5 ms·
Society, at least in the classic European model, works just the same: everyone (yes, I know, there are exceptions, that's not the point) pays their share into h
by mschuster91 3y ago
Society, at least in the classic European model, works just the same: everyone (yes, I know, there are exceptions, that's not the point) pays their share into health insurance, LTD insurance, unemployment insurance, workplace accident insurance, pension systems and a ton of other social benefit systems. And everyone benefits from this kind of collective solidarity - our societies are far less combative (both in the literal and the proverbial sense) than the US are.
- ekianjo 3y agothats one way of seeing things. If you never left Europe that is
- manmal 3y agoWhat’s your way of seeing things?
- chpatrick 3y agoThe more I see of the world the more I agree with OP, what's your point?
- anonzzzies 3y agoI left the EU and lived in many places, travelled to more. Always happy to be back; it's not perfect, but it's worse elsewhere.
- jiofj 3y agoIt's more like we pay half our salary in taxes and then we get terrible education and a healthcare system where you can't even get an appointment.
- harha 3y agoand it creates all the wrong incentives since they're overdoing it by quite a bit. it also forces people to less optimal decisions because they need to avoid taxes. at the end of the day, this makes them less resilient, since governments won't be fast enough to react to new developments and incentivized to actually solve problems. edit: just to add to this: I don't think pooling / sharing is bad, there are many cases where this makes sense (investments, insurance), especially when it's voluntary, but it's easy to overdo it in a forced model. European living abroad btw, familiar with many different ways people live.
- geysersam 3y agoOptimal decision making = poor people don't buy health insurance, rich people buy health insurance
- abwizz 3y agoon the flip side, would you rather the bribe your dr for an appointment and "donate" to the school?
- harha 3y agowell you need to in a public system that's overloaded, so you lose both when paying in and again when you need to get treatment.
- vidarh 3y agoAmericans pay more in tax towards public healthcare than we do in some European countries. Then they pay again. E.g. the UK NHS costs less per capita than Medicare + Medicaid costs per capita (not per user), despite the former providing universal service. Partly explained by artificial restrictions on Medicare limiting their ability to negotiate price - the "free" market is intentionally prevented from functioning. It's pretty much corporate welfare paid for by regular tax payers. I never understand why Americans tolerate this. The proportion who pays twice in the UK is around 10% who opt for private insurance on top. The proportion who pays twice in the US is every tax payer. Total healthcare spend per capita (public + private) tells a pretty clear picture, where costs of healthcare in the US is totally out of control.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Americans pay more in tax towards public healthcare than we do in some European countries. Then they pay again. The US system is designed to be profitable for those running it, not offer good value for those using it.
- harha 3y agoYeah US really has the worst of it all, very high taxes and not much to show for it.
- abwizz 3y agothey arguably got the best military power projection capabilities
- idontwantthis 3y agoAll we need is more doctors and nurses and that is not the fault of any kind of insurance. 8000 doctors graduate from medical school in the US each year and fail to match with a residency because there simply aren’t enough spots. That can be fixed.
- bdg 3y agoWhen I meet someone with two PhDs in Europe I started to evaluate if they're contributing massive brain-blasts to civilization or if they just wanted to delay the next chapter of adulthood and use free education as a camouflage.
- numbers_guy 3y agoA Ph.d is mostly cheap labour for the relevant research institution. I wouldn't count that as a cost to society unless the work done is not useful, in which case it is not the Ph.d graduate but the research institution that funded the project that is to blame. Get a Ph.d position is quite competitive and the ones which are less "useful" from an immediate economic perspective are paid much worse.
- consilient 3y agoPhDs are apprentices doing skilled labor, not students in the usual sense. An unfunded PhD offer, even in the US, is a polite rejection.
- vidarh 3y agoThe vast majority of people in Europe pays nowhere near half our salary in taxes. Only a few countries have total tax wedges (including employer payroll taxes) that reach that level for more than small minorities of the population.
- anonzzzies 3y agoNot sure why you get downvoted; most taxes are scales and the highest is around 50%. That doesn't mean you pay 50%. Or even close to it.
- victorbjorklund 3y agoIn sweden we also have social insurance fee (which is a tax according to all def even if it is called a fee) and VAT. 50% is just one of many taxes. You should count all the taxes an individual pays.
- anonzzzies 3y agoSo then you would need, in other countries, count all the unemployment insurance, pension, school premiums and healthcare insurance also towards their tax. Then yes. When people outside more socialist countries say they pay far less tax, they never include any of this, so I don’t either.
- ekianjo 3y ago[flagged]
- vidarh 3y agoThe average earner in Sweden pays <25% combined in tax + social insurance fee according to OECD Taxing Wages.
- Try1275 3y agoI live in Austria. I pay 48% on everything above 60k € and 50% above 90k. Our VAT is 20%. Most people who can afford it pay for private doctors because it‘s almost impossible to get an appointment with one that‘s covered by normal health care. So I guess at least for my country the statement above is somewhat true.
- anonzzzies 3y agoWhere? Nonsense as far as I have seen (lived in 4 EU countries and still living in one). Hospital wise I never had to wait (i'm on public healthcare); MRI's, operations, scopes etc are always within a few weeks. I heard far far worse stories from countries without public healthcare and people with private health insurance , including the US. If you are a millionaire or richer, sure; paying cash is faster, but that's not a system and that works everywhere anyway. We have a bunch of universities in the global top 100 and I have been to one of them which didn't cost me (or my parents) more than a few k euro.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>lived in 4 EU countries and still living in one ... MRI's, operations, scopes etc are always within a few weeks Where?
- pasc1878 3y agoUK for one from my experience. Also GP appointments within a few hours - twice in the last fortnight
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoEveryone I know in the UK said they could only get GP appointments days in the future, never on such short notice.
- ido 3y agoI’ve lived in Austria and Germany and had the misfortune of needing medical care multiple times in both in the almost 20 years I’ve spent in them so far- I’ve never had to wait long or pay much (most of the time pay nothing). I got good care, even though many doctors and nurses seem to have not hears of the concept of bedside manners.
- yardstick 3y agoIn London (both before and after Brexit), getting an appointment with the local GP was a pain and could involve waiting weeks. Also, you could only get appointments by calling at certain times of the day and normally all slots would be allocated within minutes of the phone lines opening. Sure, you could always go to the emergency room at the hospital and wait hours to be seen, but I don’t think that counts.
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoI couldn't always get an appointment in the US - and this is a common issue with specialists. At least here in Norway, if I have to wait for something and I'm sick, I get paid time off work. I'll never go bankrupt from medical bills. Taxes plus health insurance premiums was more expensive in the states than payroll taxes here. There is an actual safety net. I'm unlikely to starve or be homeless for any length of time. The VAT isn't nearly as bad since it is generally an upfront cost, included in price. Some exceptions apply with online shopping. ¨ Oh, and I'll mention that I can always get an appointment with my GP if I'm sick: They keep some time slots open for urgent things. I might wait a few weeks when it isn't urgent. And I won't lose my job for having appointments.
- draugadrotten 3y ago> At least here in Norway Norway has an enormous amount of wealth from oil and therefore it is not a good example to show any benefits from pooling wealth. Norway won the lottery, that is all. https://www.reuters.com/markets/europe/norways-wealth-fund-posts-84-billion-first-quarter-profit-2023-04-21/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/europe/norways-wealth-fund-p...
- madsbuch 3y agoIt is the same in Denmark (and most other Scandinavian countries). Also, Norways oil money, as you write yourself, go into their sovereign fund and does not directly fund wellfare. There are many theories why the Scandinavian model works on Scandinavia but does not seem to work other places, but to my best knowledge, natural resources are not any of these explanations.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Also, Norways oil money, as you write yourself, go into their sovereign fund and does not directly fund wellfare. That's orthogonal. Having a massive sovereign fund as your rainy day fund goes a long way in your strategic long term thinking and budget planning compared to countries without that rainy day fund. >There are many theories why the Scandinavian model works on Scandinavia but does not seem to work other places, but to my best knowledge, natural resources are not any of these explanations. Because lack of corruption, government transparency and regulations plus a high trust society are also needed, not just pooling all our tax money for welfare. And those qualities don't exist in many other countries. Scandinavian countries are the global exception, not the norm. The norm everywhere else is "everyone for himself, fuck you I got mine, you go get yours, if you're poor it's your fault for being lazy", despite implementing various welfare programs similar to Scandinavian ones.
- ekianjo 3y ago[flagged]
- mo_42 3y agoMight be true but I've never heard of any European who was bankrupt because of student loans or doctors invoices. Also, it doesn’t seem like Europeans are much more uneducated or unhealthy than people in the US.
- ekianjo 3y agoYou dont have student loans in the EU because the universities are subsidized...
- yorwba 3y agoThere are student loans in the EU, because subsidizing universities doesn't extend to providing free food and housing for students. E.g. student loans offered by a German state-owned bank: https://www.kfw.de/inlandsfoerderung/Privatpersonen/Studieren-Qualifizieren/F%C3%B6rderprodukte/KfW-Studienkredit-(174)/ https://www.kfw.de/inlandsfoerderung/Privatpersonen/Studiere... (Though I don't think many people need it, because most can just get a part-time job and finish in double the time, debt-free.)
- refurb 3y agoTuition is subsidized. But I don't know about you, but living expenses for 1 year are often as much or more than public college tuition in the US.
- jiofj 3y agoDunno why everybody is using this thread to compare the EU to the US, as if I cared about how it is in the US. I'm telling you I pay over half my salary in taxes and get little in return. Whatever happens in the US is not my problem.
- lapcat 3y ago> Dunno why everybody is using this thread to compare the EU to the US, as if I cared about how it is in the US. Because the comment that you replied to was comparing the EU to the US: "And everyone benefits from this kind of collective solidarity - our societies are far less combative (both in the literal and the proverbial sense) than the US are."
- lapcat 3y ago> It's more like we pay half our salary in taxes and then we get terrible education and a healthcare system where you can't even get an appointment. You're talking about the US, right? I and people I know in different states have often had to wait months to get an appointment with a doctor. The quality of education you get in the US varies drastically depending on your location, and typically the wealth of your parents.
- heavyset_go 3y agoI'm in one of the largest metro areas of the US and there are 6+ month long waiting lists to see some common specialists, even if you have great health insurance and even if you want to pay up front in cash. People will die on those lists.
- geysersam 3y agoSounds like it's the same pretty much anywhere then
- NeverFade 3y agoThe only problem with this model is that it doesn't seem to be working long term. Economically, Europe has been stagnating for a long time, and recently its been in a decline. So it's a nice model as long as you can maintain it, which doesn't seem to be very long. https://archive.ph/5eZjb https://archive.ph/5eZjb
- withinboredom 3y agoIt depends on what you value, right? There are hard limits on the number of people any plot of land can handle and feed. Stagnation is probably a good thing. Always “doing more” isn’t always a good thing. It’s not a zero-sum game where there is some kind of competition.
- NeverFade 3y agoStagnation isn't "a good thing" when you're comparing to societies that are progressing. And it may be a zero sum game, when stagnating nations are drained of talent and brains, so this model is even less sustainable, as anyone who can do better leaves, and the rest are left to support those who don't do particularly well.
- withinboredom 3y agoYes, but what is “progress” right now? Move to a country where you can make infinite money (a gamble) but lose it all as soon as you get sick? Or move to another one where every move is monitored and watched? Or where you need a phone to do the most basic things, where you are stranded with no way to eat until you charge your phone? Progress may not always be good, at least in today’s times it basically means “more efficient extraction of wealth from the middle class”.
- playday 3y agoLet’s assume what you’re saying was true: doing less is better. Well just mechanically, a “evil” society that does more will attract more labor and capital than one that doesn’t. Any area of competition except “goodness” will be won by the evil country, such as space races, weapons development, and new technologies. That means the society which chooses to do less will be culturally, technologically, and militarily at the whims of the evil society. So the power dynamic will definitionally belong to the doing more society at the expense of the doing less one, and in the final state the goal of goodness by doing less has failed. This is a contradiction disproving the assumption .
- CTDOCodebases 3y agoIt’s not fair to compare any country to the US since they get to export their inflation.
- apples_oranges 3y agoIt works as long as overall wealth is increasing, businesses and population are growing. We'll see how it goes on from here..
- playday 3y agoThen why is real gdp per capita in many Western European countries mostly stagnant since 2008? If what you’re saying was true, Europe should be growing faster than USA and even faster than countries like China that have much worse social safety nets.
- febusravenga 3y agoI don't know, but as someone pointes out, we EUropeans are less combative and maybe need less to satisfy our needs, so we don't run for more GDP? maybe it's enough? I'm not saying it's good, but maybe it's just less pressure -> less force -> less progress.
- avianlyric 3y agoThere’s more to life than GDP. Economic growth is poor measure of collective happiness or quality of life. Are you going to argue that average quality of life in china is substantially better than Europe because their GDP growth is higher?
- playday 3y agoGoing back to the original article, the subject is regarding ergodicity and economic benefits of cooperation. The commenter I’m replying to extended an analogy to claim that this research extends to certain countries social welfare system. My position is that this extension is outright false, that just because cooperation can create benefits under the conditions of the research, it doesn’t demonstrate economic growth results from social welfare policies.
- j7ake 3y agoBecause these benefits don’t necessary result in growth of real gdp per capita, but increase the stability and livability of a city. A PhD student in many places in Europe can afford to have their own apartment and have kids. Where is that possible in usa?
- machinekob 3y agoIn which European cities PhD can afford to buy apartment (Paris? London? Berlin?). Or you are speaking about smaller cities in which you can also make the same argument for US.
- logifail 3y ago> Society, at least in the classic European model, works just the same (..) everyone benefits from this kind of collective solidarity There appear to be a growing number of voters who disagree. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/30/far-right-on-the-march-europe-growing-taste-for-control-and-order https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/30/far-right-on-t...
- blowski 3y agoYes, this model works well when people are mostly surrounded by people "like them". Populists tell such people they'd be better off if it weren't for all the people with different coloured skin, wearing funny clothes, speaking weird languages. And so while everyone probably is better off, they fester that resentment, creating a cultural feeling that we're not, and it's all _their_ fault.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoPopulist parties in Europe do not necessarily oppose taxation for social programs and collective solidarity. This is the case with the Perussuomalaiset party in Finland, for example, which supports a welfare state in spite of the anti-immigrant rhetoric that gets it categorized as far-right.
- vidarh 3y agoIn fact, historically, few right wing parties in Europe in general have opposed welfare programs outright. A large portion of European welfare programs came from the centre right or right, partially on the basis of a Christian morality argument (e.g. Bismarcks original German healthcare and pension insurance reforms, backed by Zentrum, a party who went on to support Hitlers candidacy for Chancellor, and whose spiritual successor is the CDU), partially as a realisation it was either forging compromises or risk revolution (e.g. Bismarks reforms were at least in part outright "stolen" from demands from left wing parties he banned and imprisoned leading members of, as part of a two-prong strategy of appeasement and an iron fist. That free market and right libertarian parties have gained some traction again is a relatively "new" (few decades) phenomenon, after many of them were squeezed hard by the rapid growth of socialist parties to their left a century ago. EDIT: Worth adding that classically liberal parties in Europe have largely leaned socially liberally, e.g. "low overhead welfare" rather than no welfare. A lot of the universal basic income talk comes from classical liberals as a counter to social democratic "big government welfare" not by removing the welfare but by trying to minimise government involvement in the equation.
- iknownothow 3y agoI think the Personal Liability insurance that almost everyone has in Germany is an overlooked societal lubricant. For €10 a month, you get €10 million in coverage for accidental damage. * No incentive for revenge law suits. * Damages are well regulated so you can't sue for €1 million just because someone's bicycle ran over your toe. * Can't sue for exorbitant medical expenses because in most cases there are no personal medical expenses i.e. covered anyway by govt health insurance. I'm unsure if personal liability insurance is popular elsewhere in Europe.
- logifail 3y ago> Damages are well regulated so you can't sue for €1 million just because someone's bicycle ran over your toe. Counter-example: a website uses Google Fonts and the owner gets a letter from someone's German lawyer demanding they pay "damages" for the GDPR "violation" [0] https://www.bitdefender.com/blog/hotforsecurity/german-website-fined-100-euros-after-court-says-googles-font-library-violates-gdpr/ https://www.bitdefender.com/blog/hotforsecurity/german-websi... [1] https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/web/razzia-wegen-betrugs-rund-um-google-schriftarten-a-d70a829e-05b9-47ba-8eab-fa90996e4cca https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/web/razzia-wegen-betrugs-run...
- RandomLensman 3y agoYou notice that the Spiegel article talks about criminal behavior by a lawyer (and the individual sums are tiny, not even clear they would have taken this to court as German courts take upfront fees).
- patall 3y agoFrom what I have heard from someone working at an insurance company, those liability contracts are not cost covering. They have those for customer recruitment.
- bsza 3y agoThis model works well in countries that already have the wealth to support it, usually from spending centuries colonizing other countries and sucking them dry. It doesn't work quite as well in the countries that had been colonized.
- slushh 3y agoWhy? From a cash flow perspective, the monthly insurance premiums should cover the expenses.
- sleepyhead 3y agoSorry to break your bubble but most European countries did not colonise other countries. The most successful ones, Scandinavian countries, did not colonise other countries (well they did internally but not the same way as England and France for example). If you look to Norway we had a social democratic system before we gained the majority of wealth (aka oil).
- bsza 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_overseas_colonies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_overseas_colonies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_possessions_of_Norway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_possessions_of_Norway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danish_overseas_colonies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danish_overseas_colonies
- consilient 3y agoScandinavian countries did not establish successful profitable colonies (except perhaps Iceland, if you want to count that). It's ambiguous enough whether the average Briton really benefited from their colonial adventures: the Scandinavian peasantry clearly did not. Finland in particular was an impoverished backwater until the early 20th century.
- xg15 3y agoDepends. A lot of the former colonies attempted more collectivist policies but were prevented from doing so by their former colonizers (or other rich countries). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1973_Chilean_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1973_Chilean_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fran%C3%A7afrique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fran%C3%A7afrique
- tomjen3 3y agoHard disagree on that - I would be much better of with a US health insurance were there weren't months of waiting time for treatment. Sure if I am unemployed I would be better of with the version we have in Denmark, but I won't be unemployed for long. And if I get a disability, I have private insurance for that too, because the public one isn't good enough. The unemployment insurance portion I pay will pay out something like 1/2 my salary, but because everyone pays the same in I am subsidising those who are much more likely to be unemployed (bricklayers in winter, to make a simple example). Oh and many of those are going to get most of their salary paid out because they are not over the cap. So to sum up: by having a single system everone pays into you are going to be put together with people who have an entirely different risk profile and you will be better of in a system were you could choose your own insurances. Then of course I am also subsidicing all the drug users and alcoholics, but thats also an issue in the US, because society has decided that we must.
- heavyset_go 3y ago> everyone (yes, I know, there are exceptions, that's not the point) pays their share into health insurance Everyone pays their fair share based on income from working, but not from their wealth, assets, dividends, interest, etc in many places. If your "income" comes from those sources, you aren't paying your fair share compared to people who must work to eat.
- sleepyhead 3y agoThis is false. Pretty much all personal income is taxed, and definitively dividends. While it might be beneficial for the society to tax assets, any personal income from those assets are taxed in most cases. There are ways to avoid it to a certain extend but if you want a 5 million euros from one of your companies you would pay tax on that. If you want a boat you could set up HireMyBoat Inc and then avoid paying taxes on that 5 mill to pay a boat but still use the boat for vacations (this might be illegal but very rarely enforced).
- heavyset_go 3y agoI didn't say personal income wasn't taxed, and I also put "income" in quotes because capital gains aren't taxed as income, and there are various schemes one can engage in to shield value from, or reduce, taxes like income tax.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoExactly. Which is why a lot of Europe's wealth is inherited and has policies in place to protect that wealth and roll it over across generations (nearly) tax free, so most of the Government taxes are gathered on the backs of the working class, not the asset owning class, making it a serfdom with extra steps. Ironically, US has way tougher inheritance taxes than most of EU.
- anon1199022 3y agoAlso Europe has so many literal monarchy and other royal descents that still owns huge capital, banks and so on. GL with auditing royal families, so much hidden information there.
- machinekob 3y agoTbh there is a price for that, our taxation is one of the highest in the world with stagnation for past 15 years (even with enormous "immigration" flow). Also people who are in top of their fields almost never stay in Europe (especially if they are young) as potential tax burden for top brackets (which aren't that high its mostly middle class in US wealth scale) are enormous and total taxation can be as high as 60-65% (with VAT and local laws [homes, car, fuel]) for 1.5-3x less money then in US or even in some Asian based corporations which directly makes EU stagnant in most of the R&D fields (even in IT i can make like triple the money in US or 1.5x in China corporations). EU system is good if you are making money not from work but from wealth (rent, stocks etc.) which is only for folks who already make a lot of investments in younger days or just inherit a lot of cash/properties/stocks. I know US folks love to be angry about their country, but they are in best position for making decent living in the whole world, except possibly some small asian/european states like Switzerland/Singapore etc.
- lapcat 3y ago> people who are in top of their fields almost never stay in Europe (especially if they are young) > I know US folks love to be angry about their country, but they are in best position for making decent living These are two different things. The disparity of wealth between the top and the bottom, indeed between the top and everyone else, is greater than in the other wealthy countries. For decades, income in the US has been stagnant except at the top. And when the salaries of the masses finally start to rise due to demand for labor, the Federal Reserve decides that is the Worst Thing Ever and intentionally provokes a recession. > EU system is good if you are making money not from work but from wealth Every system is good if you are making money not from work but from wealth.
- machinekob 3y ago> Every system is good if you are making money not from work but from wealth. But not every system is taxing you 65% from work and 0-20% from wealth. Indeed US wealth disparity is enormous but this is also a country with highest number of billionaire, gigant corporations and biggest stock exchange. And all of that didn't change the fact that US middle class is wealthiest middle class in the world (except some small countries that cant be compared Norway/Qatar etc.)
- refurb 3y agoBut the US taxpayer also pays into health insurance (for retirees, low income and subsidies for everyone else), long-term disability, unemployment insurance, workers compensation, social security pension. So what's the difference again?