12 ms·
What the First Amendment says – 4 basic principles of free speech in the U.S.
- carabiner 3y ago[flagged]
- kstrauser 3y agoI’d prefer to have all of them. I’ve never heard of free speech preventing having the others.
- btilly 3y agoWell, now you have. Censoring speech can be used to oppose any viewpoint, and thereby strengthen the political power of its opposite. This censorship can be moral, as in the taboos that http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html points out. Or it can be legal, as in the the current Florida censorship of liberal points of view in schools. Therefore targeted censorship can be seen as a tool to help achieve a political aim. Any aim. Including the aim of electing liberal politicians, to further a liberal agenda. As happened circa 2020 with social media censorship. That's the trouble with freedom of speech. It always sounds like a good idea, but it is darned inconvenient when you have a bit of power and want to accomplish something.
- maximinus_thrax 3y agoSafeguards for democracy or democracy itself aren't antagonistic to social safety nets. Please don't spread this type of propaganda, there are already entire echo chambers pushing these ideas on Reddit, allegedly managed by foreign actors.
- Vaslo 3y agoHousing can be affordable for anyone - that doesn’t give you right to live wherever you want and expect to pay the exact same as someone who’s been twice as lucky or twice as successful as you. I’ll take my free speech and then make the other things work for myself.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoFix that title: 'in US law' The US has a long culture of endorsing freedom of speech in public, regardless of the presence or government. It's a US principle, which of course resulted in the insistence that the constitution be amended to support it in government activities. By no means is Freedom of Speech supposed to begin and end with that amendment.
- Spivak 3y agoWe do? What's your definition of free speech that people in the US actually adhere to? There are plenty of things you can't say that will cause people to not associate with you, block you, not hire you, not do business with you, refuse you service, ban you from community spaces and events, and at the margins lay you out flat. As a litmus test the number of physical spaces I could theoretically carry around or display a confederate flag is basically limited to inside my house and public sidewalks. As soon as you step into somewhere privately owned people will absolutely kick you out for it. You have cultural freedom of speech inasmuch as regular citizens can't use violence in the way the state does but literally every other consequence that can be imposed by private citizens is imposed for speech.
- abfan1127 3y agobeing free to say things does not preclude you other free individuals to deny you freedom of association with them.
- Spivak 3y agoYes but what does cultural freedom of speech even mean when it comes to the interactions between private citizens if not that? You have the freedom to say <blank> and won't be arrested for it is legal freedom of speech. You have the right to say <blank> and Johhny can't smash your teeth in for it is just the law against assault. Stated differently what would a society where there is a legal right to free speech but not a cultural principal of free speech look like and how is it different than the US right now?
- yieldcrv 3y ago“Congress shall make no law” has nothing to do with the courts autonomously creating restrictions, as the courts were incorporated in parallel within the constitution so far, courts have interpreted that to include the courts but their gag orders and heavier punishments based on a person’s speech are all constitutional “free speech” is a fickle symbiosis people are relying on, an inspirational idea that people like
- linksnapzz 3y agoCourts beneath the Supreme Court are creatures of state and federal law, not the Constitution. Punishments based on intent (which can be inferred from speech), is Constitutional.
- yieldcrv 3y agoGood points thank you, I had considered that, so the Supreme Court theoretically could outside of its goal of just interpreting the constitution If original jurisdiction was expanded
- bcrosby95 3y agoNote that the first amendment isn't the only word on free speech in the US, and there are states with laws that force private companies to honor the free speech of citizens in certain circumstances. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruneyard_Shopping_Center_v._Robins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruneyard_Shopping_Center_v._R...
- octonion 3y ago[dead]
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoFree speech as a principle is much broader than what’s protected by the first amendment.
- mindslight 3y agoExactly. This article is from that vein of attorneys explaining things in terms of the law as written. It's true in the sense of legal technicalities, but misses the forest for the trees. And being thoroughly steeped in descriptivism, they generally end up straying from their lane and making incorrect statements like "They can be booted off Twitter and any charges of 'Censorship!' don't apply." (it most certainly is censorship - it's just not illegal censorship). Ultimately the US's Bill of Rights is flawed, having been created before the discoveries of formal logic and complexity induced contradictions of the early 1900's. Framing rights in negative terms allows entities that aren't the de jure government yet still have de facto coercive power to exercise their "rights" at scale, unconstrained by any sense of equity versus individuals' rights. It's why "The Twitter Files" is such a Rorschach red herring - you either see government employees doing the exact same thing that corporate power brokers routinely do over golf games etc, or you get triggered by "government" while ignoring the rest. Either way ignores questioning the sheer majority of censorship. And as corporations become more powerful and unavoidable, they encroach on ever more of our human rights, with no fundamental legal basis to reign them in.
- bitwize 3y agoGovernor Newsom in California is proposing a constitutional amendment that radically limits the absolutism of the Second Amendment. It's high time we do the same for the First Amendment -- specifically a money-is-not-speech amendment and an amendment criminalizing hate speech. Free speech absolutism got us Kiwi Farms, Gamergate, and Trump and put marginalized folks at risk of harassment, injury, and death. (One nice side effect of these amendments is the Republican Party may well shrivel up and disappear, as moneyspeech and hate speech are the Republicans' stock in trade. Every plank and policy in their platform is traceable back to one of those two. The Democrats have an enormous moneyspeech problem too but there at least exist principled Democrats willing to do the right thing without input from corporate masters.) One of the things the Germans realized is that if you want to enjoy a functioning democracy, you must silence people who hold antidemocratic views well before they become too powerful to be stopped. Accordingly you face criminal charges in Germany for spreading Nazi propaganda. Most of the freest, most democratic nations in the world are like this. Why isn't the USA? Hint: the USA is not a democracy. It is an oligarchy of the power elite, formed by the power elite for that very purpose. It's functioning as designed, and radical rethought of the Constitution is well past due.
- hysterix 3y ago[flagged]
- karaterobot 3y agoI wasn't aware that a state Governor could propose an amendment at the federal level, that would be quite a move on his part. Is it possible it's just a PR stunt?
- BHSPitMonkey 3y agoHe hasn't proposed an amendment, he's proposed proposing an amendment. An actual proposal would require 2/3 approval by either Congress (both houses) or states' legislatures.
- bitwize 3y agoIt's a (likely to pass) bill before the California legislature to call for a state constitutional convention. If 2/3 of the states pass such a measure, a convention may be called after which 3/4 of the states may ratify the proposed amendment. It's a means of amendment specified in Article V of the Constitution that can be undertaken without involving the federal Congress.
- dfxm12 3y agoInteresting timing. Given the recent sentencing to death of a Saudi citizen because of tweets (and YT activity), is Musk still talking about how free speech on Twitter is a "bulwark against tyranny"? (This is largely rhetorical. I know that KSA is a huge investor in Twitter and Musk's principals are malleable depending on how much money there is to be made.)
- infogulch 3y ago> The Bill of Rights — the other name for the first 10 amendments to the U.S. Constitution – like the Constitution itself and all the other amendments, sets limits only on the relationship between the U.S. government and its people. > If the government is not involved, the First Amendment does not apply. The interesting point where this intersects Twitter is from before Musk took over. The Twitter Files clearly demonstrated that government agencies, from the FBI to the DHS and more, were in intimate contact with internal Twitter moderators and frequently made demands to Censor (wording!) Americans by banning or deranking their posts. Often despite significant protest by Twitter staff! Hell, there was an internal welcome group and onboarding packet for 'former' FBI agents that were hired on to Twitter, sometimes the same people that used to be on the government side of email chains. The government can't just hide its Censorship behind supposedly independent actions of a private company. If it's government action in disguise the First Amendment still applies. Musk's anomalous takeover suddenly and unexpectedly exposed rampant government-directed Censorship happening inside Twitter. There's no such thing as one cockroach. If you see one, there are a hundred hiding that you can't see. The scary part is that the same thing is almost certainly happening across the tech industry.
- octonion 3y agoThe only things I saw were occasional perfectly reasonable requests, not demands, in areas such as disinformation and invasions of privacy. Furthermore, the internal files were never released as far as I know, but were only given to certain political extremists and then cherry-picked. Am I incorrect? This is why nothing ever came of any of it.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoThe other way that the government tries to do skirt the First Amendment is by having hearings where the Congresspeople/Senators publicly berate and threaten the CEOs of social media companies over content that is protected under the First Amendment
- hellojesus 3y agoThe CEOs need to simply inform Congress of 1A. For the life of me, I have no idea why a congressional hearing is threatening to them.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> when he spoke the words that day, "And if you don't fight like hell, you're not going to have a country anymore," his intent was to incite the violence that followed. Is that right? IANAL, but I would have thought that intent is immaterial; if it's forbidden to incite violence, and you incited it, then what you meant to do is neither here nor there. Intent seems to be a difficult area of law; judges and juries are not telepathic. I don't think there are many crimes that I can commit, for which I would be acquitted if I said I didn't mean to do it.
- enoch_r 3y agoIntent is absolutely part of the law: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/373 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/373 > Whoever, with intent that another person engage in conduct constituting a felony that has as an element the use, attempted use, or threatened use of physical force against property or against the person of another in violation of the laws of the United States, and under circumstances strongly corroborative of that intent, solicits, commands, induces, or otherwise endeavors to persuade such other person to engage in such conduct, shall be imprisoned not more than one-half the maximum term of imprisonment or (notwithstanding section 3571) fined not more than one-half of the maximum fine prescribed for the punishment of the crime solicited, or both; or if the crime solicited is punishable by life imprisonment or death, shall be imprisoned for not more than twenty years. Intent is also one of the key factors that distinguishes between different categories of murder - it varies by jurisdiction, but generally premeditated murder (you intended to kill the person in advance) is different than a "crime of passion" (you intended to kill the person at the moment you murdered them), which is in turn different than an "accidental" murder (you didn't mean to kill the victim, but you did).
- denton-scratch 3y agoOK, Thanks. I forgot that the subject was the US constitution.
- freejazz 3y agoYou can testify that you didn't intend all you want, it doesn't mean anyone will believe you
- brightball 3y agoI don’t know why but it always bothers me when people comment on an amendment in long form like this but only include the excerpt instead of the full context. The article… > It simply states: "Congress shall make no law … abridging the freedom of speech." The entire first amendment… > Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
- Tao3300 3y agoThe article is only addressing that one particular guarantee. The only relevant context they left out was maybe the "or of the press" part.
- brightball 3y agoStill, when you're making a point about the amendment it's helpful to show the entire amendment to the reader is fully aware that no other important context is being left out relative to the position being stated.
- anonymousiam 3y agoThis article is all correct, but omits an important distinction in Section 1. The government WAS involved in censorship activities on social media. https://judiciary.house.gov/media/in-the-news/house-gop-wants-fbis-twitter-censorship-reimbursement-records https://judiciary.house.gov/media/in-the-news/house-gop-want...
- eesmith 3y agoThat is a copy of a New York Post article at https://nypost.com/2022/12/23/house-gop-slaps-fbi-with-preservation-notice-for-twitter-censorship-records/ https://nypost.com/2022/12/23/house-gop-slaps-fbi-with-prese... . It describes claims made by some House Republicans in response to the Twitter Files. As far as I can tell, the link you provided does not demonstrate censorship activities. For example, the NY Post story you linked to has: > An internal Twitter document published Monday by journalist Michael Shellenberger said that the FBI reimbursed Twitter to the tune of nearly $3.5 million for time spent processing law enforcement requests around the 2020 election. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Files https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Files > Shellenberger shared screenshots of an email from 2021, which included a communication from Twitter's Safety, Content, & Law Enforcement (SCALE) team that Twitter had received $3,415,323 from a 2019 program designed to meet the "statutory right of reimbursement" for the cost of processing requests from the FBI. Musk claimed in a tweet that this payment is proof of the U.S. government bribing the company "to censor info from the public", despite such payments being commonplace for processing legal requests. Twitter's guidelines under law enforcement state that "Twitter may seek reimbursement for costs associated with information produced pursuant to legal process and as permitted by law (e.g., under 18 U.S.C. §2706)". Alex Stamos, former chief security officer at Facebook and partner at cyber consulting firm Krebs Stamos Group, wrote that the reimbursements from the FBI have "absolutely nothing to do with content moderation". At the very least, please point to the specific example of censorship, rather than a set of second- or third-hand claims.
- anonymousiam 3y agoIs this a better source? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Files https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Files
- Vaslo 3y agoFor people outside the US, keep in mind the author has a very far left interpretation of the First Amendment. This is obvious with a quick google search of the authors name and the periodicals she writes in and the topics she covers. There is another side to this, her opinion about the amendment is far from absolute. I don’t want to give her too much publicity but in one opinion piece for example she pretentiously lectures a black Supreme Court justice on what diversity is. That’s all I need to know about her.
- jdkee 3y agoHow is her view "far left"? What she wrote fully comports with most constitutional scholars understanding of the First Amendment.
- Vaslo 3y agoDon't get me wrong, I agree with a good bit of what she says, but she lost me a bit with whole sections on "Only for the government" and "Don't conflate legal with morally correct". There's no consensus that people should lose their job because they say something questionable, except by liberal lawyers who would fight for your right to burn a flag or disparage someone on their right, but will suddenly clam up when one of their political opponents does something they find "morally reprehensible". Who decides what's "moral"? The extremes are easy to see - but what about someone who doesn't want to go along with someone's pronouns? Should they be fined? Should they lose their jobs?
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoActual post from February 2023: https://theconversation.com/what-the-first-amendment-really-says-4-basic-principles-of-free-speech-in-the-us-197604 https://theconversation.com/what-the-first-amendment-really-...
- LinuxBender 3y agoIt does not apply to interactions in other nations, nor interactions between people in the U.S. or companies. If the government is not involved, the First Amendment does not apply. I believe this should be tested in the Supreme Court of the United States of America. Governments are using Twitter as their primary and sometimes only means of communications to and from the people. It is not clear to me if this was intentional or a mistake. Are they abusing "It's a private platform ..." and/or that is how they felt citizens could be reached? If the primary means of communication is or should be email or telephone then I believe we should make that clear and Twitter posts from government officials should be labelled as "Unofficial Communications from the {insert government office}. Call: nnn-nnn-nnnn to speak directly to this representative" and probably also mouse-over labelled as "Potential Opinion, Potential Misinformation, not an official stance of {insert government office}." If this is not an option then all government members should be prevented from having an Official Twitter account and instead they must be labelled as Private Personal Account and the government must instead have their own Mastodon and Matrix instances on government networks.
- armada651 3y agoHow does the government using Twitter as a means of communication infringe anyone's freedom of speech? Just because the government uses the services of a corporation does not make that corporation a government agency. Twitter doesn't suddenly lose its right to moderate speech on its platform just because the government uses that platform.
- kstrauser 3y agoRight. It can and should restrict how the government uses those services, but not the service itself.
- LinuxBender 3y agoTwitter doesn't suddenly lose its right to moderate speech on its platform just because the government uses that platform. I think it does, if that is the only means of communication with them. Meaning they only engage on Twitter/X and let their voicemail boxes fill up. That is why I believe this should be tested in the supreme court. [Edit] I should also that that with the former federal agents that managed to get planted in Twitter that were colluding with active duty federal agents that puts Twitter and the US government position in control of speech. I have no idea if Elon removed all of those people or not or if it makes a difference at this point. For all intents and purposes regarding speech the federal government has functional control as if they had used eminent domain but without getting approval to do so. I assume speech on Twitter is highly curated at this point. Curated speech has no place in government communications with its people.