5 ms·
Google Meet’s new AI will be able to go to meetings for you
- myaccountonhn 3y agoThis makes me miss all the crypto spam. At least crypto applications sounded cool even if it was just snake oil (helping artists get funding et.c.). AI's applications are just horrifyingly dystopic, between this, AI art, AI girlfriends etc.
- damnesian 3y agoThis would be like the notes you take at a meeting talking back at you. I think we humans do just fine when we can't attend meetings. Most are unneccessary anyway.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoWith a bunch of these AI tools at some point some folks will have to do the actual work. Some have to attend meetings, get an idea off of a random comment which the AI won't consider important to add to the meeting notes and then come up with a way to launch it to market without AI because that data set doesn't exist yet. Those who can do work will be rewarded beyond their wildest dreams and many many jobs will be lost. The gap between haves and have nots will increase even further. What's worse is those who are using AI to do creative work are actually atrophying their own capacity to do work.
- paulddraper 3y agoThis sentiment stands at odds with centuries of evidence.
- zadler 3y agoToo much evidence to even begin to enumerate, presumably.
- paulddraper 3y agoBetween 1900 and 1970, agricultural jobs went from 35% to 5% of U.S. jobs. One out of three jobs lost in a single lifetime. During the same time, the standard of living skyrocketed.
- lossolo 3y agoIs there evidence from centuries of AI revolutions to support this? What makes you think it's the same? I don't see how it's comparable. History shows that low-skilled jobs were typically replaced with similar low-skilled jobs, such as transitioning from farming to factory work. However, we are now entering an era where we can potentially replace most low-skilled jobs. The question is, what will happen to the hundreds of millions of people who will be displaced? Without a significant revolution in the economic model, it may not be possible to address this issue. What will a 50-year-old truck driver do? Go to college and learn software engineering? We know that this is not feasible in the majority of cases.
- paulddraper 3y agoA 50-year-old truck driver will become a 60-year-old truck driver. A 20-year-old truck driver will go to trade school and become a mechanic. As much as we like to think of ourselves as special, this has all happened before and will all happen again.
- belval 3y agoIt's interesting how conflicted I am about this. On one hand having an assistant attend a meeting to report back the distilled ~2 minutes that are useful has a strong value proposition. On the other hand why isn't the meeting lead talking care of forwarding that distilled information themselves? I feel like this says more about a somewhat bad meeting culture that a lot of us partake in and less about the inevitable rise of AI.
- sdfghswe 3y ago> why isn't the meeting lead talking care of forwarding that distilled information themselves To me what this says is that devs like having their thinking done for them and the requirements spoon fed, instead of having to actually make decisions.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoWhy do you have an assistant attend the meeting at all if they aren’t directly participating. You could distill from a recording, or have your assistant distill from a recording, or maybe someday have an AI distill from the meeting based on your interests? I get the value in being in on a meeting is popping in when necessary (ask question, clarify something from your team, etc…). Many meetings could also just be done more efficiently as chat discussions.
- smallerfish 3y agoYou don't need "an AI" for that - you can just use any of the dozens of CI tools. Most of them can do auto summarization and auto highlights. Although looked at that way, this is really Google's entry into the CI space.
- Swizec 3y agoIf you go to so many meetings that you can't remember what happened, you need to stop hoarding your legos and focus. Let others take some of the responsibility. Delegate. But, like, actually delegate. Let others make decisions. Trust that they know more about an area than you do. Just because you've read their notes doesn't mean you're an expert. Trust your team.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThis is a hack for poor corporate culture where there is no autonomy or trust to shape the communications channels based on efficiency, which is shockingly common. If you don't feel comfortable enough to say, "This could be an email thread instead." or "Is this meeting really necessary?", this is probably a great fit for your org, who will eat this up as "innovation."
- cubecul 3y agoThe headline is way overselling it. It’s basically allowing you to decline a meeting and leave a note (questions, comments) that will pop up on people’s screens during the meeting.
- tlogan 3y agoThis appears to be a misguided application of AI, essentially operating under the premise that "meetings are useless, so let's automate them." However, the value in meetings often lies in the consensus-building among participants, especially when it comes to action items, ownership, and deadlines. Simply replacing this process with AI risks losing that collaborative nuance and the reason why you need the meeting. For example, meeting notes are notes all participants agree on (action items, owners, dates, etc.).
- rickdeckard 3y agoSoon all this can be replaced with a single platform spawning an AI which will pretend to have a human meeting with other iterations of itself, ultimately provide the most probable reaction given the input data and finish with meeting notes sent to all. While other humans attend this will still be very compute-intensive, but as soon as all the attendees are AI's it will only take a split-second to generate meeting-notes straight from the Agenda! ;)
- gustavus 3y agoThis has been my big question with all of these Generative AI stuff that will - write emails - go to meetings - any other type of activity that involves sharing information. Humanity didn't develop emails, or have meetings, or communications because it some sort of ritual to a strange god (barring the meetings produced by the priests of agile to appease the Agile God). We communicate in order to share information from one person to another for a reason. So if we have a workflow where someone uses AI to generate an email, that results in a meeting that is then summarized by AI, that is then sent to an inbox that is then scanned and the contents of which is summarized by AI. What was the point of any of it? At no point did a human learn any new information. It was all just various LLMs generating symbols that changed nothing in the real world. What is the end goal of this? Or is the hope that if we get enough AI hooked up to each other it will magically just start creating and selling products and money will magically appear and everyone will be happy? At the end of the day the internet revolution was all about Information Technology. That information exists to be consumed, understood and acted upon by human beings, to change our understanding of the world. If we are just having AI talk to AI to talk to AI, it was all an exercise in pointlessness.
- empath-nirvana 3y agoAlmost every meeting you attend, almost every email you read, is pointless or irrelevant to you. If an AI can do it for you, you probably should have never been involved to begin with. If all this AI accomplishes nothing but filtering out several hours a week of pointless bullshit, then "mission accomplished", IMO.
- chpatrick 3y ago> Humanity didn't develop emails, or have meetings, or communications because it some sort of ritual to a strange god (barring the meetings produced by the priests of agile to appease the Agile God). We communicate in order to share information from one person to another for a reason. So if we have a workflow where someone uses AI to generate an email, that results in a meeting that is then summarized by AI, that is then sent to an inbox that is then scanned and the contents of which is summarized by AI. What was the point of any of it? Because we didn't have a machine that can do this whole collective decision-making process. What if we make an AI that's powerful enough to replace a whole organization? A whole company? A whole industry?
- bfeynman 3y agoLLMs constantly show most promise for work that really has very little value add, and I wonder given just economics if this will guide behavior towards not even bothering with its applications. Starting with cover letters, and then towards arbitrary content generation. Some companies already started doing this, if a meeting is not really productive you don't need to go or can feel free to leave. Not sure how many people would even read follow up notes, if it's free I guess another thing people won't use.
- chpatrick 3y agoIt's definitely a weird experience when people use LLMs to generate some text and then the recipient uses LLMs to summarize that text. I also feel similarly with the office suite AI tools - if the AI can generate the presentation, do we even need the presentation at all? Do we need the people who watch the presentation and make decisions?
- rickdeckard 3y agoJust to point out the absurdity of this: If one day everyone sends an AI to attend a meeting, will all these AI's (which are all instances of the SAME platform!) still have to act out a human meeting...? Reminds me of the "Electric Monk" from Douglas Adams' Dirk Gently novels, which is an appliance whose job it is to believe in things on the behalf of its owner...
- remus 3y ago> If one day everyone sends an AI to attend a meeting... I think this is the absurd part. I can see an obvious use for some meetings, for example: where lots of people are invited 'just in case'. You could get the AI generated summary and see if anything relevant came up, then follow up if it did.
- rickdeckard 3y agoI would still prefer the meeting organizer to write the meeting notes and action items instead of him assuming "my AI" had captured all topics and decisions, and even worse, then expecting me to take on assignments without him ever explicitly requesting such resources...
- gumby 3y agoI’ve been doing this for a while, using a bot that attends meetings for me, records and transcribes it, and sends me a summary. I’ve seen other people do this too with meetings I do attend. These are big-audience meetings usually with one person presenting and then a Q&A. I read the summary and then if it looks interesting I listen to the meeting when it’s convenient. (Not gonna shill for the app: it’s just one of the ones in the Zoom “store” — there are several).
- edgarvaldes 3y agoI can think of a use case for me: Sometimes I got invited as an optional participant. Most of the time, I don't attend. If I can receive a summary focused on my area, where the decisions affect or depend on my end, it would be nice.
- rickdeckard 3y agoSo one day all attendees will be AI's, and the platform will generate the meeting-notes straight from the Meeting-Agenda without pretending to hold a meeting. We won't even need a calendar then to schedule it, you just write some text and press a button to have a machine agree/disagree with you. Soon people will wonder why this process is even called a "Meeting"... I can almost hear the AI-bubble inflating already...
- dougb5 3y agoDoes this remind anyone else of the movie "Real Genius"? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wB1X4o-MV6o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wB1X4o-MV6o
- adroitboss 3y agoR.I.P Tactiq.io
- skybrian 3y agoIt’s unclear what this is. It sounds like it might just be a way to automatically generate meeting notes for people who couldn’t attend? That could be useful for the kind of meeting where you’re just an audience member, not a participant. But here’s a more science fiction spin on it: Instead of thinking of this as “going to a meeting” think of it as “representing you.” That is, maybe it can try to answer questions on your behalf and it can give you a summary of what happened afterwards. Everyone will know it’s a representative, it can’t commit to anything, and it might not be entirely accurate, but maybe it’s better than not being able to ask you questions at all? (For example, when someone’s on vacation.) I don’t expect that sending a person to represent your interests is common outside of maybe upper management and of course the legal profession, but perhaps it’s useful. It might be better than sitting through an entire meeting just in case someone might want to ask you a question? I wonder, though, whether it would be better to just make a chatbot available for people to talk to at any time without it being a formal meeting. Also, what information does your representative actually use to answer questions? Maybe a chatbot could be a way for people to make their semi-organized work notes available to others? Or make a vacation auto-responder that’s trained on a subset of your outgoing email. Imagine what happens after someone leaves. “Sorry, she’s not available, but you can chat with her bot.”