5 ms·
> But just because there’s a serious problem doesn’t mean that every response is a good one. This is a fantastic line, one that I'm tucking away for future use
by freedomben 3y ago
> But just because there’s a serious problem doesn’t mean that every response is a good one.
This is a fantastic line, one that I'm tucking away for future use.
- jfengel 3y agoThe EFF's response is not a good one, either. The previous sentence is: "We fully support criminal and civil liability for those who abuse and harass others." That's not sufficient. These are extremely slow mechanisms, when they work at all. The harassed individual can suffer for years, and the EFF isn't rushing out to aid them. As their post says, "law enforcement and legislators have failed". The Internet is different from the physical world. It's much easier for people to cross legal jurisdictions and hide from law enforcement. Law enforcement and legislators haven't merely failed. They will continue to fail for a long time, during which there are real consequences to human beings. The Internet is going to have to develop its own ways of dealing with people who use it to harm others. The EFF could help lead that. But they haven't yet, and so others are going to take action when they feel it's appropriate. They'll take the EFF's injunction to "resist the temptation to step in" as being worth the paper it's written on.
- commandlinefan 3y ago> develop its own ways of dealing with people who use it to harm others So far, every "way" that's been developed of dealing with people who harm others has itself been used to harm others in more extreme ways than the harm they were supposed to mitigate.
- krapp 3y ago>So far, every "way" that's been developed of dealing with people who harm others has itself been used to harm others in more extreme ways than the harm they were supposed to mitigate. Has it? Some of the people Kiwifarms harassed were driven to suicide. Your argument is that having a forum taken offline is a more extreme form of harm than literal death?
- shrimp_emoji 3y ago[flagged]
- stale2002 3y agoIt is not that the forum going down in and of itself is the harm. Instead it is that this precedent can be used by much more authoritarian groups to target groups that you support. Now its KF, and after that other countries are telling these tech services to take down gay and lesbian support groups, or even a state in the US could force abortion services offline. Its a loophole that could be used as an end run around the 1st amendment, to take out groups that you support just as much as it can be used against things that you want taken down. Are you OK with sacrificing those groups for your cause? What would you tell them? That they are just worthwhile collateral damage?
- sillystate2023 3y ago[flagged]
- hobs 3y agoAuthoritarian groups are already targeting groups "you support", states and countries are telling tech services to take down lesbian and gay support groups, and states in the US have effectively forced abortion services offline. Those things have and are happening, and kiwifarms is not the reason any of that occur.
- stale2002 3y ago> Those things have and are happening Yes they are, and when other websites get taken down this gives leverage to authoritarian groups to target them even more. It directly increases the amount of requires and pressure that is put on them, even though, yes, pressure is already on these groups. The pressure increases every time a provider caves to demands.
- wredue 3y agoI am 100% okay with deplatforming fascist genocidal maniacs spreading hate
- local_person 3y ago[dead]
- zamadatix 3y agoThe EFF can defend its mission in multiple ways. One, as you point out, is offering an alternative solution all agree is better. This is fantastic if you can find a feasible solution everyone actually agrees is better but there is no guarantee such a solution is going to be found until after you've managed to find it. Another way for the EFF to defend its mission, as this article aims for, is to make an argument the loss of what the mission is trying to protect is not worth the gains made by tossing it to the side. You can be unpersuaded and disagree with the balance but the lack of alternative solution alone isn't proof of a bad response.
- Gartent 3y ago"The system is broken, we need vigilantes"
- jfengel 3y agoThe system is broken, we need the EFF to do more than just clutch their pearls about somebody trying to do something. If they want to be the Electronic Frontier Foundation, they can take inspiration from the self-organization that occurs on other frontiers. When there are no rules, you get vigilantes. Well managed, the vigilantes establish the rules, by popular consent. Poorly managed, the most violent ones impose their own rules. The EFF is well positioned to help establish rules. So merely saying "There shouldn't be any rules", they'll simply be brushed aside one way or the other.
- dotnet00 3y agoThe faster you make a mechanism, the more likely it is to be abused. We've already seen several times where bad actors have coopted movements like metoo and taken advantage of the speed of the response to ruin an innocent person and then get off relatively unscathed because almost no one cares once the initial outrage has passed.
- ThrowawayR2 3y agoEven if you are not a believer in liberalism as a philosophy, you should at least understand that the instant we agree let infrastructure businesses start pruning speech they don't like without any accountability is also the instant that the wealthy and powerful start thinking about how to gain influence over or outright control those businesses. One would have to be absolutely bonkers to think that's going to have a good outcome in the long run.
- jdthedisciple 3y ago> These are extremely slow mechanisms, when they work at all. This perfectly describes Democracy as well, however. Are you anti-democratic?
- rolph 3y agolet me tell you about a military 'headset' 1] doing something, even if it proves to be wrong, is better than doing nothing. 2] asking forgiveness is better than asking permission. these [1,2] support each other in a circular discourse. if you do nothing, you hesitate in want for confirmation of the right thing, you are ineffective. asking permission, you hesitate in lieu of risking the wrong thing, you are ineffective rather than acting, and later apologizing for doing the wrong thing.
- marcosdumay 3y ago"Being on the border of the precipice, they decided to act and step ahead." "We must do something; this is something; therefore we must do this." I've seen that thing rephrased so many ways, it's not even funny anymore. People always fall for that bias. I'm sure if you make some loud proclamations that "Global Warming will destroy everything, we must go and kill the wales", you will get followers.
- MiguelX413 3y ago*“…we must go and kill Wales”
- Akronymus 3y agoIt seems that people really dislike that place in particular.
- bewaretheirs 3y agoThe contrary belief was once mocked on "Yes, Prime Minister" as: "1. We must do something. 2. This is something. 3. Therefore, we must do this."
- fallingknife 3y agoAnd to cover the opposite case: 1. Nothing is going to happen 2. Something maybe is going to happen, but we should do nothing about it 3. Maybe we should do something about it, but there's nothing we can do 4. Maybe there's something we could have done, but it's too late now
- sassy_quat 3y ago[dead]
- jdthedisciple 3y agoYou may want to revisit how syllogisms work. Thanks for your input.
- fallingknife 3y agoYou might want to watch Yes Minister so you have the context to comment here. Thanks for the input.
- umvi 3y agoThe politician's syllogism (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician%27s_syllogism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician%27s_syllogism)