5 ms·
Is there a fifth fundamental force of nature?
- tracker1 3y agoInsert Mister Mxyzptlk reference...
- jjtheblunt 3y ago[flagged]
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoBetteridge's Law of Headlines does sometimes feel like a fundamental force of nature.
- the__alchemist 3y agoI felt a strange loss; to know that maybe this time, we really have learned the core of physics; a claim made many times in the past, and always proven wrong. BLOH is so reliable, it makes me legitimately worried there may not be another force. Perhaps only the weak form here applies; the answer isn't "no", but the headline provides no information on the topic? The strong form is, regrettably, the common one.
- bemusedthrow75 3y ago> Perhaps only the weak form here applies Oh you're just appeasing the God of The Gaps ;-) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps
- jjtheblunt 3y agoShout out to the sibling comment: maybe BLOH IS the fifth force, ironically.
- sliken 3y agoRight, we learned so much we have no idea what the nature of most of the matter is, or where most of the energy comes from.
- meindnoch 3y ago[flagged]
- olddustytrail 3y agoThat's not a force. It's a multiple of the distance. Which is why absence makes the heart grow fonder.
- smegger001 3y agoArguably love is a attractive force, but if it scales with distance than we could potentially counter cosmic expansion by separating couples and sending them in rockets flying in opposed directions
- doodlebugging 3y agoI don't think this will work if either member travels with someone else who is not the other part of their couple. The default for as long as I can remember is pretty simple, if you can't be with the one you love, love the one you're with. Therefore, love's attractive force would fluctuate too much to ever counter anything cosmically.
- doctor_eval 3y agoIs that love? Or just entanglement?
- finite_depth 3y ago[dead]
- hawk_ 3y agoThat's not a fundamental force and the insinuation made me dislike the otherwise nice movie, Interstellar.
- dr_dshiv 3y agoAlternatively, Love is the Fifth Element, according to Bruce Willis.
- archgoon 3y agoSo there are 5 observed bosons, and one postulated graviton. The strong force is associaed with the gluon. The Electromagnetism gets the photon. The Weak force gets the Z and W+/- bosons. Gravity gets the graviton, but that's mostly a placeholder since we don't know how to properly model gravitational effects with QFT. Higgs doesn't get associated with a force (yet).
- PaulHoule 3y agoIt's not that hard to model gravity with a QFT, there are so many ways to do quantum gravity now. The problem is deciding which one is right and the answer to that might involve looking inside a black hole or at energy scales of 10^19 GeV, length scales of 10^-35m, etc.
- lanza 3y agoIn the classical sense of "a QFT" then no there are no ways to do QG. The computations diverge. In the extended sense where you let yourself include non-QFT-like things like strings and spin foams, then sure.
- sojuz151 3y agoBut the fact that the computation diverges is not a problem by itself. All QFT diverge but this can be fixed by renormalisation. Problem is that for gravity this would require infinity many parameters and the theory could match any observation
- andyferris 3y agoMy understanding was that renormalization only needs "parameters" when the computational methods are approximate. I thought the issue was more that we have no idea how to perform appropriate calculations for SM+QG? Maybe I'm wrong?
- dustingetz 3y agofor those following, LHC reached 13 TeV which is 15 orders of magnitude smaller than 10^19 GeV
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- labster 3y agoThe Law of Fives is never wrong! Incidentally Eris is the one who ordered the Muon.
- alexfromapex 3y agoBetteridge’s Law is also holding well here
- xenadu02 3y agoAnswer: No. If another field exists its effects are so vanishingly minuscule and force carriers so rare we can ignore it because there are no observational consequences. Remember we discovered an extremely weak field that has no obvious observational consequences (the weak force and the Z/W bosons) because there were gaps in the then standard model that begged for an explanation. Besides the obvious gravity problem the standard model doesn't have many gaps left into which one can squeeze a new force and its field/carrier particles.
- russdill 3y agoIt's fairly obvious that we are missing at least one field (dark matter), possibly two or more (dark energy). There isn't any reason that dark matter particles could not weakly interact via some unknown force. Such a force would as you say, be pretty much impossible to detect and we can likely ignore it. That's different than it not existing.
- uoaei 3y agoIt's not at all obvious that either of those things are fields in the QFT sense, especially since MOND and particularly emergent gravity models still match observational data so well and that dark matter and dark energy are (in the case of the latter, literally admitted by Einstein himself to be) paraphrased as 'data minus existing models equals something we're still trying to explain'.
- russdill 3y agoModern MOND theories that attempt to account for modern observations do so by creating additional fields. I'm not 100%, but I'm pretty darn certain Einstein never offered an option on the accelerating expansion of the universe, nor on the evidence we have for dark matter such as the CMB map.
- uoaei 3y agoModern MOND theories modify the gravitational force at their simplest, they do not presuppose a quantum origin of that force. Ergo they're not creating new fields. More exotic MOND theories (like emergent gravity, mentioned above) reframe gravity as an entropic, not fundamental, force, akin to the "force" that "pushes" heat from hotter areas to colder areas. Again, not a quantum origin. It's still possible emergent gravity requires some kind of quantum component. Again, the "evidence" we have for "dark matter" is just inserting dark matter post-hoc to explain some mysterious misalignment between theory and data. That's all it is. Mechanisms for explaining that discrepancy are called "dark matter" because people aren't imaginative enough to entertain any other possibilities besides "it's definitely another particle, bro". I'm not saying MOND is more correct, we can't say that at this time, what I am saying is the confidence and zealotry of dark matter advocates is severely misplaced and amateurs do not have a grasp on what exactly is being claimed to notice that there's nothing actually being explained, no theory per se whatsoever, when words like "dark matter" are bandied about, and so feign the confidence that the dark matter die-hards themselves project. As for Einstein: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant
- endisneigh 3y agoMaybe. I like to thing there’s some higher spatial dimensional force that explains all of them and we can unify all the forces once and for all. Sadly even if true it’s not falsifiable. Such is the dilemma of not being omniscient. Personally I believe it simply makes more sense for there to only be a single force that explains it all.
- starttoaster 3y agoSounds like you’re trying to find God in science. Whether or not that’s a fool’s game is maybe for a smarter person than me to say.
- Dylan16807 3y agoYou can't easily falsify "there's a simpler equation" but you can get pretty sure after a while. And you can definitely find it if it exists.
- 10g1k 3y agoThe power cosmic. The pheonix force. The nova force. The dark force. ...
- zx8080 3y ago[flagged]
- lsh123 3y ago[flagged]
- nocoiner 3y agoMitichloridians are the powerhouse of the cell.
- m3kw9 3y agoThey still looking for the Fifth Element?