52 ms·
Home insurers cut natural disasters from policies as climate risks grow
- 1MachineElf 3y agoAn unfortunate situation for those in need of housing and those housed who are in need - such policy coverage is a requirement for mortgages (and reverse mortgages), at least in Florida.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bick_nyers 3y agoIf hurricane insurance becomes impossible to acquire for a region, will banks stop giving out mortgages because they require homeowner's insurance in order to lend? Are banks legally required to offer mortgages to suitable candidates, regardless of region? I would prefer that my bank, my insurance company, and the government duke it out amongst themselves, and not involve me. Central FL doesn't see nearly as much hurricane damage as the coast, but we are also being subjected to increased premiums.
- 911e 3y agoThis is quite interesting, I feel like at some point we need to cut those middleman that bail out as soon as paying is involved
- SoftTalker 3y agoThey aren't in business to give away money. Insurance is all about paying to mitigate risk. If the risk of loss increases or becomes too hard to predict, insurance will get more expensive or simply not be offered.
- alwaysbeconsing 3y agoThere's no inherent reason it must be a profit-making business. Organizeing as a cooperative, mutual insurance is also an option. Granted that any version still must set rates that cover expected payouts.
- itiro 3y agoYou’re describing government. People cooperate through government to insure stability. I will never understand the endless linguistic indirection when in the end it’s all Soylent Green; just people.
- pauldenton 3y ago[flagged]
- fluoridation 3y agoAre you saying that whenever people cooperate voluntarily, it's a government?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> no inherent reason it must be a profit-making business Insurance is an extremely demanding business. This isn’t something you can throw commodity drones at. If you’re willing to create a coöperative job that pays millions to its actuaries and risk managers, fine. Most don’t. Hence why a profit-based model works: it can incentivise the people that are needed for it to work in the long run to do the job. (In the short run, anyone can run a sloppy insurance operation.)
- bonestamp2 3y agoOne interesting experiment in this area is the Canadian Province of Saskatchewan, where the government has run a break even auto and property insurance organization since 1945. It does not receive money from the tax payers and is completely self sustaining: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saskatchewan_Government_Insurance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saskatchewan_Government_Insura...
- Guvante 3y agoI know when I bought I had to have a quote for appropriate insurance policy in order to close. I never asked what appropriate was however.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThe bank will want insurance at least in the amount of what you owe on the mortgage. They don't really care if it's enough to cover actual losses.
- Guvante 3y agoCoverage amount is not what the article is about. It is about covered things happening.
- BoxFour 3y agoAs pointed out in the article, states frequently maintain a taxpayer-backed insurers of last resort (and apparently notably prevalent in Florida). Nevertheless, as the article also highlights, this approach is unlikely to have favorable long-term financial implications for the state.
- dehrmann 3y agoAt least it might finally force states to make hard choices.
- no_wizard 3y agoI fear the end result of this is going to be federal bailouts of state insurance programs, which means that money will get politicized and used to further someones agenda as a means to passing. I often wonder how far away we are from funding being withheld from states with bad public policy as perceived by the party in power. It sets dangerous precedents of coupling human suffering to policy maneuvers (which I realize, happens even today, but in broader strokes NY gets hurricane assistance same as Florida. Imagine a scenario where Florida's general public is punished because of laws on their books, or New York public is punished because of policies it has etc.)
- LapsangGuzzler 3y ago> I often wonder how far away we are from funding being withheld from states with bad public policy as perceived by the party in power. It sets dangerous precedents of coupling human suffering to policy maneuvers This has been going on for many years. From GOP states refusing to accept expanded Obamacare grants, thereby restricting access to healthcare for the poor to refusing to extend 9/11 first responder healthcare until people like Jon Stewart got involved, oppression and cruelty has been used as leverage in policymaking going back to the founding of the US.
- civilitty 3y ago> I fear the end result of this is going to be federal bailouts of state insurance programs, which means that money will get politicized and used to further someones agenda as a means to passing. Welcome to the future: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Progr... Congress has been bailing out the program for almost 20 years now.
- Waterluvian 3y agoIdeally the system isn’t propped up by tax dollars. Previously lucrative regions becoming financially uninhabitable is probably the one thing nobody can ignore. It’s what I like about the insurance industry: it cares not for opinions and moods and politics because it is betting with cash. No amount of climate denial changes the math on a bad deal.
- shostack 3y agoAt what point do state-run insurance plans like California's for earthquakes make sense to expand to just ask housing insurance as big insurers like State Farm pull out of the state?
- bick_nyers 3y agoI am not familiar with state-run insurance plans but I would be worried if it was ran as a potential form of taxation/revenue for the state government, because then homeowners would be subject to the whims of the current dominating political party without the mechanism of free market competition to lower the cost of insurance. I would want it to be run "at cost" as much as possible. Edit: To be clear, what I am saying is that the stockpile formed from insurance premiums should not be accessible to other causes (even during emergencies unrelated to homes). I'm fine with tax revenue topping off insurance, but never insurance money being redirected to another budget.
- SoftTalker 3y agoYou also have the risk of it being underfunded, or borrowed against, as we've seen with so many state-run pension plans.
- ethbr1 3y agoOpen to correction if I'm wrong, but from the examples I'm aware of (e.g. federal flood insurance) when insurance is run by the government it's always underpriced, then topped up behind the scenes from general taxes. People tend to gripe less about an extra few dollars in taxes (which aren't line itemed), but more if the price of their insurance premium ever goes up (which they do see a separate line item for).
- applied_heat 3y agoIn British Columbia automobile insurance is legally only available from the government ICBC, and ICBC had 800 million in the bank so the government took it and at the same time changed a recently constructed toll bridge to be free, essentially buying the votes of everyone who uses the bridge at the expense of everyone who pays automobile insurance.
- pjscott 3y agoWhen insurance companies are legally forced to choose between providing insurance at a loss and not providing it at all, they'll predictably choose the latter. I have to wonder: who on earth thought those price-restriction laws were a good idea?
- dehrmann 3y agoI'm not convinced a lot of state lawmakers are smart enough to realize this, it's an easy policy to sell to voters, and when insurance companies do pull out, you just frame them as "greedy businesses."
- baggy_trough 3y agoVoters and politicians don’t want to believe the laws of economics. A tale as old as time.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoOnly when it works for them. The Lord, in his infinite wisdom, makes it rain for the rich and rain on the poor alike.
- baq 3y agoWhat’s the difference between not providing a service and bumping the price 20x in a year?
- elzbardico 3y agoThey never liked it. Now, acting in collusion, they can have the perfect excuse to do so without looking like a cartel.
- hedora 3y agoNationwide recently said they will no longer provide plans in coastal regions, excluding many of the population centers of the US. They should be required to either cover everyone or no one, just like health insurers supposedly do.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThey probably want to move in the direction of health insurance - which is to basically take on no risk, have the state mandate you have it anyway, and charge you a lot of money for almost nothing.
- silisili 3y agoGonna disagree here. At some point, people have to do the same due diligence the insurance companies have done. Anyone building a sea level house in the keys shouldn't be surprised that insurance won't cover them. And no company should have to..
- alasdair_ 3y agoYou don’t have a choice of which body you inhabit. You definitely have a choice of home you inhabit.
- kevinventullo 3y agoAs a homeowner in Southern California, this type of policy (not necessarily driven by climate) directly negatively affects me due to the risk of fires and earthquakes. However, I don’t think there’s a great solution. The basic problem is that natural disasters represent a correlated risk. Insurance pools only seem to make sense for uncorrelated risks such as house fires or pipe bursts or whatever, where the high individual cost of many relatively independent unlikely events can be smoothed out into a low guaranteed cost. Perhaps a sufficiently large insurer could dilute the risk of an earthquake destroying a large percentage of homes in Los Angeles by also covering large swaths of other high-risk parts of the country or world.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> Perhaps a sufficiently large insurer could dilute the risk of an earthquake destroying a large percentage of homes in Los Angeles by also covering large swaths of other high-risk parts of the country or world. At a certain point, this is just all taxpayers as a whole.
- bonestamp2 3y agoExactly, and we frequently see Federal Aid in lots of big disasters. Eventually, the government will be the only insurance organization that covers the catastrophic events where we really need insurance the most, and then we can stop pretending that private for-profit insurance is something that our society wants. The government is already the "insurance" for so many different types of things that we should just lean into it 100%.
- digitalsushi 3y agoAs anti-human as this makes me sound, this does make me personally understand why eyes and teeth are not covered on my health insurance. I can't take a claim out on my car's tires getting used up over 100,000 miles, either.
- gruez 3y ago>As anti-human as this makes me sound, this does make me personally understand why eyes and teeth are not covered on my health insurance. This doesn't make any sense. You can rack up way more expensive charges/procedures on the rest of your body (eg. triple bypass or hip replacement) than your eye or teeth ever could.
- oatmeal1 3y agoNot surprised WaPo leaves out relevant non-climate reasons that also contribute.
- cpncrunch 3y agoAnd cherry picks data starting at 2013. I was curious about pre 2013 and it seems i was right to be skeptical. The 2013 to 2016 period just had unusually low losses. https://www.statista.com/statistics/428870/insured-property-losses-usa/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/428870/insured-property-...
- gruez 3y ago>And cherry picks data starting at 2013. In their defense 10 years is a nice round number. Also, the text surrounding the chart says >“There’s no place to hide from these severe natural disasters,” said David Sampson, president of the American Property Casualty Insurance Association. “They’re happening all over the country and so insurers are having to relook at their risk concentration.” >That trend is too costly, insurers contend, and necessitates rewriting policies or eliminating coverages in growing geographic areas. If change the window from 10 years to 15 or 20 years, the general impression is still the same: insurance losses are trending up, and the last few years are consistently high (as opposed to having one or two years of high payouts followed by periods of low payouts).
- cpncrunch 3y agoExcept, that's now how random systems work: you don't get one high value, then some low values, then a value value. Try flipping a coin many times: if you do it enough times, you'll get 5 heads in a row due to chance. The same is true for random weather events. If you look at this graph going back further, you'll see high losses in previous years: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Olivier-Mahul/publication/23550346/figure/fig1/AS:310258397401088@1450982774100/Economic-Losses-and-Insured-Losses-due-to-Natural-Disasters.png https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Olivier-Mahul/publicati... Certainly this graph is trending higher from the 1970s, but is that due to more real estate with a higher valuation? And how much insurance premiums were collected?
- pauldenton 3y agoIt always did seem curious that people who believed heavily in climate risk never seem to put their money where their mouth is when it comes to Waterfront property. If you believed there was a serious risk of sea levels rising you wouldn't spend millions on a house with a waterfront view below sea level If banks believed there was a serious risk of sea levels rising they would put a discount instead of a premium on waterfront property. But I still cannot find any discount property that is discounted because it's next to the ocean
- massysett 3y agoIf you have millions to spend on property, you may have millions to throw away. Elon Musk wasted billions on Twitter, so it’s no surprise that smaller wealth might be willing to waste a few million on a house.
- simbolit 3y agoThis. People aren't wealth-maximisers all the time.. Also, people aren't rational or well-informed all the time.
- thecyborganizer 3y ago"The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent" - John Maynard Keynes
- mlyle 3y ago> But I still cannot find any discount property that is discounted because it's next to the ocean Sea levels are expected to rise about a foot in the next 30 years, which will impair some coastal property but not all (much worse on the east coast than the west). It's much worse on a 60-100 year timeframe. If a discount were being applied, you'd expect most of the reduction in value to be 50 years out. The present values of enjoyment over the next 50 years could far exceed those residual values, and so it could be hard to observe any discount that is present. E.g. even if future sea level rise lops 10% off the value, other factors could add more in the short term.
- 3y ago
- Havoc 3y agoIn that situation increasing the price seems more appropriate. Not being insured for natural disasters to me defeats the point...black swan events like natural disasters
- LightBug1 3y agoInsurance scum suckers ... hoarding money in tax havens while pretending to provide a service.
- metadat 3y agohttps://archive.today/wIDtr https://archive.today/wIDtr
- madaxe_again 3y agoAfter having had a home flood and another burn, and being refused a claim in each case (the flood was caused by a river, and so isn’t covered, and the fire was a wildfire, and also isn’t covered - only fires starting in the property are covered - same for our truck that was incinerated), I no longer bother with home or vehicle insurance - if they don’t pay out, there’s no point in having it. Come to think of it the only insurance claim I ever had pay out was when I deliberately set out to defraud an insurer. Never have they paid out in a situation where it would have been helpful. I would wager others will follow the same way, once they realise their policies are just a tax that they get no benefit from, and then insurers will have to come up with some new racket to defraud marks.
- t3rabytes 3y agoThat's not really an option for almost anyone with a mortgage on a home -- the lender will require home insurance with themselves listed as the primary payee. Same with an auto loan for most lenders (Lightspeed being one of the abnormal ones that doesn't hold the title to the vehicle as collateral).
- madaxe_again 3y agoSure, but if the lenders find themselves out of pocket because insurers repeatedly refuse to pay, they will change behaviour too - such as by no longer lending. Also, no such requirement in the U.K. - 3rd party vehicle insurance is mandatory, but home insurance is up to you - no lender I’ve ever had has mandated it.
- maCDzP 3y agoSomeone here that is sceptical to climate change maybe can shed some light. To me the fact that insurers aren’t insuring natural disasters due to climate change is a good argument that it’s real. Otherwise they would just sell the insurance to a premium and collect free money? Or do you guys think that it’s just some companies being dumb and are likely to go out of business?
- baggy_trough 3y agoMuch simpler than that. Price controls cause supply shortages.
- swader999 3y agoThere's certainly less effort to fight wild fires this season. I know several helicopter pilots who say they have to get approval for each bucket drop where before they just flew agreed on hours. They say it's a joke, completely budget driven. They'd have several fires they worked on out sooner if they were not subject to this. On the ground it's the same, extreme focus on safety, not working over time, not using quads, heli attack crews cancelled. Only getting intense when it gets close to structures. So you get record fires here in Canada. Lowest area burned in USA in decades. Politicians save budget, don't get called to account because of course it's climate change. Bringing in the insurance angle, they are suffering more losses, the areas are built up more in fire prone forested land, houses are more expensive and there is less labour to fight fire. Poor history of fuel management too. So they are raising rates and I don't blame them. It's easy to just say climate change. Maybe it's a way to appropriate the land back to the elites.
- isaacremuant 3y agoThe problem with your supposed argument is that just because companies don't want to insure against eventd of type Y because they think they're likely or costly does not mean that they're caused by reason X. Your argument is, on logical merits, not good enough to create a causation between, what I presume is "human influenced global warming increase" and "natural disaster increase". Now I realize this being a politically charged topic that people look at in an absolutist way, a response that looks only at the logical proposition of your comment, might not be well received.
- mkoubaa 3y agoHomes have always been inherently a risky asset, though we've been conditioned to think they aren't
- EricE 3y agolol - everything in life has risk. That risk is absolutely baked into your rent - with additional overhead.
- xenadu02 3y agoDon't assume insurers are competent. They often sell homeowner's policies entirely online or over the phone without inspecting the property, looking at as-builts, etc. My renovated up to 2015 earthquake standards house pays the same rate as the 1939 jalopy down the street despite my home having much higher quality electrical (less fire risk) and being built to a stronger standard (less likely to collapse or suffer damage from storms, earthquakes, etc). Neither private insurance nor the state chartered CA Earthquake Insurance price by actual risk. Florida and Texas are the same: insurers don't price in hurricane or hail proofing, anti-flooding measures, etc. Hail resistant and wind resistant roofs exist but they'd rather just stop writing policies. I don't know why things have gone so wrong in recent years. Insurance should be able to drive improvements in construction techniques rather than stopping policy writing. For example: instead of refusing to write policies in wildfire prone areas refuse if the home doesn't have fire-proof roofing and siding, along with a zone clear of combustibles around the house, fire screens on vents, etc. Such measures would allow far more homes to survive wildfires without damage but the insurers aren't interested. This is the opposite of vehicle insurance where the industry crash tests new vehicles and adjusts premiums for vehicles with better safety ratings.
- JackFr 3y agoYou fail to account for the cost of accurately underwriting. They can do what you suggest fir cars because it involves testing a few dozen car models. If each car needed to be tested they wouldn’t do it.
- airza 3y agoThe flip side of this is not simply assuming that insurers are stupid. Performing bespoke inspections of houses is an industry onto itself which i also would not rush into. It also doesn’t help you much; if 10% of houses have these countermeasures your regional risk pool will still be vaporized when the other 90% are burned to the ground. It’s just eventually impossible to insure these assets when these types of super correlated risks become as ubiquitous as they are.
- kelnos 3y ago
- bArray 3y agoI think there is some assumption that insurers are acting in good faith. > Major insurers say they will cut out damage caused by hurricanes, wind and hail from policies underwriting property along coastlines and in wildfire country, [..] Hurricanes and wild fires have not significantly increased due to climate change. This just allows insurers to arbitrarily refuse to deal with insurance payouts, especially those of large scale. This is essentially another "act of god" get-out clause. Given that banks need insurance to protect their investment, this will likely just kill the possibility of owning a home for the least wealthy. Some big player such as banks will come in and buy lots of cheap property, then suddenly insurance will cover these 'high risk' areas again and rent them back to the people who lost their homes.
- everybodyknows 3y agoSacramento is working on a solution for the wildfire risk problem: Force everyone in safer areas to fund a subsidy. > Potential ingredients include allowing insurers to charge all policyholders a fee to cover the riskiest properties ... https://www.politico.com/news/2023/08/21/wildfires-california-politicians-00112016 https://www.politico.com/news/2023/08/21/wildfires-californi...