6 ms·
Renting vs. Owning a Home, by State
- api 3y agoI suspect DC is an outlier because being the seat of the US Fed probably creates a dynamic like a college town with a lot of people moving in for a while to do something than leaving. There’s probably a lot of people coming with no intent to stay for the long haul. I’m surprised home ownership is so high in California since it seems like you need an exit event to afford a down payment in many of its cities. Lots of those owners must be people who bought before the 2000s.
- dymk 3y agoDC is an outlier because it's a city, not a state
- trts 3y agoDC is always an outlier in state-level comparisons because it is essentially a large city. States are otherwise averages of metropolitan and non metropolitan areas.
- dougmwne 3y agoIt’s not even a city, more like 2/3 of the urban core of a large city. DC’c population is about 700k, but the metro population is over 5 million.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoDC's population alone is larger than each of two entire states.
- shkkmo 3y agoNo, DC's population is a little larger than the smallest state and nowhere close to larger that the two smallest states combined.
- alexeldeib 3y agoThat’s not really the point though - it’s more like saying the NYC metro area isn’t only Manhattan. Brooklyn would be the 3rd largest city in America by population. I agree it’s kind of irrelevant and the original point was correct: DC is an urban core without the rural split most other states have.
- et-al 3y agoHousing in the Los Angeles sprawl is still (relatively) affordable. Same with the Sacramento/Vacaville area.
- CameronNemo 3y agoMedian household income is less than a tenth of median home listing price in Los Angeles.
- bugglebeetle 3y agoIn no world or relative to any historical period is this true. Just look at the historic ratio of income to house prices in Los Angeles.
- _8j50 3y agoWhat is affordable in your opinion? 300k won't get you a burnt down shack.
- Shandilyabh 3y agoI would be really interested in knowing if there's a correlation between number of rooms and the amount of mortgage paid for (i.e. how likely is it that a mortgage on a 2 bedroom home will be paid full before one with 5 bedrooms, or is it the other way around)
- mertd 3y agoThere is a chart on this in the article.
- breckenedge 3y agoI’m surprised to see so many rentals in Texas. I figured the high property tax rate (1.6%) would drive away landlords.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoCosts get passed down and distributed all around either way.
- twelve40 3y agoyeah property tax is like 10th+ order consideration in this
- tomohelix 3y agoIt is not that high. Average houses are around 300-500k in Texas. That is like 5-6k in taxes a year. Not high enough imo
- beebmam 3y agoHousing is strictly a significantly worse investment over the long run than stock markets, if you consider just appreciation and expenses. However, it's pretty lucrative to buy and rent, if you can find tenants. That points to the obvious problem: there's not enough housing. Unfortunately, our governments create massive hurdles to build more housing, usually spurred on by interest groups.
- AYBABTME 3y agoYou can't live in your stock portfolio.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> can't live in your stock portfolio Of course you can. You sell or harvest dividends. The same as living in an investment property forces you to give up its cash yield.
- Izkata 3y agoThey said "in", not "on".
- pdonis 3y ago> You sell or harvest dividends. But then you're not owning anything and renting it out, which was what the GGP was talking about.
- AYBABTME 3y agoYour stock portfolio isn't intrinsically useful. A house is intrinsically useful, even if you rent it out: you can do an owner-move-in, and you secured your ability to live somewhere. If the stock market crash, you can't do anything useful with your stock portfolio. If the housing market crash, you can do something useful with the house: live in it. I don't argue that you can rent with the yield of your portfolio. I'm just saying that when the music stops, a house is useful and a portfolio of stock isn't. So to me, owning a house is worth it over having a souped up stock portfolio. And if you rent out your house, even if in a high CoL area like the SF Bay area, the long term yield can be comparable to a stock portfolio. And during that time, you have an anchor in one of the most economically productive area of the world.
- drewg123 3y agoThe article concludes with "the current mortgage rates are looking painful, which I’m guessing is going to increase the share of renting." -- I actually have the hope that increasing interest rates will decrease the share of renting. This is because I had thought that the rise of rental houses was due to historically low mortgage rates leading to artificially high profitability for landlords. Now that rates are more normal, its my feeling that landlords will be squeezed out of the market, and more single family homes will be owner occupied. I'm actually hoping that the landlords and AirBNB owners on ARMs will be forced to sell when their rates adjust upwards, which will increase housing supply and finally pop this bubble.
- bugglebeetle 3y agoNope, they’ll just sell them off to large investment firms that are flush with funds after the long period of low interests rates. They intend to keep everyone renting forever so that the whole scheme can be packaged and sold as an asset class.
- drewg123 3y agoI've heard the opposite -- eg that firms like Black Rock have stopped buying houses and are now selling them. Eg: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WcL9_xd-il8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WcL9_xd-il8
- throwaw12 3y agovideo is a year old, at the time big corps started dumping anything they felt like a risk. curious if this still true today. they might not be selling, but also not buying at the moment
- Spooky23 3y agoIt doesn’t work that way. Rising rates clear out the shitty companies with too much debt, but the people with cash sweep in and buy it out. Increasing rates will raise rents in the professional demographic cohorts of folks who buy houses.
- underlipton 3y agoI do wonder how many of the "owned" properties are neither rented-out nor resided-in.
- _8j50 3y agoYou know what is depressing? Owning a house is basically trying to own your retirement old age home. Unless you start saving like 30k+ in your mid-late 20s every year, you won't actually own a house until your mid fifties because mortgages are rentals with additional cost like interest rates, insurance and maintenance costs. Not to mention even if you did outright own your home, it is still a f*cking rental, "why, because tax?" You say, no! Because HOAs! Not only do you still pay them a few hundred dollars rent no matter what, if they deem you in violation of their rules, they can just foreclose your house and take it away, even if you paid it off after 30 years! There is no such thing as home ownership for regular people. It's just a marketing term. If you own something, there are no conditions for you to be allowed to keep owning it outside of violations of the law. If paying a private entity and following that entity's rules is a requirement then it is rental with extra steps. "But equity!" You say? Hah! Haah!! a savings account at a bank could do better. For most people, after accounting for interest payments, assuming your home value went up, just beating inflation is difficult. Let me put it differently, it your insurance, maintenance cost, interest payment would be more than or close to rent cost then it's a terrible deal. If your income is a 100k then since you shouldn't spend more than a third of your income on housing, let's say $30k/yr is your housing budget, in states with decent jobs (cali,texas,ny,etc..) you would have to save that much for ten years or pay mortgage and wait like 13-15 years before it is yours on paper, and then you get to pay at least $1000/mo in overall costs on it for the rest if your life. The best you can do is buy land without hoa or deed restrictions and cheap insurance and build. If you're lucky and can WFH then finding a rural land with internet should do the trick, but if you have to commute to a big city/suburb you're screwed. Best to pay cheap rent, save up until your late 40s (if you start in your late 20s/early 30s) until you can afford to buy/build outright or pay 60%+ downpayment and take a risk. The true cancer is HOAs and house owning as an investment being legal. If only there were more high rise condos without messed up HOAs. HOAs have a purpose but their lack of regulation makes them enemies of the public.
- asterfield 3y agoAs a Canadian, the HOA is such a baffling idea. Are most homes in the states linked to one? How does the infection start?