5 ms·
Is this giving away the keys to the kingdom? Is the blur on the videos enough to keep the proprietary components concealed? Seems like a state actor could easi
by echelon 3y ago
Is this giving away the keys to the kingdom?
Is the blur on the videos enough to keep the proprietary components concealed? Seems like a state actor could easily reverse this filter and learn the underlying shapes.
How much isn't revealed by this tour? This seems like it's giving away quite a lot of the EUV process. Or has all of the content of the video been publicly known (or stolen previously)?
I get that this might excite young people into entering the field, but if the US is trying to gatekeep advanced processors, this feels like showing off a lot of the secret sauce.
How long do we think it'll take a foreign actor to replicate EUV, and how far along do we think we'll be into the next process by then?
- tw04 3y agoI doubt images alone are enough. China has had access to Russian jet engines for half a century and still struggles to produce their own.
- geodel 3y agoSeems they are skimping on 3-D printers from AliExpress. :-)
- skhr0680 3y agoIf you give professional chef an elaborate dish and the recipe for it, will they be able to make exactly the same thing?
- numbsafari 3y agoProbably not, in isolation. But can the original chef that wrote the recipe produce the same thing several million or billion times a year?
- iancmceachern 3y agoWe can't even replicate the F1 engine, or make new nukes anymore, and we have the recipe book and the chefs.
- rbanffy 3y agoWe can’t make F1s because the supply chains that made the materials and the parts no longer exist. We could try to approximate one with new materials and techniques, but it would not be an F1 - it’d be a design derived from it. That’s the thing with the chefs - you can’t make a mammoth dish because there are no more mammoth to cook.
- iancmceachern 3y agoYes they do, the supply chains still exist, we still use many of those alloys, etc. We still make rocket engines. In the F1's case we were just going too fast and didn't write things down. In the nuclear weapons case we deliberately dismantled it.
- rbanffy 3y ago> In the nuclear weapons case we deliberately dismantled it. I'd say that is actually a good thing. Nukes are meant not to be used. They are a deterrent, so it's important they exist, that they are functional, and that you are willing to use them to hit hard against an aggressor. MAD kept us alive until now.
- sudosysgen 3y agoChinese fighter jet engines are supposedly already better than the best Russian jet engines they've been given, though. General perception is that the WS-10 is generally better than the AL-31FN, hence why they started replacing AL-31s with WS-10s, both in domestic and export aircraft. The WS-15, if it does get even close to it's design goals, would be significantly better than any Russian engine. They seem to be struggling a lot with airliner engines, yes, but they've only recently even considered making them. Even then, the WS-20 has entered service, and if it matches claimed specifications, it's as good as anything Russia has either.
- kkzz99 3y agoThe recent leaked picture showing a J-20 with dual WS-15 puts their development on par with F-119/F-135. Lets see how quickly they can ramp up production. It seems they have fixed their supply chain issues.
- ls612 3y agoIt seems easier to make an engine that gives very high power at the expense of efficiency than an extremely efficient engine with reasonable power which is what airliners want.
- sudosysgen 3y agoIn the Pacific, efficiency is the main goal for fighter jet engines. The goal of the WS-15 is to have F-35 level efficiency while being able to go relatively far in the supersonic regime and outrange every US plane. And of course the engines for strategic lift planes are based around efficiency first.
- ls612 3y agoI could believe the J-20 could match the F-35, and apparently the Air Force could believe it too because there’s also the F-22. And strategic lift planes use normal jet engines not supersonic ones so they face the same issue as Chinese airliners do.
- kkzz99 3y agoThey recently got the WS-20 and WS-15 which puts them very close to US engines.
- crote 3y agoPretty much all of this has been public knowledge for a decade, or even longer. The technology behind EUV is quite simple on paper, the hard part is getting it to work reliably. It would take you years to reverse engineer it even if you had unlimited physical access to a working machine, and all the truly secret sauce is in all the measurement and calibration equipment around it.
- SoKamil 3y agoWe are now two layers deep into the secret sauce. I want to know what the secret sauce of the measurement and calibration equipment is!
- bloggie 3y agoHi, I work in laser measurement and calibration. There is no secret sauce; you take a physical phenomenon that translates optical power or energy into an electrical signal, measure that signal, then find the sensitivity value of that phenomenon and account for any other effects such as ambient temperature, fill factor, linearity, parasitics etc. and then prove that your calculations are correct by comparing them with NIST/PTB.
- Animats 3y ago> The technology behind EUV is quite simple on paper, the hard part is getting it to work reliably. EUV machines are a terrible approach to the problem made to work through a huge amount of effort. Look at the size of those things. All to get a little burst of soft X-rays and focus it on a mask and wafer. With a light source that works by using lasers to vaporize a droplet of tin falling in vacuum. Creating an internal mess that has to be cleaned up. For a decade, people in wafer fab hoped there would be some other way to do this. Small synchrotrons. X-ray lasers. E-beam machines. But those approaches all fizzled out. So what ought to be a physics experiment run occasionally was hammered into being a production technology. Examples of a commercial technology that hard which went mainstream are rare. There was the image orthicon.[1] That's a TV camera tube. Previous technologies needed very bright light. Zworklin's iconoscope accumulated the image over an entire frame time, but photon to electron conversion was very inefficient. Farnsworth's image dissector had much more efficient photon to electron conversion, because it had a photomultiplier built into the tube, but only the light received from the pixel currently under the scanning beam contributed to the output - there was no full-frame accumulation. So RCA developed the image orthicon, which combined both of those technologies. It was insanely complicated and expensive. The tube alone cost about US$10,000 in the 1950. Color required three tubes. The tubes required something like ten different power supplies, and control and alignment required hundreds of adjustments. Here's someone trying to restore one.[2] All those racks of equipment for one camera. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_camera_tube#Image_orthicon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_camera_tube#Image_orthic... [2] http://earlytelevision.org/rca_tk41_restoration.html http://earlytelevision.org/rca_tk41_restoration.html
- WeylandYutani 3y agoA story about Dutch history: In the sixteenth century Dutch merchants managed to bribe a Portuguese captain into drawing them some maps. This is why the Netherlands managed to reach Indonesia on the second expedition instead of taking the 50 years it took Portugal.