5 ms·
Do please remember that amongst the reasons nuclear is expensive and slow is the weight of legal peril and delay intruded by .. the anti nuclear movement. Not
by ggm 3y ago
Do please remember that amongst the reasons nuclear is expensive and slow is the weight of legal peril and delay intruded by .. the anti nuclear movement.
Not all, by any means but in the "it takes too long" side of things, there's a reason.
- pipo234 3y agoWind and solar have legal perils as well. Mostly NIMBYs, but some sincere concerns exist about impact on wildlife, loss of agricultural space, etc. I think the reason the effects of those concerns in monetary terms pale in contrast to nuclear, is that nuclear technology is much more complex and complicated and therefore many more issues need to be addressed. At this stage, it's still a pretty immature technology and it can't progress very fast because it's considered more hazardous than alternatives. As it is, I'm tempted to agree with the young climate activists if nuclear could short term buy us time to instantly shut down coal and gradually transition to renewable sources. Problem is, that even building "off the shelf" nuclear plants tends to take way longer than wind or solar.
- smackeyacky 3y agoInstant is not a word associated with the building of nuclear power plants.
- Loic 3y agoThey can pack a nuclear power plant on a boat/submarine. It means, they can build a system which is compact and reproducible. If the authorities would be ready to allow the use of such systems as stationary deployment and provide financial incentives to get them online fast for "base load", I expect Rolls Royce and cie. to quickly deliver.
- smackeyacky 3y agoEven a reactor designed to power an aircraft carrier wouldn't do much more than power a few suburbs. We would need many, many boat powerplants to replace a single coal fired power station which looks impractical against batteries and wind/solar both on cost and deployment speed.
- ggm 3y agoI'm not here to try and float the nuclear boat, 'that ship has sailed' -but I think your economics are true now, but somewhat shallow. There have been decades lost getting PV and wind viable to power a few suburbs and the LCOE of SMR would have been just fine if the industry had been allowed to achieve the same economies of scale of production. Now? It's two to three or more times expensive than solar/wind. (CSIRO) Instead we've got billions of overspend on giant Reactor complexes like Hinckley. It can't compete. But undeniable huge sums of money have been flung at nuclear. Both nuke, and solar and wind and batteries are dwarfed by the gross irresponsible subsidies which underpin coal, oil and gas. They launched the 20th century. They leave a trail of tears and ash behind, which will take centuries to remediate. Massive socialised losses as an externality. I like wind, and PV and batteries. We're going to do fine.
- defrost 3y ago> I like wind, and PV and batteries. As further grist for your mill: * Australia has proved a focused sunlight system with hot|cold water 'battery' storage (existing ProofOfConcept) https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-08-31/raygen-resources-opens-new-solar-and-thermal-power-plant-carwarp/102798366 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-08-31/raygen-resources-open... (funded expansion) https://www.aumanufacturing.com.au/raygen-resources-opens-new-site-gets-10-million-arena-funding https://www.aumanufacturing.com.au/raygen-resources-opens-ne... ( Prior iterations of focused sunlight have had issues ) * 'Gravity batteries' are finnally being constructed (Waterless hydro batteries for non dam friendly topography) (2018) https://insights.globalspec.com/article/10784/massive-gravity-based-battery-towers-could-solve-renewable-energy-s-storage-problem https://insights.globalspec.com/article/10784/massive-gravit... (2023) https://www.energyvault.com/project-cn-rudong https://www.energyvault.com/project-cn-rudong (cube animation 2021) https://vimeo.com/647372871 https://vimeo.com/647372871
- steveBK123 3y agoI am not a grid expert, though I am fairly well versed in EVs/solar/battery storage. I am curious if battery storage can be done on-site at solar/wind facilities rather than distributed locally in neighborhood grids. I ask, because in NY we are seeing huge NIMBY issues with installing battery storage in residential areas. A mix of realistic concerns (fire safety) and general FUD/NIMBYism for sure. The facilities aren't even that big, which is why I'm curious if they could just be built out at the generation site and fight the NIMBY env. review paperwork game once.
- hathchip 3y agoNuclear power plants on submarines successfully meet energy needs for customers who are the least price sensitive in the world.
- pipo234 3y agoTrue. The problem is that instant action is needed. In that perspective, Germany's decision to shutdown operational nuclear plants in favour of ramping up brown coal energy seems especially poor. But had it's politics been different and the existing reactors kept open at expense of ditching coal, that still would not have helped advance nuclear innovation that might possibly have led to cheaper or safer nuclear power. As it stands, nuclear is too expensive to compete with renewables. And I don't think the young climate activists would argue for leniency, building and managing nuclear plants with the same sloppiness as their coal competitors.
- tcfhgj 3y agoGermany still has a reactor for research. I think this helps more with innovation than a power plant that's just there for energy production
- suoduandao2 3y agoWhich has a huge effect on the speed of innovation, the cycle time is such that making a better nuclear system takes much longer than solar. So comparing costs gives one result, comparing cost curves quite another
- spacecadet 3y agoNIMBYs want to watch the world burn, from their safe and seclude back yards, lol. Reminds of the idiot filming the wildfires as he played golf.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> Reminds of the idiot filming the wildfires as he played golf. Was there a water hazard nearby?
- mabbo 3y ago> concerns exist about impact on wildlife My father pointed out an interesting counter to this to me recently: how many birds are killed by wind farms and how many are killed by house cats? Studies show a million or so birds killed in the US by wind each year. Other studies estimate cats kill billions of birds- and most aren't eaten, because the cats are well fed pets. > loss of agricultural space Is that something we're short of? I'd argue that food prices, ignoring recent inflation fluctuations, are the cheapest they've been ever in the history of humanity. Hunger only exists in the world because capitalism dictates that those who are poor must starve. The opposition to renewables is pure NIMBYism. Though I'd still back new nuclear any day (and my province recently announced some!)
- tcfhgj 3y ago> Is that something we're short of? Yes and no. On the one hand, we destruct rain forests to have agricultural space. Bad of course. On the other hand, we destroy the remaining nature by using pesticides to increase short term production. Nevertheless, this wouldn't be necessary if the world would switch to plant based diets as much as possible
- pjmlp 3y agoOne of the reasons Germany is behind countries like Portugal in Wind power, is exactly the legal ways that anyone can prevent wind farms to be deployed, because "they are ugly", or "break the landscape view", or other nonsense. Thankfully some states are finally voting on changing this.
- numbers_guy 3y agoWhy is the sourcing of nuclear fuel never talked about as a problem? France needs to maintain boots on the ground in Africa to protect their uranium mines. The German public, amongst others would be extremely against that level of direct imperialism.
- spacebanana7 3y agoA non-sanctioned country can buy uranium on the open market relatively easily. Production happens in many places [1], including Canada and Australia. French power plants don't need to worry much about African politics, at worst they'll have pay Canada or Kazakstan a little extra for short notice delivery. And even then, Uranium is a small part of the overall cost of nuclear energy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_uranium_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_uranium_p...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- seszett 3y ago> France needs to maintain boots on the ground in Africa to protect their uranium mines It seems rather coincidental to me that one of the countries where France has military presence happens to be a minor uranium producer (we're talking about Niger here I assume). France has military presence in many more countries, and Niger is (or was, since there was a coup there recently) only a supplier for 1/5th of France's supply, and easy replaced with other sources. None of the other suppliers have French military bases. Uranium is also very easy to stockpile since it takes little space, which makes it much easier to switch suppliers if needed.
- morsch 3y agoIt's not easy to switch suppliers. Harder than natgas even: https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-france-global-trade-only-on-ap-business-c521f2248c823f69f0a677735a78e89d https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-france-global-trad... Beyond the mere Uranium, power plants need specific fuel rods, and afaik only Russia is currently capable of manufacturing the fuel rods for the remaining old soviet bloc power plants in Eastern Europe.
- invalidname 3y agoRegulation also slows down green projects. There are reasons for these regulations and some of them will be around for thousands of years... Green energy is cheaper, less risky and regulation (while also painful) is easier in most cases. As a result a project can be built much faster. Land usage is bigger but mixed usage is OK (e.g. solar over crops, parking lots etc.). Wind can reside in the sea and geothermal can be in the middle of the city. I think the discussion over nuclear is based on data from a decade ago. The world changed. It isn't Greenpeace that should object, its the business interests. It just isn't viable anymore and the viability is declining, since solar/wind, storage etc. keep improving at an amazing rate.
- sokoloff 3y agoFrom both an engineering sense and an aesthetic sense, I would much rather have 2 nuclear plants serving as base load (not total load) for 10M people, supplemented by solar/wind, than relying solely on solar/wind/storage. (In part because that requires an incredible amount of storage to preserve the current uptime in my part of the US, but also because it's a much better match to the load profile [engineering] and a smaller footprint near people [aesthetics].)
- pydry 3y agoIt's ridiculously uneconomic of course but a limited number will continue to be built in spite of this because of the overpowering military imperative. If you have nuclear weapons/submarines/carriers/etc. like Russia or the United States or France it shares some of the gargantuan cost of building and maintaining them. I expect North Korea will get into it in the next few years too for precisely this reason. Countries like Iran, Sweden and Korea, on the other hand, want to be able to manufacture a weapon on a tight deadline because of extremely self evident geopolitical fears. Nobody else builds nuclear power plants. The vast power of the global hippy-industrial complex apparently prevented it :/ Of course, the western nuclear military industrial complex, who always HATED environmentalists with a seething passion, are aware of just how massively uneconomic it is but that doesn't stop them from trying to dress up as "young climate activists" to sell a form of power that is 5x more expensive as a green gamechanger. Consent for enormous subsidies needs to be manufactured somehow if nuclear power is to remain competitive with solar and wind.
- sampo 3y agoLong build times are more of a Western thing. China has reactors started in for example 2010 and 2015 that were finished in 5 or 6 years (and some others that took 10 years). India and Japan has reactors started in 2000 finished in 5-6 years. Pakistan has reactors stared in 2011 and 2016 finished in 6 years. Korea has reactors started in 2000, 2005, 2006, finished in 5 years.
- imtringued 3y agoThere is no anti nuclear movement against NuScale. They simply managed to do cost overruns like every other nuclear project in history.
- lamontcg 3y agoHN doesn't want to hear that.