoBeethoven Sonata No. 14 "Moonlight"
- philbarr 3y agoLet's hope it doesn't have the third movement in it or else we'll be needing new keyboards.
- nyanpasu64 3y agoIt does have the third movement. I tried it for shits and giggles: - Playing fast sections of a song is like mashing through a cutscene, but it's easier to press quickly (not sure at a consistent pace) with multiple fingers. The original piano music was meant for multiple fingers as well. - The hardest part is advancing the right number of buttons. I don't even know the right number of notes in the trills, and would kinda prefer if the website automatically advanced through trills finer than a 16th note, so it's less likely to end up desynced with the actual piece (I'm not sure if you get used to it with learning each piece or not). - The website has noticeable audio latency, which makes it hard to associate keypresses and which sound came out in fast sections.
- maxweylandt 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piano_Sonata_No._14_(Beethoven) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piano_Sonata_No._14_(Beethov...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pluc 3y ago[flagged]
- bestest 3y agoI like the idea, but there's a delay. It's noticeable enough to be annoying and making it impossible to play out the pieces exactly as I would like to. It just feels like when I get in a rhythm I end up being one tick forward. Or is it just me?
- bdangubic 3y agono delay at all for me
- bestest 3y agook, no delay on their app, and in there the experience is very satisfying. the web version seems to _feel_ somewhat better when using the touchpad instead of the keyboard, but still not the same.
- coldtea 3y agoNo delay on the web version to me. Probably depends on the system/browser/specs/etc.
- flappyeagle 3y agoAre you using Bluetooth headphones? AirPods have a delay that makes playing rhythm games impossible
- bestest 3y agothank you. it was bluetooth to blame in general (was using external speakers). now all delays are one.
- Fnoord 3y agoBluetooth codec is to blame. Some Bluetooth codecs are (very) low latency. I used my phone speaker. My daughter (5) loved it, thank you. Was odd it only worked once in Firefox Mobille (Android). I had to install Vivaldi (badum-tsh) to get it to work again. Was a let down it was only one song.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ADcorpo 3y agoI am sorry if this is not the place to discuss it and will remove my comment if needed, but seeing websites "highly recommending" the use of Chrome seems like bad taste nowadays, especially with what's going on with WEI.
- thecosmicfrog 3y agoIt seems to work fine on Firefox for Android. I wonder what the author's concern is that he'd recommend Chrome?
- ADcorpo 3y agoMaybe they only tested in Chrome and do not want to address complaints coming from users on a different web browser, who knows I just get real «this website was optimized for internet explorer X» vibes from this, I really do not want the web to end up back to this state.
- rockdoe 3y agoIt's not like putting that message there will stop those complaints, more like the opposite.
- junon 3y agoI loved this. Unfortunately the android app seems to be taken down, so no La Campanella :(
- andybak 3y agoYeah. I spent money on it back in the day but it was never updated.
- johtso 3y agoGreat choice of song! If you ever have access to a piano, I highly recommended trying to fumble your way through Beethoven's moonlight sonata, even if you don't know how to play piano. Not quite sure how to put it into words, but it's absolutely exhilarating hearing your own fingers produce these huge sounds and intense chord progressions. Every time I managed to find the right chord I'd get such a rush. "Oh no he didn't.. he went _there_!?" This webpage gives a little taste of that feeling. If you enjoyed it, try to give the real thing a go!
- globular-toast 3y agoI can't not cringe slightly when someone calls something like Moonlight Sonata a "song".
- johtso 3y agoReading back my comment now, I know what you mean! I guess "piece" would have been a better word, or even just "music".
- globular-toast 3y agoYeah, just music. I have heard people use song to mean any music before, though, so it's probably something I have to deal with. I do like some songs but 90% of the music I listen to is comprised of either tracks/records (electronic music) or pieces (classical).
- omoikane 3y agoMoonlight Sonata is a great choice, the arpeggios makes the song quite recognizable. (I don't play the piano but have learned the guitar version of Moonlight Sonata, and it looks very much like this version.)
- yawnxyz 3y agoI agree! This really gives a taste of the feeling of playing moonlight for real on the piano. I also realized there are some notes I might have been playing wrong for many years (oops)
- oerpli 3y agoIf one were really great with this - would it be possible to reproduce both the Richter and the Gould version of the WTC 1 Prelude in C Major (except maybe some flourishes)? For reference, the first few minutes of these links: - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1osi_pQcUdM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1osi_pQcUdM - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pjnKuhcfB6U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pjnKuhcfB6U
- verelo 3y agoPrelude in C is what i went to try look for before hitting the upgrade screen! Agreed, that piece changes so much with tempo, i was excited to play with it.
- Loodvigvanbtovn 3y ago[flagged]
- ktpsns 3y agoReminds me of https://hackertyper.com/ https://hackertyper.com/ (and clones)
- superpope99 3y agoIf you try this on Bluetooth headphones the latency will kill any rubato you're trying to inject into this
- fdgjgbdfhgb 3y agoWow, this really puts in to perspective how hard the Appassionata is - I could barely keep up with the tempo doing the trills with one hand, I can't even imagine actually playing it. One day maybe :^D
- jacquesm 3y agoOnce upon a time I realized that Bach had invented macro expansion. The occasion was me trying to figure out why Partita 1 doesn't sound at all the way the notes are written, and what is that little wavy thing over the notes? It turns out that that little ornament expands into an 8 note sequence centered on the note written. Not that there weren't plenty of notes already on that page... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9etK1RuN2jc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9etK1RuN2jc 42 seconds in.
- dddddaviddddd 3y agoI love that they have the Bach Partita -- I used to listed to this piece on repeat https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vuPr9m98XQQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vuPr9m98XQQ Knowing the melody makes it a lot easier to 'play' in this app.
- ctenb 3y agoVery fun. Though nothing seems to work in Chrome except for the tutorial piece.
- 0x445442 3y agoPiano Hero with one thumb, I like it!
- magic123_ 3y agoLove it! It could be even more awesome if the velocity of each key press had an impact of the volume, that way we could control two properties at once.
- dietketchup 3y agoVelocity is controlled by where you tap the screen (vertically)
- magic123_ 3y agoAh yes indeed, but I don't think it can be controlled if you're using a physical keyboard. For instance if I play using the keypad on my keyboard, 1 could be pianissimo and 9 fortissimo.
- danpalmer 3y agoI'm not sure I get it. On desktop I just click to play the next beat? On mobile there's no audio (in Safari or Chrome). And the track selection appears to be broken? Have I missed something? What's the pull here?
- intrasight 3y agoI had audio in Safari. But it didn't start right away.
- danpalmer 3y agoHow long does it take to start? I've given it a few minutes and still nothing. I'm on fast stable wifi and the audio worked immediately on a desktop on the same wifi so I can't imagine it's having trouble downloading the samples.
- intrasight 3y agoSafari iOS - started in after perhaps 8 taps
- dceddia 3y agoIt doesn’t make sounds on my mobile Chrome either (iOS) but I’ve noticed other sites don’t either. I’m guessing there’s a setting somewhere that I denied once long ago and now it can’t play sounds :/ If anyone knows what that might be please let me know!
- Matticus_Rex 3y agoIs your phone on silent?
- dceddia 3y agoHahah yes, yes it was.
- 3y ago
- pama 3y agoWith a lockdown-enabled iPhone I only get a loading page that says chrome highly recommended.
- philbarr 3y agoThis is a great kind of thing for getting people into music. There's a piano in my local pub and when people say they "can't play piano" I'll play a 2-5-1 in C and tell them to hit any of the white notes. People love that they can make up their own tunes having never played before.
- Ylpertnodi 3y agoThe pedant in me is screaming - ii V I
- WWLink 3y agoHere I was doing barre chords on the 2nd fret, 5th fret, and 1st fret on my guitar and wondering why it didn't sound good. ;)
- yayitswei 3y agoI do this too! D dorian works great as well.
- aldanor 3y agoAnd then you show them the black blues note...
- kqr 3y agoI was miserable for most of my piano lessons (I learned to sheet read well – I become a fairly adept piano-playing robot – but I never sort of "figured out" music more generally.) That said, one lesson my teacher played a basic blues chord progression and told me to hit anything on the blues G scale however I wanted. That was one of the most fun times I've had making music ever. Well, the only time that has been fun, actually.
- jefftk 3y agoIf you want to do this with someone who doesn't play, the experienced person can play in Eb and then the black notes make an Eb blues scale.
- quafan 3y ago[flagged]
- thatxliner 3y agoIt’s kind of funny how trills work in here.
- grav 3y agoNice idea. I'm really missing a way to contol the dynamics. Maybe just mapping 1-9 keys to a velocity scaling?
- gnrlst 3y agoOn touchscreen vertical height of the touch is mapped to velocity - really nifty
- amiga386 3y agoI tried out Rondo alla turca, and it's almost like a puzzle, because it's mixing left and right hand into one stream, and if you were used to doing those two separately, you're going to futz it
- igtztorrero 3y agoLove it ! I allways want to learn and play piano !
- keymasta 3y agoThis was one of the first pieces I tried to learn as a kid. I would just restart it repeatedly because my Casio keyboard had a library of classical music on it that one could listen to by hitting a function key and then a unique white key. I think it's something that Casio did in the late 80s - mid 90s. They don't seem to use the old song library much or at all anymore, but I thought it was a great feature. So I'd just restart from the beginning and learn the next note. Guess-and-check. As an adult I've continually tried to learn to read sheet music, with frustration. So I learned jazz theory and invented my own music theory system. Now I encode most pieces harmonically in my brain. It would be cool to see this kind of indication in the app, so for example, the first couple lines: 3/4 |C#mi| | | |C#mi/B | | | | |A | |D/F#| |G#5(b6)|C#mi/G#|G#sus|G#7 | ... I like to use this as a jam idea, for example play it like a montuno.
- trialect 3y agoI love the way how NOONE mentions that it is not available on android: "We're sorry, the requested URL was not found on this server." https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.earslap.touchpianistapp https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.earslap.to...
- dceddia 3y agoOh man! Thank you for posting this. I saw this here on HN years ago and loved it, and then could never find it again. Judging by the YouTube videos linked from the page, it looks like 8 years ago?! I got chills playing through it. Awesome to see that it's still up on the internet after all those years. It's interesting to compare the comments here to the original launch 8 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9490372 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9490372 And the Reddit post from the same time: https://old.reddit.com/r/InternetIsBeautiful/comments/34vcmz/oc_reddit_i_made_a_musical_browser_experiment/ https://old.reddit.com/r/InternetIsBeautiful/comments/34vcmz...
- quakeguy 3y agoWow!
- vermes22 3y agoClicked on the link to see the post's year and quite surprised that 8 years ago was actually 2015 and not 2005 as my system 1 (Kahneman) memory imagined at first!!!
- dang 3y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Touch Pianist – Tap in Rhythm and Perform Your Favourite Music - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9490372 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9490372 - May 2015 (100 comments)
- CapsAdmin 3y agoI thought it was very interesting how something so simple was able to make me zone in. Even though I can only control the rythm and velocity, it really felt as if I was playing somehow.
- mpsprd 3y agoFunnily enough, I found gymnopédie #1 harder to play, even if I actually already played on the piano. Its like if muscle memory of actual piano was fighting it.
- cloogshicer 3y agoDoes anyone know how this does the playback in the browser? Is it WebAudio? I tried to reverse engineer it but couldn't figure it out.
- thruway516 3y agoCreator has a nice writeup here: https://earslap.com/article/the-browser-sound-engine-behind-touch-pianist.html https://earslap.com/article/the-browser-sound-engine-behind-...
- cloogshicer 3y agoAwesome, thank you!
- glitchc 3y agoNah, it's no good. Especially with the Moonlight Sonata. Each chord in a bar requires both left and right hand notes. I try to press a key with each hand, but that counts as two keystrokes, whereas it should only count for one. It teaches the wrong muscle memory, definitely some work needed around chords.
- x0n 3y agoYou is doing it wrong. This game is not about chords, it's about tempo.
- glitchc 3y agoUnfortunately it doesn't feel like a game. It's a bit too close to the real thing. The multiple dots often beg for a multi-finger press. If it's really meant to be a tempo game, why not show one dot, chord or otherwise?
- petermcneeley 3y agoSame energy: https://hackertyper.net/ https://hackertyper.net/
- das_keyboard 3y agoIt seems like the Android version is not (yet) available despite it being advertised for Android.
- stouset 3y agoI think it's the opposite. This is quite old software which hasn't received App Store updates in years. It's likely the Android version has been pulled from the store or otherwise bit-rotted.
- qwertymon 3y ago[flagged]
- theoperagoer 3y agoThis is so cool. I'm a huge classical music fan. I wish you could distinguish between "right" and "left" hand keypresses to control each line separately
- david927 3y agoyes! This was my request as well. And maybe a "learn" mode where you can see the original timing or the timing of a famous interpretation, like ghosts in video games. Love it! Thanks so much for doing this.
- qwertymon 3y ago[flagged]
- lysp 3y agoThat was a lot of fun. I know the first movement off by heart so that was fairly easy. Third movement was much more fun - trying to get some of the timing on that was pretty tricky. Had to alternate between 2 fingers and then throw in the 3rd one for some of the trills.
- cflyingdutchman 3y agoiphone app is broken for me, and according to reviews, many others. I paid the $12 for full access and currently unplayable. Notes don't load, song does't start - help!
- Condition1952 3y agocould Apple give you a refund?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kaichanvong 3y agosuch a Great choice of song, especially since plugging round the ears any headphone, earphones to help the player's enjoyment. How they push it out into MIDI is beyond...
- jdjdjdjdjduuuu 3y ago[flagged]
- Matticus_Rex 3y agoGoogle Play app link says "We're sorry, the requested URL was not found on this server." Surprisingly satisfying -- I think my heart rate dropped a good 10 bpm in a few minutes of playing. I'd love a little map to know how far I am in the song, and some way to work pedals for dynamics for more advanced users; I don't play piano, but I'm a musician and am familiar enough with many of these pieces to have opinions on the expression. If I could map it to custom keys that would be perfect -- I happen to have flight pedals. Obviously that's atypical.
- yafbum 3y agoPretty cool... the third movement of that piece would be... something else!
- frud 3y agoThat was nice.
- blazebegin1 3y ago[dead]
- zengid 3y agoVery cool, great job! It looks like this is using PIXI for the graphics?
- shimonabi 3y agoCan someone suggest some good piano learning software? I really don't like subscriptions. Many years ago I used Voyetra Teach Me Piano Deluxe which ran on Windows XP, but gave up after some time. I think I'd have to create a virtual machine to run that again. My town is so small I can't find a piano teacher.
- Popeyes 3y agohttps://sightreading.training/ https://sightreading.training/ might be useful for you. This old thread go mentioned a while ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16482104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16482104
- Popeyes 3y agoQuite entertaining it as the volume knob on my keyboard counted as an interaction.
- glonq 3y agoI installed this on my phone and have never had so much fun with a 6-inch pianist.
- dwighttk 3y agoWeird lag on my iPhone…maybe Bluetooth headphones are to blame?
- bestest 3y agoquite probably. had the same issue on osx safari desktop with bluetooth speakers.
- julianeon 3y agoApp idea inspired by this that I'd like to see: Something like this, that has a big library of songs, where you specify the delay between notes and the speed at which it is played (ideally w/all notes displayed so it can be really really customized).
- SubiculumCode 3y agoOne thing I noticed about this piece is that the one thing that kills its spirit is too steady of a tempo... it is actually quite amenable to an extremely loose interpretation of tempo, with swings of 300% in the pace feeling both natural and moving ....like the tempest of the storm...sometimes racing, sometimes deliberate. Try it here by listening t the mood of the music and clicking faster or slower...its quite amazing.
- tantalor 3y agoOn web, opening up the "choose differnet piece" window, then clicking a piece does nothing. Expected would close the window and load a new piece.
- ldjb 3y agoI'm using a Microsoft Surface and had the same problem when trying to click using the trackpad, but tapping it on the touchscreen worked.
- SkyArrow 3y agoOpen up developer tools, choose "toggle device toolbar" in the top left (or equivalent in other browsers), pick a tablet device, and set orientation to landscape. This lets you simulate touch events with your mouse.
- rolandog 3y agoIn some cases, like with Mozilla's Firefox mobile browser (also tested in Chrome), you can request that the "Desktop site" be shown; that workaround allowed me to choose different songs. There are also a couple of pages that seem to have a copy of the com.earslap.touchpianistapp APK, but I can't vouch for any, as I don't have a disposable mobile with which to test at the moment.
- havaloc 3y agoThat works in Safari, but not Chrome for some reason.
- grondilu 3y agoI would love to watch someone who's never heard Beethoven's moonlight sonata try this.
- j7ake 3y agoThis is like the piano version of hacker typer. https://hackertyper.com/ https://hackertyper.com/
- turtlebits 3y agoMore pieces and menu "button" don't work for me on Chrome. It'd be nice to see actual note lengths and rests so the user can learn how to read actual notation, maybe as an alternate view.
- j7ake 3y agoIf there was a way to adjust volume based on force that would be a game changer.
- pstorm 3y agoThe higher on the screen you play, the more velocity!
- btbuildem 3y agoVery pretty. But. Have you tried pronouncing the name of the website out loud?
- sidechaining 3y agoI don’t get it?
- btbuildem 3y agoThink immature
- shashanoid 3y agoWOW I love
- lostNFound 3y agoSad to see author abandoned it. Last iOS update 8 years ago. Not working in current iOS.
- Nezteb 3y agoI wanted to see how fast I could play the entire song: const interval = setInterval(() => document.getElementById('pixi-canvas').dispatchEvent(new MouseEvent("mousedown", {bubbles: true})), 0);
- tiborsaas 3y agoThank you for this snippet, it inspired me to play to add some randomish groove :) function play(i) { document.getElementById('pixi-canvas').dispatchEvent(new MouseEvent("mousedown", {bubbles: true})); const wave1 = Math.sin(i); const wave2 = Math.sin(i * 8); const mod = ((1 + wave1 * wave2 * wave2) * .5) * 350; delay = 150 + mod; i += 0.01; setTimeout(() => { play(i); // console.log(delay); }, delay); }; play(Math.PI); Here's the wave: https://www.desmos.com/calculator/aqs7thumdm https://www.desmos.com/calculator/aqs7thumdm
- rkuykendall-com 3y agoIt's fun adjusting the final number here. I found 100 to be entertaining.
- alana314 3y agorip headphone users :D
- Hadriel 3y agoi cant change the music? clicking isnt working
- Calamitous 3y agoI had to switch to Safari for the menus to work correctly.
- michael1999 3y agoLol. That's fun, and frustrating! I can't manage tempo just repeating the same key on my short-travel keyboard, and if I start wandering around the keyboard, my old piano lessons start messing up my "fingering".
- darkerside 3y agoAs someone who paid many of these Beethoven sonatas growing up, I love this. It's like guitar hero! You get to not worry about a whole class of things and just focus on your timing and dynamics. It would be really cool to be able to work voicing in, but I can't think of a way short of another piano! Random question, but... why is everyone in this thread referring to volume as velocity?? I feel like I'm taking crazy pills.
- sthatipamala 3y agoI think that’s the term used for synth music
- darkerside 3y agoAhhh interesting, thank you!
- greatNespresso 3y agoLove it! No tutorial needed, works on mobile, relaxing
- scop 3y agoI love this, especially for Bach’s counterpoint. To be able to go through pieces I know at a speed I dictate, giving myself however long I want to “hear” the chords in their relation to the previous chords, is just magic.
- norsurfit 3y agoAnd my mom said I'd never learn piano without practicing!