35 ms·
Social media decline: Users are shifting to messaging apps and group chats
- sdfghswe 3y ago> "It's really bizarre to me that everyone's gone to this place in their mind that content has to be so curated," Bruening told us. "So curated that you can't show what you're cooking for dinner, because that's not cool enough." Uuuuuh what? Everyone is doing the thing you want to do, but everyone else is doing it better, so you're complaining. If you were number 1, would you be complaining as well? Sounds like you're just a bitter loser.
- 1-6 3y agoAfter a certain point, social media has become a source for recycled garbage. It's costly to create original content and content creators aren't being properly compensated for their efforts. AI will only further this decline as content creators will have a cheap source of unoriginal content.
- morkalork 3y agoI think nobody posting anymore is an overcorrection or reaction to the days of over sharing and posting about every little bit of drama.
- nightowl_games 3y agoSocial Media started it's down fall ~2008 when the teachers and parents joined facebook. I remember when facebook was _only_ the fellow kids you knew. There were inside jokes, offensive stuff, lots of pure text posts. It was _way_ different. Parents and teachers joined, a couple kids got in trouble for what they posted on facebook, and everyone stopped using it freely.
- 89vision 3y agoI remember when this happened. It felt like everybody's parents joined at the same time almost overnight
- lifefeed 3y agoI remember the exact moment that happened to me. I was sitting with an old friend, and we were looking at Facebook friend requests from my mom, and we looked at each other silently, and realized that everything was about to change.
- pizzafeelsright 3y agoWe call that "the public" and it's why restricted spaces with barriers to entry exist. Allowing Z people to keep X people out of their groups and vice versa.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIt was more than the public, it was authority itself. So many people were grounded. Then came the ads shortly after the parents and then it really was over as it was.
- tropicalbeach 3y agoNo i disagree has nothing to do with that. The downfall is when it became a way for people to make money. Monetizing social media ruined it plain and simple. Now it's just full of people spamming the same trends and posting anything to go viral. The fact we literally have a generation of people of average people who do cringey dances and cringey voice overs as a job is insane.
- gumby 3y agoThe funny thing for me is that my FB feed is nothing but user-generated -- no glossy productions. While I've tried instagram at the instigation of my partner and the opposite appears to be true. And twitter, which I've never really liked, is still for me at least small things written by humans.
- ChumpGPT 3y agoStill relevant today... -Post on 4Chan from a few years ago. I cleaned it up a little (removed retarded and autist). The crux of Social media.... The need for attention, validation, to fit in, and be seen fitting it. Its encourages the worst traits of old internet forums. The upvote/downvote system is a compounding factor on all of this because it gives direct feedback. Violating the group think is instantly punished. Conforming to the group think is instantly rewarded. They are thereby programmed to attempt to appease the group constantly. They live for the rush of validation and dopamine when the upvotes start ticking.This shit becomes such a powerful feedback loop that they really have grasp on reality at all. I've had the misfortune of talking to some IRL hardcore "social media people" face to face. They're socially inept in an entirely unique way. They're capable of basic social graces that an actual crazy/freak isn't, but they still lack critical self awareness. They don't know how to differentiate between the internet b.s and real life b.s. They're gullible and will believe anything from another person who is even half way agreeable to them. Its tragic. They're virtually lobotomized. Genuine NPCs.
- inopinatus 3y agoThe only winning move is not to play.
- kaycebasques 3y agoAn alternative worth pondering: maybe social media just has a shelf-life of 5-10 years. You get into it during your hyper-social teen years, and then you get bored of it. That doesn't mean it will die. So long as we keep having young people there will be a market. But the social media apps are definitely delusional if they keep projecting that the entire human population will keep using social media all the time. I know that this doesn't align with the article, because the article says that Gen Alpha prefers private messaging apps, but I still think there is something to this idea. A lot of us here are the first generation of mass computer and internet usage and I think that clouds our long-term perspective about what computer usage will be like for future generations born into a world where computers always existed.
- jraph 3y agoUsing social media seems common for people around 50 years old. Isn't it?
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThere are tons of old people on social media though
- kaycebasques 3y agoThey are also part of the first generation of mass computer/internet usage, like us. And they were often slower to adopt a smartphone. So they could very well be going through their "first 5-10 years of internet" experience. The fact that they're old right now might just be a distracting factor. Or maybe it is indeed a hint that social media is more likely to be used by certain age brackets and we can think of it in waves: * During teen years you use it for 5-20 years * You get sick of it for 10-20 years * You enjoy it again in the 50-70 age bracket * You stop caring again after 70+
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoOld people move slowly. They meet fewer new people, they get less enthusiastic about the next big thing, they're less interested in new things, hell, they tend to walk slower, too. So when a new phenomena springs up, say, a new type of social media, the fast moving teenagers and young adults get in first. The feedback loop between people joining and existing members convincing more people to join blows up the popularity. Once it's popular enough, if it can be easily translated to appeal to older people, the older people will move in. (I say "if", because SnapChat managed to hit the massive growth curve part without ever really getting the old people on-board). The old people being on the site is a downside, so eventually a new novelty springs up to attract young people. The older people, who are slower moving, get left behind.
- lifefeed 3y agoSocial media companies can get some of the people all of the time, or all of the people for some of the time. For a while Facebook and Twitter managed to be in the second group, which is an hugely profitable group to be in, and they both thought it would last forever.
- dinckelman 3y agoThe moment social media became mostly corporate, I lost interest in it. We're supposed to socialize between each other, not between ourselves and the ads that abuse us
- pmarreck 3y agoAnecdotal data of 1 but I still post to FB and Twitter (uh, X) fairly often. I never got into IG (too superficial, and I actually prefer discussion). Tried Threads for a couple days and it never latched. Reddit (arguably accidentally) permabanned me across all my accounts after I accidentally used a different login to post to a sub I had been (debatably, mods can be jerks) banned on 1 of my accounts in a long while back (this literally flags all of your accounts, which they determine via ML fingerprinting, as "ban evasion accounts" which leads to a permaban across ALL of them... I wish I was joking), so mostly out of pure disgust I haven't been back even to view the read-only bits on a multireddit, and there's no one I can contact there who will respond fairly, so f**** Reddit (which is saying a lot, especially since I've had an account there since it was brand new!) I've started checking out https://lobste.rs/ https://lobste.rs/ since I finally got an account there, but they literally make you wait 90 days before you can invite anyone else (I guess this is "anti-hockey-stick" development?)
- MockObject 3y agoReddit completely deleted all your accounts for this accident?
- JohnMakin 3y agoIt's extremely difficult to get reddit banned, let alone this - OP is telling on themselves
- pmarreck 3y agoIt's absolutely NOT difficult. I've been a Reddit user for decades (I think 2006 was my first account)... if I was actually an asshole, I would have gotten banned a long time ago, instead of 2 months ago. Step 1, have multiple Reddit accounts for anonymity (hey, look, I don't want everyone knowing my medical problems that I seek help on, for example). Step 2, encounter 1 mod on 1 subreddit who misinterprets 1 comment (or you violate TOS without realizing it, by accident) and bans you when you seem insufficiently apologetic (I can show you the conversation evidence here, apparently "I'm sorry I made a mistake" is insufficient). Step 3, accidentally post anything to that subreddit (even something tame or supportive) with a different account months later. Reddit, via fingerprinting, will detect this, and now you are irrevocably a Ban Evader(tm) and all your accounts (as well as any new ones you create, which will now automatically be considered "ban evasion accounts") will be locked in turn as you log into them, making it impossible to interact whatsoever with the site except Reddit admins themselves, and good luck reaching them. I've even bought Reddit Gold (and had plenty of credits remaining). Doesn't matter. Deleting every Reddit cookie, blocking ads and changing your IP? They'll still figure it out somehow, and now you will be even MORE guilty of "ban evasion". It's ridiculous. There's no way to appeal it. It's guilt via mere suspicion. Systems without enough humans suck. Anyway, it's bad enough that your accounts are not actually anonymous there and that Reddit can actually associate all of them with each other. That's enough of a privacy violation on its own to merit not going there.
- mancerayder 3y agoI've been observing a pattern that I've been trying to articulate here and I can best describe as a framework where stuff 'comes to you' whereas the Internet for a long time was an enabler of 'you go to stuff'. The pendulum swung back, thanks to ad tech, and centralization, that have or are trying to orchestrate a culture shift. Okay, here are some concrete examples. 1. Television/cable (absent a TiVo type device), things come to you (ads and programming were fixed and you had to conform to their schedule back in the not-so-old days). Early 2000s, we could download content (illegally), we could pay for Netflix to send us DVDs of our choosing, and the algorithm was benevolent: its recommendations were superb. Russian and French directors I positively rated -- ratings 1 through 5 stars plus a written review were permitted back then -- opened my world to suggestions for other movies that I got to select. Today, Netflix/HBO/etc display a limited UI set of options, highly hyped shows and movies shown repeatedly, and it now Comes To You. You have a tiny bit of choice, but not much. 2. Google search. Before, it was a resource for you to customize and find what you wanted: information about medicine, a product, or a store. Now, it Comes To You. You search for thing X, you end up in a rabbit hole of Y and Z topics or things, and a lot of things seem algorithmically generated or manufactured to steer you rather than help you. There are many many patterns like this, from news searches to even tech problem searches and articles. Don't even get started on product comparisons. It's scary I can't even search on medicine interactions (I add reddit to the search field). I should add, web sites all have their own mobile app so you get trapped, they can steer you, and you can't control ads, the UI, cut and paste, and so on. Thanks, world in which Things Come to Us now. Such as it is: a heavy weight on pulling and steering us, and new generations growing up on phones not knowing it could be different. Phones are an extension of our organ senses now. How will a world in which Things Come to Us and We Dont Go to Things anymore affect us cognitively long-term?
- kwhitefoot 3y agoI post something almost everyday. When I see a headline making an absolute statement like this I immediately dismiss it as an exaggeration. A variation on Betteridge's law [1] perhaps. Their are other social media than the big ones. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- datavirtue 3y ago""How does a brand show up in somebody's DMs or Discord server if they're not invited?" Haberman said. But in many ways, that's the point. People can still go on Instagram to check on their favorite celebrities and influencers, but young people don't want brands and marketers infiltrating the closed communities where they spend most of their time." Young people? That's why I left Facebook. Your brain getting chewed up by ads and alt-right trash.
- WXLCKNO 3y agoInstagram, Facebook, YouTube, Tiktok are all basically Tiktok now. Reels, Stories, Shorts etc are all just a doom scroll inducing version of the same content posted across networks.
- thefz 3y agoBest definition of "content" I ever heard: https://youtu.be/kHe4wwF9O6Q?t=149 https://youtu.be/kHe4wwF9O6Q?t=149 "content is a commodity that fills social media feeds so we can be sold as a collection of preferences [...] attention but not understanding, engagement but not exploration" Every time I hear "content creator" I perceive it as Styrofoam. Filler used to convey a product.
- chooma 3y ago"TV programs are interruptions of commercial blocks" was the quote that stuck with me back in the day.
- googlryas 3y agoI've heard content creators either say explicitly in videos, or in text under videos, things along the line of "Sorry I made a mistake here but I need to get this video out". Imagine reading an essay where the author tried to pull something like that.
- pradn 3y agoYouTube penalizes video creators who don't post regularly. So it's hard for them to take breaks. If a video takes a week to make, how will you have enough of a backlog built up to take a two week vacation?
- cfeduke 3y ago> Every time I hear "content creator" I perceive it as Styrofoam. Filler used to convey a product. This is so good. Perfect. I love it.
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoThank you for this link to "Aphew Twin wouldn't become popular, today." Grew up listening to brother's albums, and laughed realizing chair-squeaks are music, too =P
- pradn 3y agoA good chunk of the use of the word "creator" is the lack of a word to capture the work of someone who uses multiple platforms to distribute their work. Someone can be simply a YouTuber, but if they also do Twitch streams, they have no choice but to be a "content creator". If they're primarily one or another, they can call themselves a YouTuber or a Twitch streamer, but not if they do both. If you add Substack, Twitter, podcasting, and TikTok into the mix (often with significant cross-posting), you really don't have a word except for "creator". And what captures all the things you're creating - "media" or "content" or something equally nebulous. No doubt a lot of it is filler. But a lot of it isn't. I spent last night learning a bunch of cooking techniques on YouTube. Quite valuable for me!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- th0ma5 3y agoI know there's a lot of Musk stans in here, but he really did destroy Twitter, possibly at the behest of the Saudis, and it is now a late night Fox News like ads space full of scams.
- hackermatic 3y agoI've seen a lot less engagement with my Facebook posts in the last couple years, and been shown a lot fewer posts from my friends compared to groups, ads, and "suggested" posts. I used to wonder if it was primarily because Facebook was openly downranking news and politics, and my friends and I posted about those things a lot more than your average users. Now I think it's just because most of them have silently stopped using the platform -- but I think a big reason for that is we figured that if no one is going to see our stuff, then why post it at all? In other words, anticipating the algorithm led to a kind of chilling effect on our usage in general, at least for my own behavior. Not that Internet political arguments have gone great with the current platforms and their incentives, but I don't like the idea that they might not happen at all, especially at a time that seems as important to discuss as this one.
- AlbertCory 3y agoEven in the very earliest days of the Web, there was PointCast, where things came to you. So there was some demand for that mode,even then.
- tracker1 3y agoSocial media seems to be pushing a bunch of content that isn't the people that I actively follow. Twitter, I mean X keeps switching me back to the "For You" tab, and Facebook changed their page/group interface that switches my profile out every time I don't pay attention for a second and I see a feed of random. I can't speak for any of the rest as I generally don't use much else. Given that case, of course I'm less likely to engage on social media. I'm much less there to interact with random strangers. Of course so many people don't go out and do anything anymore, don't engage with people around them when they do, and may be put off if on the other side. It's a really weird time to be alive to say the least. And that doesn't even get into culture issues that most people don't care about, but those that are active in social media are nearly obsessed about (including myself at times).
- nitwit005 3y agoIf social media means a way to communicate with friends, family, and extended community online, it's pretty clear Meta and Tiktok don't want their products to be that. They've made sure you can't get a feed of just your friends. It's natural the people who want that sort of thing will go elsewhere.
- jarjoura 3y agoMeta and I'm sure TikTok as well, would be MORE than happy to follow wherever users want to take the platform. The problem is, time and time again, users do not want what they say they want.
- soerxpso 3y agoWhat you mean to say is that time and time again, users do not want what causes them to maximize engagement levels and click on the most ads. "Users said they wanted this feature, but we implemented it and engagement didn't go up," doesn't mean that the users lied about what they wanted, it just means that they don't want to use the product in a way that requires a lot of wasted time. TikTok users say all the time that they want the option to see a feed of videos from people they're following, in reverse-chronological order. They're not lying. The issue is that the reason they want that is so that they can use TikTok for a short (30 minutes or less) session to check for updates on things they actually care about and then close the app, which would be entirely contrary to TikTok's fiscal goals.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hot_gril 3y agoI think they saw engagement dipping as people got bored with it, so they started filling it with algo stuff instead. If they went back to pure friends, I'll bet it wouldn't work.
- brap 3y agoMy Facebook feed is about 40% sponsored posts, 30% suggested posts, 30% group posts (usually from very large groups), and then maybe 1% actual friends (and it’s usually just something that they’ve shared or commented on, almost never actual content). If we could go back to the days when 80% of the stuff you see is from friends with the remaining being ads, I would happily use FB more frequently and I’m sure most of my friends would too. Surely FB would make more money this way. How did we end up like this? I think once engagement dipped a bit, they started adding filler content just to keep us scrolling and seeing more ads. But that made things worse so they had to add more filler. Which made things worse. Repeat until it’s all just filler and ads and people don’t use it anymore.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoMy mastodon feed is 100% actual friends. That reality exists; it's just not evenly distributed yet.
- Zambyte 3y agoMy Pleroma feed is not 100% actual friends of mine, but that's because I choose to follow certain organizations or public figures. The Fediverse is great because it's exactly what you make of it.
- markdown 3y ago> 100% actual friends But no family because they'd never figure out how to use the damned thing, amirite?
- soderfoo 3y agoAnd if they do join, there is the implicit SLA of ongoing support anytime issues arise.
- zeta0134 3y agoProbably the nicest bonus feature of Mastodon is that I can subscribe to a friend's original posts but unsubscribe to their "boosts," which is Mastodon's way to quickly share content. This way I can follow artists that make cool stuff I want to keep up with, but I don't have to see their political reblogs and other interactions, which helps to cut down considerably on the noise. It's great because it's granular at the friend level. Some of my follows do legitimately act as curators, infrequently boosting cool content that I do want to see. Some are more noisy, and I can pick and choose and tailor my own feed accordingly. It's a nice happy medium, one I'd like to see other platforms emulate if possible, but I suspect they won't because the algorithmic feed is much easier for advertisers to pay to manipulate.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nickdothutton 3y agoWhen thinking about Internet platforms, the lens I like to view things through is one of power. As a user what power do I have if any, to control my experience? To control what I see when and from whom. If I have little or no power, or the power is only shallow or superficial, if the power isn’t very granular, then this all counts against the platform. It may surprise some (younger) members of HN, quite how much power the individual user had on early “primitive” platforms like USENET or closed user groups or chat systems, compared to the big, modern social networks of today.
- ZacnyLos 3y agoInterestingly both X (TT) and Instagram are trying to popularise their group functions, but it's not popular enough.
- Zaskoda 3y ago"If you're not the customer, you're the product."
- madrox 3y agoI've been predicting this trend for years, and it's validating to see someone else say it. It isn't even just messaging apps. Discord and Twitch are also killing social media usage. It's any walled community where people within the community get to decide who is in and who is out, and the reach of casual sharing is limited. Social media can't counter this trend, because it's not in line with their incentives (massive sharing and virality). Social media companies are going to have to react to this eventually. If I had to guess, they're going to go harder into content production.
- jacobwilliamroy 3y agoI stopped posting frequently when I realized I was putting my name on a thing in a public database, and that most hiring processes these days involve putting my real name in google and looking at whatever pops out. I still post nowadays, but it's usually under a pseudonym, from a VM, through a VPN, over HTTPS. I should probably look into encrypting my DNS too. Nowadays when I'm posting in the clear with my real name I usually stop and think "Would someone hire me if they read this?" and then delete everything I wrote and just move on with my life.
- dahwolf 3y agoGood thinking and it's a rule I live by. I do not share anything digitally that would backlash if revealed. Also not in private digital spaces. Not in work chat. Not even on a private device in a note. Nowhere. Digitally, I do not gossip. I have no political opinion on divisive topics. I have no nudes. I don't swear in game chat. There is no smoking gun to be found at all even if you get full access to my entire digital life.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago""How does a brand show up in somebody's DMs or Discord server if they're not invited?" Haberman said. But in many ways, that's the point. People can still go on Instagram to check on their favorite celebrities and influencers, but young people don't want brands and marketers infiltrating the closed communities where they spend most of their time." For some reason, it takes people a long time to figure this out. There is no room for advertising in peer-to-peer networks which is the OG design for the internet. I have been experimenting with running private L2 overlay networks since 2008, pre-Wireguard. The networks are small, managaeable, there are no strangers, no large audiences. If marketers, advertisers and so-called "tech" companies want to try to hack into each and every one of these private networks, then let them. It will be a ton of effort to do on a mass scale, and for little reward. If they are caught I think we can sue them. The open web, walled gardens and "app stores" will always be around for marketers, advertisers and so-called "tech" companies. If anyone wants to communicate person to person or person to small group through a third party's website/server, say, "Mark Zuckerberg" or some other person they don't know, they certainly can. Unless it's HN, advertisers, "creators" and "influencers" will all be there.
- ergocoder 3y agoZuckerberg is really damn good. He really positions Facebook to take advantages of this.
- dahwolf 3y agoHe predicted the privatization of social networks 5 years ago. Which isn't that brilliant, the trend can be casually observed.
- c7DJTLrn 3y agoMassive thanks to Reddit for going ahead with their API changes and killing Apollo. Since then, I waste probably no more than 10 minutes a day on there, and I don't doomscroll anymore.
- dahwolf 3y agoHardly a new insight, Zuckerberg acknowledged that the future of the public square is private, about 5 years ago.
- mrkramer 3y agoI kinda understand this because in the first 10 to 15 years of the commercial internet people were eager and hyped to get connected and share everything what they do and think. Later on this backfired with security and privacy issues like numerous hacks, leaks and privacy fiascos and now they seek more private space to get connected. Nowadays only influencers, content creators and "public personas" want get as much exposure as they can plus private businesses and public institutions. Ordinary people "hide" behind pseudonyms or rarely post with their real names unless I will say it again, they are aspiring content creators/influencers or whatever they want to become in their professional life.
- dahwolf 3y agoEven the public personas are having a rough time. Twitter is falling apart and then there is Mastodon, Bluesky, Threads and just generally a very fractured yet crowded space where you're up against dirty tactics of your peer influencers. I don't feel sorry at all for commercial grifters, but there's also genuine publishers. Institutes that just want to share a message and get it out to the public, as a service. That model is now quite broken.
- mrkramer 3y agoYea Twitter is falling apart but brands, companies and public people have other huge platforms to reach massive audiences like Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, YouTube and since recently very popular TikTok. From what I see and understand if you sell something no matter how big or small you are, first thing you need to do is create your Instagram account and get presence over there because people like visual. When Zuckerberg talks about Twitter not fulfilling completely its role as a text based social network, I would like to remind him that the biggest social network in the world is the global e-mail network not Facebook and yea e-mail is primarily textual. E-mail as a protocol is powerful but features around it are very much stuck in time. Facebook started like Zuckerberg described it as "a directory of people" and then he built around that concept adding features to connect with other people in that directory and share content. But the problem with Facebook is; it's a walled garden and if you are not in it, you are completely out of touch with other people. On the other hand virtually all people who use internet have an e-mail account and e-mail being an open protocol you can connect with anybody without much hassle. When people think about text-based social networks, they need to think again about e-mail and how we can improve e-mail experience and build more powerful features around it and not invent new protocols which are barely getting any foothold.
- daft_pink 3y agoI just wish there was a good and decent messaging app. All the high security E2E encryption apps not run by tech companies that are spying on me have no usable chat history.
- gitowiec 3y agoI and my friends 3 years ago switched to closed group on Signal. We switched from our makeshift mail group we used for 10 years (we all were just using "reply to all" to the infinity). Thanks god Signal has mute option. The emails always waited for me not knocking on the doors like Jehovah's witnesses!
- happytiger 3y agoUsers are shifting away from social media, not towards messaging and group apps. It's an important distinction. Enshitification at work imo.
- 8thcross 3y agowe are just in the beginning of a new trend; that will evolve over the next few years. we just don't know it yet.
- squirrel6 3y agoI was recently telling a friend that I find it so much more meaningful to directly exchange pictures and articles / thoughts with people individually and get their individual reactions
- dredmorbius 3y ago"Geeks, MOPs, and sociopaths in subculture evolution" (2015) [A]s soon as subcultures start getting really interesting, they get invaded by muggles, who ruin them. Subcultures have a predictable lifecycle, in which popularity causes death. Eventually—around 2000—everyone understood this, and gave up hoping some subculture could somehow escape this dynamic.... The muggles who invade and ruin subcultures come in two distinct flavors, mops and sociopaths, playing very different roles. This insight was influenced by Venkatesh Rao’s Gervais Principle,[1] an analysis of workplace dynamics. Rao’s theory is hideous, insightful nihilism; I recommend it.... The sociopaths ... work out how to monetize mops—which the fanatics were never good at. With better publicity materials, the addition of a light show, and new, more crowd-friendly product, admission fees go up tenfold, and mops are willing to pay. <https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths> ________________________________ Notes: 1. <https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00F9IV64W/?tag=meaningness-20 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00F9IV64W/?tag=meaningness-20>
- Alifatisk 3y agoThis is not surprising
- mvkel 3y agoThis seems to follow the same laws that Christopher Alexander outlined about communities. The bigger they get, the less personal they get. A regression to the mean. For example, if your town has fewer than 7,000 people, you'll often see strangers waving to each other, conversations happening at the general store, etc. Once you cross over 7,000, that disappears. Waves turn to nods, and then nothing. Warpcast is the online equivalent -- it has (I think) only 20,000 DAUs, so feels much more friendly and intimate
- dzonga 3y agothat's why tik-tok has grown. there's a sense of authenticity with it. no fake posturing. disclaimer - i'm not on tik-tok. just based on videos I see shared and posted everyn now and then
- meroes 3y agoIf you watch any food videos you’ll see the advertising soon enough though, usually in the form of rage bait or similar. Like using fast food as ingredients to recipes or way too much Velveeta in their recipe.
- neilalexander 3y agoI'm not really sure on your definition of "authenticity" but it seems to me that TikTok users are optimising for the algorithm, for engagement and for advertising revenue just like on every other platform. If anything, TikTok seems to give users the power to be even more annoying and repetitive, between the computer-generated voiceovers and the same few songs being used over and over again ("oh no, oh no, oh no no no no no").
- azangru 3y ago> no one is posting on social media anymore "Nobody comes here anymore, its too crowded".
- mandmandam 3y agoYeah but who's in the crowd? It used to be my friends. Now it's a bunch of **s trying to piss me off for engagement clicks, or scam me. I feel worst for the vulnerable - older or less cynical people, who get caught in the layers and layers of bullshit that constitute the poisoned well. There are people who live and die warped by it.
- piva00 3y agoI feel this misses just one adjective: "nobody interesting comes here anymore, it's too crowded". A similar feeling I get from overtouristed places, initially they are interesting because of some attraction: the nightlife, the art scene, the food scene, or any combination of these (and other factors I'm too lazy to list) with some quirkiness that attracts people who are interested in the twist. Over time it becomes attractive to more people because they hear about it from others who experienced it, then it goes downhill where people will flock to a place but nothing that made it initially interesting is there anymore, it just becomes a self-perpetuating meme. It feels it's a pattern that develops in social media, tourism, products, etc., something fresh appears which gets overextended and bores us out in the end, the laggards missed the magic. Rinse and repeat.
- dredmorbius 3y agoAs I've just posted top-level, "Geeks, MOPs, and sociopaths in subculture evolution" (2015) captures this sense quite well. <https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths>
- tmikaeld 3y agoI can resonate with this, the same applies to cities that are small and friendly. As they grow bigger, crime and scams rise, people are not friendly and more, stores that where quirky and odd close due to competition from low-cost big-store brands..
- nwoli 3y agoSimultaneously twitter is breaking records in number of users (if Elon is to be believed)
- zer0tonin 3y agoI don't see how that's possible, I have been a Twitter users for years and last time I checked my feed was basically a ghost town. I don't even bother logging in because I know the people I liked talking to are now either on mastodon or left social medias entirely.
- quickthrower2 3y agoBoth can be true
- tomrod 3y agoAye, logically it could be, but Elon lies and it is false.
- miduil 3y agoSimply not true https://www.similarweb.com/blog/insights/social-media-news/twitter-shrinking/ https://www.similarweb.com/blog/insights/social-media-news/t...
- lefstathiou 3y agoThe link you provided is from April. When I click on the article, then click on the cited Twitter stats “visits to Twitter.com”, then scroll to “Total visits in last 3 months” (for Twitter of course), the report appears to indicate that traffic is up 1% MoM and currently at a high for the trailing 3 month period (which is all they provide). It is just shy of Instagram (which I was surprised to see).
- redserk 3y agoThe number of users is a different metric than amount of (interesting) content created by those users.
- bluetomcat 3y agoIt's not social media anymore. In their feed, people are bombarded with ads, news, jokes as regular "content creation" and group posts where strangers with a narrow interest in, say, collectible figurines are posting pictures of their new purchase.
- p0nce 3y agoTwitter doesn't show me the people I follow, and instead show people I "might like", in no particular time order. When I do interact, almost noone of my followers can see my post because I'm not an advertiser / paid user. Same from Facebook. So it's not worth "building an audience" if you can't communicate with it, and your audience can be taken from you at will.
- agent008t 3y agoIt all went to shit the moment 'timeline' became 'feed'.
- pxmpxm 3y agoThis. All people want is to be able to see pics of their friends and kids from whatever vacation they're on, preferably in chronological order.
- sznio 3y agoBut then you'd just come in for 10 minutes a day and be done. Can't earn money on such healthy engagement.
- rpjt 3y agoPeople say they want this but I'm not actually sure that they do. Didn't FB do some study about this?
- dahwolf 3y agoPeople don't want this. They say they do but they don't. Social media is 15 years old now. Watching what your friend had for dinner or some other mundane non-event is just not that exciting anymore.
- falcor84 3y agoI wonder whether Google+ and its Circles would have seen better success if it was launched now.
- politelemon 3y agoI think its reputation of killing products would still have been a factor in avoiding using it. Maybe not a factor for everyone but at least in some... uh, circles.
- c4mpute 3y agoCircles was a great idea. But not really good enough. I'd have liked an "ignore" circle, like banning users on other platforms, just quietly, like the shadowbans some implement on a personal feed level. Also, Circles was the only good thing about Google+. The rest was average to bad, and the forced integration into all kinds of Google services, the forced realnames, and the lack of third-party integrations killed any kind of goodwill/benefit-of-doubt anyone might have had.
- everdrive 3y agoI think what people sometimes miss is that circles was a good feature for users, but a bad feature for the platform. They interrupt vitality and outrage, since all messages are potentially more contained.
- mekoka 3y agoIf Gmail was launched today would you bother?
- lolive 3y agoI have an addiction to Twitter, but I am the first to admit that top-quality tweets are one in a million in my timeline. The big advantage is that I follow so many different kind of people at once that there is a HUGE diversity of infos. On the contrary, I follow very specific topics on Reddit. And as far as I am concerned, the quality of info is top-level, and the signal/noise ratio is VERY good. Regarding Facebook, I mostly only follow [dedicated] groups now. And once again, the signal/noise ratio is much better. Conclusion: apart from Twitter, social media are all back to being fancy Usenet clones :)
- tomrod 3y agoI took a 2 year break from Facebook. It just got to be too much. I just rejoined, as kids' schools send messaging and announcements regularly there and other groups of local interest use it to coordinate. Outside of that, no one is posting anything but meme reshares that echo 1990s email forwards.
- c4mpute 3y agoI think this is an eternal cycle. Maybe related to what has been called "enshittification", but not the same: Users will flock to a platform, make it their own. The platform will grow. Then the advertisers, professionals, and hucksters will swoop in, do their thing, and slowly overshadow the old "normal" users. Then old users will leave, leaving a wasteland of ads and glossy shiny. I'd like to call it "glossification".
- Buttons840 3y agoHN loves to complain about Discord (with good reason), but Discord is anti-gloss. Small Discord communities can generate a lot of discussion, a lot of user generated content. Discord is also a poor place to do stealth advertising; if you post fake messages about how good your product is, those messages will just get buried and will never show up in a search result; it's not very effective. Things changed this year. We saw the rise of LLMs and the fall of Twitter and Reddit and the rise of federated social networks. I think the Twitter / Mastodon format is more robust for both small and large user bases; the Reddit format is dying. Real-time chat rooms still have a place, especially with the right tooling / notifications. LLMs threaten to replace all of them and end the online network effect altogether.
- Root_Denied 3y agoMy biggest problem with Discord is still more related to support communities (what would have previously been a focused forum or subreddit) moving there, and the subsequent lack of archival of topics and answers for future reference.
- margalabargala 3y agoThis has actually been fixed in the past ~6 months, and quite nicely. They added the concept of a "forum" channel, where you can have individual support questions, and each one has its own thread that addresses that specific question. Better yet; the search box and the "make a new post" box are the same box. So if you're starting to ask your question, as you type, it's filtering previous questions based on the words in the question you're trying to ask.
- iamflimflam1 3y agoThere are a number of reasons. One big one is that a lot of content is now generated by professional outfits. Why would you post something you’ve made yourself when you are competing with big budget production companies or well funded creative marketing teams?
- TjZkxkxeky 3y agoBut..... marking teams don't have interesting things to say.. "competing", perhaps, but they aren't winning.
- andrewgioia 3y ago> "How does a brand show up in somebody's DMs or Discord server if they're not invited?" Haberman said. But in many ways, that's the point. People can still go on Instagram to check on their favorite celebrities and influencers, but young people don't want brands and marketers infiltrating the closed communities where they spend most of their time. All people don’t want brands in their closed communities! Anecdotally I strongly agree with the article. I pretty much only use Discord and group texts anymore among friends and family (though I do self host and share on Mastodon/Pixelfed/Lemmy it’s a fraction). Any time I poke around on traditional social media it just feels like a wasteland, 90% ads/curated content. Fine if you want to go read a magazine for a bit I guess but a shell of what it was like a decade ago.
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> All people don’t want brands in their closed communities! Since you can't avoid having these ads/brand placed in your preferred social media platform (the users are the product (to be sold to advertisers) and not the customers), the next best thing that you can do as a user is to subvert the undesired brands that you see in your social media stream (e.g. by posting something that makes fun of an ad that you see) to make the social media platform a less desirable place for the respective undesired advertiser.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoAll press is good press
- Double_a_92 3y agoThe main thing for me is that I don't want everything I share with my friends and family to be public. If I e.g. comment on a photo that my brother posted, I absolutely don't want any of his other random acquaintances to also see that. And also the other way around, if my friends comment something on my photo I don't want my brother to see that. Private groups are the only way to avoid that. Or maybe a system like G+ had with the Circles, so I could e.g. share tech things only with my techie friends without bothering my aunt with it.
- neovialogistics 3y agoI think it might just be the corollary of the aphorism: "If you build it, they will come."
- matsemann 3y agoI posted a lot on facebook in high school. Had maybe 50 friends there, like my classmates, soccer team etc. Posted at least once a day what I was doing, same did everyone else, and we discussed in during lunch next day. Or I would post a general "going to the soccer field, just join in", and we'll be a group there. Then joining university and getting new groups of friends, it didn't feel relevant to "spam" everyone with these things anymore. And then friends and family joined. Then I got a job and new groups, and suddenly there's 500+ friends on there I don't want to tell everything to... And the opposite problem with people I follow on social media. I care about your tech writings, or your sport performances or whatever. But not everything else you post. I want a slice of you, not everything. Hence, silence.
- jonahrd 3y agoThis makes me wonder if something like Google+ "circles" or the idea of maintaining a finsta could translate into a way to bring back posting on social media. I think what Google+ got wrong is that connections are a 2-way street, you may not realize your new friend _wants_ the day-to-day updates and soccer game invites, because to you they may just be someone you met at work. Imagine if you could have a list of feeds to follow, personal, professional, etc. And when adding someone you could follow whichever feeds you wanted, and unfollow certain ones at any point. Some could be private, so you'd have to be approved to follow. Then I wouldn't feel the need to remove old acquaintances from fb, I would just unfollow their feeds. I would feel comfortable posting stuff related to my job/networking because I know only people following my professional feed would see it. And I'd be comfortable posting personal stuff to my personal feed if it was locked and I was the maintainer of who could follow it. They could pretty easily implement this in facebook and I could imagine it breathing life back into the platform.
- dahwolf 3y agoI remember the circles concept working for about 2 weeks. I'm into photography and people started creating "best photographers" circles, one of them had 700 posters in it. You could follow the entire circle with a single click after which your feed is pretty much done. A handful of circles would be massively followed which means whoever was lucky to get in early, ruled the platform or niche.
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- dutchCourage 3y agoSocial networks put engagement before everything else and alienate their products. I moved away from Facebook to Instagram when it stopped being about my friends, and did the same when Instagram tried too hard to be TikTok. And I like these services independently. I watch short content, I like following what my friends do and I follow(ed) strangers on Twitter. But the moment everything is crammed into one app the experience becomes dull. I wish they'd spin up new apps instead of adding more and more layers to the existing ones.
- nottorp 3y agoHmm the article title implies they're talking about all social media but most of it is about Instagram. Also, it smells of a marketer's perspective. Of course if most posts are fake people will stop being interested in the platform.
- pmontra 3y agoI've been using WhatsApp groups for sharing with my friends and some Telegram groups too. Everybody has WhatsApp and actively uses it here anyway, so there is no extra app to install. No need to use Instagram, Discord, TikTok or whatever. It crosses all age groups.
- buro9 3y agoIt might not be for everyone, but I'm posting more on social media than ever and seeing more engagement than ever... it's on the fediverse where smaller and safer communities are leading to much higher valuable engagement. I'm also finding it a lot more common for people to have multiple profiles / personas... the social one, the work one, the furry one, whatever is how you want to present yourself and to whom, without needing to try and contort yourself to be everything to everyone.
- BrotherBisquick 3y ago[dead]
- anonzzzies 3y agoWhere are you posting? I find so little quality content.
- orwin 3y agoOne feed I used to use Twitter for: https://infosec.exchange/public/local https://infosec.exchange/public/local (I never was a fan of Twitter, and I use mastodon like I use Twitter : only when I'm bored, every months or so). You have to find a feed/subreddit that interest you. Hell, I even spend more time on stackexchange than I do on YouTube now. It's about niche, and small communities, where read is free but write not so much.
- lexicality 3y agoIf they post it publicly then it won't be small and close-knit any more
- rpastuszak 3y ago>I'm posting more on social media than ever and seeing more engagement than ever... it's on the fediverse where smaller and safer communities are leading to much higher valuable engagement. Precisely, it's signal vs. noise imo. There's an illusion that with more viewers you're more likely to find interesting people, but in practice it's mostly a distraction.
- 3y ago
- rpastuszak 3y ago0. It's been 15 years and I still don't know how to use Twitter. 1. Most of my online social interactions come from people interacting with my work (writing, code, drawings) through: - my say hi calls (https://sonnet.io/posts/hi https://sonnet.io/posts/hi) - Mastodon Quality > quantity ("the Internet is big. Really big. You just won’t believe how vastly hugely mindboggingly big it is.", i.e. small niches are big enough) Not every company needs to be a unicorn, and you don't get closer to people with 10000s of followers vs. 100s who genuinely care. 2. When I started moving my content from instagram to potato.horse I noticed that suddenly content selection and adding captions to images became so much easier. It's so hard to escape the performative/"screaming into the void" frame of mind when using algo driven social media. Now, I still syndicate to IG and Reddit, but I have templates with comments redirecting users to potato.horse, where I can do whatever the f*ck I want with my content.
- muhammadusman 3y agoI love the domain potato.horse
- SeanAnderson 3y agoHello :) I just wanted to let you know that I intend to reach out and say hi to you soon. Your website resonated with me and I think we'll click in our conversation. I'm travelling for a week come tomorrow, but when I am back in town I'll book something. Cheers
- rpastuszak 3y agoRoger that, speak soon!
- jiofj 3y agoYou don't know how to use twitter but you know how to use mastodon? Aren't they basically the same thing?
- rpastuszak 3y agoThe other comments explain this better than I could. In short: I can post the same message on Twitter and Mastodon and get a thoughtful comment on the latter vs. no engagement/shitpost on the former. Twitter feels like a bunch of angry people screaming into the void, whereas Mastodon is like screaming in a small cave filled with friendly weirdos. I like that. Eventually you lower your voice and start chatting.
- nicbou 3y agoAn online community should feel like an online pub. It should have a vibe, some regulars, inside jokes, and a decorum that is somewhat well enforced. They're cosy places where a sense of belonging encourages participation and good behaviour. HN is like that. Small subreddits are like that. Group chats are like that. But now every social media website became like that one pedestrian street with the H&M and the McDonalds: a generic commercial space built around spending money. It has no personality, it's not safe, and no one feels at home there. Why would you invest yourself in a space like that?
- Sebastian_09 3y agoAlthough not exactly generic shopping streets you describe, but “anonymous” places also have been theorized and dubbed a “non-place” (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-place https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-place)
- vntx 3y ago> Why would you invest yourself in a space like that? Low barrier to entry. Convenience. Ease of use. Sign-up and now you can talk to your friends from across the world! Now, you have to be force-fed shit ads along the way. I don’t think anyone who values their social life would like it if you put it like that, but inertia and the gravity of network effects are a bitch. The real problem is these private platforms have the power of public utilities, and we treat them like public utilities until they pull the rug from under us, and siphon our data to profit psychopathic overlords. Furthermore, these companies don’t just throw ads at you, they also aid the surveillance state which can compromise your basic rights to privacy and fair elections. Malicious foreign governments use it to influence elections with false information and propaganda. Malicious domestic government can use it as a easy spying tool by buying or scraping data. No one will be safe on these things until we get proper government regulation. The EU’s GDPR is a step in the right direction but more work needs to be done.
- bmacho 3y ago> An online community should feel like an online pub. It should have a vibe, some regulars, inside jokes, and a decorum that is somewhat well enforced. They're cosy places where a sense of belonging encourages participation and good behaviour. > HN is like that. HN is the only place that is not a pub: jokes are frowned upon, and even moderated out. Post Valuable Content, or GTFO. You can joke and feel belonging literally everywhere else, catpost half drunk and high, noone cares really, from the small subreddits and discord servers and fb groups to the big subreddits, discord servers, fb groups. > But now every social media website became like that one pedestrian street with the H&M and the McDonalds: a generic commercial space built around spending money. We must have a different internet, every other place I know is full of personality and total unique, people repeat the same sets of inside jokes over and over. HN is way the driest and most soulless.
- nirvael 3y agoSeems like one solution could be to limit the transition from everyday users using for social reasons to brand/content creator users using it for monetisation by capping or limiting the social graph (e.g. a cap at 150 followers/following/friends/whatever you call them). Brands and content creators would have no incentive to join and devalue the network with constant marketing and high-effort posts when they can only reach a maximum of 150 people. I thought I vaguely remembered a similar idea, and a quick Google search only returns a brand called Path (no longer operational). Maybe there would be renewed interest in the idea.
- orwin 3y agoThat's why I think Twitter would've died anyway (or deflated). It was quite hard to consume niche information without posts from outside the community to pop out. The solution to this was to only read tweets with hashtag you wanted to follow, and not what was 'trending', but Twitter interface got a bit in the way. The new Twitter version have a sightly better interface, but much worse content imho (on the hashtags I followed). Also I can't read discussions without login in, and that's just a killer point.
- shmde 3y agoI loved Facebook during 2010-2014. Everyone would post their silly photos or some super inside joke that only people in our classroom could relate to. It was soo refreshing. Crush liking your photo etc. Now I don't even remember my Facebook password and the last time I logged in I remember it was just some shitty hyper local meme/news page with crass content. And I dont have an instagram account. Feels good to just connect one on one with people directly on Whatsapp nowadays.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/wXMp5 https://archive.is/wXMp5
- dathinab 3y agoIMHO this article shows a clear misunderstanding of what social media is. Humans are culturally used to interacting with limited sized communities, probably even evolutionary idk. When social media was new it was still limited sized, even through it was global, due to filter and it not yet having been adapted everywhere. (note: the term "limited sized" is a bit oversimplified, through I think most people will know what I mean) Then it tried to add many more ways to uphold the illusion, e.g. by adding better filters and similar. Then people moved to mainly consume social media platforms which do not create the dynamics of a more limited sized community, sure. But they never did stop posting on social media which did have that property! For example discord, which was fundamentally build around the idea of having limited sized communities with only some limited degree of cross community features. Similar that family group you might have on WhatsApp, Telegram, Threema or similar _is still social media_. Sure it might be a bit more private but that doesn't make it not social media. And it can be semi public, too. And people post there "social media content" all the time. Facebook is also still in use a lot, even through more in the background by older people. In the end platforms like TickTock and Instagram focused on making people consume media, instead of creation of more natural feeling social cycles, but jumping from there to "no one is posting on social media anymore" just misses the core of the issue: There are many different kinds of social media with different dynamic.
- philipov 3y agoSocial Media is a word that means less than the sum of its parts. It is not just the word Media modified by being Social; it was invented to describe algorithmic feeds like Facebook and Twitter. Discord is not social media. Discord is a forum, a type of thing that existed before social media. Social Media's organizational principle is the user page, while Forums are organized by community and discussion topic. Reddit is also not social media, despite having some algorithmic features, because it is organized by community/thread, not by social network. You go to a subreddit to read the posts there, not to a user page to follow them.
- dathinab 3y agowhat you describe is not the definition of social media which I see commonly used, especially in a legal context technical details like weather it uses threads in the end IMHO doesn't matter for weather is social medi social media is internet media used is used for socializing which means that while classical forums are most times not social media but they can be discord is not a form, it gained forum functionality somewhat recently, but the most common use case people have for discord is to socialize, hangout and chat in small communities. Does't mean it doesn't also get used as a forum, still it's more used for social interactions then anything else. Reddit on the other hand is in between a classical forum and social media, though increasingly more social media in recent years and saying it's not social media just IMHO isn't right.
- sylware 3y agoWill social media use AI to post content in order to keep attracting advertisers, showing that "stuff" is happening on their platform? Advertisers who should only trust One Metric: the correlation of the actual sales with an online advertisement campaign.
- collaborative 3y agoThat metric is never important. Brands have always lost money advertising. Spending on ads is seen as burning extra budget to stay ahead of the curve and remain relevant They are simply digging trenches for survival and domination. That is why I believe brands with profits above average should be banned from spending on ads. They polute the market and decrease competition
- sylware 3y agoI disagree, this metric is the only one which matter, and this is not related to loss or not of money on advertisement from brands.
- michaelt 3y agoA few years ago I heard an interesting description of social behaviour on a radio program interviewing a sociologist. They compared human social interaction to the way an actor can be on stage or back stage, and would behave very differently in the two situations, even though we wouldn't consider it dishonesty. Likewise, it's completely normal that a food service worker interacting with customers would behave very differently to how they do in the staff break room or outside of work. In the back stage context, for example, you can try on new ideas and then discard them after discussion, secure in the knowledge it'll soon be forgotten. Or you can speak plainly about topics where opinions differ, knowing how the people you're talking to will feel. Or you can be a bit boring, a bit derivative, a bit cringe. And of course, how public the discussion is doesn't just impact you - it also impacts who'll reply, and with what. I can well believe people have found there's much more authenticity in group chats than there is on the major social media platforms.
- kaycebasques 3y agoThe trust of a small, private group goes a long way, but I also wonder whether we've internalized the idea that things you say on the internet can last a long time. Even if the UI claims to be ephemeral, someone in your close group can screenshot what you posted and distribute it anonymously.
- jt2190 3y agoThe title I see: > Social media is dead: Group chats and messaging apps killed it Which I’d edit down to: > Group chats and messaging apps killed social media
- reportgunner 3y agoI revived my instagram account that was dormant for 5 years and I'm surprised how little my network posts. With ~100 followed I see about 3-5 posts per day before "I'm all caught up". I see about 10 "stories" per day. The rest is just a sea of ads and public posts that I absolutely don't care about.
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- bediger4000 3y agoI predict this trend to accelerate if "freedom of speech absolutism" gains more adherents, or the Netchoice vs Paxton case gets decided for Paxton. People want topical forums, without getting dogpiled/brigaded. Both trend and case degrade the ability to enforce topicality and manners.
- seydor 3y agoThey went full circle and now they are back to passive TV zapping , but now it's called doomscrolling on tiktok and watching mr beast It wasn't good while it lasted, in fact in retrospect we will see it was one of the most insane, narcissistic periods of modernity. good riddance I really hope people re-re-discover forums