10 ms·
Supporting people’s right to accurate and safe political discourse on X
- solardev 3y agoLolololol
- pjc50 3y agoIt's going to be extremely funny to see what happens to Community Notes on political advertising. Although this is very much "after the lie has got halfway round the world, we're going to help truth get its boots on".
- nancyhn 3y agoThat'll be great. I love seeing Community Notes on ads. They completely destroy the ad at times.
- zzzeek 3y agoI see no reason why "select" advertisers (where "select" means, "Elon selects them") would not be offered an option to pay extra to disable community notes from being on their ads, even though they are implying that's not the case here. why would Musk refuse more cash to support propaganda he agrees with anyway?
- convery 3y agoBecause he's in the lucky position of not needing it. They already split their revenue with creators, accepting such a bribe would not benefit him. So awful PR for no real benefit.
- nailer 3y agoThere's already political notes on ads. You're fine to tout conspiracy theories, but you need at least some evidence.
- SpaceL10n 3y agoShouldn't the URL be blog.x.com? They probably fired the guy in charge of the blog and haven't been able to update the domain yet. Rooks.
- lasermike026 3y agoX is dead. Drive a stake through it's heart and get it over with.
- rchaud 3y agoSays a lot about the state of Twitter when its most notorious bannee returned only to drop a link to his personal website, which apparently also functions as a begging bowl.
- fredgrott 3y agohmm hiring for safety team Elon disbanded.... I am just wondering how one would balance speech against the obvious revenue by ads bias as with newspapers the claim was that the editorial was that structural to balance it which then turn out to be somewhat a farcical lie. Plus, one has the system bias of the limit of characters and the way posting as implement promotes trash talking rather than other forms of discourse and it is my understanding that was done to correspond to mobile SMS at the time. Interesting discussion would be what routes Elon had at disposal to attempt: -buy twitter out-right and hope to hobble it to change it. -buy twitter hobble it and then find an upcoming competitor to buy to transform twitter into. -etc.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bloopernova 3y agoSo he's after that sweet, sweet presidential campaign advertising money? Will twitter make it that far? Doesn't it have to pay back like $13bn by the end of this year?
- lisper 3y ago"Starting in the U.S., we’ll continue to apply specific policies to paid-for promoted political posts. This will include prohibiting the promotion of false or misleading content, including false or misleading information intended to undermine public confidence in an election" Yeah, right. And Fox News is fair and balanced. The problem with prohibiting "false or misleading content" is that you have to somehow adjudicate what is false and misleading. Is it "false and misleading" to say that (say) Joe Biden is "the most corrupt president in American history"? [1] I certainly think so [2], but there are literally tens of millions of people who would profess to disagree. So who gets to decide? In the case of X, the answer is: Elon Musk. The problem is not that there's anything wrong with the policy statement. The problem is that we as a society have totally lost our grip on what is false and misleading, and this can be laid squarely at the feet of Donald Trump, whom Elon supports (or at least has supported in the past). So no, a commitment from X to "prohibit the promotion of false and misleading content" does not inspire confidence in me. Quite the opposite. It feels North-Korea kind of creepy. [1] https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/politics/newt-gingrich-biden-administration-most-corrupt https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/politics/newt-gingrich-bi... [2] https://newrepublic.com/article/175141/fact-check-republicans-biden-corruption-timeline-errors https://newrepublic.com/article/175141/fact-check-republican...
- aydyn 3y agoSo if it wasnt Musk and instead someone you align with, youd agree with the policy ?
- lisper 3y agoHumans have invented a reliable way of adjudicating truth. It's called the scientific method, a closely related cousin of which is professional journalism. There's a reason that it takes years to develop the expertise to be a scientist or a journalist. It's hard work. But it is the only defense against demagoguery. So yes, I would feel a lot better about it if the decisions were being made by someone -- or, even better, a group of people -- who were committed to a process of adjudicating truth on the basis of evidence rather than ideology. And yes, I tend to agree with such people because I personally try to hew to evidence over ideology. One of the benefits of adjudicating truth on the basis of evidence rather than ideology is that it tends to converge, and so it tends result in people who adhere to this process agreeing with each other. Superficially this looks a lot like agreement based on ideology, but there is one big difference, and that is that dissent is actually welcome -- if you can back it up with evidence. In science, progress is possible. In a system that bases truth on ideology, particularly one whose ideology is rooted in an individual (i.e. a personality cult), it isn't. That's what scares me.
- CamelCaseName 3y agoHave they finished banning all the journalists now so that they can control the definition of "accurate"?
- nailer 3y agoI think journalists are allowed as long as they don't publish realtime location data of individuals, which seems consistent with safety policies elsewhere. Edit: not complaining about downmodding, but if someone has a factual response, please post it, because I read a lot about civil liberties and haven't heard of any journalists being banned for non-safety reasons.
- pritambaral 3y ago"Rules for thee, but not for me" is not a consistent policy. Especially when the "rules for thee" bit is twisted wildly out of shape to resemble nothing beyond a schoolyard bully's lies.
- nailer 3y agoI don’t like inconsistency either. The policy is fairly clear. If Musk or another person on Twitter is revealing someone else’s location and Twitter is not applying the policy consistently please provide supporting evidence of this.
- pritambaral 3y ago> ... please provide supporting evidence of this. I don't need to. Musk himself does it pretty well. The time when he tweeted to his mob to find a guy by posting his face and car number. Just two days ago when he posted a video of himself driving to what he claimed was Zuckerberg's house. How about the journalist whom Musk doxxed before he bought Twitter? That journalist never reported on anything regarding the jet tracker. Musk still banned her. And all she'd done was post portions of court documents of a case she was involved in, where a witness claims Musk had her devices hacked. Because she'd reported on Tesla. That journalist is still banned, BTW.
- jackmott 3y ago[dead]
- celtoid 3y agoRather than some vague "right" being proffered in a blog post, I prefer to exercise my right to not use Twitter since a very toxic oligarch has taken it over.
- ck2 3y agoWhy hasn't a group of newspapers and other media together launched an exact knockoff of old twitter yet? Just neutral ground for all of them. If they have a whitehouse press pass, they're cleared as legit. It's not technically hard to build and if you run your own servers not that expensive even at scale in the millions. We have blazingly fast web servers and database software these days compared to when twitter and facebook first launched, even the hardware is exponentially faster and you don't have to support SMS anymore like how twitter got it's start.
- pjc50 3y agoBuild a social network and nobody will come. It's the audience that's valuable, and on Old Twitter the huge diversity of sources. It used to be a valuable input into news, and that's one of the things that basically been destroyed without replacement. No doubt individual journos are keeping eyes on parts of Mastodon, but it's fundamentally not as suitable.
- ck2 3y agoMastodon is basically wordpress micro-blogging with trackbacks We actually need a monolith If every major newspaper and media outlet had their own unified independent social media network and mentioned it at the end of every article and video segment, it would be millions of people within a year. That's literally how twitter audience was built, every media outlet kept mentioning it the first few years.
- ncr100 3y agoX is still merely acting like a BBS. It is not offering a tech-solution. Community-Notes could become that if AI moderation is trustworthy (judging for facts, and tone). ... Forums for political discourse are chock full of opinion. Facts are under-quantified. This article's set of rules describes a Gentlemen's Handshake, and offers nothing technologically-speaking. "No": > .. posting or sharing content that may suppress participation or mislead people about when, where, or how to participate in a civic process > You may not impersonate .. > may not deceptively share synthetic or manipulated media that are likely to ... Nothing here is enforceable from a tech perspective. It's all requiring passive human moderation. To contrast, Reddit's Up / Down vote mechanizes moderation, making it active. And one naive evolution could be an AI judging factuality and tone-appropriateness. Clever voting schemes (Reddit, +) don't scale. AI scales but could be "wrong". Human moderation is easily subject to astroturfing. Q: What is the right next-step in moderating conversation to fit within the boundaries of the forum?
- what-no-tests 3y ago[flagged]
- eterevsky 3y agoI don't really see Twitter banning users for "incorrect" political speech. Moreover, their Community Notes work very well for fact-checking.
- fl0id 3y agoIf Elmo doesn’t like it? Definitely
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adionionio 3y agoThey have absolutely tried to censor wrongthink. I don't know if the boss has had users banned, but he has clearly demanded interference. Here are the two most famous examples: https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/08/15/twitter-x-links-delayed/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/08/15/twitter... https://www.npr.org/2023/04/05/1168158549/twitter-npr-state-affiliated-media https://www.npr.org/2023/04/05/1168158549/twitter-npr-state-... EDIT: A lot has happened in Twit-land over the last year, so I forgot all about the ElonJet affair. Twitter has banned people to try to suppress news the owner didn't like. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/16/business/media/elon-musk-twitter-journalist-suspension.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/16/business/media/elon-musk-... Here is the current tracker, by the way. https://mastodon.social/@elonjet https://mastodon.social/@elonjet
- eterevsky 3y agoI disagree with Twitter's decision on the first count and don't have a good opinion about the second. However these examples fall far short of what other social media companies are doing. On YouTube a year ago you could be banned for suggesting that Covid could started as a lab leak.
- irrational 3y agoI cannot get used to Twitter being called X. When I see “on X” I think of X in algebraic terms, that it is standing in for some other value rather than being a name unto itself.
- rchaud 3y agoThink of the X Games, WWF Attitude era, Tony Hawk skateboarding videogames, and other kewl activities for kids from the late 90s. That would the period in Musk locked in his vision for the most badass letter in the alphabet.
- EarlKing 3y ago"Is it cool if I just call you "X"? I can't really pronounce all that..." "Only if I get to call you "Nutlicker"" "If bullshit were music, you'd be a big brass band..." -- The Doom Generation (maybe Elon's a fan?)
- version_five 3y agoWhen facebook became Meta it sounded really stupid to me and I had a hard time referring to them as such. Now I actually think it's a better name. I don't know if that will happen with twitter but I expect well get used to it. After a brief peak in attention it's relevance is quickly waning anyway, so more likely we just won't care.
- hotnfresh 3y agoThe difference is that Facebook is still Facebook, like how google’s Alphabet thing didn’t re-brand google, really. Incidentally, my social circle (mostly non-tech) still just calls Meta and Facebook both by Facebook, most of the time.
- andrewflnr 3y agoAt least they didn't try to change the name of the actual product. X is trying to erase Twitter from existence.
- JohnFen 3y ago
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoYou don’t have a right to anything that someone else has to provide.
- hotnfresh 3y agoWhat definition of “right” are you operating under? It’s got to be an unusual one, and I’m interested to see where that conclusion’s coming from.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoThe US one. Where it has always been absolutely clear that the government does not provide the right, that people are born with thrm, but they restrictions against the government for the people.
- hotnfresh 3y agoI’m surprised that’s the one you’re using, given your other post—the bill of rights includes rights that do make demands on others. How’d you settle on that definition? Find Locke especially convincing?
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI notice you didn’t argue any specifics.
- hotnfresh 3y agoI wasn’t really trying to argue. If you mean examples from the bill of rights, of rights that make demands on others: the big examples are trial by jury and the right to legal representation. Those rights demand that the government have the ability to compel labor (the accused in a trial has the specific right to compel testimony, even!) at least in certain narrow circumstances, for those rights to have any practical meaning. Unless we want to allow that the government may simply be unable to e.g. prosecute murderers if it can’t find enough volunteers to help, which I doubt was what anyone involved in drafting the document had in mind as an intended outcome, and besides, some parts make it clear that they mean participation may be forced if necessary. So, rights as understood solely from the us constitution & bill of rights (let alone later amendments, which aren’t necessarily concerned with rights per se) do explicitly allow the possibility of a right that makes demands on others, which is why I was surprised that was your basis for the initial claim.
- lapcat 3y agoMore like, supporting our struggling ad revenue.
- jeffbee 3y agoTheir ads inventory has fallen to zero. The only ads on there are Cheech and Chong. 24x7
- davidmurdoch 3y agoI haven't seen a Cheech and Chong ad.
- convery 3y agoSame, it's almost like ads are personalized and being bombarded by similar ads says more about the consumer than the supplier..
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- refulgentis 3y agoA new low for the...quasi-legal...ad inventory the last 6 months: 18 year old "breeder" who has "already pumped out 20 kids", and is getting "LICK LICK" https://twitter.com/jpohhhh/status/1697008262028116178?s=20 https://twitter.com/jpohhhh/status/1697008262028116178?s=20 EDIT: thread is getting derailed by whether or not people have seen specifically Cheech and Chong. Recentering: ads are widely weed edibles, AliExpress dropshippers, and sexual apps/content.
- lapcat 3y ago> EDIT: thread is getting derailed by whether or not people have seen specifically Cheech and Chong. As far as I'm concerned, this is a worthwhile line of inquiry.
- 3y ago
- HumblyTossed 3y agoGaslighting bullshit.
- adionionio 3y agoThis is burying the lede. I see only one concrete policy change: >Building on our commitment to free expression, we are also going to allow political advertising. The rest is generic discussion of their Very Important Values.
- nailer 3y agoHrm I read it for 15 seconds seconds and already noticed a second, the refocus on combating manipulation. Maybe re-read it?
- adionionio 3y agoYou mean this? >We’re currently expanding our safety and elections teams to focus on combating manipulation, surfacing inauthentic accounts and closely monitoring the platform for emerging threats. Not even a year ago they fired the majority of staff and disbanded entire teams. Whatever expansion there is now is dwarfed by those massive cuts. Twitter's policy has been, and continues to be, to keep moderation to a skeleton crew as a cost-cutting measure.
- nailer 3y agoYes that’s what I mean. The previous team famously focused on ideological purity over trust, safety and authenticity and absolutely needed to be replaced.