10 ms·
Farmers Insurance Laying Off 11% of Workforce, Citing Industry Challenges
- JKCalhoun 3y agoAll I see in the article is the discussion of "profits". I would think the PR department could come up with something about "trying to keep costs competitive for our customers" or something like that. Instead they're telling California and Florida customers to take a hike ... along with 11% of their employees. When is the last time we heard a company enact a company-wide, 50% cut in officer's salaries and a freeze on their compensation?
- Invictus0 3y agoWho cares? It's just business.
- Retric 3y agoInvestors for one, I get annoyed at overly generous executive pay because it costs me money.
- mgkimsal 3y ago> overly generous executive pay ... it costs me money But how can you prove that? The very justification for generous executive pay is that you couldn't get most people to do that role because it's so demanding and without these particular people, revenue/profits would tank. (slight exaggeration, but I don't think by much).
- orangepurple 3y agoI would buy that argument if entire American industries in question weren't mired by regulatory capture making competition impossible
- BugsJustFindMe 3y ago> The very justification for generous executive pay is that you couldn't get most people to do that role because it's so demanding That's also my justification when I eat a second bowl of ice cream. Surely nobody else will want this ice cream. I guess I'll just have to eat it myself.
- mgkimsal 3y ago"This ice cream isn't going to eat itself" :)
- Retric 3y agoOverly generous is by definition excessive, not everyone paid at or above market rates is worth it. Someone making 5 million a year could actually be worth the money. So, it’s not a universal failing at every company, but there’s many examples of such things happening. Private equity is much maligned, but it has turned around some failing companies by gutting upper management then having a new IPO which worked out fine.
- FredPret 3y agoIt'd be great for investors if the top positions were paid mostly / entirely in stock. That way we can entice a good CEO with high pay and our interests will still align.
- silvestrov 3y agoThat leads to short term thinking and pumping of stocks, often done by firing R&D and maintenance people.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThere exist both long term and short term incentive plans. See page 10: https://www.zurich.com/-/media/project/zurich/dotcom/investor-relations/docs/general/board-of-directors-report-zig-march-2020.pdf?rev=79425b28e8b04719b94d040267b85311&sc_lang=en&hash=037DB574EE518259A9915200C00A8EFC https://www.zurich.com/-/media/project/zurich/dotcom/investo...
- aurizon 3y agoA major example of this was the decline of Intel (that they are trying to reverse) that was driven by an inane diversion of $$ by accountants who spent billions on 'share buybacks' instead of R&D = the inexorable fall from grace. I have never understood this buyback philosophy and spoke against it(my whispers in a hurricane). It was done to increase the share price - it failed, buckets with no bottoms are hard to fill. Intel now has the chips program they now hope will fill the bucket - they should spend more on the bottom. TBF to Intel, they have stopped the BB and have (hopefully) repaired the bucket and might regain their lost stature. I see another bad act in the form of patent 'mining', a high brow form of trolling.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> I have never understood this buyback philosophy and spoke against it(my whispers in a hurricane) Buybacks come from net income (profit). A business always has a choice of using the profit to pay the business’s owners (via dividend or buybacks) or to invest it back into the business (such as spending on R&D). Obviously, what portion of the profit is ideal to spend on R&D and what portion of the profit to pay to owners is not an objective truth. And buybacks are nothing special, except that they allow more flexibility in how to reward the owners.
- whynotmaybe 3y ago2014 https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/nintendo-boss-cuts-salary-save-jobs-lower-paid-workers-1434268 https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/nintendo-boss-cuts-salary-save-job... 2019 https://www.hcamag.com/us/news/general/ceo-sets-70k-minimum-wage-for-employees/179153 https://www.hcamag.com/us/news/general/ceo-sets-70k-minimum-...
- sydbarrett74 3y agoThose are 'rarer than hen's teeth' exceptions that prove the rule.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/ceos-taking-pay-cuts-prevent-layoffs-economic-hardship-list-2023-2?amp https://www.businessinsider.com/ceos-taking-pay-cuts-prevent...
- jf22 3y ago7 examples out of how many companies?
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago[flagged]
- sokoloff 3y agoDo you think that Business Insider's list of 7 is the entire list? I know 2 CEOs who aren't on that list who took pay cuts. If I told BI about it, that's not enough for them to publish an errata on the article.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoExecs who are heavily compensated in equity also benefit from reducing their wage salaries to minimize tax liability exposure
- mdgrech23 3y agoI mean I rather companies just be more clear and simplistic w/ their language.
- hajile 3y agoThey have to keep it vague for plausible deniability during potential lawsuits.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThere is nothing to sue over since there is no law that says a business cannot reduce expenses for the purpose of reducing expenses.
- brookst 3y agoI think you mean there is nothing that they would likely lose a suit over. There is plenty to sue over. Statistically, are the laid-off employees older, more male/female, or more minority representative than the national workforce? Were any verbal promises of no layoffs or ongoing work made by anyone to any employee in those states? Do any municipalities in those states have unique notification other laws around layoffs? Anyone can sue anyone for anything. If I sue you for emotional distress because I allege you like clowns and that bothers me, it will be thrown out (rightfully) more or less instantly. But a huge layoff at a national corporation? There will be thousands of nuisance suits and probably tens of maaaaybe suits given the complexity of state and federal laws.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- criley2 3y agoI hate to be that person, but this is the future. Because of climate change, more of our country is barreling towards "uninhabitable". It's not Farmers fault that we released too much CO2 and now wildfires and hurricanes are way worse and getting even more worse. If the people of California and Florida want insurance so they can build matchbox houses in high risk disaster zones, then they can start a public insurance fund and pay for it with their own taxes.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThey did, from federal taxpayers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Progr... From my understanding, this subsidy to people living in flood prone areas was basically untouchable due to Florida’s status as a swing state. I wonder if that has or will change due to Florida no longer being a swing state.
- tedivm 3y agoCalifornia also has a state backed earthquake insurance program. Florida may turn into a swing state again. There's a lot of demographic changes occurring there.
- CalRobert 3y agoEarthquake risk should remain reasonably consistent though, as opposed to flooding which will become increasingly bad (though, as glaciers melt, you apparently get some seismic activity due to the reduced weight on the crust)
- pwarner 3y agoFor sure insurance companies have a chance to act as a forcing function to drive better building codes, fuel management, etc. Those are hard things, especially for existing homes, but it's a simpler calculation for a homeowner to put $100k into a retrofit of it will save them $10k a year in insurance...
- foooorsyth 3y agoI appreciate the direct language. It’s refreshing to not have to read through the lines of PR-speak.
- Simulacra 3y agoCould this also be as a result of cancelling policies in certain states? For example, withdrawing from Florida means an entire FLorida team/department is no longer required or in as much quantity.
- nicholasmoser 3y agoSpeaking to folks I know who work at Farmers, it's a mix of both. There are non-California and non-Florida working employees who were also laid off. No idea on the exact spread but it's not negligible.
- whalesalad 3y agoWhy are people surprised when a company operates in its’ own best interest? Why should we expect anything else? Insurance companies are just about moving dollars around and hedging risk. Being perturbed about this is like being mad about your dog barking at the mailman. If someone said I’m going to start free climbing the tallest buildings in the world - but I need insurance - the company will tell you to get lost because the risk outweighs the reward. This is what insurance companies are doing all over the place (fl/ca) because those environments are truly becoming uninsurable. But then people are shocked and awed when the situation happens with them. Why? An insurance company is not a charity it’s just a profit engine. Don’t get mad at the dog for barking at the mail man :)
- lifechoseme123 3y agoRe: FL & CA becoming uninsurable-- I have almost zero knowledge in that area. I assume it's because of natural disasters such as Fires, Hurricanes, and sea level rise?
- whalesalad 3y agoYes.
- aurizon 3y agoThere are many problems in Florida in addition to heat engines getting better at what they do = huge insurance fraud problems, restrictive work practices, shortage of stuff to make/fix roofs, shortage of local roof fixers = fukkit, lets walk
- orwin 3y agoI think there's a price of work element too. In my mother's area, insurance is cheaper because a plumbing job will cost 60€/hour (+ 30€ for the intervention). I'm pretty sure the costs are more like 120/150 in my area.
- seanharper 3y agoThe issue in CA is idiosyncratic to the state. In 2020 the average price of homeowners insurance in CA was $1,241 and in Illinois was $1,144. It probably doesn't make sense for California to be only 8% more expensive than Illinois. https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-homeowners-and-renters-insurance https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-homeowne... Houses are more expensive in CA, building costs are more expensive in CA and the weather is more volatile (and becoming increasingly so) in CA. The rate level in CA needs to increase. The regulator in CA makes it difficult to raise rates, so companies are responding by reducing their appetite.
- Spooky23 3y agoWhat they are really saying is that they can’t effectively model the risk. Say you were an insurer… would you want to take risk for Florida hurricane losses knowing what we know? If we want a functional insurance market in these places, we need a student loan type solution - make the Feds the reinsurer and have the insurance company mostly administer the policy.
- brookst 3y agoYou’re quite right, but I’m not sure it’s a practical solution. While those are populous states, as someone not living in either it is not super attractive to start subsidizing people who choose to live in increasingly disastrous zones. Yes, flood insurance and some other examples, but my objection isn’t based on platonic ideals of equally bad policy for everyone, it’s based on pragmatic ideals of not extending bad policy more widely. Let the market price insurance. At most I might support a mandatory tax on profits that is set aside to cover exceptional future losses, kind of FDIC-like.
- jghn 3y ago> it is not super attractive to start subsidizing people who choose to live in increasingly disastrous zones At the risk of taking this down a political path, I'll take this a step further. States like FL who fall into this bucket are further aggravating as they are also the ones that espouse personal responsibility & small government. I'm not personally against subsidizing these things. But I am against people screaming until they're blue in the face that they hate socialism and then cry foul when their insurance rates are too expensive for them to afford.
- pc86 3y agoWhat does a small government ideology have to do with a private insurance company making a business decision? You're injecting politics because you don't like the politics of Florida as you see them, which is fine, but it doesn't really fit here.
- 3y ago
- czbond 3y agoYou pay for talent. A business at this level is an entity that provides value to a lot of customers, and creates an ecosystem of velocity of cash flowing through employees families, vendors, suppliers, investors, etc. Cutting officer salaries would accomplish little, except accelerating talent loss. Man those SaaS products are so expensive, cut those programmers salaries - might be a corollary.
- Tangurena2 3y agoIn the distant past, insurance companies used actuaries to price policies, so that the companies could make informed, rational decisions like "for people in this risk category, if we want to make X% profit, how much do we need to charge for that coverage?" Instead it became "insurance company M is charging $N for this type of policy, we have to charge something similar or else our customers would switch." Along comes Hurricane Andrew in 1992 and years of 'selling policies at a price point instead of using actuarial math to determine what the real cost would be' turned into a major disaster as it turned out that dozens of insurance companies were selling policies below the actual cost of those policies. Most of those insurance companies went out of business. 30 years later, and most insurance companies are still making bad decisions. My point, and I think there is one in here, is that insurance companies have been making terrible decisions based on marketing instead of basing them on what the actual risks involved are. California's fires and Florida's weather are a lot more risky than people are willing to admit. Some coastal states have passed laws prohibiting the consideration of climate change in insurance and governmental decisions. Those states are also seeing insurance companies performing strategic withdrawals from those markets. But they aren't as big as CA & FL, therefore they don't get the media attention.
- sokoloff 3y ago> Some coastal states have passed laws prohibiting the consideration of climate change in insurance and governmental decisions. There's a significant feeling I have of "I hope residents of those states are happy with the outcomes created by their state government's choices."
- alistairSH 3y agoI never thought leopards would eat MY face,' sobs woman who voted for the Leopards Eating People's Faces Party. Memes and The Onion have become reality and I want off this timeline.
- MrMember 3y agoIn California home insurance companies cannot take into account any future forecasts (including climate change) when setting rates, only past events. There are also yearly caps on how much they can raise rates. The results of these policies on the state of home insurance in California speak for themselves.
- cryptonector 3y ago> All I see in the article is the discussion of "profits". > I would think the PR department could come up with something about "trying to keep costs competitive for our customers" or something like that. Keeping pricing competitive and staying profitable are both things that a business has to do when it doesn't have a monopoly (or oligopoly). It can't stay profitable for long while losing customers, and it can't keep customers w/o having competitive pricing (or quality). It's a tight rope to walk. Which of these they talk about will depend on what audience they are talking to.
- hk1337 3y agoCould be 11% of the workforce now or 100% of the workforce later.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoCEO get's golden parachute either way.
- seanharper 3y agoI am the CEO of a tech company that provides homeowners insurance in hard to insure places. I don't think it's really a bad thing for a company like Farmers to cut costs. Insurance companies are by and large pretty bloated from a cost perspective and could do to be more efficient, reduce overhead, use more technology. It's very common for homeowners insurance companies to have expense ratios of 30-40%. So if you are paying $3000 per year thats ~$1000 EVERY YEAR that is being wasted on branches/agencies you don't visit and corporate overhead.
- londons_explore 3y agoI really don't think an insurance company should have 24,000 employees. Even 240 employees sounds like too many to me. They serve 10 million customers. Nearly every customer should be able to use an entirely automated online form for signing up and for making insurance claims. Claims should be settled entirely with the customer uploading a 1 minute video showing what damage occurred, plus the bill to fix it. Assume 1 claim per customer per decade, and each claim takes an average of 10 minutes to handle (check video, spot check bills, make payment), thats 100 full-time claim agents. The other 140 employees can make a great website, policy pricing algorithm, and be in the finance/HR department.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoYou seem to have found an edge in the insurance business, which will enable you to offer more competitive premiums and win business from existing insurers. Best of luck!
- robertlagrant 3y agoAgreed - please start this company.
- justin66 3y ago> Claims should be settled entirely with the customer uploading a 1 minute video showing what damage occurred, plus the bill to fix it. And your plan for when clients are unwilling or unable to conform to your idealized filing process would be what? Simply don’t reimburse them? Or when they’re unsure what’s covered ? Or have some other question that’s urgent and not covered by an online FAQ? It’s a highly regulated industry, so that’s all going to go great. Have people been so beaten down by shitty non-service from tech companies that they think this approach is normal?
- londons_explore 3y agoIf you write it in the policy "To make a claim, you must upload a 1 minute video via our app or website, together with photos of all receipts you want us to reimburse", then you are totally within your rights to deny all claims where the customer can't/won't follow your process.
- nvahalik 3y agoI wonder which part of the business they laid off those folks from. The article doesn't say. In general, there are 3 main parts of an insurance company that are "in house": underwriting, claims, and accounting. Accounting isn't really something that can be automated or outsourced. You can't automate claims, but you can outsource. You can automate/outsource _some_ underwriting and/or parts of the underwriting process. Increasingly, I've seen independents adjusters (IAs, not to be confused with Public Adjusters [PAs]) doing underwriting inspections. Basically, when your adjusters aren't adjusting, they are inspecting new policies to ensure that they meet guidelines. So I am guessing these layoffs are probably from one or both of those areas.
- tallanvor 3y agoSome claims can certainly be automated. Not everything requires sending someone out. If, for example, there's a burglary, and a customer submits a list of items stolen and the value is within a certain range, it may be easier and cheaper overall for a company to cut a check rather than have someone spend time trying to verify the claim. There's a higher risk of fraud, but if the personnel savings outweigh it, then the company is likely to accept it.
- nvahalik 3y agoFor car insurance, this is already happening and is fairly reasonable. A lot of car claims are handled by desk folks because you take it to a repair shop and they figure it out and negotiate it. But P&C is a different beast. > and the value is within a certain range This is called a deductible. We literally had a guy who got denied on a claim end of last week because it didn't meet his deductible. (He provided the list.) Then literally the next day he re-submits with MORE STUFF. So yeah, the human element, even in a reduced form, will always be required. Stuff that he cannot prove was actually even damaged because he had "thrown it away".
- ethbr1 3y agoI was under the impression that most insurance was moving to an efficiency:cost-optimized model. I.e. Creating fraud scoring engines and auto paying claims they greenlight (usually incorporating history and total value as major signs). Essentially saying "there's not enough potential fraud value here for it to be cost effective for us to apply human review." Although someone submitting claims at an abnormal rate would be flagged. But I'm more familiar with healthcare.
- pcurve 3y agoThe same ceo who ordered RTO earlier this year.
- oofta-boofta 3y ago[dead]
- game_the0ry 3y agoThis is a trend -- corporations are lowering services offerings and quality for short term profits. Why would they do harm to their own business? Bc they think the future is going to be worse and, instead of figuring out how to grow revenue, its easier to cut costs. Airline service, healthcare, government, etc. Take your pick, you will notice it wont work as well as it used to. Expect more of the same. Climate change is just a part of this, the other part is end-stage capitalism. This is what it looks like when quality of life goes down for the next couple of generations.
- pyrophane 3y ago> The layoffs come after Farmers has pulled back from Florida and California in recent months. Implies that these two things could be related. Would make sense that reducing/stopping business in two very populous states could impact their workforce.
- ethbr1 3y agoShould definitely be highlighted. Property insurance is always in tension between actuarial statistics (estimates of ground risk) and politics (governments of various levels wanting insurance to be as cheap as possible). I'd be fascinated to take a peek at whether actuarial models have changed in California and Florida (I can't imagine they haven't), and it might not make sense to sell property insurance there from a risk:marketPrice perspective. On the other hand, I'd imagine the Fed boosting rates should have made the cash streams that insurance companies are more profitable?
- antasvara 3y agoFor severe weather risks, traditional actuarial models are often insufficient to fully capture the risk. Most (if not all) insurance companies use catastrophe models to accurately price severe weather risk. As someone that works closely with these things, I can confirm that the approved models in question haven't changed significantly in the past few years. I know for a fact that one of the major hurricane models in use in Florida hasn't seen major changes over the past few years (just updates to incorporate the next year's worth of hurricane data). However, two major factors impact losses to insurance companies in these states. In Florida, litigation cnan inflate losses to an absurd degree. The state accounts for 9% of all claims in the US, but 79% of the legal cases. Laws are trying to improve this, but it's a significant deterrent to writing business in the state. California, on the other hand, doesn't allow the use of catastrophe models outside of earthquake risk. Instead, they rely on claims from the past 20 years to set rates. For a peril like wildfire (which is infrequent enough that claims data won't give a full picture of the risk), this significantly impacts a company's ability to account for wildfire risk.
- jgalt212 3y agoThe only people with excess cash these days are NVDA and those who buy $40K chips from NVDA.
- gpapilion 3y agoIs this a side effect of low interest rates not allowing the traditional investment returns expected for the risk? Largely these folks held commercial real estate and bonds. I keep thinking the near zero interest rates messed up a lot of things, and we’ll continue to see them pop up for the next few years.
- hnmoonlaunch 3y agoYes. Insurance companies hold gigantic reserves of cash that must beat inflation and for the past 40 years the "safe" return was bonds of all varieties. And they do not have access to the newly created 'temporary' facility to mitigate bond loss as the banks do.
- no_wizard 3y agoAppears their attempt at stealth layoff[0] didn't work out. [0]: https://nypost.com/2023/06/06/farmers-insurance-workers-blast-return-to-office-mandate/ https://nypost.com/2023/06/06/farmers-insurance-workers-blas...
- CapitalistCartr 3y agoI'm sitting here relaxing after a long night of hearing my home getting pounded. Rough night. If I were an insurance CEO, I would run away from Florida.