14 ms·
Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recognize Union, NLRB Rules
- mplewis 3y agoA fitting punishment. It's about time.
- workingdog 3y agoLabor is becoming a liability. Expect much more automation, outsourcing, and shipping jobs overseas.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xbpx 3y agoThis is a hilarious comment. It's exactly the comment that was made in the 70s when workers had a larger share of national income and when average salaries could afford a house. Indeed, soon thereafter in the late 70s we saw rounds of union busting, neoliberalism, Thatcherism and Regan and drastic cuts to taxes and employment security. Inequality spiked, wages stagnated, many millionaires and billionaires produced and the growing frustration and malaise in the working classes generating the rise of nationalist and populist movements the world over. It's becoming a bipartisan realization we went too far with both Republicans and Democrats calling for reshoring, investment in industry and yes, worker protection. The most minimal watered down corporate friendly worker protection. This is 10% of what any radical would wish for. And already this comment. The reactionary spirit has been embedded deeply.
- Aloha 3y agoThe pendulum swings. Those things were reactions in many cases to overreach and an oversized role of the state, and a status quo that failed to innovate. Now we're (for good reason) going to go the other way. I think its a natural cyclic cycle, the market is now out of good new ideas, and now we need innovation from someplace else, and to rebalance social equity too
- randyrand 3y agoyou’re downvoted, but it’s true. Hiring should be avoided if you can get away with automation or slower growth.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoWe’ll come to tax the automation next as a society. As long as democracy functions and the fiat hits a regulated endpoint (ie a bank), the majority can wag the minority seeking to maximize returns with automation and offshore labor. Attempts to evade these mechanisms could use punitive measures resulting in exclusion from a market.
- kadoban 3y agoLabor has _always_ been a liability for rich amoral capitalists. Should one assume by you saying this in response to this story that labor should race to the bottom, becoming just as cheap and disposable as a machine? Sounds like a bad world to live in, and it also wouldn't even work.
- asu_thomas 3y ago> Labor has _always_ been a liability for rich amoral capitalists Just capitalists. It doesn't matter how rich or amoral they are.
- autoexec 3y agoExactly. Companies will replace human workers with AI or robots or whatever else as soon as it's possible no matter what happens. Even if companies paid their workers nothing at all (slavery) it would still be worth it to get rid of their human employees because AI won't want vacations or family leave or call in sick or infect coworkers. Robots never show up late, or steal, or end up dragging the company into sexual harassment lawsuits. Machines don't have to sleep and most importantly they don't say no. All human workers should fight for a living wage. Times are likely only going to get harder and when the robots do finally and inevitably replace us lowly human workers we'll be much better off after having fought for fair wages.
- ETH_start 3y agoWages increase the fastest in countries with the most market freedom and security of private peoperty. Capitalists generate capital, which is the basis for all wage growth and improvements in quality of life.
- olddustytrail 3y ago> Capitalists generate capital Why of course they do! When I buy shares in a company, it's me that's generating all the capital, not those idle workers who just sit around making things!
- 3y ago
- FreshStart 3y agoUnfortunately for employers, the robots software Abo has unionized and raised the price to extract maximum value.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoThis new rule is simply a power grab for leftists. It will be cheered on by everyone too dimwitted to realize there are huge negative externalities to unions and minimum wage laws, which ironically affect the working class the most.
- colinwilyb 3y agoLabour is often most costly part of running a business. Once people can be reliably replaced they will be. One can only guess that cost, availability, or proficiency, of machines is still not matched by machines.
- UncleMeat 3y agoI think it is fascinating how employers have the gall to call themselves "job creators" and talk about their contribution to society through employment while this is so obviously happening.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoYou project a narrative to meet your needs.
- chmod600 3y agoI admit I just don't understand how unions are formed or how they work. Once I saw picketing (not sure if I'm using the term properly) outside of a grocery store. When I asked what their complaint was, I found out they didn't work there and I got confused. What does "a majority of the workers" mean? Is that a majority in a particular establishment, or employees of a company (across many locations) or an industry? And if they vote Yes, do they then choose what kind of union to be (Teamsters, etc.) and doesn't it get kind of complicated? What happens to the people that vote No?
- creato 3y ago> What happens to the people that vote No? I think this is what the difference between “right to work” states and not is. In “right to work” states, unions cannot stop someone from working at an employer. In non-right to work states, unions have more power to determine that, but I don’t understand how exactly. Personally I find it pretty hard to reason through this. On one hand, right to work seems utterly reasonable, how can a third party tell an employer and employee that they can’t conduct business to their mutual satisfaction? But at the same time, it’s clear that right to work will gut unions. So if you feel that employers have too much power over employees and unions are a good answer to that, but also think it’s absurd to allow a third party to block an employment contract, then it seems like there are no options left.
- zerocrates 3y agoFederal law allows for arrangements where employees can be required to join the union after being hired, or can choose to not join but have to pay the union a fee for their representation. "Right-to-work" states change this and don't allow those arrangements: employees are free to not join and not pay. The "closed shop," where only members of the union are hired, is illegal everywhere in the US under federal law.
- wincy 3y agoYeah good luck working a job where everyone else is union and you’re not though, you’ll find your lunch missing and people will be total jerks to you at every possible turn…
- superq 3y ago> Company must .. voluntarily. It's not merely semantics to point out: if a someone must do something, then it's not voluntary anymore.
- defrost 3y agoThey're not required to voluntarily recognize a union though, are they? Companies have the option to allow workers to hold an election to recognize or reject a union.
- ahahahahah 3y agoRight. It's more that a company already had the option to voluntarily recognize the union. This says, if they aren't willing to take that option of voluntarily recognizing it, they must do something else (hold an election).
- mlyle 3y ago> It's not merely semantics to point out: if a someone must do something, then it's not voluntary anymore. If you have the choice between: * letting the union election go on unmolested, or * recognizing the union without an election. The latter would be voluntarily recognizing the union (instead of exercising your option to demand an election).
- elgenie 3y agoBut that's not how English works. When you pull some words out of a sentence and exclude others, you often get another sentence with a different or nonsensical meaning. It's "company must [ (1. voluntarily recognize union) or (2. hold election) ]". Choosing option 1 is voluntary because option 2, which you elided completely, exists and may be chosen instead. The "must", on the other hand, denotes the overarching mandate to select from the enumerated options. The part that the ruling the article is about changes is after that, BTW. The penalty for interfering with (2. hold election) is no longer a redo of the election, but rather imposed recognition of the union and a mandate to bargain with it. The previous penalty wasn't much of one and thus provided no deterrent for companies.
- baron816 3y ago[flagged]
- asu_thomas 3y ago> Unions have arguably been good for straight white native born men. Everyone else who has had to pay higher prices or has had to deal with worse products and services has lost out. I criticize unions all the time, but your comment is so incredibly ahistorical and out of touch it makes me rethink my position because I don't want to be confused with people as clueless as you are. Nothing in US history has come remotely close to improving race relations like the union movements of the 1930s and 1940s. The ruling class deployed racism to divide working people and unionization brought them back together, making the civil rights movement viable. People like you who spout nonsense they know nothing about disgust me and I hope your employees unionize ASAP.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- VirusNewbie 3y agoRight, it is a way to gatekeep people in the industry and allows those who are better at politics to rise up than those who are simply good at their job.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI don’t see how this differs from current state. You believe people getting to the top of corporate structures aren’t there because of politics and their network? Workers support unions (71% of Americans, the highest amount in 60 years) because they’re tired of having the shit kicked out of them by the American employment arrangement. Workers who are members of labor unions in the United States make 18% more than their nonunion counterparts, per the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics' annual report on union membership. > The survey also found about one in six Americans live in a household where at least one resident belongs to a union. > Of the union members surveyed, 65% cited better pay and benefits as the top reason for joining a union. The second-most-chosen reason was employee rights and representation. Your profile indicates you work at a FAANG company. I recommend some perspective on median working conditions and compensation for the average American. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/aug/30/americans-support-labor-unions-highest-60-years https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/aug/30/americans-su... https://www.bls.gov/news.release/union2.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/union2.nr0.htm
- Pet_Ant 3y agoThe only thing I have ever thought of that could provide balance without unions is making standardized work shifts and forbid full time work. That way to work full time you wouldn’t have have to have two part time jobs. That would give jobs to employees a similar level of fungibility as employees to employers and leaving or changing one of your two jobs wouldn’t be as challenging.
- rightbyte 3y agoIt is an interesting concept. E.g. work every other day for one of two companies. It would remove alot of the risk for the employee to not have all eggs in one basket.
- ETH_start 3y agoThere is already balance without unions. The balance is provided by companies competing with each for employees.
- Pet_Ant 3y agoThat only works for industries where the supply of employees is low.
- ETH_start 3y agoWhen the supply of employees is high, you still want competition between employers to establish wages. Setting wages to above that rate reduces profit rates to below what the economy needs to get optimal investment levels.
- catboybotnet 3y agoProvably false. You don't even have to look far -- there is no "labour shortage," what there is a shortage of is "desperate people and suckers." That has not led to higher wages, only enough for people to bite. If there was balance, then you'd be getting paid your labour's worth, which would never happen as that's where all the money lies. You might have a good product, but if nobody assembles it? If nobody makes the parts? If nobody makes or maintains the machines that assemble the parts? Nothing, and therefore, no value.
- mcpackieh 3y agoIf I understand this right, if the company misbehaves then the punishment is that the workers are no longer entitled to vote on the matter? Or does "automatically recognize the union" imply "if the workers vote for it"?
- waitwhatwhoa 3y agotldr: the election only happens after significant organizing and demonstrated worker interest in forming a union. Currently it’s a two step process: get a threshold % of workers to indicate interest in unionizing, then hold an election over all workers to see if a majority want a union. The ruling makes it so that if the company interferes with the election, the NLRB deems that initial interest level sufficient for allowing a union to form and recognizing its authority to collectively bargain on behalf of all covered workers.
- ETH_start 3y agoThe Vice journalist who wrote this has an ethical duty to disclose that she herself is unionized, and thus benefits from these contract liberty suppressing government actions in favor of unions.
- wtfwhateven 3y ago[flagged]
- DannyBee 3y agoThe small issue with reviving Joy Silk is that the Supreme Court is the one that abandoned it. As such, the NLRB, despite what they may want, doesn't actually have the authority to revive it. They are just hoping the facts in this case are egregious enough that a court lets it slide. That may or may not happen - the NLRB traditionally does not have the greatest success in court, even in days where unions were much more supported in the US than they are now. One outcome in fact is that the courts decide to gut the power of the NLRB
- thebradbain 3y agoPro-union sentiment is the highest its ever been since 1965 and growing. https://news.gallup.com/poll/398303/approval-labor-unions-highest-point-1965.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/398303/approval-labor-unions-hi...
- johnnyanmac 3y agoAnd I imagine trust in the supreme court is at an all time low. I know part of the point of the SCOTUS is to be shielded from popular sentiment, but that used to include not taking large bribes from corporate entities and corrupt cabinets. And a retroactive lookup seems to support my imaginations: https://apnews.com/article/supreme-court-poll-abortion-confidence-declining-0ff738589bd7815bf0eab804baa5f3d1 https://apnews.com/article/supreme-court-poll-abortion-confi...
- tptacek 3y agoThe level of public support unions and the NLRB have is material, because it could influence SCOTUS justices. The amount of trust in the Supreme Court doesn't have the same materiality, because one of the most fundamental ideas in American civics is that the courts are meant to be insulated from public opinion.
- johnnyanmac 3y agotrue, but insulation isn't equal to being completely isolated from the public. Judges are still ultimately human and bound to the same overton curtain as any other member of society. Even if a particular justice wants to repeal the 13th amendment, they know better than to say or even write that out loud, despite it not affecting their job security (or at least, they should).
- CraigRo 3y agoSo the standard way that this works out is that an employee testifies that he was improving coerced to sign a card, and the company challenges the nlrb and the court reaffirms the sc decision. So this strikes me as political grandstanding at taxpayer expense; Congress needs to change the law and the nlrb doesn't have the authority to do it unilaterally