6 ms·
Some context [1] that is missing from the article: > 3M has said the CAEv2 earplugs, which were designed in the late 1990s so soldiers could carry only one set
by crazygringo 3y ago
Some context [1] that is missing from the article:
> 3M has said the CAEv2 earplugs, which were designed in the late 1990s so soldiers could carry only one set of earplugs in multiple types of combat, aren’t faulty unless they are worn incorrectly and 3M said it worked in “close coordination” with the U.S. military to develop the design.
> 3M tried to use the government-contractor defense, which allows companies to be protected if equipment made under a government contract is later found to be defective, but the court rejected the defense because there was never a written contract between the U.S. government and Aearo regarding the earplugs' design.
Unfortunately, I can't find any clear answers around whether they do always work when worn correctly, whether they were manufactured to specification or not, or whether the specification was ultimately (verbally?) approved by the government.
All of which makes it exceedingly hard for any of us to judge whether this was 3M being negligent in design or manufacturing, or the government being negligent in ordering something it knew or should have known was defective in advance, or the military being negligent in not ensuring soldiers were using them correctly, or multiple of these. Unless someone here has more sources?
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/maryroeloffs/2023/08/27/3m-may-settle-lawsuits-over-defective-military-earplugs-for-over-55-billion-report-says/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/maryroeloffs/2023/08/27/3m-may-...
- 1970-01-01 3y agoIt sounds like (pun intended) one side of them was not working as described. The green end was designed to block out all sound. The yellow end, signaling “whisper mode,” purported to block out loud sound — but allowed the user to hear quieter noises, like conversations. My source is hear (hah): https://www.cnbc.com/2023/03/15/3m-legal-battle-combat-grade-earplugs.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/03/15/3m-legal-battle-combat-grade...
- crazygringo 3y agoThanks for that. A lot of interesting details: > “The purpose of the creation of [the Combat Arms earplugs] was to collaborate with the military to solve one of the longest-standing problems they have had, that soldiers won’t wear their hearing protection around loud noises and in combat,” Rucker said. > Rucker said the plugs were designed in collaboration with the U.S. military and tested by the Air Force, Army, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, and others. > “3M has purposefully skewed this data by relying on hearing standards that do not measure frequencies most affected by noise, concealing the hearing damage suffered by veterans,” said Bryan Aylstock and Chris Seeger, co-lead counsel for the service members and veterans, in a joint statement. > 3M disagreed with those claims, telling CNBC: “The data support what 3M has maintained throughout this litigation: the Combat Arms Earplugs version two were safe and effective to use. This has been confirmed by every independent, third-party organization that has tested the product, including the Army Research Lab, the Air Force Research lab, NIOSH, and others.” Ultimately, whose job should it be to determine whether or not they're defective? If the military tested them in advance and determined they met standards, and they were manufactured identically to what the military approved, should 3M be the one held responsible?
- hyperhello 3y agoIf all of that is true, it’s arbitrary whether 3M is part of the military or not, and can be held responsible.
- Nition 3y ago> soldiers won’t wear their hearing protection around loud noises and in combat I haven't been in combat, thankfully, but I assume the problem is that you also want to hear quiet sounds clearly, and others around you talking etc? In the audio world we would fix this with a compressor or a limiter. You set a loudness threshold and then reduce the component of the audio input that's above that threshold in volume by a fixed ratio, e.g. 4:1. A limiter is the same but the ratio is infinite (or near it), so the threshold becomes the maximum loudness. Basically, reduce the dynamic range. I wonder how much it would cost to have active processing like that integrated into hearing protection. I'm sure they've thought of it. Or maybe I'm thinking too fancy - maybe you could achieve the same thing without electronics. Loud sounds are just more pressure after all... could we have a little hole that's open in normal conditions but loud sounds push it closed? I know this is probably one of those things where "random idiot on hacker news thinks he has a new idea that we've of course already researched thoroughly in the industry" but if these exit it'd be cool to see, or if they don't it'd be cool to know why.
- jiaaro 3y agoI’m not an industry expert either, but ear plugs don’t block sound taking other paths to the ear drum like bone conduction. The mix knob on this limiter can’t be turned to 100%
- Auracle 3y agoYeah, that’s absolutely already a thing for regular Joe Schmoe hearing protection. I have a pair. They’re big earmuff types though, not earplugs. I suppose they very well might exist now too. The fun thing about them is you can turn up the volume and essentially have super hearing while still keeping gun shots quiet.
- 3y ago
- remarkEon 3y agoI was in the Army for a while and used these all the time. I had no idea that the yellow vs green end was for different sound levels, wow.
- mkmk 3y ago> Plaintiffs allege Defendants failed to warn or instruct of the following risks and dangers of using the CAEv2 as intended: (1) that the CAEv2 loosens imperceptibly in a user’s ears, thereby allowing damaging sounds to bypass the earplug and enter the ear; (2) that Aearo’s testing subjects did not follow standard fitting instructions, but rather used a reconfigured method of folding back the opposing flanges before inserting the device into their ears; (3) that following Defendants’ standard instructions for insertion of the CAEv2 would not achieve the 22 Noise Reduction Rating and would thereby pose a serious risk to users; and (4) that Defendants did not adequately or properly test the CAEv2. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-flnd-3_19-md-02885/pdf/USCOURTS-flnd-3_19-md-02885-13.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-flnd-3_19-md-02...
- TylerE 3y agoWow, I had no idea they were that bad. 22NRR for guns at close range is...not much. Most range shooters will be using at least 30+ (which is WAY MORE than ~40% effective - decibels are logarithmic). Some will even wear 30+ plugs under 35+ muffs. (Which don't add, btw, again, logarithms, but doubling up does get you a few extra decibels reduction over either component alone.
- mkmk 3y agoTradeoff with retaining ability to hear commands/maintain situational awareness on the battlefield, perhaps?
- kazinator 3y agoYes, it should add! If we cascade a 30 dB reduction with another 30 dB reduction, we should get 60 dB reduction. The only reason you likely won't get anywhere near 60 dB from a combination of plugs and muffs has nothing to do with logarithms, but with physics/topology. Namely, the reason why these devices have the rating they do and not something better is not only that sounds goes through them but that it goes around them, e.g. through your skull or Eustachian tube or whatever. When signal is leaking around the attenuators, then their decibel reductions cannot simply add. Even if the attenuators completely block signal, they will be bypassed, and so the best decibel reduction is limited by the floor of the bypassing signal. But decibels definitely add. E.g. in an electronic circuit where we have vanishingly low leakage around our attenuation stages, if we cascade a -6 dB drop with a -12 dB drop we will get -18 dB. Now suppose we have a parasitic leakage from input to output so that even if we disconnect our circuits signal path, some input still reaches the output: say -100 dB. It might be going through ground wires, or inductive or capacitive cross-talk between circuit traces or whatever. That then sets the upper bound on our attenuation; we will not be able to attenuate better than -100 dB, because then the leakage dominates. I mentioned the Eustachian tube. If your ears are stuffed to heck and you have muffs over that, and then yawn with an open mouth, you may suddenly hear a lot more noise. Oops!
- killingtime74 3y agoI think you can take it from their settlement that they think they have some reasonable chances of losing. Fighting a lawsuit you are likely to win only costs a fraction of this amount.
- delta-26 3y agoIt’s worse: https://prospect.org/power/monopoly-misrepresentation-and-malpractice-3m-earplugs/ https://prospect.org/power/monopoly-misrepresentation-and-ma...