6 ms·
Experts fear crooks are cracking keys stolen in LastPass breach
- Exuma 3y agoLastPass is such utter trash.
- sethammons 3y agoAmong their many failures, I am still shocked that the notes section for each password was not encrypted. All kinds of assumed-safe info will be in there from secret question answers to former passwords and account numbers. What fool of a project manager pushed for that?
- Operyl 3y ago> we need that extra 300msec of speed, Jim! Web metrics are all that matter!!!!11one
- peblos 3y agoI don’t recommend lastpass but notes were encrypted. This stemmed from an original miscommunication from a CS rep to a customer before it blew up but was later corrected. Independently verified because we can’t take Lastpass at their word: https://www.reddit.com/r/Lastpass/comments/zzz5x4/notes_are_encrypted/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Lastpass/comments/zzz5x4/notes_are_...
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoThat was my understanding as well, but there were definitely unencrypted portions like URL. I assume for sharing purposes.
- peblos 3y agoYeah you’re right, URL was unencrypted along with some others. Doesn’t seem critical if we’re talking Facebook and twitter but becomes problematic with human rights orgs and the like. The justification was that it was used to match login fields against vault items. I’m no crypto expert but it seemed flimsy to me
- gboss 3y agoI agree. I’m looking for a better alternative. Been putting it off, any recommendations?
- taberiand 3y agoDepends on your requirements but 1Password and BitWarden are decent.
- hedora 3y agoBitWarden works ok. I run the rust reimplementation of the server on a lan with no incoming port forwards. The main problem is that I can’t add or edit passwords when I am not home. I’d love another, similar, open source solution that used a crdt to merge offline database edits.
- rumblefrog 3y agoBeen loving 1Password. If your work has 1Password Enterprise, you can get a free separate personal account.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoThat is true for most services now, including Lastpass and BW (iirc).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bboygravity 3y agoI'm using Keypass with Syncthing which is really great (both on Android and PC), but I need something that can properly auto-fill forms. Lastpass wasn't great at doing this automatically, but Keypass cannot do this automatically at all. Any recommendations?
- skeaker 3y agoI run the Kee extension/plugin for autofilling with KeePass, works without issue in firefox (I have tried briefly in chrome and it seems okay there too, haven't used it nearly as much though).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- be_erik 3y agoThe warning that displays when bringing up a JavaScript console on their homepage was always enough to steer me clear of that product. Stop! reqaccts_js_bundle_jquery_3_6_1?1693888551:2732 This is a feature for developers and researchers! If you are not a developer or researcher, pasting something here could cause your account to be compromised
- yuliyp 3y agoWhy? A password manager's web site would be a natural place I'd expect people to fall prey to self-xss attacks. That they had such a warning there feels appropriate, and likely to be the result of actual attacks against users that they'd seen.
- joahua 3y agoThat feels sensible to me. Facebook (used to?) do similar. The risk here is different but you could imagine someone trying to migrate password managers and pasting a script they found on GitHub that purported to help.
- capableweb 3y agoI mean, duh? Anything that gets breached and leaked will obviously end up in various lists, and has always been doing so. > In November 2022, the password manager service LastPass disclosed a breach in which hackers stole password vaults containing both encrypted and plaintext data for more than 25 million users. Since then, a steady trickle of six-figure cryptocurrency heists targeting security-conscious people throughout the tech industry has led some security experts to conclude that crooks likely have succeeded at cracking open some of the stolen LastPass vaults. > longtime cryptocurrency investors, and security-minded individuals I'm not sure how "security-minded" you are if you, months after a breach of your password manager, still haven't changed all the involved passwords and keys, especially those involving things worth a lot of money!
- krebsonsecurity 3y agoI thought about that also, and then one of the victims I talked to brought up a good point. An 8 character password with symbols and numbers doesn't sound like a great password today, but many of the accounts getting drained were tied to people who were very early LastPass users, and mostly longtime investors. Back then, affordable GPUs that can do 4 million hash cracking attempts per second weren't really a thing. What I found was a lot of people made security assumptions and never revisited those assumptions. Or never fully did.
- gxs 3y agoHonestly, if this is truly the case, LastPass is partially to blame here. Sure, there's nothing in the TOS contractually obligating them to do this - but starting a low level awareness campaign to warn people with passwords that haven't changed in years about this risk seems like an easy thing to do that a (in keeping with the theme) "security minded" company should be enthusiastic about doing. You can't nanny everyone, but surely if you're paying for a password manager you'd appreciate these kinds of notices.
- djfdat 3y agoThey did have something like that back when I used it. It would tell you repeated passwords, passwords that have appeared in leaks, weak passwords, etc
- p1necone 3y agoI'd trust a (trustworthy) password manager with most things, but I think wallet keys or similar are more of a post it note in a locked safe kind of thing (+ committing it to memory). Maybe a passworded encrypted flash drive in a hole in a tree stump somewhere as a second backup in case my house burns down.
- wzyboy 3y agoI agree. Crypto currency private keys are something that is better stored offline instead of online. I'm comfortable storing my online banking password in an online password manager as I know even if these credentials are leaked, there are still anti-fraud department and maybe insurance protecting my money in the bank. But with crypto currency private keys? If they are leaked, those crypto currency would just be gone without any way to do a "stop payment" or something.
- osigurdson 3y agoI wonder what insurance would cost per year per Bitcoin in order to be viable?
- kl4m 3y agoWhy oh why haven't they pushed an update that made it easy to identify and change passwords that were leaked. They have the feature to identify weak or compromised passwords ALREADY. Instead a user still has to create a folder for compromised secrets, change them and move them out of the folder one by one. Best of all, users would hit a bug where moving entries to/from shared folders would destroy the entry. Edit: at least let the user (or entreprise admin) mark a vault as compromised. Must have been an absolute nightmare to get corp users to rotate their passwords.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- judge2020 3y agoSounds like they're banking on uneducated users not finding out about the breach and continuing to pay them - although I don't use the product, so I'm not 100% on that.
- ww520 3y agoAny password managers with centrally stored databases run the risk of this kind of compromise, no matter how many levels of encryption the companies have promised. The central database is just a big target.
- readthenotes1 3y ago"Monahan said virtually all of the victims she has assisted were longtime cryptocurrency investors, and security-minded individuals." Apparently this was said without laughing out loud, unlike my reading of it.
- ww520 3y agoAny security-minded crypto investors would put the cryptos in an offline wallet, with portions of the passphrase written in different papers stored in different safes.
- gambiting 3y agoSo every time you want to "invest" you have to gather this incredibly inconvenient password? Maybe I misunderstand how it works.
- ww520 3y agoYou invest by HOLD. If you trade with exchanges, that's just speculating. Also not your key not your coins. The money will be lost eventually with rug pulls, scams, or hacks anyway. Password being compromised is the least of the worries. Offline wallet making it slow and difficult to transact is a feature, less chance to be scammed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mcdonje 3y ago>...it would take a single GPU about a year to crack a password of average complexity with 500 iterations, and about 10 years to crack the same password run through 5,000 iterations. >However, these numbers radically come down when a determined adversary also has other large-scale computational assets at their disposal, such as a bitcoin mining operation that can coordinate the password-cracking activity across multiple powerful systems simultaneously. Wow. I'll bet Satoshi didn't consider this second order effect of the proof of work scheme. People who build energy intensive mining operations have the means and incentive to turn their mining operations on existing accounts when that becomes more lucrative than creating new blocks.
- havnagiggle 3y agoPretty sure Bitcoin mining has been ASIC dominated for ~8 years now. Maybe you could point at Eth which only just recently moved away from being GPU heavy.
- wkat4242 3y agoIf LastPass happened to use the exact same primitive as bitcoin this Asic hardware could still be used. Not sure if the case.
- everfree 3y agoBitcoin's primitive is sha256(sha256(x)). There's zero reason anyone would ever use a funky construction like that for password hashing.
- andirk 3y agoIs cracking a sha256(x) the same runtime as sha256(sha256(sha256(sha256((x)))))? I remember the first time I saw bitcoin's double use of sha256 like this, and I was confused as to whether there is a security benefit to this.
- ronsor 3y agoI can see it now: a developer copying Bitcoin code into his authentication library because "Bitcoin is secure"
- sunnyba 3y agoIs there a simple way to download the portion of the data that was breached for just our own account? I've switched providers and deleted my LastPass account after this last breach but getting to see that would make it a lot easier to understand risks.
- BXlnt2EachOther 3y agoUnfortunately I think you might have some work to do: it might be a good idea to change all your passwords stored in LastPass up until last year, and I'd suggest changing passwords for high-value and financial sites ASAP. I still have low-priority sites to migrate myself, this article is a nice reminder. Anyone please correct me if there have been updates here: In August-October 2022, attackers obtained, among other things, backup files containing LastPass users' vaults. I don't think the company mentioned what timeframe the backups covered, or whether this contained vaults from users who already deleted their accounts. A vault file contains both plaintext and encrypted information. The Secure Notes function which might be used for, say, crypto seed phrases, was encrypted. Passwords are encrypted. However the URLs for those passwords are in plaintext, possibly along with last-access time. Someone with your vault can see what sites you have passwords for, before even trying to crack the password. Not great for anyone but especially for high-value targets or for those who are in politically-hostile environments. Since attackers took the files from the source, it does not matter whether you had 2FA (edit: 2FA on LastPass that is. 2FA, with secret outside of LastPass, for sites in your vault is very beneficial here!). They can throw a bunch of GPUs at cracking our master passwords offline. There's nothing we can do; the horses have left the barn or rather were abducted by UFO. One other thing that affects mostly older accounts is that while modern best practice is to use 600k+ password hash iterations, some users had far smaller numbers, like 5000, or 500, or 100. Or even 1. Not joking. LastPass could have upgraded users on login for years--I believe they do now, but that has no benefit to the compromised data. [1] is an article on what might have happened: engineer with high-level credentials logged on from a home machine that was compromised from an old version of maybe-Plex (which fixed the relevant vulnerability long before). And of course the company had security practices that allow engineers to access the kit and caboodle of user vaults from their home machines, even if indirectly. In the end it seems this was caught due to Amazon's automated warnings around certain IAM change actions. ETA: I do appreciate the difficulty of guarding high-value data against determined adversaries. I also wish LastPass would have been more forthcoming as to the details here; to my knowledge they haven't provided exact details on what was taken, or suggested users change passwords in vaults as of October of last year. Is this still correct? [1] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2023/02/lastpass-hackers-infected-employees-home-computer-and-stole-corporate-vault/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2023/02/lastp...
- jagged-chisel 3y agoHow is LastPass even still in business? I have technical colleagues who still use them, even after years of breaches. I suppose momentum is much more important than I thought.
- mtillman 3y agoLastpass has been sketch for years but AOL was still making money thanks to those CDs and email addresses last I checked. My chase card also recommends lastpass in their app’s shopping section.
- jjoonathan 3y agoSpeaking of the Rise and Fall of password managers, Bitwarden has served me well for years but lately it has started to get reallly slow for my friends and I. Is there a newer cooler kid on the block?
- jvanderbot 3y agopass https://www.passwordstore.org/ https://www.passwordstore.org/
- darkstar999 3y agoVendor lock-in.
- bboygravity 3y agoThere are large companies out there (example: Orbia) who explicitly recommend ONLY using LastPass as a password manager to their employees "for security".
- stubish 3y agoLastPass will remain dominant until someone else with similar functionality offers a free tier. 1Password is similar functionality, but you have to subscribe after 14 days and that drives alot of people away even if they can afford it. And so LastPass has most of the mind share, and thus most of the sales.
- osigurdson 3y agoMaybe we should store our credentials on fully publicly accessible network using an enormous key. This way, at least there is no surprise when a breach occurs and it isn't necessary to trust dummies like LastPass to have good practices - only trust yourself and the quality of your key. The good guys can let people know if their key sucks and there might be some auditing of the bad guys. Eventually the bad guys will stop bothering since they won't be able to crack anything (with current technology).
- wkat4242 3y agoWhat I do is use zx2c4 pass ( https://www.passwordstore.org/ https://www.passwordstore.org/ ) where every password is encrypted by several gpg public keys, of which the secret ones are stored on several Yubikeys in openpgp mode. This way there is no "master password". You need one of the keys and its PIN even if you have the encrypted passwords. Anyone with access to the encrypted files would need to brute force a truly random RSA2048 key which is NSA territory (and elliptic key can also be used now). Or steal one of the yubis and crack the hardware because the PIN is limited to 3 attempts just like on a bank card. Or attack the endpoint which is feasible with any password manager, in fact mine has extra protection because the yubis require a touch for every decode. Clients are available on desktops (CLI and with GUI) and Android. iOS is sadly not possible because you need more access to the NFC chip to talk to OpenPGP smartcards than Apple allows. They only allow fido2 and basic tags. I wonder if this could be done with fido2 hardware backing but for now it's not possible. This attack in the article uses the fact that the encryption key is directly derived from the master password using a key derivation algorithm. I'm surprised there is no commercial password vault that uses hardware-backed security like I do because it doesn't have this vulnerability which is clearly an issue in the real world. With hardware backing there is no delicate balance between usability (waiting for the master password to go through the key derivation) and security (a feasible brute force attack) because these two items aren't directly related. This kind of breach shouldn't have happened.
- osigurdson 3y ago>> Anyone with access to the encrypted files would need to brute force a truly random RSA2048 key which is NSA territory (and elliptic key can also be used now). I'm thinking the canonical example of an open network is Bitcoin. Here, everyone knows the public key and could potentially crack the private key from it (for enormous gain obviously). Just do the same thing with a sufficiently large AES key for example.
- balderdash 3y agoIs it because these people didn’t know about the breech or just didn’t update their passwords? I mean I understand not immediately changing the password for some online fan fiction forum, but I’d assume you’d at least put changing your password for your dozen or so important financial/email/health accounts on your todo list?
- superchroma 3y agoPeople don't know and don't know to care. People think it's enough to disclose breaches, to send an email, whatever, and other people happily go about recommending password managers as some kind of magic silver bullet, but if you're not tech savvy, and if you're not security savvy, you're honestly no better off.
- chatmasta 3y agoMost non-technical users of LastPass probably aren't even aware of the breach(es). LastPass was not exactly clear about the breadth of the impact. All their announcements were obfuscatory emails during the holidays.
- naedish 3y agoChanging your password wouldn't help in this case. They used lastpass to store their crypto wallet seed phrase - this can't be changed. They would have to move to a new wallet and pay transfer fees in the process.
- balderdash 3y agoYeah I guess some people also don’t want to go through the hassle or cost to change the locks on on their actual homes when their keys are compromised/move into a new home
- antiframe 3y agoConsidering it cost me $750 to rekey all my locks and now one can duplicate keys from just an image, I don't think I would rekey ally locks every time my key is visible in public (which one should consider compromised).
- WXLCKNO 3y agoI personally know someone who lost approx 300k to this. It was across tons of addresses on a hot wallet and not his main holdings. However after some verification there was simply no other answer other than the fact that he did indeed have that seed on LastPass.
- dataflow 3y agoDo you know/can you share any info about how weak that person's password was? So people have an idea what to expect in terms of what can/has been cracked.
- jongjong 3y agoI've always said over and over that password managers are a bad idea and kept getting down-voted each time. It centralizes the risk as it creates a large target for hackers to focus on. A good alternative is to use rules-based passwords; each website/app has a different password based on a common non-obvious rule which depends on the website, app or company you're using.
- andrewfong 3y agoI tried that but it's just really hard to keep up over time -- e.g. I used a rule based on the domain name but domain names change somewhere often. Toss in things like "ugh, which of my three emails did I use on this site" or "which high school teacher did I say was my favorite for this site" and it ends up being a big hairy mess that screams for an encrypted place to stick my notes. Also, what I consider "non obvious" isn't that non-obvious. Given enough of a sample size, a committed attacker can guess a lot of rules. And if the prize (a crypto wallet) is big enough, they might be motivated enough to give it a go.
- jongjong 3y agoIf the domain name,, company name or whatever changes, you can change your password too. Also, it doesn't have to be domain names though.
- benhurmarcel 3y agoAlso when there's a breach and you need to change your password, you have to make an exception to your rule. And remember it for that specific site.
- lxgr 3y agoBy rule, do you mean something like PW = PBKDF2(TLD || master_password), or something like “mysecurepw!amaz0n”? I see the latter a lot, and it makes me quite nervous – it seems quite pattern/AI-iteratable.
- usr1106 3y ago
- bastawhiz 3y agoBack when I worked at Mozilla in 2012 a coworker excitedly explained Bitcoin to me and said that "someday the mining difficulty will be so high that it'll be more profitable to mine the keys protecting wallets than to mine new bitcoins". I don't think anyone could have thought far enough ahead to understand how much more trivial it would be than that. All those consumer gpus in now-illegal Chinese crypto farms are probably hard at work mining for keys. What else are you going to do with them? > these numbers radically come down when a determined adversary also has other large-scale computational assets at their disposal, such as a bitcoin mining operation that can coordinate the password-cracking activity across multiple powerful systems simultaneously. Yeah, and the best part is they already paid for the cards and can't use them for mining anymore because they're on their last leg and have been surpassed by newer generations of hardware. I'd bet a lot of the operations that got stinking rich five years ago are absolutely swimming in cards that they'd otherwise just be paying to get rid of. The ROI must be incredible, it's probably just a few hours to crack a key and you get to do a Storage Wars-style walkthrough of the secrets some poor LastPass user thought would be secure.
- ronsor 3y ago> All those consumer gpus in now-illegal Chinese crypto farms are probably hard at work mining for keys. What else are you going to do with them? No, they're still mining Bitcoin. There's absolutely no way to crack secp256k1 keys with even a datacenter GPU. We're firmly in the realm of quantum computers if you expect to crack anything before the heat death of the universe.
- px43 3y agoFirst off, GPUs haven't been used for mining Bitcoin for about a decade. There has been a lot of work being done to crack brainwallets, also there are a number of leaked/hacked/shared wallets that people are working on cracking. There have also been a number of wallets generated with weak RNGs which get cracked, vulgarity wallets etc, and of course, the LastPass vaults as described in the article.
- bastawhiz 3y ago> There's absolutely no way to crack secp256k1 keys with even a datacenter GPU That's not what the article is implying is happening. > “An Nvidia 3090 can do roughly 4 million [password guesses] per second with 1000 iterations, but that would go down to 8 thousand per second with 500,000 iterations, which is why iteration count matters so much,” Weaver said. “So a combination of ‘not THAT strong of a password’ and ‘old vault’ and ‘low iteration count’ would make it theoretically crackable but real work, but the work is worth it given the targets.”
- darklycan51 3y agoThis is why I simply don't understand the modern approach in Password requirements, while yes, it is simply too easy to crack a password if it's somewhat simplistic. I've been on websites where they force you to update your password every X months (and it has a lot of special key requirements) and you cannot reuse old passwords (which would really not be a problem regarding cracking... unless they store your old passwords... which is counter productive...) It basically turns into being unable to memorize all your passwords and being forced to use a service like this, which OBVIOUSLY any genius knows eventually will get hacked and your passwords leaked, ALL your passwords, at the same time. If you instead attempt to memorize (like I do) because of all the different cases in which you have to swap passwords, you end up with at least 20 passwords you gotta memorize for every site... I actually absolutely hate how the web works today especially regarding logging in.
- tedunangst 3y agoThe rotation requirement is possibly misguided but does solve the problem where the passwords were leaked months ago. If everybody affected had rotated passwords three months later, this problem wouldn't even exist today. Old leaks often show up a long time later. A lot of people had yahoo? email accounts hacked because they used the same linkedin? password, but the leak was from years prior. If yahoo had required rotation, the password list would have been useless by the time it circulated.
- lxgr 3y agoHow would you enforce mandatory password rotation for wallet seed phrases, though? That kind of defeats the purpose of a cold wallet.
- maerF0x0 3y agoThey broke my trust multiple times across my ~9 yrs as a customer. They failed to use enough iterations, they failed to update my vault to the right number of iterations when they discovered the flaw, they failed to keep the weak vault safe. This spring I spent a good 2-3 days pruning old accounts, I used 1passwords migration tool (which worked flawlessly)[1], and changed every password that had any monetary or identity value. I've definitely been targeted for attacks in the ensuing months as numbers keep texting "Hi <name>" or other kinds of (spear) phishing. At this point I don't really know how to protect my self and think it's mostly 2factor thats kept me safe. [1]: https://support.1password.com/import-lastpass/ https://support.1password.com/import-lastpass/
- YeBanKo 3y agoI know that 1password has a far better track record than LastPass, but this is an argument against their removing local vaults and not offering on-premise storage.
- davely 3y agoYeah. I’ve been a loyal 1P customer forever. Still annoyed about the move to cloud vaults and making it really obnoxious to try and use locally. At this point, I think it’s just a matter of time before they suffer their own breach for some reason or another.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]