9 ms·
Fifth Circuit: Law enforcement doesn’t need warrants to search phones at border
- dannyphantom 3y ago> In response to Mr. Malik’s assertion of privilege, Officer Sullivan informed Mr. Malik that DHS was seizing the iPhone and that the digital contents would be searched. Officer Sullivan did not disconnect the iPhone from the internet or the communications network. He failed to take action that would protect the iPhone from accessing the internet or a communications network. Officer Sullivan ordered Mr. Malik to leave the deferred inspection area without the iPhone while the iPhone still was connected to the internet and a communications network. That's the part I was curious about. For a while now, the suggestion shared by bar associations [on both sides of the border] has been that assertions of privileged should always, always, always be accompanied by disconnecting the device from the internet. Here is a letter [1] from 2017 sent by [President of] the ABA to policymakers on changes that should be made to the process; but I'll just summarize the relevant part: [Linda Klein, ABA President] suggested that, if and when a lawyer travels across the border with any electronic device that could contain privileged or otherwise confidential client information, officers should only be allowed to conduct a standardized, cursory physical inspection - AND - unless the officials obtain a subpoena based on reasonable suspicion or a warrant supported by probable cause, border agents should absolutely not be allowed to read, copy over, seize or share any privileged or confidential documents and or files stored on those devices. For an attorney, the professional obligation to do everything you possibly can to disallow unauthorized access to privileged materials is essentially the golden rule of the profession; NY/Michigan has, for a while now, strongly suggested to members that, in the event of a border agent getting dangerously close to accessing information they shouldn't - the attorney should escalate to a superior officer to find a solution where the privileged information remains confidential - but - this decision seems to renders escalating as a waste of time which really isn't great. Best thing to do is disconnect and power electronic devices off prior to presenting yourself at the border. That should be safest for the foreseeable future and I'm not aware of any specific challenges on whether LE should be allowed to power on/reconnect a device during an investigation - that would be an incredibly concerning development and thankfully we aren't there. At the end of the day, there are tons arguments for how these interactions should be conducted presented by both sides. The whole 'security' thing does have some merit - but allowing increasingly infringing behavior in the spirit of 'security' isn't something that should go unchallenged. [1] https://www.lexsage.com/documents/May%205,%202017%20ABA%20Letter%20re%20Solicitor%20Client%20Privilege%20at%20Border.pdf https://www.lexsage.com/documents/May%205,%202017%20ABA%20Le...
- cheese_van 3y ago>Best thing to do is disconnect and power electronic devices off prior to presenting yourself at the border. I might argue that unpowered mobile devices, including laptops, bring attention to the devices. Border inspection types are certainly inclined to ask that you power your devices if they are off - at least they often do with foreigners entering Germany.
- jmspring 3y agoI've been required to power on devices (even RPis) when traversing through Spain. Some places do require seeing devices power on (even if it's some blinking lights).
- genocidicbunny 3y agoI have had TSA and CBP ask that I power on my laptop when traveling in the early 2010's.
- realusername 3y ago> Border inspection types are certainly inclined to ask that you power your devices if they are off - at least they often do with foreigners entering Germany. The reason for that is that you could disguise a bomb as a laptop where the battery would be the explosive. That device would never been able to be powered on though, hence the check.
- tiahura 3y ago0 expectation of privacy at an international border. This has been the law since King Narmer and should surprise no one.
- gottorf 3y agoThat doesn't mean any and all treatment at a border crossing is legal. Would you not object to an anal probe administered by CBP?
- tiahura 3y agoI wasn’t giving my opinion. IAAL, I was giving you the law.
- wolfram74 3y agoAnd the general thrust of pointing out things like this is to discuss whether or not the law is wrong. As laws are made and enforced by societies, it is entirely possible that they might need to be changed by those same societies as their needs and ethical standards change.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Y_Y 3y agoAnd would they object if I insisted on one, being in the "border zone"? This has to be a two-way street.
- nickthegreek 3y agoThey define the border as 100 miles. Do you think that is reasonable?
- tiahura 3y agoMe personally, 100 miles, probably not - most of the time. In Criminal Procedure, many law professors skip this section of the book (a bunch of drug cases) and summarize the caselaw with “you have no rights at the border.”
- throw0101b 3y agoReminder that the "border" (zone) is / can be considered 100 mi (160 km) inland: * https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone * https://elibrary.law.psu.edu/pslr/vol124/iss2/3/ https://elibrary.law.psu.edu/pslr/vol124/iss2/3/ * https://ballsandstrikes.org/legal-culture/border-patrol-100-mile-zone-explainer/ https://ballsandstrikes.org/legal-culture/border-patrol-100-... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception
- jfoutz 3y agoDoes that apply to international airports?
- Tostino 3y agoA.k.a pretty much the entire state of FL.
- loeg 3y agoSomething like 200 million Americans live in this zone near a border.
- patmorgan23 3y agoAnd the population of the US is approx 330 million
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Avshalom 3y ago"international airports" also count as borders
- bumbledraven 3y agoNot for the purpose of the 100 mile border zone rule, apparently.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoWhat I don't understand, and perhaps I'm trying to apply logic to things that are outside of it : The ostensible reason the border officers have these powers is to protect the country. We don't want undesirable types allowed in (let's defer the fun of defining the undesirable types:). But... This feels like "real time process". You let somebody in or you don't. How does confiscating the phone and keeping it for five months aid in this? Is the assumption that any evil deed would take 6 months to execute? And that if we discovered something bad on the phone, five months later we'd have an easy time catching the owner? Basically,in which twilight universe is searching a phone off line for months part of border security prerogatives?? Is it not obvious to everybody involved that this search is for purposes, good bad or ugly, other than border protection? How is this not even addressed in any of these articles or rulings?
- WanderPanda 3y agoAlso some parts of the border are overly secure (airports) while others aren't secured at all
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt's even sillier than that, because the point of searching something at the border is to identify contraband. Drugs or explosives or invasive plants. The border is not a chokepoint for information traveling between countries -- anyone who wants to transfer information internationally can just use the internet. So it makes no sense for the border to have any less strict of a warrant requirement for the information content of a device than there is anywhere else.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoOstensibly I assume point of the search is not to filter data,but to examine the data for evidence of malicious intent to sent entry. But again, taking five months to do it... Seems implausible.
- Zak 3y agoThe legal theory is that the information on the device could be contraband. Indeed, some people have been caught and prosecuted for bringing devices containing child pornography (or adult pornography officials decided must be child pornography[0]) across borders even in the internet era. I do think the law should be updated, but I imagine it being a non-starter politically right now. [0] https://reason.com/2010/05/03/porn-star-saves-man-from-incom/ https://reason.com/2010/05/03/porn-star-saves-man-from-incom...
- ericfrazier 3y agoHas this policy ever saved a life or stopped a terrorist
- olliej 3y agoHaving the information, and even being explicitly told by friends and family in advance has not stopped attacks. Hell, in Uvalde we saw that law enforcement won't even do anything during an attack that is killing kids.
- Brybry 3y agoI think there are a lot of issues with law enforcement in the US but using Uvalde to generalize to all police is a bit unfair. There are plenty of counter examples where police responded rapidly. For example the Nashville school shooting[1] or Allen, Texas mall shooting[2] (there's footage where an officer chatting with a mom and her kids immediately ran towards the shots). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Nashville_school_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Nashville_school_shooting [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Allen,_Texas_mall_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Allen,_Texas_mall_shootin...
- tacocataco 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_v._District_of_Columbia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_v._District_of_Columb... Cops exist to protect capital, not the working class. SocialistRA.org
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- refurb 3y agoI’m not defending searches, but it’s certainly stopped people entering the US to work illegally.
- john_the_writer 3y ago
- unethical_ban 3y agoConsidering How easy it is to store data online, securely and anonymously, and access anywhere in the world; and How important cell phones are for critical communications, multi-factor authentication for websites, and airline/transportation needs, It is nothing short of stasi to be searching cell phones at the border without specific cause.
- shim__ 3y agoBecause convenience, creating a secure cloud backup and restoring it once you passed immigration is a lot of hassle must people would rather skip doing.
- john_the_writer 3y agoWhat? Change the password on your github account to something you can remember (grand mothers full name) and log out on your phone. Done.. Would work for google docs too.
- buro9 3y agoIf you're traveling to the USA or China, take a burner phone.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NoImmatureAdHom 3y agoI get the sense the implication is that the U.S. doesn't have strong protections. That's wrong. Many governments in allegedly civilized Western countries have security services with much more power than in the U.S., permission to seize and search your phone being pone of them (the U.K. and Australia are especially bad). The U.S. actually has unusually strong protections against the police in this regard and in others. You also might consider that usually these protections don't apply to you if you're a foreigner who's trying to get in to a country not your own. They have no obligation to let you in and they can ask anything they want in exchange for access.
- jltsiren 3y agoThe US also has unusually large differences between the rights of citizens and non-citizens. In the European way of thinking, most rights are human rights. Citizens only enjoy a limited set of additional rights. In particular, citizens have the right to enter the country, while non-citizens can be turned away. However, border officials do not have substantially wider powers at the border than the police have inside the country. You don't lose your constitutional rights just because you happen to be a non-citizen trying to enter the country illegally with the intention to commit crime.
- refurb 3y agohttps://www.wired.co.uk/article/europe-immigration-refugees-smartphone-metadata-deportations https://www.wired.co.uk/article/europe-immigration-refugees-... “In 2017 both Germany and Denmark expanded laws that enabled immigration officials to extract data from asylum seekers’ phones. Similar legislation has been proposed in Belgium and Austria, while the UK and Norway have been searching asylum seekers’ devices for years.”
- jll29 3y agoWarrantless search of a locked phone is one thing (and should be illegal also at borders). Warrantless search of a lock phone of an immigration attorney (!) who travels under a pre-approved government program is quite another. This creates the suspicion that they perhaps did not honor the "privileged filtering", and wanted information about one of his clients. Those people should not travel to "such states" (USA, GB, AU, ZH) carrying smartphones, get a pack of Nokia 110 Dual-Sim non-smart phones at $40 a piece, all they can do is make calls [EDIT: and play "Snake"]. Before getting on a place, clear the call log. Don't store client phone number in contacts.
- politician 3y agoIt would be more privacy preserving and just as effective to have a policy of bulk erasing devices when they cross a border. The e-waste version of being forced to buy bottled water in the airport.
- orangepurple 3y agoCan this be avoided if you simply walk across the open border area? https://nypost.com/2023/08/22/border-patrol-admits-its-responsible-for-open-floodgates-in-arizona-border-wall/ https://nypost.com/2023/08/22/border-patrol-admits-its-respo...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whoiscroberts 3y agoIt was explained to me that they can also search without warrant within a large swath of the border, inside the country. I want to say I was told 50 miles, which covers an absurd portion of the citizenry. Can anyone confirm my understanding?
- realce 3y agohttps://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone
- sodality2 3y agoIt's important to realize this 100 mile zone only covers entering a public transport vessel (bus, train), and immigration checkpoints (only along N/S border). Within 25 miles, they can enter private property without a warrant (excepting dwellings). So it's a lot more limited in scope than it first seems. Source: "Customs and Border Protection's (CBP's) 100-Mile Rule" - ACLU Washington office.
- ISL 3y ago'The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.'
- qingcharles 3y agoYes, but it is a prohibition against unreasonable searches and the courts keep finding ways to make things look ever so much more reasonable.
- ISL 3y agoThe word 'border' appears nowhere in the text of the amendment.
- qingcharles 3y agoNeither does cellphones or GPS, but the court has to keep trying to apply a 250 year old text to modern culture. When SCOTUS was doing the GPS case they had to try and imagine the 1700s equivalent, which was an officer hiding in the trunk of a horse-drawn carriage and writing down all the places they stopped at. Think about that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thih9 3y agoDoes carrying a dummy phone works? And a follow up question, should I start a business renting smartphones short term, with locations near popular airports?
- slim 3y agothat would be a great business. rent them over the internet and deliver them to the airport
- thih9 3y agoEither that or set up a kiosk 10 metres before the gate where you could backup your smartphone to a usb stick and do a factory reset. And another kiosk at the destination airport, for reversing the process. Data 100% encrypted. Bonus, collect payment upon decryption, a la ransomware. Maybe start a chain and call it "runsomewhere". While I'm mostly joking here, things like this are already happening; the mechanism of 1Password's "Travel Mode"[1] is pretty similar to the above idea. [1]: https://1password.com/features/travel-mode/ https://1password.com/features/travel-mode/
- 1letterunixname 3y agoWhat happens when the courts are packed with political appointees working on behalf of those free trips from the billionaires. Oh and those judges think so much of their prestige and absolute power that they don't both disclosing their perks. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brantley_Starr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brantley_Starr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Willett https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Willett https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Edwin_Smith https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Edwin_Smith <-- Regan appointee who required the EPA to measure profits vs. deaths before deciding to ban a substance. https://www.propublica.org/article/clarence-thomas-other-billionaires-sokol-huizenga-novelly-supreme-court https://www.propublica.org/article/clarence-thomas-other-bil...
- rasz 3y agoSeems all we need now is one law officer with enough backbone to dump smartphone contents of Supreme Court judge in 100 air mile range of the border, or as federal gov would say "at the border" https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone
- nixpulvis 3y agoWouldn’t it be nice if we could set union the rights of all sides of any border vertex/line and use that as the baseline of understanding? I’m not sure how rights to property would play out in this regime, but it may still be useful to think about it like this. Imagine being detained at the border. Human rights advocates would argue strongly that you still have a right to a speedy and fair trial, for example.
- user6723 3y ago[flagged]